This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Patient Physician Relationship: The Effects Of Autonomy And Paternalism

2390 words - 10 pages

The practice of medicine in general has changed due to changes in technology, economics, epidemiology, and demographics. But particularly, the patient-physician relationship has been transformed during the past century, from one characterized by strong physician paternalism to one that reflects strong patient autonomy. (1)
Medical ethics in general is not a modern term; it goes back in time to the 12th century to the Hippocratic Oath. Recently in the 21st century the interest in medical ethics was provoked by a series of medical scandals: Nazi medical experiments, the infamous Tuskegee syphilis studies and so on. After which autonomy in the form of an informed consent was obligatory for minor and major procedures. (2, 3)

What is Autonomy?
Patients’ autonomy is the respect for the decision-making capacity of competent adults. This has now been fully integrated into the practice of medicine. This ‘patient’s right’ to accept or refuse medical care changed the balance of power in the patient-physician relationship and engaged the patient more in ownership of care plans and it is viewed by patient and physician, essential for honoring the individual and his or her dignity. (4)

The effect of autonomy & paternalism:-

Both autonomy and paternalism and their effect on patient –physician relationship evolved over time due to their advantages and disadvantages which can be summarized as following:-

The previous mastering of paternalism in decision making had the advantage of physician being the one to struggle in choosing the best treatment for the patient without burdening the patient or his family with decision making. But excessive paternalism, or over-influence of physician, had disadvantages: as deprivation of the patient from the opportunity to make decisions that reflect the reality of their conditions; inappropriate biases were caused by sex, race, and socioeconomic status that affected decision making; and it didn’t take into account patients’ best interests. (5-7)

From there came the importance of autonomy in preventing inappropriate paternalism and unwanted interventions that may burden the patients more than benefiting them, and on the other side of the line, involve the patients more in their health care. (8)
Involving patients in decision making is not just about offering and allowing choice, but also enabling informed decision-making. And not the wrong idea, that respecting autonomy means obliging clinicians to tell patients about health care options then stand back and abide by their choices. (9)

The degree of autonomy differs from one person to another also in the same person from one time to another, due to a number of factors that affect a person’s autonomy including: health conditions, treatment, knowledge, experience and skills, personal approach as well as familial patterns, type of relationship, life history and social context. (10)

So if the physician’s focus was mainly on decision-making,...

Find Another Essay On Patient-Physician Relationship: The Effects of Autonomy and Paternalism

"At long last the English courts now recognise and endorse patient autonomy" Discuss

2766 words - 11 pages In relation to health care law the principle patient autonomy entails taking into account and giving consideration to the patient's views of their treatment.Autonomy was first recognised as a relevant ethical principle to be endorsed by the courts in relation to heath care law by Mr Justice Cardozo in America and later affirmed in the English courts by Lord Donaldson; "An adult patient who suffers from no mental incapacity has an absolute right

Conflict and its affects on the nurse-Physician relationship

1544 words - 6 pages . Analysis In health care it is crucial that the health care team is cohesive. When conflict interferes with the nurse-physician relationship it can and will impact communication and eventually impact patient care. In the context of this paper, according to Tabak and Orit (2007), a conflict is defined as a situation arising where one party in a workplace relationship perceives that the behavior and objectives of the second party are not compatible with

The Effects of Staffing on Patient Care

1849 words - 8 pages The Effects of Staff Ratio on Patient Care A common problem today that many nurses face is the lack of staff to properly care for the residents in the long-term facility that they work in. When a nurse is forced to work short on the floor, there may be some details in a resident’s care that are left undone. This type of behavior can lead to minor problems, such as the inability to ensure a resident’s personal body alarm is in place, or

The Effects of Staffing on Patient Care

1803 words - 8 pages , competition for talent is becoming more heated in several parts of the country,” (Stanford, 2013). By nurses taking on jobs in other areas of the field, we are left to find people to replace them and when that happens, it creates a shortage on the front line of patient care. The literature, “The Unintended Consequences of Staffing Mandates in Florida Nursing Homes: Impacts on Indirect-Care Staff,” talk about the effect that staff shortage has on the

The Comparison of Paternalism In The Bean Trees and Animal Dreams

760 words - 4 pages Merriam- Webster defines Paternalism as “the policy or practice on the part of people in positions of authority of restricting the freedom and responsibilities of those subordinate to them in the subordinates' supposed best interest”. Many individuals simply define it as the lack of control one has. Whether that’s through a doctor not being truthful with their patient about their illness or even a husband hiding pills from a depressed wife. In

