Perspectives Of Justice Essay

999 words - 4 pages

Chelsea HamerlinckCJ 2209.17.13Perspectives of JusticeThere are many different perspectives of criminal justice. The two perspectives that really dominate the field are the crime-control perspective and the non-intervention perspective. These two perspectives are unconditionally opposite of each other, which is why I believe that they dominate the field. Society views crime in a number of ways and no one is sure which view is the correct one. Crime is present in all societies of all types. There is no society that is not confronted with the problem of crime; however different societies tend to react individually to the problem of crime. These two perspectives will display that.The crime control perspective is a model of criminal justice that emphasizes that control of dangerous offenders and the protection of society through harsh punishment as a deterrent to crime (Siegel, 2012). The crime-control perspective benefits the upper and middle classes of a society. They follow the very distinct criminal law. Criminal law is when any society prohibits certain acts and prescribes the punishments to be meted out to violators using the criminal justice system (Kornblum, 2012). Most Americans operate with this perspective due to the fact that it is the most common perspective to follow. This perspective grows off of the classical deterrence theory. The two main points of this theory are that decisions to violate the law are weighed against possible punishments and to deter crime, the pain of punishment must outweigh the benefit of illegal gain. Human beings have made assumptions about their own nature with ideas such as free-will and maximized pleasure. Free-will is the freedom to make personal behavioral choices free from environmental factors such as poverty or ideological beliefs. Humans behave to maximize pleasure and minimize pain. They weigh their benefits and costs of their future actions before acting on a particular behavior. This perspective focused mainly on society as a whole. It is assuming that if the criminals are punished harshly then they will conform back into society and follow the norms. By punishing the offender society hopes that others that commit the same crime will not think that it is worth it (Paciotti, 2005). They do not want to rehabilitate or help the offender; they want to send a message. This perspective dictates that if the offender is in jail, society is safe. This perspective has three main points overall. One, prevent crimes by encouraging harsh punishment (Siegel, 2012). Two, the punishment must always outweigh the benefit of the crime, and three, there is little, if no, confidence in rehabilitation (Siegel, 2012).The non-intervention perspective favors the least intrusive treatment possible, decarceration, diversion, and decriminalization (Siegel, 2012). I believe that this perspective mainly focuses on the lower class of society. The main idea of this perspective is whenever possible keep the criminal justice system...

Find Another Essay On Perspectives of Justice

Modernization and civilizational clash Essay

632 words - 3 pages Theoretical perspectives help us study the underlying questions we have about society. Each perspective concentrates on diverse characteristics of society. These aspects are analyzed on different levels to develop theories. When it comes to comparative criminal justice, the focus perspective is the comparability and connectivity of criminal justice systems. The world’s criminal justice system contains four theoretical perspectives

Organizational Justice and Psychological Contract Essay

1880 words - 8 pages Thibaut and Walker, 1975). Just behavior has the potential to bring more meaning of work life (Cropanzano et al, 2001 and Folger, 1998.). a. Definition and Forms of Organizational Justice The concept of organizational justice is a broad, multifaceted construct, encompassing several dimensions. Perceived justice previously discussed in two different perspectives. As Greenberg (1990) give details, that initially researchers focused on the content

Justice in Literature

922 words - 4 pages The concept of justice is an essential, guiding principal in society and a complex notion, which has been explored by a range of contexts. A Idea of the complexity of the issue relating to moral, legal and social justice maybe achieved through the perspectives offered by Author Miller's play "The Crucible" 1953, in the feature article "Old Enough To Die" and the related material "US Court Ruling Saves Teen Killers From Execution." By using a

Feminist Approach to Moral Decision Making

1475 words - 6 pages Feminist Approach to Moral Decision Making While ethics theories often focus on justice, care, an "equally valid moral perspective," is usually disregarded because of male bias (Sterba, p. 52). The two perspectives are often harmonious, but a need for care point of view precedence exists. While truth is evident in both these statements, the problem of distinguishing between them becomes apparent soon after. Many feminist look to

The Function of Punishment

2114 words - 8 pages The Function of Punishment "Justice must not only be done but seen to be done". Most would agree with this statement - the wicked must surely be punished (or should they? - do two wrongs make a right?) but why is it so important that the punishment must be seen to be done? To the utilitarian the answer is simple - punishment must be witnessed in order to deter others from committing the same act. Thus, to a utilitarian

The criminal justice system has been important in defining, explaining and controlling behaviors understood as deviant. Discuss two sociological responses to concepts of criminal deviance.

