Personal Identity: Philosophical Views Essay

1278 words - 5 pages

Personal Identity: Philosophical Views

Alan Watts once said, "Trying to define yourself is like trying to bite
your own teeth." The task of personal identity is to define a quality of a
human which makes him or her a unique self. The person whose identity is in
question must realize themselves, and other people must identify this person.
In other words, what makes John unique from Bob? One must consider both
internal (mind) and external (body) perspectives. There are several general
philosophical theories of this identity problem. In the following paragraphs
one will find the body theory, soul theory, and a more detailed explanation of
the conscious theory.
     One theory of personal identity is known as the body theory. This is
defined as a person X has a personal identity if and only if they have the same
body Y. However there are two problems with this definition. The first is
qualitative. It is necessary to have the same body, but if that body is changed,
is one the same person? Someone's body is surely different at age 40 than at
age 4. Also a problem arrives in alterations to a body. If John goes to war,
becomes injured by a mine, and then has his legs amputated is he not still the
same person, John? Therefore, the preceding definition of body theory is not
sufficient, since it does not account alterations to the same body. Yet another
problem is numerical. If someone were to get a finger chopped off, would that
finger be considered another person? What if a scientist was to use someone's
DNA and replicate another person with the same body? Surely just because there
are two identical bodies, these bodies cannot be the same person. They would
live two different lives. Therefore, the body theory alone cannot be considered
a necessary and sufficient definition when defining personal identity.
     Another common theory of personal identity is the soul theory. This
theory is: a person is has personal identity if and only if they have the same
soul. The problem with this theory is arrived from the definition of a soul.
Soul is a very difficult term. It is thought by many to be a spirit that passes
from your body into another realm (i.e., heaven, hell, etc.). However, since no
one has ever seen, felt, touched, smelled, or tasted a soul, it is a mysterious
phenomenon. Since we have no clear and distinct idea of a soul , it would not
be wise to base the definition upon it. For instance, some religions believe in
reincarnation after death. This is when a soul enters another body. With this
in mind, someone's soul such as Elvis could become reincarnated in someone else
named John. However, we would not say that this Elvis and John are the same
person . Therefore, the definition of the soul theory fails in that the
definiens does not become sufficient for defining personal identity.
     The most recognized true...

Find Another Essay On Personal Identity: Philosophical Views

Philosophy Paper #1: Personal Identity

1121 words - 4 pages Personal Identity and Multiple Personality - Reviewed by John P. Lizza, Kutztown University of Pennsylvania - Philosophical Reviews - University of Notre Dame." About Philosophical Reviews - University of Notre Dame. Notre Dame Philosophical Reviews, 2004. Web. Mar. 2011. . Moore, Brooke Noel., and Kenneth Bruder. "Chapter 6- The Rise of Metaphysics and Epistemology; Chapter 9- The Pragmatic and Analytic Traditions; Chapter 7- The Eighteenth and Nineteenth Centuries." Philosophy: the Power of Ideas. New York, NY: McGraw-Hill, 2011. Print.

Understanding and Accepting Parfit's Nature of Persisting Persons

2043 words - 8 pages Parfit’s view on the nature of persisting persons raises interesting issues in terms of identity. Though there are identifiable objections to his views, I am in favor of the argument he develops. This paper will layout Parfit’s view on that nature of persisting person, show support as well as argue the objections to the theory. In Derek Parfit’s paper Personal Identity, Parfit provides a valid account of persisting persons through time through

Critically Examine Pythagoras This is an examination of Pythagoras's philosophy

1166 words - 5 pages onto further issues around the topic of personal identity. According to Jonathon Barnes the soul is; "...the seat of consciousness and of personality; a mans psuche is whatever makes him the person he is, whatever is responsible for his particular self and personality. Metempsychosis is the doctrine of the transcorporation of the self; and the psuche is the self. It is this which gives Pythagoras' theory a potential philosophical interest; for

Introduction to Kierkegaard’s philosophy

3516 words - 14 pages creativity. This creates a kind of intrigue. Kierkegaard takes as its starting point his personal destiny, where we find a memorial to curse dissolved marriage, full of false hypocrisy surroundings, community, unable to understand the messages of his countryman, religious institution that kills, not exalted soul. Can an autobiographical philosophy is philosophy? Yes, when it combines literary talent, a philosophical idea and psychological film

memory and personal identity

839 words - 4 pages Questions about God, knowledge, freedom, and immortality are asked not only by philosophers, but by all individuals. Answers to these questions are extraordinarily contradictory because different beliefs and opinions are held by everyone. A major philosophical issue is that of personal identity and immortality. Most commonly, philosophers attempt to discover what makes someone the same person they were ten or 20 years ago. Some argue that memory

