This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Overview Of Authorship Attribution Essay

2839 words - 11 pages

Authorship attribution is one of the largest areas of Forensic Linguistics. It entails determining who wrote, or more commonly, ruling out who wrote a text when authorship is unclear. Linguists assume that each particular choice the writer makes as a whole will enable identification as authors are consistent in their choices. Linguists have three main problematic scenarios when attempting authorship attribution; there is no candidate set and a profile is required, there are many candidates for a limited sample and verification where one determines whether the suspect is the author or not. In regards to whether a communication was written by the suspect or deceased, we would need to focus upon the third scenario. Documents that would entail authorship dispute regarding a deceased individual would include wills, last testaments and suicide notes.

In the case of a suicide note being left behind the linguist has several issues to consider. Most importantly, why the deceased may have committed suicide. Normally it has little relevance to the linguist why a person commits a crime or does something but knowing the reasons why will help distinguish genuine from simulated and it is almost always the first question relatives ask. In order to discover why, it is useful to know what friends and family feel after initial grief. Common views are that the person was crazy, a coward or a loser. This popular view of suicide helps the linguist to an extent as a fake suicide note is more likely to reflect popular attitudes instead of how the person actually feels.

One of the main approaches to the methodology of authorship attribution is the Unitary Invariant Approach which was pioneered by Mendenhall (1887) who sought to distinguish the literary style of those such as Bacon and Shakespeare. This attempt at a scientific approach was based on the assumption that a unique curve would appear which showed the relationship between word length and relative frequency and could be used to identify an author where none was known. By the twentieth century those such as Zipf (1932) and Yule (1944) helped to update this method through the suggestion that a feature or marker such as sentence length could help identify a possible author. However, they admit themselves that this method using statistics is unreliable (Sichel 1986; Burrows 1992; Grieve 2007) especially for the much shorter texts that many Forensic Linguists have to work with.
Another key moment that revolutionised authorship attribution was Mosteller and Wallace’s (1964) work on the Federalist papers. They argued that stylometrics (which combined information from textual clues) was more successful in authorship attribution. By analysing the frequencies of functioning grammar words it yielded a reliable method which opened up the field to new textual features and modelling techniques. Principal components analysis (PCA) furthered this idea and found that “if good separation is seen between...

Find Another Essay On Overview of Authorship Attribution

Computer-Assisted Text Analysis

740 words - 3 pages and availability and power of computational tools, there has been an increasing amount of humanities computing literature on text analysis and interpretation. Studies of this kind are generally classified under the broad heading computer-assisted text analysis (CATA). CATA includes numerous applications including authorship attribution, stylometric analysis, thematic analysis, the use of imagery, genre classification, characterization, and textual

An Early Feminist: An Essay in Defence of the Female Sex

881 words - 4 pages opportunity to education. (Jones ,1990). Works Cited. Smith, Hannah. "Abstract: English 'Feminist' Writings and Judith Drake's An Essay in Defence of the Female Sex (1696)." The Historical Journal. Cambridge University Press, 2001. 18 December 2006 . Devereaux, Johanna “Affecting the Shade”: Attribution, Authorship, and Anonymity in An Essay in Defence of the Female

Deference and Reference of Authorship in Dictee

2145 words - 9 pages variety of media in Dictee multiples the book’s unusualness. Identification of the plurality inherent in the material and structural levels of Dictee shows that the contradictions originate from considering Dictee as a ‘work’. Roland Barthes’s approach gives a more accurate description of Dictee, as a collection of self-deference. Yet, whereas Barthes claims the complete removal of the author from the text, Cha manages to assert her authorship

Analyzing the Writings of Thomas Hardy

1111 words - 4 pages found will contain only the relevant documents. • The study has gone some way towards issues of authorship attribution. Exploratory multivariate analysis methods proved successful too in identifying authors. In this they are recommended as effective methods for authorship problems. • The current findings add to a growing body of literature on Thomas Hardy’s Wessex. • There is much agreement between the classification proposed in this study and

Self-Plagiarism is Allowed by Jewish Law

1459 words - 6 pages world. However, is self-plagiarism considered a form of stealing according to Jewish law or is it just frowned upon by society. According to Green, a professor of law, plagiarism is a relatively recent concept which started sometime in the eighteenth century: It was not, until the Romantic Era of the eighteenth century—when the notion of “authorship” and “originality” emerged as significant cultural values—that the norm of attribution and the

