This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Summary Of Stanley Milgram's Prison Experiment And "The Abu Ghraib Prison Scandal: Sources Of Sadism" By Marianne Szegedy Maszak.

778 words - 3 pages

In “The Abu Ghraib Prison Scandal: Sources of Sadism” by Marianne Szegedy-Maszak, Szegedy-Maszak says that rationalizing the stark change in mentality of the young American soldiers who kept watch over the Iraqi prisoners in the Abu Ghraib prison would be a very challenging task. Some may blame inexperience or dereliction of duty by commanding officers. Others may say that stress caused by living in a war zone was responsible. However, it has become clear that no single reason would be sufficient to completely explain the events at Abu Ghraib prison.Throughout this essay, Szegedy-Maszak attempts to answer the question: “Are there particular conditions in Iraq that might shed light on why these soldiers committed these unconscionable acts?” (Szegedy-Maszak p. 173). She begins by presenting two famous psychological experiments that “explore the capacity for evil residing in “normal” people,” (Szegedy-Maszak p. 174). The first experiment, conducted by Stanford psychologist Philip Zimbardo, attempted to mimic a real life prison scenario with students impersonating actual guards and prisoners. Surprisingly, the results were analogous to the actual events that took place at Abu Ghraib prison. The second experiment, created by Stanley Milgram, studied some people’s willingness to follow orders. The experiment began with an actor sitting in a chair supposedly wired with electricity. For every wrong answer this actor would give, volunteers were asked to deliver increasingly dangerous electric shocks to the actor in the chair. The results showed that two out of the three volunteers delivered potentially lethal electric shocks.Judging by the outcomes of these two experiments, Szegedy-Maszak concludes that some evil may be present within human nature. To help tie the results of these experiments in with the Abu Ghraib prison scandal, Szegedy-Maszak references Robert Okin, a professor of psychiatry at the University of California San Francisco, who said that “the abuse [in Abu Ghraib] became an inexcusable way of working off [the soldiers’] rage, anxiety about their own safety, and their sense of helplessness.” (Szegedy-Maszak p. 174) These feelings, along with the stress of living in a war zone, may have driven the soldiers to commit such heinous crimes.Szegedy-Maszak determines that another possible reason for the soldiers’ actions was the lack of a place where the soldiers could fulfill their sexual desires. It is...

Find Another Essay On Summary of Stanley Milgram's Prison Experiment and "The Abu Ghraib Prison Scandal: Sources of Sadism" by Marianne Szegedy-Maszak.

The Standrof Prison Experiment Essay

588 words - 3 pages experience the students revealed no lasting negative affects but learned a lesson. They should never underestimate the power of a bad situation that overpowered the personality of even the most behave and smart student, a system that made the situation possible by creating a realistic prison. The experiment presented raises many questions about how well we know ourselves whether we appreciate the power of external forces. The prison experiment deals

Stanford Prison Experiment Essay

772 words - 4 pages Gandhi once said “Our thoughts become our words, our words become our actions, our actions become our character, our character becomes our destiny.” That very quote was proven in the 1973 Stanford Prison Experiment conducted by Philip Zimbardo. Zimbardo placed an ad in the newspaper asking for young males to par take in his experiment with in return getting paid $15 a day. Out of 75 volunteers 24 were chosen as participants. Zimbardo randomly

Stanford Prison Experiment

1338 words - 5 pages When put into an authoritative position over others, is it possible to claim that with this new power individual(s) would be fair and ethical or could it be said that ones true colors would show? A group of researchers, headed by Stanford University psychologist Philip G. Zimbardo, designed and executed an unusual experiment that used a mock prison setting, with college students role-playing either as prisoners or guards to test the power of

The Stanford Prison Experiment: Philip Zimbardo

1937 words - 8 pages nailed to the floor and a metal toilet which is also nailed to the floor. They close the metal bars behind you and it’s loud. Then all you can hear are the chains of your neighbors. All of this, and you're innocent. These are the events that happened to twenty four college males who participated in the Stanford Prison Experiment. This is just one example of many controversial psychological experiments. Certain psychological experiments

Comparing Views on Stanley Milgram's Experiment on Obedience

1168 words - 5 pages Milgram’s stimulated the creation of several responsive articles. Two articles that respond to this experiment are authored by Diane Baumrind and Ian Parker. These two authors attempt to review the methods, results, and ethical issues of Milgram’s experiment. “Review of Stanley Milgram’s Experiments of Obedience” was written by Diane Baumrind. Baumrind is a psychologist at the Institute of Human Development at the University of California

Revisiting the Stanford Prison Experiment: a Lesson in the Power of Situation Critique