Comparing Thomas Reid and David Hume on the topic of the mind-body problem

851 words - 3 pages Is there an "I", or a "self"? What exactly does this "self" refer to? These are questions raised by personal identity that many philosophers have attempted to answer. Most people would probably believe that they have a self, but there are people and philosophers that think differently. One such philosopher opposed to the idea of a self is David Hume. On the other side of the argument, Thomas Reid, another philosopher, believed that there is

Construction of one's self identity in today's society

2031 words - 8 pages of social and personal identity to which one chooses to allude. We seek to be as simple as we present ourselves to the world. This technology is as much about viewing ourselves a certain way, as it is about having other people view us. By abstracting oneself unto a web page, one sets a goal to which one should stand true.It is clear that due to the contemporary media with which we engage it is more likely that instead of experiencing, achieving

Identity Politics within Design Literacy

1957 words - 8 pages An informed understanding of identity within design is virtually a prerequisite of design literacy. Without the knowledge of such key design issues within design, how could designers possibly hope to create an artefact of social, cultural or even personal significance? Therefore to effectively operate as a designer one must come to an understanding of key design issues such as identity. Who you are, your origins, your environment - these are all

Memory Particles

737 words - 3 pages Imagine a scenario where you are in danger and your only chance for survival would be taking a teleportation device to another planet where you are not teleported, rather recreated. Furthermore, your body’s “blueprint” is sent to another planet where you are reconstructed as an exact copy of your original self – Down to the last particle. The question of whether or not you would take this journey creates the philosophical argument of personal


1735 words - 7 pages identities that he identifies with. He conveys the cry of Rumi in an attempt to match his personal response with proximity to the Persian poet’s sensibility. Khair not only suffers the dilemma of identity but also a severe stress of longing for his home town which interrupts his life. In his poems, he emphasises his homeland with its culture and its typical day to day life which he misses. In “Nurse’s Tales, Retold” the poem describes a common

Head Trauma in Memento, a film by Christopher Nolan

1851 words - 7 pages pictures, notes, and tattoos. Leonard’s single life mission is to find and kill his wife’s murderer. However, his condition allows him to seek vengeance over and over again. As a result, there is not only a barrier between Leonard and reality, but also a barrier between Leonard and the understanding of himself. Rooted in this confusing film is an important philosophical study of identity. How does the ability to make memories contribute to the

Similar Essays

Personal Identity, Philosophical Views Essay

1392 words - 6 pages philosophical theories of this identity problem. In the following paragraphs one will find the body theory, soul theory, and a more detailed explanation of the conscious theory.One theory of personal identity is known as the body theory. This is defined as a person X has a personal identity if and only if they have the same body Y. However there are two problems with this definition. The first is qualitative. It is necessary to have the same body

If You Know You Have Alzheimer's, How Do You Regard The Person Who Will Inherit Your Body? Is That Person You? How Is This Case Connected With Philosophical Theories Of Personal Identity?

769 words - 3 pages character traits, but rather, it is the fact that there is bodily continuity between me without Alzheimer's and me without any of my memories. The case of whether one holds this view or holds a different view is very closely connected with the various philosophical theories of personal identity. These theories are namely the psychological continuity view held by Parfit, the bodily continuity view, and the view that a persisting person is marked out

Dialogue Of Personal Identity And Immorality

1037 words - 5 pages reader or audience to the discussion to create their own thoughts in this discussion. Gretchen doesn’t find life after death as possible and challenges Sam to prove her wrong. In Perry’s Dialogue on Personal Identity and Immortality , Gretchen is dying and used her last days engaging in a philosophical debate with Sam over immortality or life after death. In this essay , I will present and compare both sides of the debating argument of immortality

John Locke’s Theory Of Personal Identity

1849 words - 7 pages John Locke (1632-1704) said ‘To find wherein personal identity consists, we must consider what person stands for …’ (Locke, in set book, p. 275). Therefore, to recapitulate Locke’s philosophy on personal identity it is necessary to clarify how he inimitably used the term ‘person’ and consequently other words, such as ‘substance’ and ‘man’, which he utilized to form his philosophical ideas. Furthermore, his work on personal identity inspired