Prosecutorial And Judicial Independence Of The Superior Courts In Hong Kong

1445 words - 6 pages

Basic Law provides for both prosecutorial and judicial independence, as both are vital under the Rule of Law in Hong Kong.

This paper looks at issues in connection with prosecutorial independence and judicial independence of the superior courts. Indeed both are not functioning with total independency with the judiciary perceived to be more independent. As both are vital to the rule of law in Hong Kong, the prosecutorial independency and judicial independency of the superior courts shall be kept to the highest standard.

Prosecutorial independence:

The prosecutorial function of the Department of Justice is carried out by the Prosecutions Division, whose role is:

‘to prosecute trails and appeal on behalf of the HKSAR, to provide legal advice to law enforcement agencies upon their investigations, and generally to exercise on behalf of the Secretary for Justice the discretion whether or not to bring criminal proceedings in the HKSAR. The Division also provide advice and assistance to government bureaus and departments in relation to any criminal law aspects of proposed legislation.’

The Basic Law assures the criminal prosecutions shall be free from any interference. Section 15(1) of Criminal Procedure Ordinance (Cap. 221) provides that ‘the Secretary for Justice shall not be bound to prosecute an accused person in any case in which he may be of opinion that the interests of public justice do not require his interference.’ Section 1.1 of the Prosecution Code states that ‘a prosecutor is required to act in the general public interest, but independently as a “minister of justice”. In making decisions and exercising discretion a prosecutor must act fairly and dispassionately on the basis of the law, the facts provable by the admissible evidence, other relevant information known to the prosecution and any applicable policy or guidelines.’ Section 1.2 of the Prosecution Code provides that a prosecutor must be influenced by any investigatory, political, individual interest or representation; the personal feelings or beliefs, etc. It is noted that public interest, a vague yet broad concept, is cited as an important criterion for prosecution.

Judicial Independence:

It is the constitutional responsibility of the judge to provide fair and impartial justice in accordance with the law based on the relevant evidence presented in court. When carry the judicial function, the judge must be free from any influence and act independently.

The Basic Law provides a comprehensive guarantee of judiciary independence. Those provisions include Article 2 (independent judicial power, including final adjudication), Article 19 (jurisdiction over all cases in HKSAR), Article 81 (court system in HKSAR), Article 82 (Court of Final Appeal as the apex court of HKSAR), Article 84 (adjudicate cases according to laws applicable in HKSAR; refer to precedents of other common law jurisdictions), Article 85 (exercise judicial power independently, free from any interference;...

Find Another Essay On Prosecutorial and Judicial Independence of the Superior Courts in Hong Kong

The Lure of International Schools in Hong Kong

3623 words - 14 pages attract parents and students. To conclude, we can see that the international schools attempt to give an image that they are different from, or more precisely, superior than the local schools. In the following paragraphs, I am going to explain why these packaging are so attractive in Hong Kong context 2. Why are the packagings of international schools so attractive in Hong Kong context? In the previous paragraphs, I summarized the packaging and

Discuss the advantages and disadvantages of online shopping for consumers in Hong Kong.

889 words - 4 pages In the past few years, a great deal of people created an online shop and exploit the online purchasing market in Hong Kong. Not only had some general residents do that, but also some large-scale chain stores, such as, IKEA and Sasa. These stores have also established their own online shopping system. In addition, the online shopping phenomenon has continuous increase. While some online shopping system’s users welcome this new technology that

Balancing Democracy and Reality in Hong Kong

3409 words - 14 pages rising demand from the public and to achieve any constructive progress in political development in Hong Kong. In the paper, explanations about the incompetence of the chief executives (CE) in Hong Kong will be focused under the umbrella of lacking legitimacy and institutional weakness that pose hurdles for the CE in his governance as well as providing suggestions to improve their performance. The executive is defined as the central policy-making

The education system in Hong Kong

1092 words - 4 pages The education system problems in Hong KongFrom 1841 to 1997, Hong Kong education was closely modeled on the system that was found in the UK, at that time Hong Kong was administered by Britain. On 1st July 1997, China got back the former UK colony. Since then, the education system had experienced a lot of changes. For example, the Hong Kong government has changed the nine years compulsory and free schooling system to 12 years education. Nowadays