893 words - 4 pages ," (Zimbardo, 2007, p. 4). The Stanford Prison Experiment is compared to the Abu Ghraib situation, and also discussed are the implications of this research to the criminal justice system. The problems specified in the article addresses the social power of groups and as to whether a person could be influenced to exert power over someone else. The experiment called for twenty-four student participants to act as either a prisoner or a guard in the "prison

The Stanford Prison Experiment: Taking a Deeper Look

1023 words - 5 pages . The volunteers were unaware of the process of the experiment, let alone what they were getting themselves into. They were in shock about what was happening to them. Once taken into the facility, the experimenters had set up as their own private jail system; the twenty-four volunteered individuals were split up into two different groups (Stanford Prison Experiment). By the flip of a coin, 12 members were assigned to act as prison guards and the

The Stanford Prison Experiment - Choosing to Remain A Prisoner

1015 words - 5 pages Allowing & Choosing to be a Prisoner The Stanford Prison Experiment was a great example of how people can become imprisoned by accepting the roles others assigned to them. Also, some of them remained prisoners because they did not want to be scrutinized by the other participants for trying to be different. Furthermore, the experiment demonstrated how people will go along with something even if they don’t want to. As children most of us are

Crossing The Line Question Posed By Instructor: Describe how The Stanford Prison Experiment relates to an event in history

1406 words - 6 pages in action. So what would people who had undergone stringent psychological evaluations and testing be doing torturing people in the most inhumane ways imaginable? Was it just a few bad apples, or could it be something more? We can get a better understanding of what happened at Abu Ghraib by taking a closer look at The Stanford Prison Experiment conducted by Dr. Philip Zimbardo in 1971. In this experiment a group of young men answered an ad in a

Abu Ghraib and Guantanamo Bay: The Safety of Nations or the Rights of Few?

1107 words - 5 pages Ritchie 1 The hood goes on and darkness closes in, the snide laughter of soldiers can be heard, the buzzing of the electricity running through the wires grows closer, the growling of dogs sounds as they stand nearby, ready to attack--these are the haunting sights and sounds remembered by detainees from Abu Ghraib and Guantanamo Bay prison camps. Located 20 miles west of Baghdad, the 280-acre prison camp of Abu Ghraib housed as many as 3,800

Was Stanley Milgram's Study Of Obedience Unethical

726 words - 3 pages whether an experiment is ethical. A small degree of suffering by the subject can be tolerated if no better way can be found to obtain the important and beneficial information desired in the experiment and if the subject's suffering is quickly and fully alleviated after the experiment. When questioning whether Stanley Milgram's study of obedience is ethical, one must address these questions in the context of his experiment.The purpose of Milgram's

Similar Essays

Comparitive Critique Of Stanley Milgram's Prison Experiment And "The Abu Ghraib Prison Scandal: Sources Of Sadism" By Marianne Szegedy Maszak

1529 words - 6 pages prison environment affects the guards who work there. In her article "The Abu Ghraib Prison Scandal: Sources of Sadism", Marianne Szegedy-Maszak looks at the Abu Ghraib atrocities and the possible reasons why "normal" people turned into sadists who committed unfathomable acts of torture. Although Szegedy-Maszak and Zimbardo both suggest that every person has the potential to be a torturer, Zimbardo's experiment adds specificity to Szegedy-Maszak's

This Paper Covers The Scandal Of Prisoner Abuse In Abu Ghraib In Iraq

896 words - 4 pages environment where soldiers are placed in a position of power, it is understandable to see them turn into sadists. "Abu Ghraib also has three traits the psychologist Herbet Kelman has described as necessary for torture; authorization, routinization, and dehumanization" (Szegedy-Maszak 1). This shows that soldiers in Iraq are capable of becoming sadists and abusing prisoners without any orders from a higher official.The scandal going on in Iraq right

The Ethics Of The Stanford Prison Experiment

941 words - 4 pages worked in a real prison. As for the prisoners, real police surprised them at their homes and arrested them outside where others could see as if they were really criminals. They were then blindfolded and taken to the mock prison in the basement of a Stanford Psychology building that had been decorated to look like a prison where guards fingerprinted, deloused, and gave prisoners a number which they would be called by for the rest of the experiment

The Implications Of The Stanford Prison Experiment

1115 words - 4 pages shock if encouraged by a figure of authority. This coincides with a popular explanation from soldiers who have committed war crimes "I was just following orders". Whilst studying this thought provoking topic I have composed several ideas on how humanity can develop from the concepts learnt from the Stanford prison experiment. The experiment put good people in an evil environment and the results showed the people became evil