This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Performance Evaluations Essay

943 words - 4 pages

Performance EvaluationsAs indicated within the following website,, there have been many downfalls with respects to performance evaluations despite all the efforts put into such evaluations to ensure their effectiveness. In "Effective performance appraisals," by Brian Gill, the author notes that a number of major problems have arisen within numerous organizations upon the performance evaluation process. Such potential problems include situations in which the a supervisor gives either excellent or poor ratings on every trait. Such traits may include quality of work, quantity of work, knowledge of the job, attendance and punctuality, dependability, adaptability, initiative, judgment, cooperativeness and personal qualities such as leadership, honesty and appearance. This is known as the "halo effect." Another potential problem is dubbed the "sunflower effect" and occurs when a supervisor gives his/her employees only high marks, despite bad performance, to make him or herself look like a good supervisor.Also noted within the website, as indicated by the text of Brian Gill, "Effective performance appraisals," yet another problem is giving everyone average marks to make the process easy and avoid conflict, which is known as a "central tendency." Some supervisors instead rate those employees who they know well and really like as exceptional performers, regardless of actual performance, which is a form of "favoritism." Personality and emotions an influence any evaluation process as well. For example, "guilt by association" is when a supervisor rates an employee not on performance, but by who the employee associates with. This is not a fair form of evaluation as the one employee may perform very well and the other may be a slacker. The exceptional employee should not be considered a lazy employee as well due to the fact that they eat lunch together everyday and maintain a friendship at work.It may be quite difficult to remain objective during a performance evaluation process, however, managers and supervisors alike must recognize that evaluations measure how well an employee performs his assigned function and not his direct personality. There should not be any bias or room to judge an employee with other forms of criteria other than those that relate to the job itself. It is important to create a rating system for employees and superiors to follow in the performance evaluation process in order to help eliminate the above noted problems encountered within the process. The rating system in place should not be based on merely personality rates of an employee, such as attendance and punctuality or honesty and appearance. Instead, the rating system should be based on goals to attempt to prevail over the limitations of trait-based systems by focusing on agreed upon performance goals instead of personal characteristics.The goal-based approach should be performed on a regular basis (i.e., semi-annually or quarterly) and...

Find Another Essay On Performance Evaluations

Plan for Evaluating and Improving Formative and Summative Teacher Evaluation

1284 words - 5 pages summative evaluation is not the recommended evaluation to improve teacher performance. Formative evaluations are the preferred evaluation methods used for increasing teacher performance (Glickman, Gordon, & Ross-Gordon 2009). Formative evaluations can take place over several different observations during the school year. As instructional supervisors, the evaluation of teachers, teaching methods, and classroom management skills are the most

The Navy's Poor Advancement Process Essay

1029 words - 4 pages qualities that are required to be an effective leader in today’s Navy. One aspect of the advancement process that should be changed is the evaluation program. Navy evaluations are based on several characteristics such as job performance, collateral duties, college courses taken, plus several other items. I want to focus on one specific aspect of this process, the collateral duties. These duties are secondary duties that an individual would volunteer

Evaluating Computer Professionals for Raises and Promotions

2073 words - 8 pages - -Evaluating Computer Professionals for Raises and PromotionsEvaluating Computer Professionals for Raises and PromotionsBackground of Evaluations of ProfessionalsSince the industrial revolution, all levels of management have used performance evaluations and performance reviews as standards for determining the productiveness of employees. This has been true for every type of job, from manual labor positions to top level managers. While the

The Importance of Performance Appraisals

1407 words - 6 pages job performance many evaluations provide quantitative measurements essential for a production-oriented work environment. An evaluation also sheds light on development programs, which benefit employee and employer. Other employee evaluations provide employers with metrics regarding the quality of employees' work. The importance of an employee evaluation is that it's instrumental in determining whether an employee's skill set is appropriately matched


1401 words - 6 pages that is responsible for education the youth. Likewise, it would mean that it would not matter if a teacher possessed a master’s, or even doctorate, degree or if they held a bachelor’s degree. Their compensation would be totally based on the rating they received on their evaluations (Sherman 2014). Critics of the performance pay model assert that the concept may lead to a popularity contest. Instead of the highest performing teachers being

