Paideia And The Matter Of Mind

3442 words - 14 pages

Paideia and the "Matter of Mind"

ABSTRACT: Paideia refers to a particular sort of education which has historically been concerned with learning for the sake of learning, i.e., for the development of mind. As such, paideia is distinguished from specialized learning, training and learning for extrinsic purposes. Paideia is embodied in the traditional notion of Liberal Education which holds that such an education is the development of mind through the achievement of worthwhile knowledge and understanding. A contemporary trend in the literature of philosophy of mind and epistemology is a concern with cognitive functions of the human mind and the role of these functions in the acquisition of knowledge. The functional conception of the mind emphasizes learning (cognitive development) through cognitive training to monitor and control one's own mental processes. The uncritical incorporation of cognitive theories of mind and knowledge acquisition into current educational theory and practice suggests that paideia can be combined with, if not enhanced by, cognitive training. This paper takes the position that such an assumption is misguided and that the 'matter' of mind is an issue which requires clarification for advocates of paideia. The paper contrasts the cognitive approach to a 'conventionalist' conception of mind which, arguably, is the concept of mind assumed by advocates of paideia.

Paideia refers to a particular sort of education which historically has been concerned with learning for the sake of learning, i.e., for the development of mind. As such, paideia is distinguished from specialized learning, training, and learning for extrinsic purposes. Paideia is embodied in the traditional notion of Liberal Education which holds that such an education is the development of mind through the achievement of worthwhile knowledge and understanding.

No modern philosopher of mind or epistemologist explicitly denies that there is a relationship between knowledge, mind and education. Nevertheless, a contemporary "trend" in the literature of epistemology and philosophy of mind is a concern with the cognitive functions of the human mind, e.g., the conception of mind as an information-processing system, and with the function of these information-bearing processes in the acquisition of knowledge. (1) The emphasis in this literature is on either: i) theories of knowledge acquisition which do not refer to the development of mind through education or conversely; ii) theories of mind which ignore the consequences of such conceptions for the achievement of worthwhile knowledge. Both sorts of theories are supported by current research in cognitive science and psychology. (2)

The uncritical incorporation of such "theories" of mind and knowledge acquisition in contemporary educational theory and practice suggests that the concept of paideia can be combined with (if not enhanced) by cognitive research on learning and cognitive training to proficiently monitor...

Find Another Essay On Paideia and the Matter of Mind

States of Matter and How Matter Changes

2164 words - 9 pages Matter is defined as anything that occupies space and can be perceived by one or more senses; a physical body, a physical substance, or the universe as a whole. There are four distinct states of matter: solids, liquids, gases, and plasma. There are other states of matter such as Bose-Einstein condensates and neutron degenerate matter, but those states can only be found under extreme conditions. These phases can go from one to another when

Argument and Discussion Against Smoking Mind over Matter

1309 words - 5 pages   Argument against Smoking Mind over Matter “Nicotine patches and gum are common -- and often ineffective -- ways of fighting cigarette cravings, as most smokers have discovered. Now a new study from the American Friends of Tel Aviv University (AFTAU) shows why they're ineffective, and may provide the basis for more successful psychologically based smoking cessation programs” (American Friends, 2010). With smoking some feel that willpower

Of Ideas, the Mind, and the Universe

1315 words - 5 pages ’ proposition by asking him to imagine a world in which the idea of extension or motion is abstracted from the secondary qualities. Hylas confesses that he cannot and Philonous explains that there is no distinction between primary and secondary qualities, as both exist solely in the mind . The discussion now moves from the subjective qualities of matter to the nature of matter. Philonous explains that while he believes that all sensible qualities and

The Meaning of The Mind and Soul

1059 words - 4 pages Death and immortality Since the times of Plato and before, humans have pondered the existence of a soul and the afterlife. I am going to present my argument for the existence of a soul and the potential for surviving one's physical death. For the purpose of my argument I will define that the meaning of the mind and soul are one and the same. The two main accepted views of the human condition are that of the physicalist and that of the dualist

Theories of the Mind and Existence

874 words - 3 pages the universe, but act together in one great cosmic dance that David Bohm called the 'holomovement'.(11) Bohm advocated an unbroken and undivided wholeness where the observing instrument is inseparable from what is observed. Curious correlations between the properties of distant systems implies that "with the implicate order, mind enfolds matter in general and therefore the body in particular. Similarly, the body enfolds not only the mind but also

