Our Duty To Obey The Law

1038 words - 5 pages

“The trial of Socrates: A vehicle to analyse the Jurisprudential question as to why in a Modern Constitutional Democracy the Citizen has the duty to Obey the law”
WHAT IS LAW
Law in my view may be described as a set of rules that are manmade, through the formal legislative frameworks such as the parliament, with the intention of regulating aspects of life of those subject to it.( "Province of Jurisprudence Determined”) It generally governs the social behavior of its subjects and affords rights, but also imposes duties and responsibilities on them with the purpose of creating order and certainty. Along with the aforementioned it generally provides for sanctions when these laws are not obeyed.(China Law review pg.1) What is important to notice is that in a modern constitutional democracy the constituency of law is theoretically decided on by the society, meaning their moral values are bound to influence what they would want to be law. Further laws are regulated by a constitution, or supreme law. In South Africa for instance the Constitution (The constitution of the republic of SA, 1996) is founded on values such as human dignity, equality and freedom. These are not only found in law, but also in morality.

WHAT ARE MORALS
Morals are the intrinsic rules contained within human beings, otherwise called the embodiment of reason (Aquinas) instilled through evolution and social conduct in the world around the possessor.(LAW VS MORALITY PG.231) It is important to note that these intrinsic rules are not created by man, but are found within as a result of internal factors. In agreement with Hart such an internal factor may be the instinct to survive, based on the truism that all humans want to survive. Further external factors such as the higher powers of religion that embed values in the conscious minds of humans also undoubtedly come into play. Morals are only enforced in a sense through ones own emotions by feelings of guilt and responsibility, and the reactions of other members of society that may judge ones actions in accordance with the moral standards of society(China law review) Because of the origins of morality in evolution and in religion it is safe to assume forthwith that morality exists universally in humans.

THE DIFFERENCE BETWEEN LAW AND MORALITY
As a general rule of departure the main differences between law and morals is their origin. Law originated out of human conduct, when humans formalized what they believed to be right and wrong. This formalization should be portrayed at the legal heart of a constitutional democracy, in the constitution. (ref american const and SA)Morals on the other hand originate from a broader spectrum of influences as mentioned above. These lead to differences existing in what is said to be moral, however there are certain moral values that are generally held high amongst civilised society at least. In my view however it is important to note that there are also similarities between law and morality. These...

Find Another Essay On Our Duty to Obey the Law

Analysis of the Psychology's Duty to Warn

2137 words - 9 pages Appelbaum, P. S. (1985) Tarasoff and the Clinician: Problems in Fulfilling the Duty to Protect. American Journal of Psychiatry. 142, 425-429. Borum, R., & Reddy, M. (2001) Assessing violence risk in Tarasoff situations: A fact based inquiry. Behavioral Sciences and the Law, 19, 375-385. Buel, S., & Drew, M. (2007). Do ask and do tell: Rethinking the lawyer’s duty to warn in domestic violence cases. University of Cincinnati Law Review, 175, 447

Duty of care is the responsibility to do everything reasonably

1907 words - 8 pages . Therefore they were negligent in their duty of care. The province defended them selves by saying that they maintained the highways reasonably and responded in reasonable time considering the strange nature of black ice.Statute Law states that the government has a duty to maintain the highways reasonably, no matter what provincial law says. The ministry has charge and direction of everything relating to highway maintenance. This includes

Duty to Warn Ideology: The Doctor-Patient Confidentiality

1094 words - 4 pages his/her own. This is the same perspective being advocate for in the “duty to warn” ideology. Doctors have a duty to warn the responsible bodies on potential victims. In fact, after California adopted this directive other states went ahead to adopt the idea, although South Carolina, Florida, Virginia and Texas continue to reject it. References Rosner, F. (2007). Contemporary biomedical ethical issues and Jewish law. Jersey City, N.J: KTAV Pub

Critically Evaluate the implied duty of fidelity - Employment Law Leeds University - Essay

1396 words - 6 pages encompasses many different duties and this may be because of the way it developed over time and through case law. Reports often state that the earliest evidence of an implied duty of fidelity existing within employment contracts is seen in the case of Robb v Green [footnoteRef:1] in which the implied duty of a servant not to misuse information obtained during service and how it could be seen as a breach of confidence was discussed. Robb v Green as

"Throughout web of English criminal law one golden thread is always to be seen, that is a duty of the prosecution to prove the prisoner's guilt". Woolmington v. DPP (1935) Viscount Shanley

1616 words - 6 pages of an accused person, arising from Art 38.1.Conclusion:I would agree with Lord Viscount Shanley, that "Throughout web of English criminal law one golden thread is always to be seen, that is a duty of the prosecution to prove the prisoner's guilt". A defendant person always has a right to presumption of innocence, it means that the prosecution must prove his guilt with evidence, this evidence must be proved by facts.If the prosecution had proved

Does the Duty of the Government Include taking away rights to ensure safety?

