This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Passage Analysis From "If This Is A Man"

1533 words - 6 pages

This passage, which is taken from the closing pages of Primo Levi’s ‘If This Is A Man’, describes the final days in the concentration camp. To put it into context; the Germans, who were keen to save themselves, have abandoned Levi and the others, who are too ill to travel, to fend for themselves. Levi focuses on the irony of their situation; after suffering the horrors of the camp Levi and his fellow abandoned prisoners are finally free, but in reality they do not receive the benefits normally associated with freedom, they are in fact in many ways worse off than before. In this extract Levi highlights how despite the freezing conditions, there is a thaw in human relationships.

“I have a ration of bread under the sack. Divide it among you three. I shall not be eating anymore”
These are the first words of this passage, they are important because they clearly show that this man has been through countless horrific experiences, and as a result he has lost the will to live. He has accepted that death is around the corner, and so chooses to give up his ration of bread, to help his fellow prisoners. The act of kindness of giving up his bread, shows that these men are still able to be kind to one another, they still have their sense of decency. Which is rather a contrast to what has been seen by these men throughout the book and their time in the camp. It would have been expected that in their time spent being abused, they would have lost their ability to be kind. Instead there is evidence that the rules of the Lager, where every man is for himself, are no longer being adhered to, they have chosen to remain respectable men, by offering to help each other, and by not accepting the bread offered to them, shows that they still have the ability to be ‘polite’ and respect one another. It says that the men did not know what to say to the old man’s kind gesture of offering his bread, perhaps they did not know how to react to the mans acceptance of death.

“A harsh silence” is the phrase used to describe the atmosphere in the hut. Harsh is a good choice of word for it allows the overall scale of the silence to be pictured. It is a strong word, and gives the impression that the silence is almost piercing.
The harsh silence is soon broken by the old man, Somogyi, who gave up his ration of bread. He had become delirious, haunted by the very ideas of slavery, and having already accepted that death was approaching, his madness had driven him to repeating the word ‘Jawohl’ constantly, mechanically. He had become so accustomed to the ways of the Lager that when he finally reached madness, he was stripped of all that made him man, he was now just as good as a machine, a machine programmed by the laws and rules of the Lager. He accepted all that he had been through, and he was now awaiting death to take him. This way that Levi describes Somogyi’s madness is a good way of showing how man can change, and come to accept death when it approaches. It makes the reader...

Find Another Essay On Passage Analysis from "If This Is A Man"

It was pure chance that enabled Primo Levi to survive Auschwitz. Evaluate. Levi, P "If This is a Man", Abacus, London, UK (2004)

972 words - 4 pages one's "personality is fragile, that it is much more in danger than life itself" (p.61).Through friendship and comradeship came hope and a reason to live. Man is naturally a part of a community from which he will personally benefit. A human needs to give or receive care to prevent dehumanisation. Friendships and even comradeships were an exception in the Lager as it was difficult to facilitate others. Levi was fortunate. He was able to develop a

The ways in which the Häftlinge in Primo Levi's 'If This is a Man' and zeks in Alexander Solzhenitsyn's 'Ivan Denisovich' overcome the dehumanisation through the formation of friendships

1511 words - 6 pages human soul's inseparability from physical sufferings of the body can lead to the destruction of an individual's humanity. In both the Gulag camp described in 'One Day in the Life of Ivan Denisovich' and the Nazi Lager portrayed in 'If This is a Man' detainees undergo systematically cruel and brutal treatment. They suffer from hunger, lack of sleep, exposure, exhaustion, and above all, deprivation of human rights. Nevertheless, in the worst

This is a first person analysis essay on the Middle Passage Slave Trade

1167 words - 5 pages History has forgotten those who died in the Middle passage. For me it was just yesterday. As white men came into my village and tore me away from everything I had ever known. Taking me to an unknown ship which would be worse than a living death.I saw the ships coming into port. Lined up in front and behind me were hundreds of others who had been "selected" to go to this new world. They branded us and shackled our wrists and ankles, leaving just

Analysis of a Passage from The Grapes of Wrath

2870 words - 11 pages . This hesitation is apparent how he speaks, or how he thinks before speaking, so as not to disturb the parents-figure: ?Joad cleared his throat? (l37). Besides, in not taking part in the discussion, or not even feel empathy for Muley, Tom proves to be more or less innocent, or artless. Actually, it is as if he were not part of that world. Once released from prison, his goal was to go back home, and live a happy life made of working, and having

This was a passage paper from Lord of the Flies by William Golding

555 words - 2 pages anybody else can escape from it or fight it, because it is an integral part of every human being. And since it is in there, things will forever go wrong. What the Lord of the Flies suggests Simon to do is to accept it, ignore it, and have fun with it. The only way to survive is to join the dancing crowd. Otherwise, if he points out at the devil, the evil, which lives even in the hearts of his best friends, will kill him.This conversation between

