Parliament’s Piecemeal Approach To The Indian Act Reform And Its Implications University Of Alberta Pol 224 Research Paper

2337 words - 10 pages

University of Alberta
“Parliament’s Piecemeal Approach to the Indian Act Reform and its Implications”
Ardrianna Mairs
Political Science 224
Nicole Marshall
10 of 10
The Constitution Act of Canada gives exclusive legislative authority to the Parliament of Canada in dealing with Indians[footnoteRef:1] and Land Reserved for Indians.[footnoteRef:2] Within the scope of its authority, Parliament has implemented the Indian Act which is a punitive, restrictive and regulatory regime that purports to govern healthy interaction between the Canadian state and First Nation bands. The history of the government is prominent for its unethical attempts to silence these self-determined peoples, and its past failed attempts to adopt a comprehensive and inclusionary amendment pursuant of the Charter, is indicative of its abdication of legislative power by relying on judicial interpretation of individual cases. Contemporarily, Indigenous women are living in a misogynistic Canada, where the government perpetuates such beliefs through legislation that usurps their rights to identity and membership. The government’s piecemeal approach to remedial legislation perpetuates the sex-based inequities of the Indian Act that deny access to political power for Indigenous women and these inequities create broad implications for their identity, membership and belonging in their communities. This essay will argue how the government’s failure of past amendments to the Indian Act without the consultation of those affected, are precedents to the necessity of an inclusionary response on Bill S-3[footnoteRef:3] with the Senate Standing Committee on Aboriginal Peoples. [1: In this paper, “Indian” means a person registered or entitled to be registered as a status Indian under the Indian Act.] [2: The Constitution Act of Canada s91(24)] [3: An Act to Amend the Indian Act (Elimination of Sex-based Inequities)]
Canada has a bicameral legislature with two chambers, the Senate and the House of Commons. Legislation must be approved by both chambers in order for it to become a law. Certain legislation requires extensive study and review that is difficult to conduct in a House of 338 members. Thus, the creation of parliamentary committees — empowered by the House to comprehensively study matters it requests — are necessary in this case to review the historical effects of the Indian Act pursuant to the Charter[footnoteRef:4]. In order to amend established legislation, the cabinet must propose a bill that attempts changes to it and given that the Senate is comprised of various political members, bills are subject to roadblocks. This allows the Senate to perform its ‘sober second thought’ function in an independent form and with the help of the APPA[footnoteRef:5] it holds the government accountable. [4: Canadian Charter of Rights and Freedoms ss.15 and 28.] [5: APPA: Standing Senate Committee on Aboriginal Peoples.]
The Charter of Rights of Freedoms guarantees women equality...

Find Another Essay On Parliament’s Piecemeal Approach to the Indian Act Reform and its Implications - University of Alberta POL 224 - Research paper


1418 words - 6 pages those in parliament, and showing that pressure from the outside of parliament was needed to catalyse change.It is therefore hard to imagine the Reform Act being passed on its own accord - a case study being Catholic Emancipation of 1929, which required agitation prior to its success - as it was these pressures that called the need for reform and were crucial in mauling the notion straight over the Parliamentary try line in 1832.Although agitation

The Historical Context of The Bhagavad Gita and Its Relation to Indian Religious Doctrines

2519 words - 10 pages The Historical Context of The Bhagavad Gita and Its Relation to Indian Religious Doctrines The Bhagavad Gita is perhaps the most famous, and definitely the most widely-read, ethical text of ancient India. As an episode in India's great epic, the Mahabharata, The Bhagavad Gita now ranks as one of the three principal texts that define and capture the essence of Hinduism; the other two being the Upanishads and the Brahma Sutras. Though this work

Research Paper: The research on using a Tethered Agonist Approach to Map the Structure of the Receptor

857 words - 3 pages The tethered agonist approach to mapping ion channel proteins – toward a structural model for the agonist binding site of the nicotinic acetylcholine receptor. Research by Lintong Li, Wenge Zhong, Niki Zacharias, Caroline Gibbs, Henry A Lester, Dennis A. Dougherty. Condensation of the Research Purpose of the Study: The purpose of the study was to develop a structural model for the nicotinic acetylcholine receptor and use newer

Historic development of the atom and its implications

1149 words - 5 pages also suggested that chemical equations occurred when combination of atoms were rearranged. Daltons model is shown belowThe problem with Daltons model is that it regarded atoms as units without structure and it needed further research to show that his model was incorrect. Thomson in 1904 put forward a model, which suggested that there were sub-atomic particles. Thomson suggested the atomconsists of a positively charged fluid in which negative

An assessment of the BEST model and its approach to teamwork:

1761 words - 7 pages Table of Contents 1. Introduction: 2 2. Nature of the project: 2 3. An assessment of the BEST model and its approach to teamwork: 2 3.1. An overview of the BEST model in respect of teamwork: 2 3.2. Comparing the components of management quality to the BEST model: 2 3.2.1. Employee Development: 2 3.2.2. Communication: 2 3.2.3. Performance Measurement: 2 3.2.4. Employee participation: 3 3.2.5. Integration: 3 3.2.6. Delegation: 3 3.2.7. Direction

