This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Outline Plato’s Arguments For The Distinct Existence Of The Soul.

1235 words - 5 pages

Plato's arguments for the distinct existence of the soul are presented best in the Phaedo where Plato voices his opinions through a recital of Socrates "˜death bed' philosophies to present the case that the soul is immortal.The link between the argument for the immortal soul and the dualist view of the soul is rudimentary; without belief in one the other cannot be justified, as any other type of soul could not survive the bodies death.The first argument Plato presents can be labelled the argument from opposites. Socrates starts the argument by stating that "all things which come to be and which have an opposite must necessarily come to be from their opposite and nowhere else" or more simply put as opposites are generated by their opposites. He furthers the argument by logically applying it concluding that life must generate death. In this line of arguing then it is fair to say, as Socrates does, that if the soul dies it must at some point resurrect and therein starts the cycle of an immortal soul. This has relevance to the view of the soul as distinct in that within this model the soul continues to cycle independently of the body.The second argument commonly marked as the argument from recollection, moves to suggest that the soul must have pre-existed ourselves because we carry knowledge which does not originate from experienced learning but rather from recollection i.e. a previous knowledge gained of ideas. This is an allusion to Plato's theory of forms, which suggests that we all recognise concepts such as equality because we all have knowledge of absolute equality or as Plato called it "the perfect form of equality". Returning to the Phaedo Socrates sums up the argument from recollection like this. Firstly knowledge [of equality] cannot be based on bodily sensations, as it is recognised by all; bodily sensations begin at birth hence knowledge [of equality] must precede birth. From this line the conclusion follows that learning is recollection and that the soul must pre-exist embodiment in order to give us this knowledge. In respect to the notion of a distinct soul this argument applies in two ways. The first is the notion that the soul has to be distinct and immortal in order to gather its knowledge from other lifetimes of experience and live to tell the tale, as it were. The second is the notion that the soul has to be distinct as this is the way it has the capability to enter the body and give us our knowledge.For the final argument Socrates turns to a more traditional response to the problem of immortality and develops an argument based on a traditional philosophy; that only what is complex can dissolve or "scatter". He draws a simile between the soul and an idea to suggest that just as ideas are simple so is the soul. Socrates has reached the conclusion that the soul is non-composite and that as non-composite things do not change i.e. our idea of the form equality does not vary, neither does the soul and it is therefore labelled as...

Find Another Essay On Outline Plato’s Arguments For The Distinct Existence Of The Soul.

Plato’s Theory of The Soul in The Republic

2176 words - 9 pages philosophy. An example of this is the existence of sin, or human evil. With Plato’s theory, a man will choose to do wrong only if a part his soul has been formed incorrectly, or if the parts of his soul are in conflict with each other. This is analogous to the christian teaching of the malformed conscience. Today, most scholars and less educated people alike hold David Hume’s view, which states that the passions are the primary motivator for all

Plato’s Theories on the Immortal Soul

1810 words - 7 pages . I, however, disagree with Plato’s theory, believing that everyone should have the equal opportunity to reach his or her potential, and that there is no perfect society. Plato often argued that the soul was separated into three parts, also known as the Tripartite Theory. The first part of the soul identified by Plato is eros, also known as appetite. This is defined as the base of biological cravings for food, thirst, and sexual desire. The

Outline the arguments in favour of abortion

545 words - 2 pages Religious Studies - website)They also believe that if the pregnancy is a result of a rape, then abortion is the lesser of two evils, also if the mother's life is at risk, then abortion should be permitted."It is argued that in these tragic cases the great value of the mental health of a woman who becomes pregnant as a result of rape or incest can best be safe-guarded by abortion." (Christian answers.net)These are only a few of the arguments for abortion, there are many more.