645 words - 3 pages and cultural phenomena are stressed in both sociological responses, considering social systems, structures and processes for the plight of criminal deviance. The underlying limitation of all sociological theories is that they ignore the role of personal choice to engage in deviant acts though despite the criticisms and limitations of the sociology of deviance, the theories still remain as a useful tool to analyze the functions of the criminal justice system.van Krieken R. et al., Sociology: Themes and Perspectives, 2000

The Holocaust: The Basic for a Good Novel

660 words - 3 pages what is interesting is how their relationship grows. Leo and Sage become closer through discovering the horrible and awful past of the Holocaust. They developed a relationship unique to their scenario. The novel The Storyteller was tremendous because of different perspectives, splendid descriptions, and stimulating character development. The novel was written through Sage, the main character, Leo, a Department of Justice, Minka, a Holocaust

Strategies of Youth Justice Policies

2368 words - 9 pages philosophies which have seeped into the foundations, which still monopolise and govern contemporary practice and although new perspectives have emerged over the recent history, it is necessary to trace the evolution over the last century to understand the logic behind the practice. The strategies of youth justice, as identified by Muncie (2009), will now be discussed throughout the emergence of the youth justice system and how the arrangements and certain

Education and Awareness Will Promote Environmental Justice

1497 words - 6 pages Education and Awareness Will Promote Environmental Justice The goals of this environmental justice conference are stated simply: firstly, to explore whether racial minorities and the poor are being environmentally victimized, and secondly, to evaluate public policies that promote environmental fairness. Each speaker provided insight and information from their respective area of expertise. Led by keynote speaker Dr. Bunyan Bryant, they drew

Is Restorative Justice More Appropriate in Dealing With Young Offenders Than Conventional Criminal Justice?

2674 words - 11 pages . Fischer, C, T. (1984) A Phenomenological Study of Being Criminally Victimized: Contributions and Constraints of Qualitative Research. Journal of Social Issues 40(1), 161-178. Hudson, B. & Galaway, J. (1996) Restorative Justice International Perspectives. London: Oxford Johns, R. (2003) Young Offenders and Diversionary options: NSW Parliamentary research Service. (7)3, London: UK Johnstone, G. (2002) Restorative Justice; Ideas, Values, Debates


1383 words - 6 pages Reflection of Good on Justice in Plato's Republic Book II Within the close of Book II of Plato's Republic, Thrasymachus and Glaucon are still unconvinced of Socrates' perceptions on justice. They both accuse Socrates in rejecting every idea that is proposed on the matter and stubbornly refuses to provide his own perspectives. At this time Glaucon demands more from Socrates to truly convince him that the benefits of being unjust truly outweigh

Similar Essays

Criminal Justice Perspectives Essay

1069 words - 4 pages Is there a right way of dealing with crime and recidivism rates in the United States? How do we know what is the most effective way? What one may feel is correct is the other may feel is inappropriate. Because of such inconsistencies, the Criminal Justice System has identified six perspectives on justice. I am going to explore each perspective and discuss how each one would relate to domestic violence.The first perspective, Crime Control, has a

Women's Perspectives Essay

1610 words - 6 pages females. This is probably ideal because the whole debate really targets women and whether their ethical perspectives have broken out of the mold of their maternal duties after the onset of the revolution. Friedman shows us that men do not just base their moral perspectives on justice and women do not just base theirs on care; they both coincide. It is almost required that they both exist together. In caring relationships, one becomes very

Justice In David Williamson's "The Removalist" And Harper Lee's "To Kill A Mockingbird"

842 words - 3 pages white girl, Mayella. The complexity of the justice system derives from the fact that its applications and receptions alter with people of different, race, religion, and economic and social status. This corruption leads to a biased view of society, creating conflicting opinions between the individual and social perspectives of justice.Justice, over the centuries, has become multifaceted in its application and reception based on one's race

Geoffrey Roberston's "The Justice Game" Speech Entitled "The Reality Of Law And Justice"

985 words - 4 pages ;Rumpole of the Bailey" - Rumpole and the golden thread; justice and law are twins but not identical twins. Justice is a game. It is played by manipulating a jury to believe a particular perspective, whether just or not, all within the confines of the law. Fellow teachers. Changing times bring changing perspectives, but the birth of the new is always painful. "The trials of Oz" in 1971 pitted tradition against modernity