1389 words - 6 pages serve in every decision they make. It must ensure our survival, to keep us from falling into which that our founding fathers broke away from. It has a duty to keep the peace, and fight the wars in our interests. The Government is our Guiding-light, which we ourselves create and it is our Anti-Christ, our greatest creation and our ultimate undoing.

Why did some men desert and refuse to obey orders in the Western Front, and were they treated too harshly? Looks at the results of shell shock and punishments in the trenches

1621 words - 6 pages Why did some men desert or refuse to obey orders on the Western Front and were they treated to harshly?The western front was a place of in despicable suffering and death. The trenches were damp and wet. They were brimming with disease. Amongst this there was constant shell fire described as 'true hell on Earth.' The trenches were physical protection from the raging war, but they offered no physiological shelter. Numerous men were pushed past

Our Obligation to Help the Homeless

1198 words - 5 pages it’s our sole responsibility to help those in need, including the homeless. A common stereotype for the homeless includes being lazy or unwilling to help themselves. However, homelessness is often a direct result of poverty and a lack of affordable housing. But for those remaining they include substance abusers, the mentally ill, or more often than not caught in a cycle of hard times. 1 in 7 people were at risk of suffering from hunger in the

Stop The Deforestation To Save Our self

4037 words - 16 pages being depend to living. Oliver Newton-Mason analyzed that principle of the hydrological cycle and the carbon cycle with figures, and explained thedeforestation caused effects of excessive CO2 in our atmosphere, and the effects of deforestation on the rain that falls on the trees in question.http://users.aber.ac.uk/omn9/page1_four.htmThe deforestation is the reason that caused our ecosystem changed. Through research, Chris Trucksess presented the

Our hearts fell to the ground

573 words - 2 pages of the Plain Indians views on how the West was lost. It provides us with the actual perspectives of Indian people who lived through those times of manifestation and assimilation. From the Lewis and Clark expedition to the building of railroads, he attempts to explain the traumatic changes of the Native Americans during the nineteenth century. He opens our eyes from what earlier historians whose work seems now outdated, preferring to rescue

Our Life Belongs To The Media

720 words - 3 pages Advertising and the media are taking over how we live our lives. Major organizations use the power of the airwaves and publications to distribute their message to millions of homes. We are bombarded with so many commercial campaigns these days that it's hard to imagine a world without them. Will it ever stop? These tactics and techniques which are used, hook us so soon that by the time we are a teenager, we have experienced millions of ads. If

Similar Essays

Is There A Moral Obligation To Obey The Law?

2788 words - 11 pages movement in the United States, and the Vietnam War with its political scandals. People who disagreed with the governments' policies started arguing that sometimes, a citizen is justified in acting illegally.The question is: does a citizen have a moral duty to obey the law and if so, why?In the writings of Honoré, Raz, Smith, Finnis and Bix there are many arguments for and against a general moral obligation to obey. Often, they take each

According To Socrates, Should You Obey An Unjust Law?

685 words - 3 pages Q: “According to Socrates, should you obey an unjust law?” Convicted For Living? Do we have an obligation to obey any law, no matter how unjust or evil, provided only that it is in fact a valid rule of the legal system in which we happen to be physically located? In the following composition, I am going to examine the answer to this question in accordance to what Socrates believes. The best way to understand this almost “WWSD” (What Would

Can A Free Person Ever Obey The Law? Jurisprudence Essay

1182 words - 5 pages impeding the primacy of reason and autonomy.[footnoteRef:4] Thus, he comes to the conclusion that authority is incompatible with autonomy, meaning all authority is illegitimate and there exists no obligation to obey it. According to Wolff, one can come to the same conclusion to that of the law, however one has a moral obligation to come to that conclusion autonomously.[footnoteRef:5] [1: Robert Paul Wolff ‘In Defense of Anarchism’ (1970).] [2

Duty To The E Wmpire Essay

1675 words - 7 pages This essay will look at the structure of governance in the British and American Empire in the nineteenth-century and further examine if, as the quote of J. M. Coetzee states, the empire only requires that its servants perform their duty, not that they love each other. These two empires have accomplished much in the way of expansion and development of civilisations. This led to people of vastly different cultures being absorbed under one empire