Should People Living In More Affluent Countries Have The Moral Obligation To Provide For The Poor In Other Parts Of The World

1512 words - 7 pages

In this paper I will look at the argument made by Peter Singer in his paper, “Famine, Affluence and Morality” which advocates that those people living in more affluent countries have a moral obligation to provide assistance to the poor in other parts of the world. I will first outline the basic premise of Singer’s argument supporting this moral obligation and whether it is a sound argument. Secondly, I will look at an alternative view provided by Garrett Hardin in his paper, “Living on a Lifeboat”, which suggests that maintaining one’s own self-interest is more important and, in fact, necessary to prevent our own downfall. Finally, I will show why, in principle at least, I support one of the ideas put forth by Hardin and why it allows for some charity while at the same time acknowledging the limitations of aid.
Singer believes that coming from the benefit of an affluent society we are morally obligated to provide aid and assistance to those in the world who do not share our level of comfort, but are actually suffering from lack of the necessities of life. Singer states, “If it is in our power to prevent something bad from happening, without thereby sacrificing anything of comparable moral importance, we ought, morally to do it.” (Singer, 2013, p. 684) What Singer is trying to say is that providing aid to those who require it should be an automatic response and that if we are able to provide such aid, we are obligated to do so. What is not so easy to know, however, is how much we should be willing to give and when to give. Problems arise based on many factors which I will attempt to explain why this is a problem.
First, often we make statements such as, if everyone was willing to give the same small amount, say $5.00, there would be more than enough money to provide for relief for those suffering in dire conditions. (Singer, 2013, p. 685) In theory, this sounds like a wonderful idea, and although it might be true that if everyone was to give $5.00 to help those in need, the reality is that this is not realistic as the probability of everyone giving $5.00 is most unlikely. Another problem posed from this example of equal donations from everyone, it does not take into account the ability of individuals to pay more or less than the $5.00. This example does not seem to recognize that one individual may be able to pay $500, while another may only be able to pay $1.00 and have the same economic impact on the individual personal situation, that those who have more potentially are able to give more.
A second scenario which raises another issue, might be that instead of asking that everyone give a donation, is that everyone who is willing to donate should donate as much as they possibly can in order to make up for those who do not donate at all. (Singer, 2013, p. 685) This can also have unexpected results which I do not think the intent of Singer’s argument intend to create. This could allow for more money to be collected than is actually...

Find Another Essay On Should People Living in more Affluent Countries Have the Moral Obligation to Provide for the Poor in Other Parts of the World

"Governments should provide funding for artists so that the arts can flourish and be available to all people."

525 words - 2 pages expressing the negative of society such as bribe and scandal are always not welcomed by governments. by funding selective, the governments encourage some artists while disencourage the others.In conclusion, the government should not provide funding for artists so that the arts can flourish and be available to all people, at least not purposely.The funds from government will disbalance the discipline of competition and decrease the integrity of arts. arts are more powerfull than we thought, we should not worry about the vitality of them.

America Must Provide Foreign Aid to Poor Countries

2239 words - 9 pages moral obligation to help those less fortunate than ourselves.  It is unfair that 80 percent of global GDP of $30 trillion accrues to only 20 percent of the world's population and the remaining 80 percent of the people only have a 20 percent share of world income.               Although it is unrealistic to expect that Singer's proposition, that we give ten percent of our annual income to aid the poor, will be implemented in full, I

Should developed countries provide debt relief to indebted African countries?

1943 words - 8 pages , the people of these countries suffer or even die because their governments are not able to comply with these 'conditionalities'. Essentially, this has become a moral issue - why should 2 billion people's lives be in jeopardy because the rich developed countries want to make more money? It has been theorised that debt cancellation will have no significant effect on the world's economy, "... the external public debt of the DCs involves a sum much

Should The Police Have More Power?

959 words - 4 pages We live in a country with many freedoms. We each have many rights that citizens of other nations do not have. With all these rights and all these freedoms, there is a need of regulation. At one moment the police officer is a hero, the next a monster...to people in trouble he is a savior..to criminal suspects he is a demon (Geller 53). The police in this country protect citizens everyday and yet need protection themselves. Police officer have the

Should We Interfere With Laws In Other Countries?

