Patriotism, Glory, And Other Lies Essay

1798 words - 7 pages

Patriotism, Glory, and Other Lies
Author: Billy Smith

    Many themes, in World War I literature, hinge on the distinction between the soldiers and the elite.  Soldiers in World War I were, metaphorically, the swords with which elites of opposing countries would strike each other: the swords were continually bloodied while the hands of the elite remained immaculate.  Since the soldiers were doing the grunt work for the elites, they were able to witness, first-hand, the atrociousness of war.  This atrociousness was, however, in contrast to what the soldiers had been told about war; concepts such as glory were mysteriously absent from the trenches on the Western front.  War, rather than being portrayed as the dehumanizing tragedy that it is, was portrayed as a glorious adventure.  Not too long after a soldier experienced their first bombardment did they realise that glory had nothing to do with war.  War, it could be seen, was merely a game played by the elites at the expense of the working-class.
    The glorious perception of war was grossly incongruous with what the soldiers perceived.  To a soldier, the war was devastating; yet, the elite were oblivious or neglectful of this devastation.  This notion is exemplified by the following quote from Base Details: "`Poor young chap, ... I used to / know his father well; // Yes, we've lost heavily in this last scrap.' // And when the war is done and youth stone dead, // I'd toddle safely home and die - in bed" (Course Kit, p131).  Apathy to this extent is repugnant to people outside of a war; however, amongst soldiers, this is a necessary mental tactic.  Yet, this quote was not by a soldier, it was by an officer.  The irony thus lies in the lack of association with the soldier by the officer.  It is unlikely that the officer feels any sorrow for the individual; if there is any sorrow, it is for the loss of the potential killing that this figurative war machine could have produced.  This objectification of soldiers as instruments of death is echoed in Siegfried Sassoon's Counter Attack: "Down, and down, and down, he sank and drowned, // bleeding to death.  The counter-attack had failed" (Silkin, p130).  The fact that this poem ends with the statement, "The counter-attack had failed," indicates that this individual's death, viewed from a macroscopic perspective - that is, the perspective of the elites - is insignificant: significance is seen to lie in the fact that this killing-machine's production had been halted, and it's task remains incomplete.  Two additional quotes implying the insignificance of soldiers is in A Working Party: "He was a young man with a meagre wife // And two small children in a Midland town..." (Silkin, p94) and in All Quiet on the Western Front "...almost all of us are simple folk.  And in France, too, the majority of men are labourers, workmen, or poor clerks....

Find Another Essay On Patriotism, Glory, and Other Lies

Patriotism and The American Flag Essay

1006 words - 4 pages representation is that the flag represents our history, and the formerly mentioned idea of patriotism. Others believe the flag also represents our history as a nation, but these beliefs focus much more heavily on the negative aspects of our history; such as slavery and other injustices carried out by our nation. These people often believe we should find a new iconography for our country’s ideas of patriotism. As Barbara Kingsolver states in “And Our

Reasearch Paper Outline

1070 words - 5 pages hatred of other countries and therefore brings about hostility and international tensions. Besides, Tolstoy argues that patriotism is stupid because it makes people claim that their country is the best of all, which is impossible. In the current context of globalization, with borders disappearing, cultures getting in touch with one another and supranational organizations increasing their power, one can also reject patriotism. Karl Marx’s appeal

"Patriotism in America: Common, yet Nonexistent"

963 words - 4 pages someone who has never stopped to separate patriotism and nationalism, and even now, when I have begun to form different ideas about the two, have trouble seeing where one ends and the other begins. My definition of patriotism that Americans experience is pride in your country, and love of your possession of it, something which leads to feelings of hate and superiority.A lot of my ideas on patriotism come from the fact that I live in a country

The Red Badge of Courage by Stephen Crane

2715 words - 11 pages for Students). Henry’s views do not change from the beginning to end of the book as Breslin states. Henry only superficially grows when he lies about being shot in the head and this was his desperate attempt to attain his goals. But without this brave soldier front he is still desperate to achieve glory. Henry’s first battle is his real test to see if his visions of war and glory will be upheld and during the battle he runs away from the fighting

The Glory Of War Analyzed in Homer’s The Iliad and Ishmael Beah’s Autobiography, A Long Way Gone

649 words - 3 pages stop trusting each other, and every stranger becomes an enemy.” (Beah 37) In this passage and throughout the text, there are no hyperboles or exquisite descriptions regarding the plights of war; only Beah’s legitimate experiences described in as few words as possible. That the glory of war is not intrinsic in and of itself becomes increasingly evident by virtue of the fact that Homer must employ language to glorify war; rather than simply describe

British National Cinema: This Happy Breed

2449 words - 10 pages seem disinterested in the “glory of the empire” and all they care about “is the dodgems” This alludes to the dying tradition of patriotism itself. Older generations such as Frank and Ethel still retain patriotism towards the dwindling British Empire, yet it doesn’t hold the same majesty to younger generations. Robert Newton’s character, Frank Gibbons, is given to making statements that desensitize his experiences of the First World War. During a

Is American Patriotism Also Blind Patriotism?

