Mainstream International Relations Has Excluded Multiplicity Of Voices And Issues

4188 words - 17 pages

For the most part of second half of twentieth century, realist mode of thinking had dominated the discipline of international relations (IR), at least in the United States. Scholars and diplomats such as Hans Morgenthau and Henry Kissinger steered US foreign policy towards a state centric realist ‘highway’. The main signposts on that highway, among many others, were anarchy, national security, sovereignty and power politics. However, in 1960s, realism came under attack for its lack of scientific vigor. In response to their critics, neo-realists attempted to develop their methodology on a truly ‘positivist’ grounds to account for an objective and universal ‘science’ of IR (Tickner, 1992; 11). In the subsequent decades, realist ideology, along with its dominant positivist methodology, was confronted by multiple schools of thought. Notable among these are, liberal institutionalism, Marxism, constructivism and Critical theory of Frankfort School. The particular ‘voices of dissent’ (George & Campbell, 1990; 269) under consideration in this paper, however, are postmodern and feminist responses to mainstream realist and liberal IR theory. In the light of post-structural and feminist insights to social theory and knowledge construction, the paper endeavors to build on the thesis that mainstream IR has been narrowly defined and contested by the dominant players of the field. In carrying out this narrowly defined ‘modernist’ project, it is argued here that mainstream IR has excluded multiplicity of voices and issues. Furthermore, these voices and issues not only have the potential to bring their unique insights to IR, but are also sensitive to changes in international affairs. The second part of argument flows naturally from the first preposition and tries to illuminate the ways in which postmodern and feminist IR has used different lenses to inquire into certain marginalized issues and voices. The study is divided into three sections; first section expands on postmodernism, its meanings, methodologies and contributions to the field of IR. The second section, in a similar fashion, brings in various feminist insights and contributions to IR theory. The final section concludes that both postmodern and feminist IR have challenged the dominant discourses, metanarratives and representations in mainstream IR and, in doing so, they have carved out thinking space that can be appropriated by different voices that had been ‘silenced’ by mainstream accounts.
Under critical IR theory, postmodernism constitutes an umbrella term that embraces various sets of theories. It denotes a rejection of the idea of modernism. The foundations of this modernist project of 17th century were rationalism (as opposed to religion), individualism and empiricism. This modernist project, based on the philosophy of progress, paved the way for industrial revolution and scientific progress in Europe (Burke, 2010; 365). It is very difficult to trace a single unifying thread...

Find Another Essay On Mainstream International Relations Has Excluded Multiplicity of Voices and Issues

China Entrepreneurs: Voices of Experience from 40 International Business Pioneers

1100 words - 5 pages attributed that drive growth. Regardless of the perspective, the commonly used definition of the competitiveness always has an indirect connection to overall national economic performance. National Bureau of Economic research in The Determinants of National Competitiveness identifies macro and micro factors that have an effect of country’s competitive performance. Macroeconomic factors such as SIPI (social infrastructure and political institutions) and

Critical Issues of Female Managers and International Assignments

6277 words - 25 pages Critical Issues of Female Managers and International AssignmentsStanley C.T. NgBA (Psy), BBA (Honours), MIB, MIRMacquarie UniversityBusiness DepartmentAbstract"Globalization" and "internationalization" are undoubtedly two of the major catchwords of the past decade. While the specific meaning of these terms varies widely, one commonality is that both of these processes require the transportation of labours across national boundaries. Without

International Legal and Ethical Issues

1381 words - 6 pages Gentura subsidizes the production of VioBrax, the payment terms of the contract between Gentura and CadMex will be violated.In event of a contract breach, CadMex has the following options: By taking legal action can affect future relations with Gentura and Candore. At the same time, not taking any action and letting Gentura vary from the payment clause by more than 5% will lead to disregard of the contract by Gentura. If no legal action is taken

International Legal and Ethical Issues.