An Investigation of Language in Hong Kong

1382 words - 6 pages 4. Results   In this section, the results of different variables in the recorded language diary and the inferred relationship between the variables are presented to show the subject’s use of languages in different communicative situations in Hong Kong.    4.1 Overview of language use   Over the seven-day period, 83 interaction entries were recorded with 114 principal interlocutors involved (see Table 1). The largest number of interaction

Dim the Light: Light In Hong Kong

2068 words - 8 pages protruding from each of its districts. Ironically, this award had led to another one; being entitled as the worst light polluted city in the world. Light pollution had been a major phenomenon in the last few decades, particularly in urban areas. It was mainly caused by outdoor lights that scattered in the atmosphere and eventually reflected back to the ground. According to a survey conducted by physicists from University of Hong Kong, the light

The Management of 21st Century: Hong Kong

838 words - 3 pages Hong Kong is the most suitable place for business. It is characterized by its high degree of internationalization, business friendly environment, rule of law, free trade and free flow of information, open and fair competition. Therefore, the business management is a very important part in the business. The management of Hong Kong includes the external environment and the internal environment. The external environment includes the

The Fall of Hong Kong December 1941

794 words - 3 pages Punjabis had all their experienced officers and troops in Europe and India, strengthening Hong Kong with hastily trained troops. The last group defending Hong Kong were the Hong Kong Volunteer Corps, they had 1000 men that were too old for the professional army but were amazingly enthusiastic to fight in defence of their home and they knew the local area well. Adding on to all that, rumours were passed around us about how the Japanese could not see

Toronto and Hong Kong.

579 words - 2 pages When it comes to making a decision upon where to live, many people would often decide to look at the most suitable places on earth that qualifies for their expectations of living standards. Some of the factors that may affect the outcome of the decision are education, government, economy, climate and other things that have an impact on our living conditions. Toronto and Hong Kong are in fact two of the top ten ranked world cities for both

Homosexuality in Hong Kong

1807 words - 7 pages Introduction In the last decade, the issue of homosexuality has been widely discussed and known in Hong Kong. People have more opportunities to approach the word `homosexuality' in their daily life through literatures, movies and occasional news revealing celebrities' homosexual behaviors. Simultaneously there has also been significant growth in commercial venues such as restaurants and bars, catering to gays and lesbians. In short, the

Prostitution in Hong Kong

2547 words - 10 pages . At the same time, some argue that sex worker is a kind of jobs and those involved in, their rights should be protected by the society, by law (Delacoste & Alexander, 1987). As a result, there are different responses, different countries or regions, toward prostitution. How is the situation in Hong Kong? Is there any enhancement if changes being made? These will be answered in the following part. Prostitution in this paper will be focused on

Similar Essays

The Transformation Of Hong Kong Essay

1336 words - 5 pages The Transformation of Hong Kong A drastic change came over Hong Kong during my supposed three month long business trip. This was not my first time in Hong Kong since I work for Walt Disney Imagineering and my team of engineers had been spending years planning the creation of the fourth Disney resort in Hong Kong. I had arrived in Hong Kong in mid-February 2003. My coworkers and I were staying at the Island Shangri-La which is located in

Comparing The Democratic Progress In Taiwan And Hong Kong

1794 words - 7 pages Internal factors: The political system and the public involvement Progress of development of the political system The different progress of development of the democratic system in Taiwan and Hong Kong can be attributed to their internal and unique political structure and role of political parties. First of all, it should be noted that there are fundamental differences in the design of government structures in Taiwan and Hong Kong. In Taiwan, as

The History Of English Common Law In Hong Kong

833 words - 3 pages be maintained, except for any that contravene this law, and the subject to any amendment by the legislature of the Hong Kong Special Administrative Region.What is Article 84 of the Basic Law AboutAccording to Article 84 of the Basic Law, it provides that the courts of the HKSAR may refer to the precedents of other common law jurisdictions. In addition, the Court of Final Appeal and the Judiciary of the HKSAR is given power to invite judges from

Insignificant Moments In The History Of Hong Kong

2132 words - 9 pages The short story I have chosen is "Insignificant moments in the history of Hong Kong" taken from Xu Xi's History's Fiction: stories from the city of Hong Kong. The story consists of two diaries written on 30th June and 1st July 1997 which describe how the main character, Lam Yam Kuen, spent these two important days in Hong Kong's history. Through the description of Lam's visit to Uncle Check's restaurant and the dinner party at his workplace, the