Thou Shalt Not Steal: Should Self-Plagiarism be Allowed in Colleges

1406 words - 6 pages world. However, is self-plagiarism really considered a form of stealing or is it actually allowed and just frowned upon by professors? According to Green, a professor of law, plagiarism is a relatively recent concept which started sometime in the eighteenth century: It was not, until the Romantic Era of the eighteenth century—when the notion of “authorship” and “originality” emerged as significant cultural values—that the norm of attribution and the

Memory and Text in Dictee

2184 words - 9 pages manages to assert her authorship by deliberately altering details of the Text, as if her memories are blurry. Working with the pluralities of material, structure, and readership, Cha posits Dictee as the Text projected through the author’s memory. The usage of plural media in Dictee informs the reader that interpretive reading, the traditional method of dealing with literary works, does not work. It is different to classify Dictee into one genre


2076 words - 8 pages privacy in certain films and photographs. Also included was, the right to not have the false attribution of Authorship, which already existed but in a somewhat different form under the Copyright Act 1956 . These shall all be discussed in depth with references to specific case law and in comparison with other copyright legislation.It is firstly necessary to understand the main difference between moral rights and other rights contained in the Copyright

Analysis: Pagan Survivals by Tomás Ó Cathasaigh

1158 words - 5 pages disentangled. However, he remarks that Ireland has the benefit of a large body of literature from an early medieval time, a set of literature marked by an evident interest in pre-Christian mythology. While potential avenues of discussion regarding these works are vast and equally complex, the article instead chooses to limit itself to an overview of the methodology utilized for the study of early Irish narrative. The purpose of the overview is to

The Rhetoric of the Book of Hebrews

3186 words - 13 pages the author needn’t be the choice for the addressees and he attempts to persuade them by straightening up their theology about Christ. Authorship Scholars have not been able to agree on who is the author of this instructive book. The debate continues, hopeful there will be a consensus among the academia sometime later. Many names have been associated with the authorship of the by scholars. Notable among them is Paul, whose attribution is

Latin American Research seminar - Latin American history - Assignment

2688 words - 11 pages to deal critically with the main issues and documents of Latin American history · Preparation for intermediate and advanced college courses by making demands equivalent to those made by full-year introductory college courses · Analysis and interpretation of primary and secondary sources— their relevance, historical context, authorship, intention, point of view, their reliability, and their importance — and weigh the evidence and interpretations

Similar Essays

Stylometry: Quantitative Investigation Into The Characteristics Of An Author's Style

2261 words - 9 pages so established in stylometry that it is unusual to find papers which do not use them” (1998: 114). 2-2-4 Authorship attribution Authorship attribution is the process of looking for salient features in a literary work that relates the work to its author. Craig (2004) points out that “authorship studies aim at ‘yes or no’ resolutions to existing problems, and avoid perceptible features if possible, working at the base strata of language where

Role Of Homoeroticism Essay

3373 words - 13 pages distinctive tenor of Hazlitt's written 'voice', he distinguishes both the lexical and syntactical features of his prose and 'the twists and turns of thought, packed into a small space' (II 271): as he asserts, 'though one may imitate his style, his mind is beyond imitation' (I lxi). In the process of attribution, circumstantial evidence for Hazlitt's authorship of specific texts is supported by such persuasive stylistic markers as the paradoxical

Lakira James Rough Draft Essay

644 words - 3 pages of his poems was about an egalitarian view of the races and his attitude in life reflected many of the racial prejudices common to the nineteenth -century his opposition to slavery was not necessarily based on belief in the equality of races. Paragraph 7: Whitman was adherent of the Shakespeare authorship question, refusing to believe in historic attribution of the works to William Shakespeare of Stafford upon Avon. In his November boughs he

Did Shakespeare Really Write Everything? Essay

1619 words - 6 pages . Theatre demand for scripts was sky-rocketing. As a result, people banded together in order to finish writing plays faster (Hope 3). Therefore, it is plausible to conclude that a group of people may have written the works commonly attributed to William Shakespeare. Another issue clouding the legitimacy of Shakespeare's authorship is that many famous authors and figures have been accused of either passing Shakespeare's work as their own, or passing