769 words - 3 pages Upon completion of the University of Phoenix simulation "Addressing International Legal and Ethical Issues," we as a team have outlined below several concerns that must be addressed prior to entering into any legally binding business contracts with international organizations.Addressing International Legal and Ethical Issues.Prior to entering into international contractual business agreements it is important to take into consideration the rules

Idealism and Realism in International Relations

1539 words - 6 pages failure of the League of Nations, Treaty of Versailles, and World War II, political realism has become the first mainstream thought in international relations. This mainstream of theory analyzes things the way they are instead of how they should be. A good example would be the failure of League of Nations. In a realist’s view, the League failed because of multiple reasons. Firstly, powerful members like Britain and France refused to take action when

International Relations of the Israeli-Palestinian Conflict

2343 words - 9 pages The Isreali-Palestine Conflict has been present for many years and dates back to when there was British dominance in the region. One of the most prominent issues is the matter of resources, such as oil and water present in the state. Another source of conflict is the support of Israel from the Western countries, like the United States during the Gaza Strip conflict, which creates an imbalance of power between Israel and Palestine. The idea of

Critical analysis for theories of international relations

1809 words - 7 pages . Basically speaking, the concept of critical theory as applied in the field of international relations speaks of the criticism made in line with the status quo attached to the ideals of Marx. It is a known fact that before the emergence of the principle of critical theory, the societies are being distributed according to the wealth an individual has. Critical theory is one of the most talked about political concept nowadays and that which is being

International Relations Theory: Changes in the Hierarchy of International Politics

1786 words - 7 pages one in contention is Waltz's neorealism. The notion of a "given" structure and hence consistent nature of actors can very much be linked to his thought. Ever since Waltz's book in 1979, almost all international relations literature has revolved around either confirming, adapting, or refuting his work. Much of the motivation behind Waltz's neorealist thinking is his observation of recurring patterns in international politics. Despite what might

Discussion on the Secularism of Turkey in it's politics, culture and international relations.

3507 words - 14 pages had extensive economic ties to Iraq, and that the disruption has hurt Turkey badly, with estimates of losses up to $40 billion.ConclusionTurkey has the advantages of extensive associations with the West, and the control of commerce coming from the Middle Eastern region. Hindrance to the expansion of Turkish influence seems to be its human rights issues and economic conditions. The Kurdish people should be considered as component to the mainstream

The Impact of Climate Change and Hostile International Relations on the Philippines

1760 words - 7 pages The Impact of Climate Change and Hostile International Relations on the Philippines The Republic of the Philippines, an island country located in the Malay archipelago in Southeast Asia, including 7,107 islands, known as Philippine Archipelago, has a total area of nearly 300,000 square kilometers. The country, named "Las Islas Felipinas" after King Philip II of Spain, fell prey to Spanish colonialism in 1565 (Jezek, 2006). In nowadays

The Role of Diplomacy and International Relations in the 19th Century

1009 words - 4 pages The international relations theory of realism represented the why and how the domination by certain powers occurred in the nineteenth century. Control of land during this time was directly proportional to the allocation of wealth among European states. This made the states that controlled the most land the dominate powers, and created the international environment that influenced states interaction with each other. Centuries before, states

Similar Essays

What Are The Assumptions Of Realism And Why Has It Been So Influential In The Studies Of International Relations?

1611 words - 6 pages Originating from the German word 'Realpolitik' , realism is often used as a term which fits a more realistic and unpretentious political theory, as opposed to an unrealistic ideological theory. It is this theory which has been one of the leading and most prominent ways of thinking in terms of international relations in modern times, with its stark view of nation states and people appealing greatly to the Western leading political institutions

International Relations Of Asia Essay

4362 words - 17 pages conceptualize pre -Cold War international relations in strategic geometric terms: the past is replete with instances of three-way interactions between Japan, China and the Soviet Union. According to Mandlebaum, the fate of the region has "for the last two centuries' depended ‘on the fate of three major powers--China, Japan and Russia, on the stability and tranquillity of their mutual relations." Hence we may presume that it is not novel or

International Relations Of Djibouti Essay

1150 words - 5 pages Many Americans have never heard of Djibouti, and many less are able to locate it on a map. While this small African country may have eluded the American population, it has not gone unnoticed to US policy makers. This country’s location, social situation and cultural dynamics, establish it as key terrain in the US’s long term strategic plan to eliminate terrorism. The purpose of this paper is to provide cultural information for the country of

Investigation Of International Relations Between Arabs And China

2737 words - 11 pages German literatures have been in existence ever since the beginning of this century” (Hsia, 1998). This is equally true for the Arabic literature. This essay is a preliminary attempt on an investigation of one dimension of international relations between the Arabs as an ethnic group and China as an imaginary realm. This paper focuses on the nature of the Arab imagery in the context of the initial image of China found in Arabic literature, the