This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Parental Notification Laws For Abortion Essay

2110 words - 8 pages

More than one million teenagers in the United States will become pregnant this year. Eighty percent of these pregnancies are unintended, nearly all of the teens are unwed, and forty percent will choose abortion (Reproductive freedom, 1). With girls aged seventeen years old and younger, most states require by law that at least one parent must be notified or give consent before an abortion can be performed. Currently, thirty-two states have either parental consent or notification laws, and eight are pending (The Abortion Controversy, 108/Website 3, 1-2). Despite the good intentions of parental consent and notification laws, they have caused great tragedies, such as that of Becky Bell. In 1988, Becky Bell was a pregnant, seventeen-year-old junior attending Indianapolis High School. She wanted to have an abortion, but Indiana state law required that she obtain the consent of one of her parents. Aware of her father's potential disappointment, she opted to travel out-of-state to Kentucky where she could terminate her pregnancy without the consent of her parents. A day before her trip, she grew anxious and became emotionally unstable; and while attempting to self-abort, she lost her own life. (Teenagers and abortion, 1). Today, William Bell, her father, is fighting the consent laws that, he believes, killed his daughter (2). Becky's tragic death points to the horrible implications and consequences of these laws. Although parental consent and notification laws are designed to aid parents in helping their daughters with the decisions to terminate their pregnancies, protect their health, and improve family communication, these laws actually are unconstitutional, and pose real physical and emotional threats to teenage girls seeking abortions.On January 22nd, 1973, the United States Supreme Court ruled that Texas law outlawing abortion was unconstitutional. This overturned all previous laws that banned abortion, in the paramount case of Roe v. Wade. The Supreme Court ruled that abortion is a private, personal act, and women have a right to privacy. "This right to privacy"¦is broad enough to encompass a woman's decisions whether or not to terminate her pregnancy" (Gold, 70). The Court also ruled that "[States shall not] deny to any person within its jurisdiction the equal protection of the laws," arguing that women should have equal protection under the law, and no laws existed that prevented men from exercising their reproductive wishes (73). Today, the case of Roe v. Wade is applicable to parental consent laws. Arguably, a woman has the same rights to privacy and equal treatment under the law""regardless of her age. Despite this fact, parental consent and notification laws were deemed constitutional in the 1979 Supreme Court case Bellotti v. Baird, because of a process called judicial bypass, in which a minor can go to court and ask a judge's permission to obtain an abortion without parental involvement (The Abortion Controversy, 109-110). Judicial...

Find Another Essay On Parental Notification Laws For Abortion

Abortion Restrictions are Unconstitutional Essay

1000 words - 4 pages abortion law is constitutional, it should not be enforced.Ayotte v. Planned Parenthood of Northern New England has been found unconstitutional by New Hampshire's federal district court and a federal appeals court in Boston. This law requires parental notification and a waiting-period and does not allow an exception for a medical emergency that endangers the minor's health (Halloran, 2005). Halloran's article, Abortion Wars, Once Again, discusses

Abortion in the United States Essay

1937 words - 8 pages to preserved fetal health and life.” (Schroedel) Even though abortion was legalized to prevent unsanitary conditions and death in women, illegal abortion still occurs, like teenagers to perform an abortion without the consent of the parents. “Although teenagers may trust their parents, they had negative attitudes toward parental permission laws on abortion. No matter how strongly the participants opposed abortion and even if they discussed their


2702 words - 11 pages choose abortion is becoming progressively more dependent on the state in which she lives. Currently, thirty-seven states, including New York, have operational laws that place restrictions on late-term abortions. Only seventeen states presently provide funding for abortions. Like all political concerns, there are differing opinions with regards to abortion. However, unlike others, the abortion debate seems to be more controversial

Legality of Abortion

1595 words - 6 pages over the world, for thousands of years. In the United States, from the time the first settlers arrived abortion was legal during the first trimester or what was then called the quickening. The quickening was the time the mother first felt movement. Often times the herbs used to induce the abortion were fatal. The first laws banning abortions were actually laws making it illegal to sell the drugs that induced abortions. But just as it is today

Common Social Problems in the United States: Abortion

1813 words - 8 pages husband of her intentions to abort the fetus. These conditions were reviews by many different abortion clinics and doctors for approval. Later on, federal courts upheld all new provisions of the new law except the notification of the woman’s husband. This became the new standard of determining the validity of laws regulating abortion.