The Existence of God: the Arguments of Locke and Descartes

1366 words - 5 pages material things are there for man to receive through the senses, but that these things were not created by Man, it necessarily follows that a More Superior Being is responsible for these. Added to the fact that man's mind is capable of discerning the ideas gleaned from the senses and the mind's power to look deeply inward into the soul, to fathom the operations of the mind in clear reflection--these to me are the powerful arguments that a Being more

Descartes' arguments for immateriality of mind/soul based on the notion of dualism: body is extended object and mind/soul is non-extended

1858 words - 7 pages Descartes' Arguments for the immateriality of the mind/soulDescartes is one of the rationalists, who believed that the only way to acquire knowledge is through reason; as opposed to empiricists, who thought it is possible only through sense experience. This shaped Descartes' view of human nature as dualism. He believed that human mind/soul and body are totally different entities. He defined mind as non-extended entity with notions of thought

David Hume: Against the Design and Cosmological Arguments for God's Existence

834 words - 3 pages is impossible to prove matters of fact with a priori arguments. The reason for this claim insists that if something is demonstrable then its contrary implies a contradiction. Nothing that is distinctly conceivable implies a contradiction. Whatever we conceive of as existing we could also conceive of as not existing. So there is no being whose non-existence implies a contradiction. Therefore, there is no being whose existence is demonstrable

The Argument for the Existence of God

1710 words - 7 pages The Argument for the Existence of God It is an undisputed fact that some people claim to have experienced God. It is these religious experiences that have been used by philosophers to argue for the existence of God. The main way of expressing the argument from religious experience is as follows: P1 Someone experiences an entity C1 The entity exists P2 Someone has experienced God C2 God exists Those

Descartes Argument for the Existence of God

1209 words - 5 pages have three sides. Secondly, all the angles of a triangle must add up to 180 degs. These two essential properties of a triangle must always be found together if we want to claim that triangles exist. One without the other is of no value when it comes to triangles. For Descartes this is an example of a clear and distinct idea. It is also an example of necessary existence. In exactly the same way God has two essential properties. Firstly, God’s

Descartes Proof For The Existence Of God

1542 words - 6 pages notices that the idea of his existence is very clear and distinct in his mind; based upon this clarity, and the fact that he has just determined his own existence, he infers that the things that he sees as very clear and very distinct are all true. Descartes employs another interesting rule for his logic, or way of thinking: an objective reality cannot exist without formal reality. That is to say that an idea cannot originate without a cause. The

Proof For the Existence of God

1531 words - 6 pages driving force. The Law of Causality properly states, “Anything which begins to exist must have been brought into existence by something distinct from itself.” Therefore, only something outside of the world could have created the world. Logic and natural law can easily prove that this Being is an All-Powerful God through four different arguments: the Cosmological, Historical, Moral, and Teleological arguments. The strongest of these is the

Analysis of Arguments for the Slavery Institution

495 words - 2 pages Analysis of Arguments for the Slavery Institution The foundation of this paper will highlight the following questions: How might southern apologists for slavery have used the northern “wage slave” discussed in the last chapter to justify slavery? To what extent do you agree with this argument? How did slaves use religious belief and kinship to temper their plight? Did this strategy play into the hands of slaveholders? How were non

Similar Essays

Descartes’ Arguments For The Existence Of Body As Distinct From The Mind And His Justifications To Princess Elizabeth Of Bohemia

1722 words - 7 pages comprehensive attempt to answer the question. In this paper I will examine Descartes’ arguments for the existence of body as distinct from the mind; outline Elisabeth’s objections and proposed solutions, and argue that Descartes’ responses to Elisabeth are inadequate to address the problem of mind-body interaction without resulting in contradiction. Descartes sets out in meditation six to determine what justification there might be for the existence of

Ontological Arguments For The Existence Of God

1647 words - 7 pages ’ epistemological quest for truth finds ground in order to build up the rest of his philosophy. Thus, having proven his own existence beyond doubt, Descartes can now proceed to discover other clear and distinct truth, i.e., God. After Descartes proves his very existence out of the shadow of a doubt, he must now find a perfect and all-knowing God in order to escape the evil genius. For Descartes, sensory experience are all doubtful and thus, he

Aquinas' Arguments For The Existence Of God

1952 words - 8 pages Aquinas' Arguments for the Existence of God In Summa Theologica, Question 2, Article 3, Aquinas attempts to prove the existence of God. He begins with two objections, which will not be addressed here, and continues on to state five arguments for the existence of God. I intend to show that Aquinas' first three arguments are unsound from a scientific standpoint, through support of the Big Bang theory of the creation of

Arguments For The Existence For God

1233 words - 5 pages and ask themselves the question of what caused these two? It is at this point where one is forced to admit that there is an “unmoved mover”, an independent being, and an uncaused cause who is called God. 3. Out of all three arguments for the existence only one of them is based on an a priori knowledge and it is the Ontological Argument. This argument is based on the knowledge that God does exist. In St. Anselm’s presentation of the