This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Patient Rights And Autonomy Essay

1547 words - 7 pages

Caitlin enters the room with her significant other Isaiah to wait for the nurse in the family planning clinic. Elise is a nurse who has been working for the family planning clinic for a few years, enters the room to meet her next patient of the day. To Elise’s surprise, she notices her best friend Kim’s husband sitting with another woman in the waiting room which happens to be Caitlin. As Elise calls out the name of her next patient, she hopes it is not the woman that is sitting with Isaiah, but to her surprise the patient she is looking for is the woman sitting with Isaiah. Elise quickly grabs Caitlin, and as they begin walking into the exam room, Isaiah begs Elise for mercy stating “please don’t tell Kim, it was just a one-time thing. You need to force Caitlin to terminate this pregnancy”. Elise stresses Isaiah stay out into the waiting room while she collects Caitlin’s information.
As Caitlin arrives in the exam room and sits in the chair and waits for Elise as she goes over Caitlin’s past medical history and reason for her visit. Elise opens the conversation by stating “Caitlin, I’ve read in your chart that you are here today for termination of pregnancy and I’d like to go over policies and procedures with you”. Caitlin displays her emotions all over her face stating how she is unable to go through with this termination and how Isaiah has declared her that he would leave his wife, but to her surprise he will not. Caitlin desperately asks Elise if termination of pregnancy is her only option in her situation and Elise is quick to respond that it is Isaiah’s right too, and he has expressed he would like to go through with the termination, so unfortunately this is her only option.
It is evident that Caitlin is devastated by Elise’s remarks, and is torn between the lack of options expressed to her by the nurse. This pregnancy, is indeed what Caitlin wants, but the father of the baby wants nothing to do with it and would like to terminate it. Elise steps out and allows Caitlin some time to herself as she “goes and gets the physician to proceed with the procedure”. Elise appallingly exits the room to go to nurse’s lounge where she finds her boss Tristen sitting reading a magazine. Tristen notices the distress on Elise’s face and begins questioning her what is wrong.
Elise opens the conversation up with Tristen stating her best friend Kim’s husband Isaiah is here with another woman who happens to be her patient at the moment and they are requesting a termination of pregnancy. Without even thinking, Elise grabs her telephone to begin calling Kim to tell her exactly what is going on. Before Kim could answer, Tristen interjects the phone call begging Elise to hang up the phone and discuss the consequences that would happen if she continues that phone call. Elise immediately hangs up and thinks about the point Tristen just brought up and begins discussing how she feels obligated to explain this situation to her friend Kim regardless of how others...

Find Another Essay On Patient Rights and Autonomy


2287 words - 10 pages For centuries, physician beneficence went unchallenged as the first and foremost principle of medical ethics. The doctor knew best and was to have the final say on all medical decisions. This paternalistic approach focused very little, if at all, on the rights of a patient to dictate their medical choices on the basis of their own thoughts and decisions. However, in the last half century there has been a substantial shift from paternalism to the

Ethics Paper

1813 words - 8 pages which medical practices are ethical and acceptable. These principles are not only used to protect the rights of a patient but also the physician from being violated. The principle of autonomy states, that an individual’s decision must be respected in all cases, also an individual can act freely in accordance to their plan. For example, in a case where a patient and family demands to continue medical or surgical care and a physician want the

Psychiatric Advance Directives versus Recipient Rights

1146 words - 5 pages would be within her rights to file a complaint in order to ensure that John’s rights to confidentiality and the services that his condition requires. Summary John’s case includes many facets of ethical and legal dilemma. John’s advance directive, which may not have a patient advocate assigned to it, could be legally binding. This form of consent and request for individualized care relates to the ethical principle of autonomy and also of

The Placebo Effect: Ethical or Unethical

874 words - 4 pages a placebo in a trial for a new medication. The use of a placebo is deemed to be ethical only if the patients physician follows the guidelines given by the AMA that protect a patient against deception and lack of autonomy (Gold and Lichtenberg). In medicine, a patient’s autonomy is essential for proper medical care. Autonomy is the ability for an individual to have rights regarding the amount of control a physician has over his body when subject

DNR: Whose Right to Choose?

