Personhood Essay

873 words - 4 pages

In session one of this class one of the things that was discussed in our reading material in "The Bedford Guide for College Readers" was writing an opening. The Bedford Guide suggests to "Begin with a story" it advises that "Often a simple anecdote can capture your readers’ interest and thus serve as a good beginning" (2011 pg 429). The story of Aaron is very powerful; as a parent it tugs on my heartstrings and immediately drew me into the rest of the story.
The subject of this essay is, at what point do we stop being meaningless cells and become an actual living person. My personal opinion on this subject, is that we have always been people; at every point from beginning to end. The Bible tells us in Jeremiah 1:5 “Before I formed you in the womb I knew you, and before you were born I consecrated you; I appointed you a prophet to the nations" (ESV). God is specifically talking about Jeremiah in this verse, but I firmly believe it applies to all of us. God knew us before we were ever born, how could he have known us if we weren't alive and in fact people.
The essay brings up several complex points, there is no definitive proof of personhood, and many different people have many different beliefs on when it actually begins and ends. Does it begin once you are born? Is it something you have to have a specific level of capability to obtain? Is it something you could lose if you dropped below that capability.

Smietana cites many people of many different mindsets in the essay. The first of course being Susan Barg she seemed to be of the mindset that God knew what he was doing from the start. At the very least I would say she would agree (though not specifically stated) that life begins at conception.
Robert D. Orr, director of ethics at the University of Vermont College of Medicine also shares this view, as does John Kilner, director of The Center for Bioethics and Human Dignity. Susan Haack, a Wisconsin OB-GYN and member of the ethics commission of the Christian Medical Association shares this belief as well.
Amy Laura Hall adamantly opposes IVF. She feels that it is clear looking at an embryo that life begins before conception.
Bioethics professor Peter Singer of Princeton University would argue Aaron is not a person; this would indicate his stance was that a specific level of development is required to obtain personhood. Michael was, ceo of Advanced Cell Technology does not believe that an embryo is a...

Find Another Essay On personhood

Assisted Suicide- Facing the End of life with Personhood

1972 words - 8 pages policy should respect the idea that dying with personhood may involve dying by means of a legally prescribed substance when dying time arrives, as in the Death with Dignity Act approved for terminally ill patients in the state of Oregon. As noted by Norman Cousins, (2004) "Death is not the ultimate tragedy of life. The ultimate tragedy is depersonalization". (p. 24).A slippery slope argument is an ethical argument based on the idea that certain

A Case Against Warren and Abortion

1309 words - 6 pages “I intend to judge things for myself; to judge wrongly, I think, is more honorable than not to judge at all.” What author Henry James meant by this was that it is better to make up one’s mind and have an opinion than to remain complacent, such as the case of Mary Anne Warren. Warren’s arguments for abortion’s possible permissibility are lacking in substance. The aim of my paper is to discuss Warren’s insufficient criteria for personhood and

The Immorality of Taking the Future from a Person: The cons of abortion based on the ideas that a fetus has potential for a future.

2468 words - 10 pages that when debating abortion a key factor is determining whether the fetus can be classified as a person. If the fetus is characterized with personhood, then abortion is considered morally wrong. It is important, however, to conjecture what it means to be a person, and philosophers have developed criteria to determine personhood. There must be sufficient conditions present in a being to guarantee it personhood. The logical movement of this theory

Analysis of Warren's Book, On the Moral and Legal Status of Abortion, Questions of Life and Death

869 words - 3 pages For Warren the central question in the debate over abortion is the status of the fetus as a moral person. According to Warren a fetus, while part of the human community in the genetic sense, is not a member of the moral community as it does not meet the personhood criteria, and therefore can be justifiably terminated. It’s important to note the difference between being a biological and moral member of a community. A fetus is biologically human

Abortion: Is it Possible to be both Pro-life and Pro-Choice? Carl Sagan and Ann Druyan

1032 words - 4 pages personhood, the problem is another matter. Mary Anne Warren suggests the concept of personhood (Warren): 1) Consciousness (of objects and events external and/or internal to the being), and in particular the capacity to feel pain; 2) Reasoning (the developed capacity to solve new and relatively complex problems); 3) Self-motivated activity (activity which is relatively independent of either genetic or direct external control); 4) The capacity to

