Peaceful Protesting As A Liberty University, Year 1 Essay

1150 words - 5 pages

Ruthven 5
Caitlin Ruthven
Dr. James Sikkema
Philosophy
400051826
27 March 2017
Peaceful Protesting as a Liberty
For years now, there has been an on-going conflict between the objectors of the North Dakota Access Pipeline and law enforcement. By attacking the protesters, law enforcement introduced legislations banning peaceful protesting, which is in direct conflict with John Stuart Mills’ One Simple Principle (also referred to as Harm Principle). Policies that criminalize protesting are illegitimate, and intrude upon the constitutional rights of the United States of America (U.S) citizens; specifically, rights introduced within the first amendment. This paper will reflect upon the legitimacy of peaceful protesting (provided it remain within the classifications of Mills’ Harm Principle), and the illegitimacy of legislations banning peaceful protesting, as it not only silences citizens, but infringes upon their rights.
“[T]he only purpose for which power can be rightfully exercised over any member of a civilized community, against his will, is to prevent harm to others.” (On Liberty). This statement made by Mills is an introduction to his One Simple Principle, which proposes that liberty is respected, but only to the extent that it does not harm others (Mills 134). In this context, harm refers to anything that damages one physically or mentally. This includes one’s mind, body, and property. In the case of the North Dakota Pipeline protest, the objectors were peacefully protesting; something that causes no harm to others. At most, peaceful protesting may be viewed as a nuisance. The pipeline protesters were described as non-confrontational, but defiant, by the County Sheriff, Kyle Kirchmeir (Macpherson). The ultimate purpose of this protest, as with most protests, was to provoke a response from the authoritative figures. This goal was accomplished; however, the response was not what the objectors had hoped for. Despite protesting peacefully, causing absolutely no harm to others and ultimately pushing trying to defend the environment, protesters were attacked and silenced by law enforcement, simply for being a nuisance. According to Mills One Simple Principle, law enforcement was completely unjustified in their actions, as no harm was caused by the protest, therefore making it a legitimate form of protest.
Furthermore, Mills proposes that there are certain scenarios in which causing harm to others may be justifiable. This includes instances in which one is ultimately preventing harm to others (133). In other words, it is acceptable for one to harm another only if that person is going to harm another person, or society as a whole. In the North Dakota Pipeline protest, the tribes argued that the placement of the pipeline is a threat not only to water and cultural sites, but to the surrounding wildlife as well (Macpherson). Similarly, the Standing Rock objectors feared not only losing their rights, but losing the well-being of the land. The placing of...

Find Another Essay On Peaceful protesting as a Liberty - University, Year 1 - Essay

Conceptions of Canada as a Peaceful Nation

1548 words - 6 pages Canadians often pride themselves as being different from, and more innocent than their American neighbors, who have a well-known history of slavery and racism. Canada is built upon naïve and passive conceptions of being a kinder, gentler, and more peaceful nation in comparison to the United States. These unchallenged assumptions, or myths, allow Canada to "tell a story of national goodness," while effectively erasing sections of history

Obedience As the Means to a Peaceful Life

1648 words - 7 pages those with authority over them. Through obedience the participants were able to accept that their actions were not theirs, but that they were justified in their reactions, which enabled them to come to peaceful terms with the Stanford Prison Study in which they played a role. The human need to be obedient and please those in authority as a demand of one’s role was also seen in the study conducted by Stanley Milgram in 1964. Milgram designed a

Economic Integration as a Peaceful Solution to the China-Taiwan Crisis

1941 words - 8 pages PAGE PAGE 3 International Relations of East and Southeast AsiaEconomic Integration as a Peaceful Solution to the China-Taiwan CrisisMy argument for the economic integration and the interaction between Taiwan and China will help both countries to define their sovereignty in the future, which China and Taiwan have fought over for the past fifty years. I believe the sovereignty of Taiwan and its ambiguous identity will work itself out through the

Masculinity and hegemonic masculinity - second year of university - essay

2780 words - 12 pages ” person. Through virtue of this trait, a person is seen as reliable, capable of tackling issues first hand and able of coming to problem resolution more efficiently, not being dependant of support from another party. Up until contemporary times, in societies where female social/financial independence was not as common or easy to achieve, the independent man has been sought after for a couple of key reasons: 1. Assuring one’s wellbeing, through the

Judicial activism vs Judicial Restraint - 2nd year University - Essay

778 words - 4 pages Research Essay The debate on whether the judiciary should be only a firm administrator of the law or whether it should actively engage in deciding on moral wars or interpreting the law not so strictly so that to pursue . Particularly, in societies where there is a Supreme Court like the United States, this debate is intensified. In the United States, the Supreme Court, as per the Constitution, is capable of overturning laws passed by the

