Peer Production: An Agent Of Good Or Evil?

2077 words - 9 pages

Peer Production: An Agent of Good or Evil?
A Comparative Essay in the Context of Wikipedia

Traditionally, centralized organizations such as governments, religious institutions and universities were responsible for information production and sharing. However, over the past decade, the Internet has decentralized the process and promoted open-source software (OSS). OSS is software that is freely used, edited, and shared by anyone. As a result of OSS, users are able to generate content, also known as peer production. Peer production, according to Yochai Benkler (2006, p. 85), is a way of voluntarily donating meaningful, collaborative information from dynamic people. One modern example is ...view middle of the document...

Similarly, diverse ideas are important in creating high quality information and making educated decisions. For Surowiecki (2004):

The fact that cognitive diversity matters does not mean that if you assemble a group of diverse but thoroughly uninformed people, their collective wisdom will be smarter than an expert's. But if you can assemble a diverse group of people who possess varying degrees of knowledge and insight, you're better off entrusting it with major decisions rather than leaving them in the hands of one or two people, no matter how smart those people are. (Surowiecki, 2004, p. 31)

This means that diverse opinions (due to different levels of knowledge) are more valuable than the views of a few experts. Surowiecki (2004) explained that most experts within a field tend to think alike and conform to what other experts believe without challenging the results. Moreover, these experts can also be biased due to restricted amounts of information. Rarely, he added, does an expert show the complexity and the entirety of a question or research topic (p. 22). Agreeably, no single expert can understand everything about a topic, especially in a constantly changing environment. However, many people can give multiple views and illuminate the issue better.
Nevertheless, Surowiecki (2004) admitted that peer production has flaws. It does not always produce precise content and informed decisions. He clarified that the failures are often caused by the contributors becoming biased or concerned with the opinions of others. Consequently, they often follow the ideas of others (called “group think”) rather than thinking separately (p. 30).
Likewise, the Joseph Reagle’s book titled Good Faith Collaboration: The Culture of Wikipedia (2010) supported Surowiecki’s claim that peer production and collaboration can have many advantages. According to Reagle (2010), Wikipedia allows content creators and editors to give and synthesize their views. This ability, he said, creates a comprehensive and reliable resource since people assume “good faith” (p. 60). Good faith implies that everyone attempts to objectively help the project without hidden agendas or malice.
In sharp contrast, Andrew Keen (2007) blamed peer production for producing low quality information. For Keen, society’s support of the amateur-generated content means that “in today’s cult of the amateur, the monkeys are running the show” (p. 9). He stressed that Internet contributors know little about fact-finding or writing skills. Moreover, Keen explained:

In the digital world’s never ending stream of unfiltered, user-generated content, things are indeed often not what they seem. Without [expert] editors, fact-checkers, administrators, or regulators to monitor what is being posted, we have no one to vouch for the reliability or credibility of the content we read. (Keen, 2007, p. 16)

However, Keen disregarded the fact that Wikipedia does have administrators who vet the information. And, he also...

Find Another Essay On Peer Production: An Agent of Good or Evil?

Themes in "Lord of the Flies" : Good vs. Evil --Are people generally good or generally evil?

1053 words - 4 pages There are various outlooks of a man in the novel ?Lord of the Flies.? Piggy and Ralph viewed man as being essentially good and that evil happens because something was wrong with people. Jack used power over others and believed that forces more powerful than him must be appeased through ceremony and sacrifice. Simon believed that both good and evil lay within each person. William Golding?s point of view is also represented by one of the

Mankind; Naturally Good or Evil? Essay

965 words - 4 pages . In regards to this, William Golding’s novel, Lord of the Flies, is a story is told about many guilty boys, however, the boys are very young. In so, many wonder if the boys are naturally evil or good and they do not know what to do without adults. As Simon said in Lord of The Flies, “Maybe," he said hesitantly, "maybe there is a beast." [...] "What I mean is, maybe it's only us.” (Golding 89). In Lord of the Flies, the boys are afraid of an

Is man Good or Evil?

698 words - 3 pages Man is innately good, but has the ability to be evil.I believe that a majority of people do what they believe to be right.Whether they are correct or not is another matter. In order to be trulyevil, I believe that one has to purposely, consciously, try to hurt others.Be it physically or mentally, a conscious effort to injure others is for noobvious benifit to the human race is evil. I also think that good and evilare on totally different planes

The Mind: Evil or Good?

1824 words - 8 pages live his life, he just went day to day doing what he had to do. The power his mind held over him was extensive and it weighed on him every day of his life. These two characters, from two expert-written books, perfectly exemplify the potentially damaging effects the mind can have on an individual. It is able to manipulate a human being into believing their life has no worth or that there is no good in the world or within themselves. It is

Is Love Good or Evil?

