Outline Briefly The Managerial Criticisms Of The Profit Maximising Firm Compare And Contrast The Neo Classical Profit Maximising Model With The Management Model Of Baumol.

2384 words - 10 pages

Since the 12th century and the escalation of separate owner / managed business organizations, the assumption that firms maximises profits has been at the forefront of economic theory. Cyert and Hedrick (1972) stated:"The unmodified neoclassical approach is characterised by an ideal market with firms for which profit maximisation is the single determinant of behaviour. Thus predictions can readily be made by combining the description of the market with the results of maximisation of the relevant Lagrangian."In recent years their has been extensive literature by economists questioning the theory of profit maximisation, given that the standard "theory of the firm" is based upon rigid assumptions which can only exist in a perfect market. Tollison (2003) stated:'The debate about whether firms maximise profits serves as a purpose of forcing scholars to be more careful in framing maximisation hypothesis, and as a consequence, the profit-maximisation hypothesis is basically a non-issue today."Perhaps the most controversial assumption that compromises the neo-classical hypothesis is that firms always maximises profits (and minimise costs). This is further explored by incorporating more recent managerial models in particular Baumol.There are however a number of other generic managerial criticisms of the Neo-classical model, all of which have been widely investigated by economic literature.The first criticism concerns the inevitable conflict of interest between management and shareholders. In the modern economy, where ownership and control of firms often lie with different groups of individuals economists have found that each stakeholder group has conflicting objectives, regarding the use of resources by the organisation.Managers employed by companies have a contractual relationship with the owners of the company i.e. they are the shareholders agents. However if the interests of shareholders and managers differ, then management are likely to be selective in the information they provide to their shareholders, resulting in managers having discretion to peruse their own objectives which may not be profit maximising; thus not conforming to the Neo-classical profit maximising model.Friedman (1980) found that individuals always follow their own interests depending on what they value and what goals they wish to pursue, thus the assumption that individuals act rationally may be viewed as ignoring important aspects of human behaviour. In order for a firm to profit maximise all parties must hold the same values and goals, which is extremely unrealistic, with the exception of an owner managed sole business.Another managerial criticism of the theory of profit maximisation is the existence of natural constraints within in the market (forces of demand and supply) and rules and regulations imposed by third parties such as the government (trading quotas, tax etc.). These limit the ability of firms to maximise profits, e.g. The Canadian government controls its domestic...

Find Another Essay On Outline briefly the managerial criticisms of the profit maximising firm - Compare and contrast the Neo-classical profit maximising model with the management model of Baumol.

Explain briefly Ninian Smart's seven dimensional model of religion. Do you think that Smart's model solves the problems that arise when attempting to define religion?

1161 words - 5 pages , actions, and institutions that assume the existence of supernatural entities with powers of action, or impersonal powers or processes processed of moral purpose. (Block 5, page 37)This would allow non-religions such as Marxism to be excluded, while still including such faiths as Buddhism.In conclusion, I would be more inclined to agree with Bruce's definition of religion, as the inclusion of common sense eradicates to some degree the problem of vagueness that arises from Smart's model. I would also agree that for many a 'religion' is a way of life, a philosophy that enables them to live by morals and principles that help make them better human being.

Neo-liberal model of economic policy-making Essay

1898 words - 8 pages approaches to planning. The three fundamental arguments of the author included criticisms of Neo-liberal model of economic policy-making, as well as the planning and planners during the era, and the possible ways to reconstruct through planning. The article started with criticisms of Neo-liberal model of economic policy-making. In this section, the first argument the author clearly stated that the Neo-liberal model is over, as well as its

Compare Viable Systems Model (VSM) and Soft Systems Model (SSM) in terms of their way of dealing with organisational issues.

2555 words - 10 pages the techniques offered by Checkland. Thus, we see the two approaches as entirely complementary. Checkland mentions the possible use of the VSM in this role; although in general he views the VSM as too much in the tradition hard-systems thinking. In contrast, we suggest that the VSM with its cybernetic grounding in the concept of variety management serves to enhance the model building in SSM.2.2 Combining use of the VSM and the SSM1. Develop the

Classical Model vs. Keynes theroy.