An Analysis of the Relationship between Theory and Practice in Nursing Assessment in the Delivery of Patient-Centred Care

2317 words - 10 pages In this essay I will be exploring the relationship between nursing theory and practice in patient assessment. I will analyse the activities of daily living section (Appendix 1) of the combined nursing assessment tool and look at how it facilitates patient centred care. I decided to focus my essay on this after working on a ward on placement where it was routine to complete a Combined Nursing Assessment within four hours of any patient arriving

Creole Culture and the Idea of Autonomy in Martinique

2054 words - 8 pages mind that Martinique and Guadelaupe have technological and deal schools which can make softer the collision of school stoppage. The Haitian team has a heavier chore. Quantitative data aren't federal and the schooling difficulty itself comes up at two levels.The Idea Of Autonomy For Martinique And The History Of The CountryNo doubt, The French West Indies viewer the transfer of farming manufacture from capitalistic agricultural estate to minute

Standoff Rocket Program: The Power of Autonomy and Learning

1984 words - 8 pages conducted by Terry, occur infrequently even with the most experienced, and can not devote time to develop people, listen to them, give feedbacks and run instead of delegating and coaching staff. Incongruity or even a vision of the relationship manager and outdated staff are signs that a revision in the style of leadership is urgent. The manager whatever his demand development can find support in Coaching on all issues related to managing people

The psychological effects of a cardiovascular accident on a patient

2687 words - 11 pages The psychological effects of a cardiovascular accident on a patientOur patient, Peter, is 42 years old. He is married and has two children, a daughter, who is 13 and a son, who is 11. Peter is highly qualified; whose job requires a lot of travelling and human contact. He suffered a cardiovascular accident when he was at home with his family a month ago. His life lacks certain risk factors, he does not smoke; drinks only socially and frugally. He

Therapeutic Relationship between Nurse and Patient

2151 words - 9 pages According to William C and Davis C, (2004), page 3 it has been said that a nurses most essential tool is the therapeutic use of self to understand clients health needs and their knowledge and skills to facilitate the healing process. A therapeutic nurse and patient relationship is defined as a serving relationship that is based on mutual trust and respect, the nurturing of faith and hope, being sensitive to self and others, and assisting with

Paternalism in the USA and Johhn Stuart Mills

3050 words - 12 pages The idea of paternalism is based on the fact that not all people are rational all the time and sometimes states intervene into the lives of others for their own good. These paternalists advance people's interests such as life, health, and safety at the expense of their liberty. John Stuart Mills was a Utilitarian Philosopher and political writer that has been extremely influential to our society today. He is against most paternalistic action and

Similar Essays

Fundamental Elements Of The Patient Physician Relationship

2211 words - 9 pages Fundamental Elements of the Patient-Physician Relationship The following are some the values for the medical profession: 1. Beneficence: doctors should do well. They ought to attempt to heal others and to greatly improve the situation off; 2. Non-misbehavior: doctors shouldn't do hurt. They ought to practice medication painstakingly and honestly and, when beneficence is unthinkable, they ought to still attempt to minimize hurts

The Decline In The Patient Physician Relationship

1993 words - 8 pages elevation in price of prescription drugs. Similar to half a century ago, family members are still forced to fill out healthcare forms upon checking someone into a hospital before they’re able to check up on their child or spouse. The amount of knowledge available on the internet regarding medicine and medical treatments has also had detrimental effects on the patient-physician relationship (vadscorner, pg 2). Many patients, in an attempt to

Autonomy V Paternalism In Mental Health Treatment, Outline And Review Of The Nys Case On Jacob Gordon

2617 words - 10 pages out the need for close scrutiny of ethics whenever agenciesinterfere with a client's autonomy. In an attempt to plan in Mr. Gordon's best interest, appeaseMrs. Gordon and become less liable for any poor outcomes to the treatment plan, the agenciesacted paternalisticly. Agencies imposed paternalism in each of the ways cited by Rooney (1992),by opposing Mr. Gordon's wishes of no medication. The agencies withheld information about thepossible side

Patient Rights And Autonomy Essay

1547 words - 7 pages Elise to hang up the phone and discuss the consequences that would happen if she continues that phone call. Elise immediately hangs up and thinks about the point Tristen just brought up and begins discussing how she feels obligated to explain this situation to her friend Kim regardless of how others may be affected by that decision. The ethical issue from Caitlin’s perspective is patient rights and autonomy, both of which were not upheld by