1546 words - 7 pages ethical dilemmas that the physicians and nurses are facing are autonomy, beneficence, paternalism and fidelity. Autonomy plays a big role the nurse must respect the patient’s autonomy by respecting the rights of the patient’s family to make her medical decisions. The act of beneficence to “benefit the patient” and fidelity to “keep promises” also conflict the nurses and physicians. Paternalism on the physicians part because they do know what is best

Negative Critique on Alan Goldman's View on Medical Paternalism

1718 words - 7 pages their comments. One such author is Alan Goldman. He draws a very firm line on paternalism, simply put: medical paternalism is deleterious to a patient because it intrudes on their primary rights of liberty and autonomy. This paper is going to expound upon Goldman’s viewpoint in detail, going through point by point how he presents his argument. There will then be a critique of Goldman’s viewpoint that will counter his main points. The counterpoints

Patient Information Rights

1776 words - 7 pages future generations: this boils down to being a matter of intergenerational justice, not only in the present but also in the future of the healthcare industry. Another major ethical value relevant to health care resource distribution and patient rights in health information management is that of autonomy, which is the right of all patients to control both individually, and as a community, their health care and treatment. This includes the right of

Assisted Suicide: A Personal Decision & Nurse Advocating

1755 words - 7 pages validate the wishes of the patient and have the professional confidence to pursue that role. In conclusion, respect for autonomy is a obligation that healthcare professionals have to abide and ultimate right for patients. Autonomy refers to the mental state of persons who are at liberty to choose their own life plans. Proponents of physician assisted suicide individuals have rights to decide when and how they will die (Friend, 2011

Autonomy: A Concept Analysis

2222 words - 9 pages span to philosophy, technology and general decision making. The medical meaning is significant in the care of patients for improved outcomes through choice and educated decision making on the part of the patient. Autonomy can be empowering as a concept or even as a single word. Current Uses of Autonomy Autonomy is defined by dictionary reference as the state or quality of self-governing, also known as the right of self-government and also

The Distinction Between Passive and Active Euthanasia

2166 words - 9 pages murder as the death of his patient had been a ‘primary rather than an incidental consequence of his actions’. The creation of distinction between acts and omissions and intentions is to protect the doctor from incurring liability. Furthermore, taking this approach recognises that the patient is not the only autonomous agent within the relationship. Physicians are equally autonomous and should have their rights to refuse to render the desired

Welfare Liberty

872 words - 4 pages and assess the healthcare rights and ethical aspects of patient care which they could potentially encounter. Welfare Rights Welfare rights, also called claim or positive rights, allow people to pursue their legitimate or personal interests that do not interfere with the interest of other people that are similar and equal to one’s own (Masters, 2014). The people who commonly fall into this category include the poor and the elderly (Butts & Rich

Similar Essays

Patient Physician Relationship: The Effects Of Autonomy And Paternalism

2390 words - 10 pages Introduction The practice of medicine in general has changed due to changes in technology, economics, epidemiology, and demographics. But particularly, the patient-physician relationship has been transformed during the past century, from one characterized by strong physician paternalism to one that reflects strong patient autonomy. (1) Medical ethics in general is not a modern term; it goes back in time to the 12th century to the Hippocratic

"At Long Last The English Courts Now Recognise And Endorse Patient Autonomy" Discuss

2766 words - 11 pages In relation to health care law the principle patient autonomy entails taking into account and giving consideration to the patient's views of their treatment.Autonomy was first recognised as a relevant ethical principle to be endorsed by the courts in relation to heath care law by Mr Justice Cardozo in America and later affirmed in the English courts by Lord Donaldson; "An adult patient who suffers from no mental incapacity has an absolute right

The Importance Of Patient Advocacy Essay

1405 words - 6 pages attributes that are: safeguarding patients’ autonomy; acting on behalf of patients; and championing social justice in the provision of health care. (Bu & Jezewski, 2006) Problem Solving Problem solving is when there is a problem or issue that needs to be resolved. When there is a problem with a patient the nursing staff needs to try and resolve it to make all parties satisfied. When trying to solve a problem, keep in mind about the core attribute

Role Of Medical Interpreter As Patient Advocate

1725 words - 7 pages in the interest of patient health and well-being.” (45) In order to understand the advocate role is important to know the characteristics of the Latino patient. The Latino patient faces language, cultural, educational, and economic barriers when seeking and accessing medical care. Also, often they are unfamiliar with the healthcare system and their rights. For all these reasons, a medical interpreter can advocate for a patient who does not