Abortions Pros and Cons

1184 words - 5 pages pregnancy which tends to run high in persons considering abortion. The reason for this would be their lack of direction or decision in this matter. But all of this boil down to amending the U.S. Constitution, to the Canadian Charter of Rights that will give equal protection under the law, to all living humans from the time their biologic life begins at conception until natural death and to have parental notification and consent for abortion for minor

Abortion is Woman’s Right to Choose

1942 words - 8 pages abort it. Responsible parents should also be involved when their daughters face crisis pregnancies. In fact, most teenagers do turn to their parents for guidance. But the government cannot mandate healthy family communication where it does not already exist. Laws that restrict minor’s access to abortion by mandating parental involvement actually harm teens and families they mean to protect, by increasing illegal and self-induced abortions, family

Sandra Day O'Connor: Ayotte v. Planned Parenthood

938 words - 4 pages or incompetent person unless the physician performing the abortion has given forty-eight (48) hours notice to one parent or the legal guardian of the minor or incompetent person” ( 2012). This bill flagrantly disregarded the need for medical exceptions. The only way for a minor to have an abortion without parental notification that was even designated within the bill was the opportunity of judicial bypass, which could still consume

Abortion: A Social and Moral Issue

1493 words - 6 pages the undue burden test. “The "undue burden" test, long advocated by Justice Sandra Day O'Connor, stipulated that no state could place an "undue burden" on a woman's right to choose.” Today abortion is legal in the United States, however there are states that have restrictions, for instance in several states parental notification is required for minors or in some states a parent must accompany a minor. There are also certain states that require

Abortion: Unconstitutional State and Federal Laws

933 words - 4 pages to pay for an abortion. Teen under the ages of 18 that want to have an abortion must first have parental discretion before it is performed. Women that are planning to get have an abortion, the states laws require them to wait at least twenty-four hours before the abortion is performed. Also, state require that providers give women information over the abortion and potential risks (Medoff, 579). In conclusion, womens's rights to an

Essay looking at the abortion issue from a strictly legal standpoint, with opinion based thesis pro-abortion. From 1973 to 1995, landmark cases, political climates and bibliography included

1865 words - 7 pages abortion advertising and promotion, licensing and reporting requirements for clinics, fetal protection statutes, consent and notification laws, regulations on public funding and the use of public facilities. Roe had left so many questions unanswered that it stood as an open invitation to states to challenge. During this same time, the Equal Rights Amendment was struck down, Illinois being one of the three states needed for ratification. The backlash was

Similar Essays

The Motive For Anti Abortion Laws Essay

1100 words - 4 pages Abortion Abortion have been around for many years, studied for different societies. It was legal in the United States from the earliest times. In the middle 1800s, states began to pass laws that made abortions illegal. There are two different types of abortion.One is Clinic abortion, and the other one is an abortion pill. Abortions are very common. In fact, 3 out of 10 women in the U.S. have an abortion by the time they are 45 years old. The

Abortion For Underage Children Should Require Parental Consent

1650 words - 7 pages providing for their children. Therefore, parents have the right to know what their children are doing. Parents must be included in their children’s decisions because parents can influence their children in a significant way. For instance, parental consent laws reduce the minor abortion rate by 19 percent (qtd. in Davis). “A 2008 study done by Michael J. New, Ph.D. shows that parental involvement laws reduce the abortion rate among 17 years old

Women's Rights In The Us Essay

2364 words - 9 pages , in 5 states consent as well as notification of the parents is needed in order to procedure. (Guttmacher Institute, 2014)The equivocation of 'legal abortion'Due to the restrictive laws in several states, women feel that abortion is becoming illegal again. For them, it feels like a pre-Roe period, the period before abortion was legalized. Abortion is a legal right, but since there are numerous restrictions and limitations, it does not feel as a

Should Minors Receive Parental Consent Before Having An Abortion?

1999 words - 8 pages other escape routes for the minor. Only 38 states require some type of parental involvement, 21 states require the consent of one or both parents, and only 5 require consent and notification before the abortion can occur (Guttmacher Institute, 2014, p. 1). These statistics show that there are 12 states that allow minors to receive abortions without any parental involvement. The article, “Abortion parental consent debate and poll” shows that