Essay for Admission to Business School - Second Year University. SImon Fraser University - Essay

873 words - 4 pages score of 17 of 20 made it even more memorable. nces in which I learnt so much and it was not so much as for myself as it was for the people I was to be impacting. It was a responsibility that required patience, perseverance and sympathy. We were to be welcoming new students, some international, some who had never left their homes to begin a new life that was to be their University experience. It was overwhelming for a lot of the students and it

An Analysis of Steve Jobs as a Leader - Ashford University - Essay

2592 words - 11 pages Steve Jobs was a highly controversial but extremely successful leader of one of the largest and most successful companies in the world. Jobs dazzled the business world and the general public with his drive for excellence, but annoyed at even angered many of his executives and employees with his single-minded vision. Jobs was remarkable and visionary, and he helped to revolutionize personal computers and the digital industry as a whole. Thanks

Comparison paper - Declaration of Independence and US Constituion - Liberty University Govt 200 - essay

712 words - 3 pages Comparison Paper Comparison Paper Angela DeRubbio Liberty University – GOVT 200-D02 The Declaration of Independence, U.S. Constitution, and Thomas Jefferson’s Letter to the Danbury Baptists in 1802 are all very important documents in our nation’s history. All three documents are similar in that their very foundations were based on the religious beliefs of our founding fathers, whether written or implied. Some of the Founding Fathers were

What I Hope to Gain from a Honors Program Education at Liberty University

1721 words - 7 pages can happen. Yet, as my parents would say, college is all about preparing for your future. I know that Liberty takes its motto seriously and I intend to keep “Knowledge Aflame” by being challenged educationally at Liberty and ultimately preparing for my law career after graduation. I also look forward to being a part of several extra-curricular activities, such as acapella and theatre. This past year in high school I have discovered my passion for

My future goals as a University Student

923 words - 4 pages Personal Goals that I wish to Attain as a University Student Antoinette Sachetta Outline: Personal Goals that I wish to attain as a University Student I)Meaning of the word goal a)All Students have Goals b)Overachieving and Goals II) Why I have set goals to achieve a)Wants and needs b)Personal satisfaction III)The Goals I have set for myself a)Patience b)Getting through the first course c)Learning to use critical thinking d)Learning

Reality of FDR's Liberty for Japanese Americans During World War 2 - History 1 - Short Essay

870 words - 4 pages progress in a wider and constantly rising standard of living” (Roosevelt, 1941). Yet even such “basic, simple” things were actually out of reach for racial minorities such as Japanese-Americans. Iiyama’s father leased a low-income hotel, however “He could not buy it, because there were laws at that time against Asians owning property” (Chizu Iiyama, p.1). When she started college education in University of California, Berkeley, wanting to be a school

Similar Essays

Waste Analysis Hotel Industry Holiday Inn University Year 1 Essay

826 words - 4 pages WASTE Source: (Environmental management for hotels: the industry guide to sustainable operations, 2008) Fig.1 WATER WASTE A hotel requires considerable amounts of water which becomes an increasingly scarce and expensive resource (Kirk, 1996). Water accounts for 10% of a typical hotel utility bill, therefore a lower consumption would lead to reduced costs (Fig.1). Moreover many hotels pay for the water they consume twice: purchasing and then

Genesis 1 11 Essay For Old Testamanet Liberty University Old Testament

1023 words - 5 pages Madison Brooke Gauldin ID #L25233028 BIBL 105-002 October 3, 2016 Genesis 1-11 Essay New International Version Bible Introduction Genesis 1-11 is extremely important in understand God’s creation and the foundation of God’s word. It identifies what God teaches on the natural world, human identity, human relationships, and civilization. These four aspects are extremely significant when trying to understand the world, as well as all that God

Replacing Qualified Nurses With Less Skilled Support Workers, Linked To Greater Death Risk”. London South Bank University Year 1 Essay

3153 words - 13 pages Government in 2015, which has commenced in December 2016, a 2-year programme in nursing taught in few universities which trains the existing support workers to sit alongside registered nurses and support workers. They are said to also undergo almost equal training, knowledge and skills of a Registered nurse, as they aim to deliver the high-quality care patient needs (Glasper, 2017). However, studies have revealed that this new role are lower skilled

Summary Of The Context Of Our Character, Part 1 Rhodes University, 2nd Year Assignment

699 words - 3 pages Summary of The Context of Our Character, Part 1 In this chapter, Dan Ariely explores why people are dishonest and what factors this. Ariely notes that there are two types of dishonesty, the first being the explicit type, where the perpetrators consider every aspect of their crime and acknowledge that what they are engaging in, is dishonest behaviour. The second type is that which is exerted by people who consider themselves as honest; this type