Paine Vs Plain What Is The Truth? Us History Article

1703 words - 7 pages

Paine vs “Plain”
A debate over loyalty and rebellion by Thomas Paine (author of “Common Sense”) and James Chalmers (author of “Plain Truth”)
Thomas Paine's Common Sense was like a lightning bolt in the colonies. Its message was simple: Britain had no right to govern America, the Monarchy system itself was basically corrupt, and Americans would be much better off on their own. His arguments certainly struck a chord. The French and Indian War of the 1750s had shown the colonists just how far they had drifted from their English counterparts in nearly every aspect of politics and culture. England saw colonists as crude and uneducated, while the English were seen as drunk with power and subservient to a monarchy that had no meaning to the average colonist, who pretty much lived by his own rules.
Not everyone, though, read Paine's work and nodded with approval. Hard-core loyalists were realizing that they had been blindsided by a powerful piece of propaganda. Anxious to put out the fires that Common Sense was igniting, they attempted to strike back. One of the very first to do so was a gentleman of means from the colony of Maryland -- a planter named James Chalmers.
While Paine had written in the plainest language possible in order to reach the common man with his argument, Chalmers took the high road with a strong emphasis on literary references and history through the ages. A semiliterate blacksmith who could muddle his way through Common Sense must have looked at “Plain Truth” and shrugged his shoulders. Many educated and learned men were already loyalists.
By the time of the revolution, the American colonies were about the best place in the world to live. Opportunity was everywhere, land on the frontier was for the taking (or stealing as the case may be) and taxes were almost nonexistent in comparison to what the inhabitants of England were forced to pay. Best of all, the heavy-handed authority of King George and Parliament was diffused by several thousand miles of ocean.
…[in his pamphlet, Chalmers] moved on to the heart of all loyalist argument: the colonists couldn't possibly win a war against Great Britain. At every level, England outgunned and outmanned the colonies. On paper, the weakness of the colonies was almost comical. A nonexistent navy, badly disciplined recruits, and a great scarcity of heavy industry to produce arms and ammunition combined to create the picture of a colony of wishful thinkers who didn't stand a chance once England roused what Shakespeare called "its sleeping sword."
…Chalmers felt that a simple desire for liberty wasn't enough to keep the colonists from losing a war with England. Alone, they didn't stand a chance. To win, they would have to have a great European power such as France or Spain on their side.
Here, Chalmers made an important and often overlooked observation: he found it illogical for any foreign power to side with the colonists against England, and with good reason. "Can we be so deluded, to expect aid...

Find Another Essay On Paine vs Plain what is the truth? - US History - Article

Truth, what is it? Essay

629 words - 3 pages Ultimately, the objective content of true truthfulness. All truth is objective: its content does not depend on the subject, his intentions or will. A correct answer to the question, "What is truth?" presupposes apperception of the fact that outside our consciousness there subsists an illimitable world developing according to objective laws. Truth is the precise reflection of the object in the consciousness of the subject. Authenticity is the

Secrets vs. the Truth Essay

512 words - 2 pages A civilization based on fear, hatred, and cruelty would have a good chance in enduring. There are many people that agree that indeed it takes violence and hatred in order for a government to succeed. As in George Orwell's novel 1984, or the history behind Joseph Stalin, which demonstrates how installing fear in people and making them believe hate is a good factor for a government. Therefore, the traits can be included in having stable

Truth: What is its Purpose?

2061 words - 8 pages , culture, history, etc. but to convey a deeper meaning than chronological events. The question must not be, is this story true, but instead, what is reason behind the telling of this story. In TTTC, the point of each story and each reiteration is the psychological need to work through the trauma the characters faced in Viet Nam. The analysis of O’Brien’s latest novel can be centered on the meaning behind the telling of each story. The questions

thomas paine with the pamphlet common sense - history - assignment

4100 words - 17 pages England,” and damning reconciliation as “truly farcical” and “a fallacious dream.” To think otherwise, he charged, was “absurd,” “unmanly,” and “repugnant to reason.” As Virginian Landon Carter wrote in dismay, Paine implied that anyone who disagreed with him “is nothing short of a coward and a sycophant [stooge/lackey], which in plain meaning must be a damned rascal.”6 Paine knew what he was doing: the pen was his weapon, and words his ammunition. He

The Surprising Truth About What Motivates Us by Daniel H. Pink

1073 words - 4 pages Psychology test do not have to be a stressful thing; test scores can go up with just a few changes by the professor. In Drive: The Surprising Truth About What Motivates Us, Daniel H. Pink explains that Motivation 3.0 Autonomy is giving a person the freedom to do things in their own way which produces better result because Motivation 3.0 “presumes that people want to be accountable-and making sure they have control over their task, their time