Write a critical analysis of the passage from A Handful of Dust

1037 words - 4 pages Write a critical analysis of the passage from A Handful of Dust starting is mummy coming back today? (p55) and finishing I've been carrying on anyhow this week (p 57), showing how far you think it typical of Waugh's methods and effects in the novel. The passage starts with John Andrew, the most innocent person in the novel speaking. He is questioning the absence of his mother and waiting eagerly for her return from "monkey-woman's party

"If thought corrupt language, language can corrupt thought", this is a statemnt from an essay "politics and the English language"written by George Orwell

1110 words - 4 pages "If thought corrupt language, language can corrupt thought"This is a statement from the "Politics and the English language" written by George Orwell. He says, " A bad usage can spread by tradition and imitation". The whole essay is mocking other writers on their language usage. He claims that the language is not used to its full extent. People use words the size of continents and in the end those big words say the same thing as a three-letter

Analysis of the way voice and dialogue are used in a passage from Pride and Predjudice

1129 words - 5 pages speech from Elizabeth. Her words are provoking, turning the romantic idea of poetry on its head. The exclamation mark hints this to be a form of outburst. By using direct speech, we are given the maximum impact of this, and although witty, it is excessively cynical with regard to love, using phrases such as 'driving away love' and 'starve it entirely away'. It contrasts with Darcy's moderation of tone and word which follows a more traditional

Analysis of the way voice and dialogue are used in a passage from "Pride and Prejudice"

1090 words - 4 pages , prior to changing to free indirect speech as she apologises for 'troubling him also with Lizzy'. The use of the word Lizzy as opposed to Elizabeth confirms this change to the persona of Mrs Bennet. The following sentences contrast Mr Bingleys 'unaffectedly civil' behaviour with his sisters lack of 'graciousness'. Here the narrator is commenting and therefore leading us to a poor opinion of Caroline. There is no dialogue from her to 'show' us this

Explication Of a Passage from "The Odyssey"

1314 words - 5 pages sea. "I fear that the goddess told it all too well, predicting great adversity and far from home." The passage has already told us that he is close to "free[dom]...from the bondage of his exile," yet he feels "far from home." This is a significant revelation of his mental state, because it gives us a peek at the sensitive side of the mighty Odysseus. He is isolated in this storm, with no one to look toward for support, and in this period of

A Boy is A Man in Miniature. This is an analysis of the novel Fifth Business by Robertson Davies. Specifically about the concept of being twice born

1079 words - 4 pages "A boy is a man in miniature, although he may sometimes exhibit notable virtue… he is also schemer, self-seeker, traitor, Judas, crook, and villain - in short, a man." (Davies 9). The theme of being twice born is prevalent through the novel Fifth Business and is strongly demonstrated by the characters, Dunny, Percy and Paul. All three change their names, deny their past and become what their parents could never have imagined. Consequently

Similar Essays

If This Is A Man Essay

1016 words - 5 pages If This Is a Man by Primo Levi is a story about his personal experience of the journey through Auschwitz Concentration Camp. Right from the very first trip to the unknown destination, to the point of near death, Primo’s life was a constant battle between life and death. Throughout the book, Primo portrays his walk through living hell in a way that is both powerful and painful. The cover of the book displays a black and white picture of three

Analytical Essay On Primo Levi's "If This Is A Man"

988 words - 4 pages Primo Levi's book 'If This Is a Man' is a novel about a German concentration camp, one among many novels on the same subject. However, this book is exceptional as Levi never 'raises his voice, complains, or attributes blame'. 'If This Is a Man' is an objective story told in a detached tone using scientific language, which sometimes makes this book not a confession but an analysis. Nevertheless, distant tone and unemotional language bring the

If This Is A Man By Primo Levi, Survival In Auschwitz

1306 words - 5 pages comes through the ruthless labor disengagements until he is admitted into a skilled workers’ detachment in November 1944, to function as a chemist. In January 1945, he “is allowed” to do toil in the lab, away from the coldness of snow, until he acquires scarlet fever and, enduring in the sanatorium, sees the discharge of the camp. If This Is a Man carries its title after a verse by Primo Levi, which fiercely calls for preserving the memoirs of the

To What Extent Will Man Go To Ensure His Survival? Explore With References To 'if This Is A Man' By Primo Levi

1368 words - 5 pages In 'If this is a man' by Primo Levi the male inmates vary greatly, yet each goes to great lengths trying to ensure his survival. Each has different ways in which he tries to survive, depending on the personality of the individual. In life there always comes a point in which the circumstances are so horrific that ones survival instincts take over and any act, no matter how horrific, is then considered normal as long as one survive and so morals