1023 words - 4 pages Is Love Good or Evil? Love is an emotion we all experience in our lives. The feeling is amazing for most people and not so wonderful for others. As I searched for the word love in the dictionary, the definition explained it to be a strong affection and warm attachment for another person. I believe the word love has a more intense and deeper meaning than any dictionary is able to represent. It does little to define what love is

Hackers good or evil? Argues civil liberities of true hackers

1474 words - 6 pages . A cracker is one who breaks security on a system. Coined by hackers in defense against journalistic misuse of the term "hacker". The term "cracker" reflects a strong revulsion at the theft and vandalism perpetrated by cracking rings. Hackers think of themselves as a person who enjoys exploring the details of programmable systems and how to stretch their capabilities or a person who is good at programming quickly (Slatalla). An example of a

Offshore Outsourcing: Good or Evil?

1977 words - 8 pages business’s productivity are not necessarily the same. Outsourcing occurs when a business pays another business or individual – sometimes called a vendor or subcontractor – to perform work that is important to the operation of the first business. For example, a computer manufacturer may hire an outside programmer or group of programmers to write special software for a new line of computers. Obviously these programmers may reside in the same

Living Together; good or evil

866 words - 4 pages directly correlates to almost 5 million people. While this number might not be that significant Popenoe and Whitehead (2001) report that “66% of high school senior boys and 61% of the girls indicated that they ‘agreed’ or ‘mostly agreed’ with the statement ‘it is usually a good idea for a couple to live together before getting married in order to find out whether they really get along’” (p.3). This research shows that cohabitation is an accepted

Celebrity Worshipping: Good or Evil?

1376 words - 6 pages influences to the teens (18). I think it is definitely true that we should appreciate and learn from the good behaviours of the celebrities. But sometimes we should not go extreme, especially when they have done something horrible to people or to the society; we have to reconsider to admire them and follow their steps as usual. People have been overly dedicated to make the kids immune to idol worship through books and speeches. Actually, people need

Video Games: Good or Evil?

3639 words - 15 pages answer questions easily shows the ability of being able to talk among others easily gives more confidence to the individual and increases their social skills (Griffiths). Everyone who plays video games act differently they could put themselves in isolation, or they can help improve their social skills by playing with their friends. A number of sources see specific video games as effective teaching tools. One study has shown that Tetris can help

Do you think that human nature is good, or evil, or both good and evil, or neither good nor evil?

1154 words - 5 pages that human nature is good but Xunzi believed that human nature is evil. In another points of view, YangHsiung believed that Human nature is mixture of good and evil. In the principle of Yin-yang, human nature was considered to be neither good nor evil. Since people were born with good and evil human nature and human nature is influenced by our surroundings, therefore human nature is both good and evil. In this essay, evidences and some examples

Similar Essays

Choosing: Good Or Evil Essay

1015 words - 4 pages bees from the comb. Yet today the behavior of people mostly from ignorance, descending to vulgarity, possesses souls of pride, malice, hateful, divisive and these feelings can be amplified and can lead to real disaster. People are bitter, eager for revenge, they want to hurt or even kill souls. 'Smoke' obscures them! What we choose for our lives? We want to be good, to live in harmony, or want to be evil, revengeful, to live in discord? Choosing

Walmart: Good Or Evil Essay

1001 words - 4 pages that as far as I can see no job in Wal-Mart allows sitting down. It doesn't pay a "family wage," but does pay enough to give teens some income and experience or provide a second income to a household. Most people prefer to shop at Wal-Mart because (a) they have the best prices, (b) I can buy nearly everything I need in one location. In order to get more opinions I decided to ask a fellow shopper, "Is Wal-Mart good or bad for America?" One of

Rorschach Good Or Evil? Essay

695 words - 3 pages peaceful, gentle lamb, which is symbolizes Jesus in Blake’s poetry, then can God be a God of duality, of both good and evil, as symbolized in the ferocity of the tiger. In one view the “The Tyger” appears frightening and destructive, whereas in another view its creation is a triumph of a disarming and refreshing nature, an event to bring a smile. When you apply this relation of “fearful symmetry” of good and evil to Rorschach it complicates his

Good Or Evil Essay

2369 words - 10 pages The argument as to whether humans are born good or evil is one that been philosophized for hundreds of years by many of the world’s greatest minds. Are humans born with a particular set of qualities that define their character and how they are perceived in society? Are they born with the power to choose between good and evil? The idea of human nature relies on the theory that there is an engrained set of features which are shared by all humans