1257 words - 5 pages The great depression marks a great divide in America's way of dealing with economics. The economical war between professional economists today is a never-ending battle. On one side there are those who believe in a classical idea that was born before the 1930's. Then the great depression influenced another army of economists that followed the ideas of a man named John Meynard Keynes. The reason this war is never ending is because it doesn't

The Profit of Slavery

1008 words - 4 pages Despite common beliefs held my many historians today, slavery was, in fact, profitable. The market value alone of slaves suggests profitability. In 1815, a typical U.S. slave was worth $250; by 1839 the price was $500; and by 1860 it had climbed to $900. Prices of slaves would not have quadrupled if they were not a means of profit for the owner. The average price of slaves quadrupled because the average Southern crop production per slave

Contrast the essential differences between the best-fit and the best-practices compensation model. Which do you think is more suitable for Egyptian organizations?

1017 words - 4 pages systems will prevail across organizations and industries.However, advocates of either approach are not in complete agreement about the impact on reward systems. Schuster and Zingheim (1993) suggest that employee rewards should always be tied to organizational performance. Lawler's (1995) approach is truly contingent. His traditional management design option does not include any pay element that varies with organizational performance. Although

Psychology's Classical Theorists (Compare and contrast Freud, Adler, and Jung.)

1185 words - 5 pages In the field of psychology, Sigmund Freud, Alfred Adler, and Carl Jung, developed three distinct theories of personality that to this day, continue to be the foundations on which all modern psychological theories are built. All three of these remarkable men knew and worked with each other. When Adler and Jung praised Freud's book on dream interpretation, they were invited to join Freud's circle of peers, who met weekly at his home in Vienna

Different Views of the Comparison Between Non-profit and For Profit Organizations

1416 words - 6 pages for profit organizations have a cause, people donate money, the government gives them grants, and they are not required to pay income tax (Sandilands, n.d.). For profit companies focus on finding the next big product or next market in which they can succeed. In contrast, non-profit companies stick with their cause. Not for profit companies may try to reach different donors but the cause is portrayed as an identity for the company and the

The Importance of Non-profit Organizations

1341 words - 5 pages together by an awesome God and His mission for us as a people. Devoting our time and love, we also aided many in need with medical necessities: taking their blood pressure, addressing any problems they may have, and relinquishing all medicines that may be needed. Through my experiences, I’ve found that many non-profit organizations work to assist a multitude of hurting individuals through various methods of relief and invoke the initiation of

Delegate model with the truste model of representation.

631 words - 3 pages Comparing the "delegate" model with the "trustee" model of representation poses pertinent questions concerning the heart and will of democracy. With a large population, the need for elected representatives of the public is obvious, yet their very presence is controversial. Relying on a few select persons to make decisions which will affect literally thousands of people seems a bit precarious; it's tough to imagine the amount of responsibility

The Scope and Severity of Arson for Profit

2103 words - 8 pages criminals to not only commit but get away with these dangerous and sometimes deadly crimes. Recent crackdowns on arson for profit in places like Michigan and Florida, however, show promise for reducing the negative effects of this destructive white collar crime. Works Cited Federal Emergency Management Agency. (1997). Arson in the United States. United States Fire Administration. Arlington, VA: TriData Corporation. Retrieved from http

Similar Essays

Compare And Contrast Of: Four Stage Team Performance Model &Amp; The Drexxler/Sibbet Team Preformance Model

1452 words - 6 pages The Four-Stage Team Performance Model & The Drexler/Sibbet High Performance Model The exploration of two models will show an interesting relationship when compared and contrasted. Both can increase competency levels in team building. The models are the Drexler/Sibbet Team Performance model (Human Performance Strategies) and the Four Stage Team Performance model (Developing Management Skills). When they have been used correctly they’ve been

The Classical Model Theory Of Public Administration

2330 words - 10 pages organization is very dominant. While in Public Management or New Public Management, the indicator of someone is considering as successful or not is through the agreed target oriented, and to meet the target they were given little flexibility, so that it can run it is fullest in accordance with market expectation. This is an answer to the impasse goes on a classical model, as stated by Pollit and Bouckaert (2011) that New Public Management was

How The Firm Chooses The Level Of Output That Maximises Profit Under Perfect Competition

1652 words - 7 pages , such as total cost, average cost and marginal cost in terms of cost. Then, it will apply some crucial concepts to explain why marginal revenue and marginal cost are significant and it will explain marginal revenue in detail, especially under perfect competition. Subsequently, this essay will employ one graph to analyse how the firm chooses appropriate level of output to maximize the profit under perfect competition. Finally, it will briefly

The Classical Model And The Great Depression.

2084 words - 8 pages has yet to see. Economists today are still debating the causes of the great depression, and how we're going to avoid this from happening again. Most economists at the time were known as classical economists. Without a doubt these people did not go without work, they were busy figuring out what was going on with our economy and how to fix it. The majority of classical economists came up with something called the classical model. The classical