Profesional Skepticism Related to Auditor´s Performance

606 words - 3 pages 5-98 b. How does the fundamental concept of professional skepticism relate to audit quality? PCAOB standards and oversight emphasize that professional skepticism is fundamental to the role and performance of auditors. The application of professional skepticism throughout the audit is a foundational aspect of audit quality and the integrity of the audit process. Professional skepticism is a key element of a quality audit, meaning not accepting

Introduction to Employee Evaluation

795 words - 4 pages essential. If goals are unrealistic and unattainable, the employee feels discouraged and employee moral become low. Evaluations are in place to promote and build dialogue with employees and leaders with a clear understanding of job expectation, also to apply standards provide opportunities to acknowledge good performance and coach when performance falls below expectations. Encourage self improvement and reward and recognize employee excellance

Performance Management System

919 words - 4 pages elements related to the reliability and validity of measures, the acceptability and fairness of evaluations and rewards, and the lack of consistent standards and ethical criteria for providing evaluations, negatively affects the efficacy of the PM system. In particular, the lack of reliable and valid measures of performance and evaluation undermines management’s ability to monitor the quality of appraisals for consistency of evaluation, which

Performance Appraisal

1120 words - 5 pages supervisor (Youssef, 2012). Exercising behavior-based methods, Schraeder, expresses that appraisals of employee performance should be directly connected to the accomplishment of job-related duties (p. 20, 2007). In addition, Schraeder supports this by further instructing that evaluations should be less biased in overall nature. Behavior-based systems, which help define job performance in stipulations of specific, observable results, offer strategic

Performance Evaluation

1839 words - 7 pages There is a purpose in doing performance evaluations, in which it helps management make general human resource decisions. Performance evaluations provide input to help make important decisions such as promotions, transfers and even terminations. Also, could help to identify training and developments they need, as well help develop programs and providing feedback to employees on how they performed on their review. Performance evaluation can

Evaluation of Programs

747 words - 3 pages ). Ethical standards must be maintained as well as positional standards (ASCA, 2012). The ASCA National Model and the Texas Counseling Program Guide provide a job description for professional school counselors, as well as performance appraisals/evaluations (ASCA, 2012) (Texas Counseling Association, 2004). Several school districts use these as guides when developing their own performance evaluations or use the ones provided directly from the website

Similar Essays

How Employee Evaluations Affect Performance Essay

910 words - 4 pages Based on our findings, performance appraisal is able to provide employees with feedback about their performance. XX Therefore, the supervisors should evaluate their employees because through performance appraisal evaluation, the supervisor is able to measure their employees’ level of performance and able to provide them feedback for further improvement on their weaknesses because supervisor is more experience on the daily process compare to the

Decision Making Identify And Describe A Minimum Of 3 Problems, Relating To Decision Making That Occur When Managers Complete Performance Reviews

877 words - 4 pages When managers and supervisors perform employee's performance appraisal/performance evaluations it has come to my attention that they are being inconsistent in the way they rate or evaluate employees. This could jeopardize our performance appraisal program. The problems I found can be rectified very easily and need to be taken care of as soon as possible. One of the problems I found was many managers and supervisors are affected by the halo

Organizational Behavior And Leadership Essay

1301 words - 5 pages The success of a corporation has been traditionally tied to how well the managers execute the roles of leading, planning and controlling. One of the key components of the controlling aspect of management is the evaluation of the people that they are managing. The function of this process involves monitoring performance goals and has management taking corrective actions when necessary. Performance evaluations can be described as the measurement

Student Evaluation Of Educators Essay

1661 words - 7 pages would be helpful to teachers who need views on how to reach slower students and whom welcome helpful criticism. However, the entire evaluation should not be based solely on students opinions. Teacher evaluations should not be done solely by students. However, if students filled out 10% of a teacher evaluation, which stated the student’s opinion about the teacher’s performance, this could be constructive for both teachers and students. Louisa