Immorality of Abortion

980 words - 4 pages After reading many positions on abortion, I have come to the conclusion that a fetus is a person and the right to life of a fetus outweighs that of a woman's right to bodily integrity. Hence, that abortion is immoral. Supporters arguments are that a fetus has no right to life at all based on the belief that is does not meet a set of criteria for personhood. Therefore, a woman may choose to abort at anytime during her pregnancy. Some may say that


596 words - 2 pages , because her partner wants her to have an abortion, etc.When it comes to an issue like abortion, there will always be opposing beliefs. These contrasting views are categorised into the pro-life view and the pro-choice view.*To most pro-lifers, human personhood begins at the instant of conception. Thus, they view each abortion as a form of murder. They note that at conception, a human life with its own unique DNA comes into being. They feel that all

Abortion: For or Against? - Write a persuasive essay

547 words - 2 pages The topic of abortion has been a controversial issue for several years. Many people believe that abortion should not be legal, that it is murder. Still others believe that abortion should be legal, stating that the mother should have the right to choose. The question is what do we, as a nation, do about it?Those who are totally against abortions (pro-lifers) believe that “Personhood begins at conception.” This belief is based on the

Permitting Abortion and Prohibiting Prenatal Harm

4016 words - 16 pages There is a basic contradiction involved in permitting abortion while at the same time prohibiting prenatal harm. (1) This contradiction can be stated in personhood terms and in terms of the woman's rights. I'd like to elucidate that contradiction and examine three solutions which rise out of current literature; I'd like then to propose a somewhat new, fourth solution. The Contradiction Stated in terms of personhood, the contradiction is

Turing, Searle, and Artificial Intelligence

1443 words - 6 pages referred to as an “it,” to avoid an unintentional bias in favor of or against personhood. Now, to formulate plausible opinions that could emerge from Turing and Searle, we simply need to remember what tenants found their respective schools of thought and apply them logically to the given conditions of this scenario. Part A: From Turing It is best to begin with Turing’s hypothetical opinion, considering Searle’s will later require an additional

A Rational Look at the Abortion Controversy

3845 words - 15 pages rights in the first place; it seems that she considers it self-evident that this is so, mentioning only that she thinks "there are very good reasons for not defining the moral community"6 in such a way that every human being is ipso facto included. Be that as it may, she asks: "What moral characteristics entitle an entity to be considered a person?"7 and goes on to list five "traits which are most central to the concept of personhood"8 in her

Similar Essays

Personhood Essay

642 words - 3 pages There are many different levels on which us humans have the ability to function. From, the lowest, being in a coma all the way up to an intelligent person, who is well educated. Can our ability to reason be the only determining factor in whether or not we possess personhood? What about those amongst us who do not have that ability? Does that mean that they don’t have moral worth? It depends on whom you ask. Some believe that

Personhood Essay

749 words - 3 pages Personhood What is a person? That sounds like a harmless question, but the answer can get very complicated. Is a person just a lump of skin, muscles, bones, and other materials? Is a person something immaterial like a mind or a soul? Or is a person a combination of these two things? Really there is no right answer, and it all depends on the point of view that you hold.      First of all, what is a body? Some say that

Human Personhood Begins At Conception Essay

1114 words - 4 pages Human Personhood Begins at Conception Peter Kreeft, Ph. D, is a professor of philosophy at Boston College and at the King's College, in New York City. He is a regular contributor to several Christian publications; he speaks at conferences, and is the author of over 75 books. In this article, Peter Kreeft explains one of the most important arguments in the pro-life debate, whether or not human personhood begins at conception. This is a huge

Privacy And The Self: Personhood, Autonomy, And Identity

2339 words - 9 pages . The “self” entails personhood, autonomy, and identity. Privacy can be experienced in a number of forms. Alan Westin defined four states – or experiences – of privacy: solitude, intimacy, anonymity, and reserve. Solitude is a physical separation from others (31). Intimacy is a “close, relaxed, and frank relationship between two or more individuals” resulting from the “corporate [collective] seclusion” of a small unit (31). Anonymity is the “desire