This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Overseas Outsourcing Essay

1464 words - 6 pages

In this assignment there will be an analysis of the effectiveness of the rhetorical devices used in two of the articles in the assignment. First, I will address two of the rhetorical devices that were presented in “Ban Outsourcing? Bad Idea” by Manjeet Kripalani. Second, I will review the rhetorical devices that were presented in the article “Outsourcing: the good, the bad and the inevitable”, by Cindy Kibbe. The articles are both strong in opinion and detail with persuasive arguments; the analysis will review the validity, logic, accuracy, misleading statements, ambiguity, and credibility of each article.
Ban Outsourcing? Bad Idea by Manjeet Kripalani
Accomplished journalist, Manjeet Kripalani, in the article, “Ban Outsourcing? Bad Idea”, describes positive impact of the United States (U.S.) outsourcing information technology positions to India and how this can benefit both the United States and India. Kripalani’s purpose is to provide readers a valid viewpoint of the positive impact on the economy in India. She generates a euphemistic approach on the communication to her readers that the United States politicians use this subject or their own gain.
In the first statement, Kripalani utilized the rhetorical device of emotional association, “But U.S. politicians better watch out they don't invoke a backlash, India-style” (Kripalani, 2004). The emotional association is brought to the reader’s attention as she is from India, so her emotional attachment to the country is strong. The strong innuendo that is stated with the “backlash, Indian style” (Kripalani, 2004) is definitely a negative statement of something that is not directly explained in the article. It is not mentioned what the backlash would be if the United States did not stop the negative talk of outsourcing to India for Information system support. This argument due to it’ extreme vagueness is construed as ambiguous, as here are not definite facts that are stated that would tell the readers what the meaning is behind the backlash. Also, the article does not provide the details of what the outcome would be is they use the “India Style”. There is misleading information provided, as there is not validity to the backlash that is stated.
The second statement, Kripalani used the loaded language and comparisons, “Just as jobs are a crucial issue in the upcoming U.S. election, jobs are an issue in India, too” (Kripalani, 2004). The loaded language and comparisons are used to make the readers beliefs and feelings affected by what it is compared to. It is a type of association to an issue that they also have to deal with on a personal level. This will also try to clarify the claim that is made by Kripalani in her article. This statement is effective in the persuasion on the sheer fact that many countries in 2004 were in fact feeling the economic issues. Even if this statement contains truth to the times, it is can be considered a group ambiguous statement as it is made to a group of...

Find Another Essay On Overseas Outsourcing

Outsourcings and its effect on business

1140 words - 5 pages problems or pitfalls with outsourcing, including their effect socially and politically.American Heritage dictionary defines outsourcings as "The procuring of services or products, such as the parts used in manufacturing a motor vehicle, from an outside supplier or manufacturer in order to cut costs." In the past,outsourcing predominately affected the manufacturing sector. Cheap manual labor overseas made it profitable for corporations to shift many

Outsourcing Essay

979 words - 4 pages , the American consumer, have become accustomed to.Although there are many advantages to outsourcing it doesn't come without its disadvantages. When outsourcing overseas or across the border, communication can often be a problem, the difference in language can cause misunderstandings or misinterpretations about work-related directions. Bad relations between the company and the public can also be an issue. Many American's believe that outsourcing

Outsourcing American Jobs

1564 words - 6 pages Introduction Outsourcing of American jobs overseas is displacing American's in the United States. American blue-collar workers and the Middle Class American will soon be a word of the past if the US government continues outsourcing the low-skill jobs overseas. One of the concerns in regards to the outsourcing of jobs is that wages of American jobs versus the wages of the Chinese, Japanese, Indians and Philippians are much less. If

Advantages and disadvantages of outsourcing

802 words - 3 pages being just a management tool to becoming a business-critical process.Outsourcing allows the companies to save monies that can eventually reinvested and often create new jobs. There are also disadvantages to outsourcing. Some drawbacks include the "loss of direct knowledge within a company, and difficulties managing the outsourcing process." Ironically, as much hype that is going on about the mass numbers of companies outsourcing (overseas

Outsourcing and its Effects on Business

3073 words - 12 pages competitiveness, it is wise for the companies to transfer their high-cost professional jobs to low-cost countries.HISTORICAL BACKGROUND OF OUTSOURCINGOutsourcing has been occurring for decades and has using affected the manufacturing sector in the past. Since cheap manual labour was available overseas, corporations became profitable by outsourcing tasks to foreign markets. In the early years in North American History, America outsourced tasks of