651 words - 3 pages trying to make them do something instead of letting them decide what is best for their country on their own.Although the issue of the "Sharia" law should be taken seriously, there is little that our government can do since it is not in our country. We should not forget what it would feel like to be in their shoes. If the islam government tried to change our laws, we would not want to listen to what they would have to say. Also, if our government

The Courts Should Not Have the Right to Make Legislation that the Majority of People Do Not Approve Of

680 words - 3 pages represent us and voice our opinions. Therefore, the law should correspond with the will of the majority. If we were voting for leaders to represent us, why would they want to protect someone else's opinion other than our own? Some people argue that the minority's individual rights are violated when the majority is given favor. However, our Constitution has provided for their protection. During Thomas Jefferson's inauguration speech in 1801, he

TOK essay: Do questions like "why should I be moral?" or "why shouldn't I be selfish?" have definitive answers, as do some questions in other Areas of Knowledge?

1363 words - 5 pages deducted from this axiom with some other mathematical rules. In this way, to the question "why don't two parallel lines intersect?" we say that "two parallel lines do not intersect" which is a mathematical axiom, then, we get a definitive answer. Similarly, to the question "why should I be moral?" we say that "People should be moral" which is an ethical axiom, hence, ethical questions have definitive answers too.However, are all the definitive

Parents Should Have More Say in Vaccinating Children

2475 words - 10 pages force behind most of our State immunization programs and school mandates that are in place today. They provide health benefits to the individuals who are vaccinated, while protecting other people in their community. Diekema reports that “Courts have repeatedly upheld compulsory vaccination laws in the United States as reasonable exercise of the state’s police power—even in the absence of a disease outbreak” (Diekema 3). Although many choose

Explain why indentured servants and other poor whites were given more rights than slaves or free blacks during the early 1800's

1046 words - 4 pages were theoretically available to poor whites because they were denied to the blacks, in truth it is only that white plantation owners were trying to prevent an outbreak of riots.Originally, white indentured labor was the easiest to come by. Tobacco growers desperately needed more labor and searched for a source. Though African slaves were available, they were too expensive. Fortunately, England could provide thousands of out-of-work farmers who

Should people on welfare have to have drug testing?

1389 words - 6 pages everyday life and since it is not voluntary, the government cannot monitor their recreational activities. It can be debated however that welfare money is voluntary on the basis of people continuing to stay on it for years and generations. These people can either get a job working for a low wage and living a low wage lifestyle or go to school (using grants) to try and set themselves up for more opportunities. In the final principle, where the

Drug Abuse...This essay is about drug abuse, and more commonly the club drugs of today, and the effects they have on people.

2841 words - 11 pages , faintness, and chills or sweating. Use of the drug has also been associated with increases in heart rate and blood pressure, which are special risks for people with circulatory or heart disease. Recent research also links MDMA use to long-term damage to those parts of the brain critical to thought, memory, and pleasure.Brain imaging research in humans indicates that MDMA causes injury to the brain, affecting neurons that use the chemical

Similar Essays

Wealthy Nations Have A Moral Obligation To Educate Poor Nations

3669 words - 15 pages The most substantial and important ethical problem of the 21st century will be the correction of the vast and undeniable imbalance of the possession and consumption of the world’s material, economic, and cultural resources. In this paper, I will argue that the primary long-term moral obligation the world’s over-privileged have to the underprivileged is to provide those in need with the means necessary to develop a foundation for fair future

Should The United States Help Other Countries?

1694 words - 7 pages guerilla warfare to kill American soldiers. That's what America gets for sticking its nose into other countries' business (Snyder). So why does America keep policing the world? Maybe its because of the image America wants to have of peace and prosperity. It should be noted that no one ever appointed America to be the world's policeman. In fact, "The government's founding document, the Constitution, does not and could not do so." "By assuming that

Should The Blame For The Failure Of The British Terra Nova Expedition (1911) Be Assigned To Poor Weather Conditions And Other External Circumstances Or Scott's Leadership?

1866 words - 7 pages A. Plan of Investigation1.) Subject of investigation - Should the blame for the failure of the British Terra Nova Expedition (1911) be assigned to poor weather conditions and other external circumstances or Scott's leadership?2.) Methods of investigationa.) Much of the evidence shall come from the journals of the men of the expedition itself. These journals are the only primary source of the final critical legs of the journey.b.) Internet search

Should The Blame For The Failure Of The British Terra Nova Expedition (1911) Be Assigned To Poor Weather Conditions And Other External Circumstances Or Scott's Leadership?

1956 words - 8 pages A. Plan of Investigation1.) Subject of investigation - Should the blame for the failure of the British Terra Nova Expedition (1911) be assigned to poor weather conditions and other external circumstances or Scott's leadership?2.) Methods of investigationa.) Much of the evidence shall come from the journals of the men of the expedition itself. These journals are the only primary source of the final critical legs of the journey.b.) Internet search