Participatory Development Essay

814 words - 3 pages

Golooba-Mutebi’s report on decentralization and popular participation in Uganda highlights the shortcomings of participatory development. He traces the development path followed within the primary health care sector and concludes that decentralization and popular participation have failed to correct the short comings thought to have been a result of the top-down political system previously in place. He does not support the top-down approach and acknowledges its shortcomings, but argues that decentralization fails to correct them.

Enthusiasts of participatory development stress empowerment and accountability. Golooba-Mutebi correctly argues that the transfer of power does not necessarily lead to empowerment, and that local level management does not lead to greater accountability. While decentralization and popular participation in Uganda’s primary health sector did yield improvements in infrastructure, it failed to address service delivery and accountability. This is where Golooba-Mutebi makes his greatest contribution. Following authors such as Hyden and Chaason, he argues that participatory development makes little significance in states that are weak. He does not argue, as do authors like Cooke, against the usage of participatory development. But rather states that efforts made using the participatory development model, within the framework of a weak state, are bound to be insignificant.

Golooba-Mutebi identifies two broad obstacles present in weak states that hinder participatory development efforts; limited access to resources and restricted information and knowledge. He argues that community health workers failed to provide adequate services as a result of not receiving their salaries on time. This lead to various forms of corruption that all impacted negatively on service provision. In addition, medicine and other medical supplies were also in short supply which lead to many users of the public health system going elsewhere (often to the private practices set up by the community health workers themselves) to find what they were looking for. He goes on to argue that community health workers, individuals in managerial positions, and those serving on the boards of the various ‘watchdog’ organizations were, as part of the participatory approach, drawn from local sites, and in many instances lacked the appropriate knowledge and information to fulfill their duties correctly. Many educated Doctors refused to take direction from their uneducated counterparts. As a result the, participatory development failed to increase accountability.

I do, however, question Golooba-Mutebi emphasis on participatory development. Undoubtedly, Uganda pursued a set of reforms based on a platform of decentralization and popular participation. These ideologies influenced and dictated the actions taken, and...

Find Another Essay On Participatory Development

Participatory Design In Interior and Spatial Design

2085 words - 9 pages Participatory design simply means encouraging and producing new social relationships. It is an approach to design attempting to actively involve participants in the design process. Sometimes it is useful in order to help ensure the product designed meets their needs and is usable. The term has been used in many different areas such as; product design, architecture, software design, graphic design… Also it has been used in various scales

Discusses paticipatory democracy and its relevance to big business and how it is expanding and limiting the nations growth

744 words - 3 pages elected an individual, political action is his business not theirs'."Representative democracy's legitimacy stems from the minimal but equal participation of all through the vote, whereas the legitimacy of participatory democracy lies in the high degree of activity of what is likely to be a minority through institutions that are transparent, open to all and based on mutually agreed rules. Representative institutions based on one person one vote


1773 words - 7 pages of literature (e.g. Benit-Gbaffou 2008a, 2008b, Piper and Nadvi 2010, Tapscott 2010, 2005, Ballard et al 2006, Miraftab 2006, and Zeurn 2001) already exists on the state-civil society nexus in the post apartheid era. A majority of these studies point to the failure of the institutionalised participatory system of governance such as ward committees and integrated development planning. Such failures of the mainstream participatory channels have

Community-Based Participatory Research

1249 words - 5 pages Community-based participatory research (CBPR) is an asset-building model that was constructed by the medical community. Essentially, the model was based on the asset-based community development (ABCD) approach; however, CBPR has been adapted to research study. CBPR uses research methods to use both quantitative and qualitative information to obtain the community’s strengths. Authors Lightfoot, McCleary, & Lum (2014) claimed that, although

The Environmental Impact Assessment in South Africa

1760 words - 8 pages environmental law (promulgated in the Environmental Conservation Act (73 of 1997, under Section 21, 22 and 26) and management (Sandham and Pretorius, 2008). EIA can be seen as an evaluation process. This process is aimed at the determination, evaluation and or assessment of the consequences that any development might have on the environment, whether negative and or positive. This assessment is used to aid decision-makers, prior to approval, to