Electric Charge and the Electrical Structure of Matter

1656 words - 7 pages 15.1 Electric Charge and the Electrical Structure of MatterFundamental Law of Electric Charge:Opposite electric charges attract each other. Similar electric charges repel each other.A Simple Model of the Structure of Matter1. All matter is composed of sub-microscopic particles, called atoms.2. Electric charges are carried by particles within each atom that are called electrons and protons.3. Protons are found in a small central region of the

Decreasing Brain Matter In Schizophrenia! Scientific Tests And Progress Of Testing And Preventing The Degeneration Of Gray Matter

1378 words - 6 pages Decreasing Brain Matter in SchizophreniaAbstractSchizophrenia is a primary focus in the medical community due to its complexity, the lack of understanding about it, and increasing need for treatment in the field of neuropsychiatry. It is thought that the progression of the disorder influences its severity of schizophrenia, which in turn is perceived to be caused by degeneration in the hippocampal, cerebral and peripheral gray matter, peripheral

A Matter of The Heart

1524 words - 6 pages Sin is like an open sore that if left to fester will continue to grow worse not improve. Nathaniel Hawthorne examines this concept, as he seeks to connect with his reader. Many of his works revolve around a theme of sin and the effects it has on the mind, body, and soul. Sin is one of those permeating areas that has lasting consequences that affect all of life. Many characters in Hawthorne’s works go through their lives struggling as they try

Andrew And The Mind

1279 words - 5 pages has a mind. Firstly, Andrew could pass the Turing test. The Turing test, devised by A. M. Turing, is the definitive test for determining whether or not a machine has mind. The test, called by Turing the "Imitation Game," consists of 3 players. One player is an interrogator and the other two, being of opposite sex, are placed in a separate room. The object of the game is for the interrogator to determine which player is the female and which is the

Descartes and the mind

1105 words - 5 pages Descartes and the mind The topic of the mind and how do we know has been around since the beginning of time. It is one of those questions that will most likely never be answered. I mean, the mind itself is so perplexing that we are still learning stuff about it daily. One question that Descartes proposed was “how do we know?” we still are pondering this one today. We ask it almost every day, maybe not in that way but in some form or another

Yoga and the Mind

1074 words - 5 pages “Conquer the mind and you can conquer anything.” That is a popular saying amongst Yogis (yoga instructors) very few people recognize the truth and meaning behind this statement. There is a clear connection between the health benefits associated with yoga having to do with the body, power strength, balance, flexibility. Few people are aware of the multiple benefits it can serve for the brain and mind as well. Is there a clear benefit and

Similar Essays

Spring Reawakened: The Mind And Matter Of Rock And Rebellion

1741 words - 7 pages What constitutes a rebellion against conformity? Is the desire for revolution a matter of action or simply a state of mind? In the 1990s, America’s counterculture was founded on the alternative, grunge, and punk rock movements that embodied the spirit of intrapersonal tension and social upheaval. The ideas emphasized through this counterculture have utilized and influenced many art forms, including theatre. Steven Sater’s Spring Awakening

Mind Over Matter: The Effects Of Cocaine

679 words - 3 pages Coca plants may be just a plant. However, coca contains a popular and much known element that is extracted from its leaves and traced back many decades ago. An element that is manipulated and can be transformed into a mind altering, euphoric, and abused substance. The effects of Cocaine are not only to the body, but our main control center, the Central Nervous system. Whether snorted or smoked cocaine’s psychoactive effects are known to be

Rhetoric, Paideia And The Phaedrus Essay

3353 words - 13 pages Rhetoric, Paideia and the Phaedrus ABSTRACT: Some of the notorious interpretive puzzles of the Phaedrus arise from reading it in terms of a static version of mimesis; hence, the concerns about its apparent failure to enact its own norms and the status of its own self-commentaries. However, if the dialogue is read in the light of the more dynamic model of a perfectionist paideia — that is, Plato’s portrayal of Socrates as attempting to woo

Mind Over Matter: The Unique Components Of Womanhood & Depressive Disorders

2176 words - 9 pages various components of how the female mind works, however for the interim we as women can embrace our natural tendency to be “emotion-focused” and strive to place our minds, our thoughts, our reactions above the inevitable tough times in life. But for those of us suffering from depression, cognitive interventions can be a lifeline, if only for a day to get you to the next. Because as I’ve laid out depressive disorders are a complicated bunch, there is