Outsourcing: Staying Competitive In The Global Market

1722 words - 7 pages outsourcing a company's best way of cutting costs? Will it actually lower their overall costs or will it create more by moving a part of their business overseas? Organizations need to explore the advantages and disadvantages of important outsourcing issues such as customer service, security, and fiscal impacts, to determine if this strategy will improve their competitiveness in the global market. Security Outsourcing is an attractive option for

What are the ethical issues concerning the outsourcing of jobs by the business community to our society in general?

1220 words - 5 pages What is the defination of outsourcing?Outsourcing is the delegation of tasks or jobs from internal production to an external entity (such as a subcontractor). Most recently, it has come to mean the elimination of in house staff to staff overseas, where salaries are markedly lower. It became a popular buzzword in business and management in the 1990's.Outsourcing is a legal business activity affecting America, and it is an inevitable response to

Labor in the United States and Outsourcing

1158 words - 5 pages outsourcing as they squarely blame it for his or her impoverishment. Despite that an excessively excellent image of outsourcing was provided to individuals one or two of years back, the truth check they were confronted with shattered the dream badly. Recent statistics reveal that over four-hundredth corporations are concerned either in experimenting or are already engaged in shifting their services overseas in search of low-cost labor and

The External Environment for the Development of Foreign Package

1927 words - 8 pages European market growth is expected after following the United States and Japan to become China's offshore outsourcing market, "the third pole." Market share from Europe has grown from 4.5% in 2007 to 7.8%, although still far behind Japan and the U.S., but already has more than 80% growth, Europe will become China's software and information service outsourcing enterprises in overseas development The key areas. 2) The classification by business

The Effects of Outsourcing in America

1354 words - 5 pages ). This quote indicates that there is a large potential for jobs that can go overseas, meaning that the growth of outsourcing could skyrocket, which would make the trade deficit increase, plunging the U.S. into greater debt than is the current dilemma. On the other hand, other research sustains that outsourcing may actually have positive effects on the U.S. economy, rather than crippling it as the previous evidence proposes. Some researchers

An American Economy

916 words - 4 pages closer inspection, the reverse may be true. Job outsourcing, though initially stressing on the workforce, is helpful in creating a strong economy. Job outsourcing creates an initial job loss to the area in which it concerns. This happens because in a global economy, the idea is to move ones workforce to the most efficient location. Of the outsourcing that occurs in the US, less than 30% was even sent overseas (Reed Business Information, 7

Similar Essays

Discuss The Impact Of Overseas Outsourcing

548 words - 2 pages In researching this subject it seems that outsourcing work overseas has a positive and negative effect on the US economy for a few different reasons. The most important I feel is taking the jobs away from the people in the United States. As we all know, especially at this time, jobs are not easy to find. There are some people that are under qualified for jobs available in the US that these jobs we are outsourcing could be done by these under

Shifting Jobs Overseas, With Outsourcing Essay

515 words - 2 pages in the increasing "offshoring aand outsourcing". The 2006 report of one real estate corporation claims that millions of square feet of U. S. office space were not used during year leading to "$1.2 billion in annual rent losses for real estate corporations. Explanation of that phenomenon could be found in the fact of the offshoring of white-collar jobs. Results of research shows that is not offshoring, at least 54 million square feet could be

What Is Outsourcing Essay

2180 words - 9 pages manufacturing, Americans worker are fighting to resist the push to send jobs overseas (Strassmann, 1995). Although it has not yet passed in the Senate, there is a movement to limit the outsourcing of work paid for with federal funds. Democrats are using this political lever in campaigning against the difficult economy under President Bush (Hayes, 1994). Within the pros and cons of outsourcing, there are different viewpoints. There’s the company’s stand

Outsourcing And Off Shoring Is Unethical

651 words - 3 pages productivity growth in the concluding half of the decade. Any cost saving from outsourcing and off shoring is productive gain for businesses. On the other hand, manufacturing workers from the middle class are seeing their wages pressured downward. For the most part, white- collar industries viewed as unwavering and less invincible to global competition are seeing their jobs also now moved overseas shedding light certain jobs, and certain