Book Review-Drive: The Surprising Truth About What Motivates Us: Daniel Pink

638 words - 3 pages lessons with meaningful application that encourages student autonomy and provide opportunities for individuals to demonstrate autonomy in their achievements. “We should focus our efforts on creating environments for our innate psychological needs to flourish.” (p. 72) and remember that “Positive feedback can have an enhancing effect on intrinsic motivation.” (p.67) Works Cited Drive: The Surprising Truth About What Motivates Us: Daniel Pink

What is The Problem with the US Correctional Systems

2033 words - 8 pages Rehabilitation (CDCR), Capital Punishment is a legal infliction of death as a penalty for violating criminal law. In addition, throughout history people have been put to death for various forms of wrongdoing. The methods of execution include such as practices of crucifixion, stoning, drowning, burning at the stakes stabbing, and of course beheading. Today, in most states, capital punishment is typically accomplished by lethal gas or injection

Feature article "Truth is never pure and simple"

601 words - 2 pages congratulates all three; Brian, Brooke and Emma for the story, we then see him taking full credit of the story as he speaks to the 'upstairs' bosses. Brian is a ruthless and unscrupulous manipulator of people and the truth, and therefore a great example of what I am trying to prove that 'truth is never pure and simple'

This is an Article analysis for an Economics class. Examines the US economy and inflation

627 words - 3 pages If someone earns a sum of money, and saves it rather than spends it, then, in no way can a person be losing wealth if not for inflation, which prompts the prices of all goods and services to rise. One may see this as a trend among businesses to maximize their profits. In reality, the root cause of the problem is not with businesspeople, but the Federal Reserve System continuously adding more money into the economy. The article I have chosen to

Does the truth really set us free?

1394 words - 6 pages the understanding of how the entire situation had unfolded. At this point, her only true goal is to protect what she now knows to be true, and she begins to beg and plead with Oedipus not search for the truth any longer: IOCASTE. Why think of him? Forget this herdsman. Forget it all This talk is a waste of time. OEDIPUS. How can you say that, When the clues to my true birth are in my hands? IOCASTE. For God’s love, let us have no more

Would America be What it is Today Without Slavery? - Early US History - Essay

1622 words - 7 pages 1 Cole Stephen Cole Dr. James Hill Early US History 1063 27 September 2017 Would America be what it is today without slavery and servitude? The answer to this question is simply no. Since the first settlers arrived in the Americas, slavery was apart of their lives here. Christopher Columbus, after arriving in the Americas, immediately began capturing the native people and put them into forced labor. Forced labor was embedded into the deep roots

Similar Essays

What Is The Truth? Essay

1764 words - 8 pages Before I begin to pen ink on paper I want to ask you a question. “What is the truth?” I like any prolific author am trying to be concise about my whole contexts. Before long it suffices me to say you will know enough and be equipped well enough to understand the discontinuity of these passages. I want to make it clear that before your journey reaches its end you will come across many liars. Many books, characters, its plot holes and all its

History: Southern American History: The Roswell Mystery. What Do You Think Is The Truth?

1020 words - 4 pages suspicious.Based on the evidence stated above, the UFO theory seems more reliable. The US government changed their statement twice, which makes people doubt the reliability of what they say. It is most likely they are covering up the truth behind this mystery. Therefore, I believe that the UFO theory to be a reasonable explanation.Bibliography:Stenner, J. (2000). The Roswell Mystery; A History X-File. Classroom Resources Ltd. Bristol, EnglandStrange and

"History Vs Hollywood: The Truth Behind Braveheart"

1259 words - 5 pages surrounding "Braveheart", but this is to be expected. In order to make a successful film they felt they needed to add what's exciting while omitting what isn't. The film was obviously a huge success because of its entertainment value, but this is unfortunately at the expense of the actual History behind the story. To be fair there are many aspects of Sir William Wallace's life that are unclear or unknown, and the essence of the majority of the

History And What Is Teaches Us

559 words - 2 pages "History teaches that history teaches us nothing". These are the words of the great German philosopher Georg Wilhelm Friedrich Hegel. Whilst forming my response to these remarkable words, I stumbled upon the words of many other laureates, intellectuals and philosophers, who have also challenged the reasoning and thought of man. And through the words of these individuals I tried to make sense of this astute pun. This pun is blatantly harsh. And