1074 words - 4 pages wrong for the wife in “Peace and War” to underestimate the dangers around her. However, we must also honor the micro-society, both here and in other parts of the world. Will our actions as a nation lead our soldiers into traumatic situations like the soldier in “An Easy Death”? Or will we consider the families and communities involved, saving ourselves from micro-societal damage? I only hope that we can learn from stories such as these and not take our “blind” patriotism too far. Works Cited Global Cultures. A Transnational Short Fiction Reader, ed. by Elisabeth Young-Bruehl (University Press of New England, Hanover and London, 1994)

Pefines patriotism on a philosphical level

637 words - 3 pages articles of clothing may come upon feces or other bodily fluids is deemed disrespectful and degrading. Americans are proud people and are enthusiastic when displaying our colors. The purpose of American flag fashion is to express our patriotism. When contemplating the issue of respect associated with patriotism one should consider the intent and actual purpose behind the action.Whether wrong or right, Patriotism is supporting your country in the

The Exploitation of Patriotism to Serve the Government's Interests

1905 words - 8 pages One of the most important tools that any government can take advantage of to advance its control is the patriotism of its people. Throughout the history of the world patriotism has been used to justify war, injustice against others and to manipulate a whole population of people. Patriotism is not a word which is meant to have negative effects. As the Merriam Webster online dictionary defines it, patriotism is the "love for or devotion to


1212 words - 5 pages should be expressed. Reading articles on patriotism has helped me to learn and understand how I feel about my own patriotic view.War often stirs feelings of patriotism amongst citizens as the nation unites against a threat to its existence. The tragedy seemed to reinforce patriotism in many souls throughout America. Society is being more honest and less selfish regarding patriotism by expressing their feelings and by volunteering their time and


1212 words - 5 pages should be expressed. Reading articles on patriotism has helped me to learn and understand how I feel about my own patriotic view.War often stirs feelings of patriotism amongst citizens as the nation unites against a threat to its existence. The tragedy seemed to reinforce patriotism in many souls throughout America. Society is being more honest and less selfish regarding patriotism by expressing their feelings and by volunteering their time and

Similar Essays

What Is “Patriotism”? Essay

1253 words - 5 pages and in the world. It stands as method for citizens of the United States, patriots, and defenders of "Old Glory" to voice their support of our flag and for freedom.Henry believes in displaying flags, wearing patriotic clothes, pins and buttons.The third person I interviewed was Katie Ford, a 24-year-old independent.She believes that Americans should be patriotic and show a love of their country.Katie believes that patriotism should come before

The Patriotic America This Is A Research Paper About The History, Changes, And Effects Of Partiotism In America

1788 words - 7 pages that America will win the 'War on Terrorism' (18). Assurance of one's country rising to glory presents a typical example of how Americans, such as the president, view patriotism. However, even the enemy believes in his cause and Osama bin Laden has fought for both his beliefs and country. A close friend of Osama, Khaled al-Fawwaz describes him: "Humble, charming, intelligent, a really significant wealthy chap for Islamic causes who gave up

Defining Glory Essay

1620 words - 6 pages selfish and wrong? The problem requires more than an understanding of God’s desires. First, it lies in understanding what glory is. As is evident through the nature of glory, the nature of God, and the nature of man, God’s glory is something difficult to define, but man can be sure to know that it is not pride. The first thing to be examined here is glory itself. In C.S. Lewis’ article The Weight of Glory, Lewis notes the complexity of the issue

Overwhelming Patriotism Essay

762 words - 3 pages , Cummings juxtaposes them almost right on top of each other, with on running into the other. This gives off to feelings of an overwhelming amount of patriotism that is forced upon the listener. By doing this, Cummings gives dual meaning to the first four lines of the poem. The emotion of the poem takes a turn in the next five lines. In classic Cummings style, he combines the words “deaf and dumb” into one which makes it more pronounced within the