Discussion Topic

1703 words - 7 pages : Lessons from Nicaragua. Children & Society. doi: 10.1111/j.1099-0860.2012.00443.x Speer, J. (2012). Participatory governance reform: A good strategy for increasing government responsiveness and improving public services? World Development, 40(12), 2379–2398. Taylor, M. (2007). Community Participation in the Real World: Opportunities and Pitfalls in New Governance Spaces. Urban Studies, 44(2), 297-317. Williams, G., Thampi, B.V., Narayana, D.D., Nandigama, S., & Bhattacharyya, D. (2011). Performing Participatory Citizenship - Politics and Power in Kerala's Kudumbashree Programme. Journal Of Development Studies, 47(8), 1261-1280. doi:10.1080/00220388.2010.527949

Library User´s Perspective Regarding Library Usage

2520 words - 11 pages or to add details to an issue of interest. It was intended that the interview questions and follow-up questions avoided using terminologies or jargon because “participatory library” and “Library 2.0” were not always terms with clear definitions. Lay language was also used in probing questions to orient participants to the phenomenon of study. Data analysis was implemented simultaneously with data collection and adhered to grounded theory

The dynamic blogosphere: changing culture through global communication and collaboration

781 words - 4 pages of reading and research. It had its shortcomings. Only a handful of people were able to code which limited user communication because the semantic web was static and read only. The cost of software, slow computers and internet speeds. Citizen participatory behaviour prompted the development of higher capacity computers and higher speed internet. The increase in activity led to cumulative advances which increased capabilities allowing global use

development for whose benefit?

1286 words - 6 pages perspective is seen primarily as a tool to enrich human lives through participatory and emancipatory endeavors, e.g. knowledge sharing and community building activities, or participatory governance. Development happens sans extractive and exploitative undertakings by firms. Knowledge remains properties of individuals and communities, and this is respected. Knowledge is utilized to directly meet the developmental needs of the public and not simply

Convergence Culture: Where Old and New Media Collide

2836 words - 11 pages This essay is a response to the following question: In participatory culture the consumer and producer no longer occupy separate roles rather “we might see them as participants who interact with each other according to a new set of rules that none of us fully understand”. Jenkins, Henry, Convergence Culture (London: New York University Press, 2006) 3. Identify a text or series of texts that challenge the previously established rules of

Disaster Management

1143 words - 5 pages Magistrate/Officer and Blocks and Tehsils under the administrative control of the Block Development Officers/Tehsildars needs to coordinate with the functioning of the various departments in their respective jurisdiction ( Appendix I). An important step in planning process is to identify the problems and issues related to disaster management. There can be various sources for identifying these issues. These are diagnosis of disaster

Similar Essays

Participatory Democracy: The Better Of The Two

3309 words - 14 pages is much evidence that proves that the advantages of participatory democracy heavily outweigh the drawbacks and that it is a better way of government than patriarchy. This evidence can be found in historical analysis, scrutiny of the patriarchal international system, the development of participatory democracy, and the values of a participatory democracy versus the values of a patriarchal democracy. Participatory democracy is when the individuals

Communication For Facilitating Participatory Extension: A Case Of East Java Region In Indonesia

675 words - 3 pages This study assessed the public extension agents’ responses to participatory extension approach. Since the independence in 1945, Indonesia’s extension agency has been providing services to farmers to enter the core of development. The government has enacted the Law Number 16/2006 on Participatory Extension as a consequence of political decentralization in the country by the year 2000. In principle, the new law mandates a change from a top-down to

Thompson’s Four Hypothesis Of Organisational Change

1835 words - 7 pages . Second, policy shifts from GW development to GW management increased community’s accountability over the management and judicious use of natural limited resource. Subsequently, modifying GW Act and making it more participatory has attempted to support complex dynamics of GW new paradigms in resource management. Third, WB and UNICEF projects of community managed GW resource and experience from proactive initiative in Village Water Account increased

Participatory Design Process Essay

1219 words - 5 pages . However, due to open space’s advantages, planners are able to deny its presence, which has to be renovated and developed in order to support social integration. Base on the data collected from the surveys and the Molenbeek’s specific identities, I make recommendations to support the reconstruction process of these open spaces. Participatory design process: During a design process of open space, in order to make sure that renovated open space is