Growing Distrust: Police and the Community - University of Minnesota / Sociological Research Methods - Research Paper

1599 words - 7 pages research, I plan to conduct multiple unstructured interviews with police officers that were either directly, or indirectly involved in police brutality cases. This will provide little information towards my conclusion. However, I do find it necessary to receive both sides of a story to form a result. I have chosen the unstructured style of interview because one of its benefit towards sensitive topic and ethical strengths. In addition, unstructured


691 words - 3 pages , Muskogee, Chickasaws, Cherokees, and the Seminoles. In the 1830, the Removal Act went into effect. The Removal Act gave President Andrew Jackson the power to remove Indian tribes living east of the Mississippi river by a negotiate removal treaties. The treaties, made the Indians give up their land for exchange of land in the west. There were a few tribes that agreed to sign the treaties. The others that did not sign the treaty were forced into

The Environmental Implications of Political and Economic Reform in Communist China

2477 words - 10 pages , speedy, large scale, and often unregulated development will obviously have dire consequences for their natural environment. However, recent economic reform isn't solely to blame for the massive environmental degradation which China is experiencing. A long history of political negligence and disregard for environmental policy and practice are also a key contributor to the recent state of unrest. In recent years however, the question of equilibrium

ACT and College Research Paper

763 words - 4 pages , a research of the ACT and Oregon State University gave me an insight on how to prepare as a high school student next year. Through this examination, my worries for next year eased, and I became more certain in what to major in college. Choosing a major and a college that interests one the most is a good way to start planning ahead. Without knowing anything about the national exams and universities, the opportunity of a scholarship can fly away in an instant.   Works Cited Oregon State University. Oregon State University. 2014. Web. 16 April 2014. The ACT. ACT, Inc. 2014. Web. 15 April 2014.

The Cinema and Its Environmental Implications

1248 words - 5 pages Every development project today is creating many implications on the environment, some of which do not entail positive growth but rather cause stress on the natural component. For small island states such as Malta, these implications, particularly in the entertainment sector, are an even greater matter of concern (Briguglio & Briguglio, n.d.). In response to these statements, this essay aims to discuss the processes and impacts of a cinema, both

The of volume and concentration in the body fluids of earthworms - Leyte Normal University - Research Paper

1174 words - 5 pages stress in the fresh-water types, and the secretion of mucus by both classes. Now, we will define and know what tonicity is and how does tonicity affect the body fluid of an organism like the earthworm. Tonicity is the ability of an extracellular solution to make water move into or out of a cell by osmosis. A solution's tonicity is related to its osmolarity, which is the total concentration of all solutes in the solution. A solution with low

Similar Essays

Constitutional Issues And The Scope And Character Of The U.S. Government: Free Speech Ashford University Pol 303 Research Paper

3078 words - 13 pages 1 Running Head: CONSTITUTIONAL ISSUES 11 CONSTITUTIONAL ISSUES Constitutional Issues and the Scope and Character of the U.S. Government: Free Speech Niamh Moore Ashford University POL 303 Prof. Lawrence Olson August 21, 2017 Constitutional Issues and the Scope and Character of the U.S. Government: Free Speech Free Speech has afforded American citizens the right to express themselves freely. It’s, arguably, the most contested part of our

Paying The Price For Selfishness In Mary Elizabeth Braddon’s Novel Lady Audley’s Secret University Of Alberta Research Paper

1311 words - 6 pages Chen 2 Research essay 1 Student: Jiani Chen Instructor: Neale Barnholden English 103 X54 7 March 2018 Words count (1217) Paying the price for selfishness in Mary Elizabeth Braddon’s novel Lady Audley’s Secret In Lady Audley’s Secret, Mary Elizabeth Braddon tells about one of main characters, Lady Audley, relying on her beauty to achieve self-interest through doing immoral behaviors. A woman’s identity in typical Victorian society is directly

The Abusive Use Of Alcohol And Its Effects On Men Harvard University Research Paper

451 words - 2 pages more relaxed laws on alcohol will show a decrease in overall use. (CE-2) I believe that we should take a different approach in our laws against alcohol and to make them less stringent. Understanding that teenagers are rebellious and will find a way to drink alcohol if they desire, making alcohol legal may discourage illegal methods. This also allows someone to ask for help when intoxicated without the fear of backlash from authorities. (CE-3) After

The Contemporary Team Approach To Organizational Success Organizational Behavior And Theory Research Paper

1774 words - 8 pages Cornelia Jammer PAD 507 Organizational Theory and Behavior Summer 2017 Final Paper The Contemporary Team Approach to Organizational Success Introduction Creating a collaborative work environment, where teams are built is the way to increased productivity and organizational success or is it? The concept of team building is an old age argument that dates to our early trendsetters and organizational theorist. There is a substantial amount of