This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Peter Medak's Gain Of The Viewer's Sympathy For Derek Bentley In The Film Let Him Have It

2246 words - 9 pages

Peter Medak's Gain of the Viewer's Sympathy for Derek Bentley in the Film Let Him Have It

The film 'Let Him Have it' is a powerful social drama based on a true
story. The film's Director, Peter Medak, made this film in 1991
because he thought the judicial hanging of Derek Bentley in 1953 was a
grave miscarriage of justice. Peter Medak, like many film directors,
used his bias to show his sympathy to the viewers, probably in the
hope that the he could pass his sympathy on to many people in order to
influence their view. Bias is a tendency to support or oppose a
particular person or thing in an unfair way by allowing personal
opinions to influence your judgment.

By influencing the public view regarding the events surrounding this
November evening in 1952, Peter Medak was perhaps hoping that people
would be drawn into sympathising with Derek Bentley and his family,
ensuring that a miscarriage of justice such as this would never happen
again. The film showed the Bentley family's suffering and may have
also subsequently helped clear Derek Bentley's name. Having said this,
I also maybe think that Peter Medak wanted to make some money from the
film, after all it is his job. Films based on true stories draw many
people to the box office in the name of entertainment and curiosity,
but Peter Medak's careful reconstruction of events reveals why this
miscarriage of justice shocked our nation.

Derek Bentley was hanged at the age of 19, on January 28th 1953, for a
murder he did not commit. He had been a recluse for most of his life
since suffering brain damage during the World War 2 bombing of London.
He was illiterate and epileptic with the

mental age of 11.

Derek Bentley went out with his friend, 16 year old Christopher Craig
on Sunday November 2nd 1952, to see if they could burgle a warehouse
in Croydon. Craig gave Bentley a knife and a knuckle-duster, and Craig
carried a similar knife along with an Eley revolver. They intended to
break into a warehouse occupied by a firm called Parker & Barlow.

Craig and Bentley were spotted on the warehouse roof by a child whose
mother notified the police. Bentley surrendered at once to DC Fairfax,
the first police officer who arrived on the roof. When Craig aimed his
gun at the officer, the officer asked Craig to surrender and hand over
the gun. Bentley then yelled to Craig, "Let him have it, Chris." Craig
then shot and wounded that DC Fairfax and later shot and killed a
different officer, PC Miles.

Six weeks later, both Craig and Bentley were tried and convicted of
the murder of PC Miles. The jury returned guilty verdicts on both
youths with a recommendation for mercy in Bentley's case. Craig was
sentenced to ten years in prison as he was he is too young to face the
death penalty. Bentley was sentenced to death by hanging.


Find Another Essay On Peter Medak's Gain of the Viewer's Sympathy for Derek Bentley in the Film Let Him Have It

Sympathy for Oedipus in the Oedipus Tyrannus

2262 words - 9 pages investigations that hit us before and we just sit back and take stock of what it all means, the incestuous corruption at centre stage. During this period, Oedipus is blind, with blood and tears running down his groaning face. The fact that Oedipus is left on stage for such a long time in this condition is no co-incidence. We are meant to feel sympathy for him or else Sophocles would have removed him quickly. Instead Oedipus has blinded himself

Sympathy for the Sinners Essay

883 words - 4 pages ugliness?” the man is reluctant to give him his name, but regardless Dante remembers him and says, “May you weep and wail, stuck here in this place forever, you damned soul for, filthy as you’re I recognize you” (Cantos VIII 417). Here it is clear that his worldview has changed and his belief that the sinners should have a second chance is no longer. As they reach the Ninth circle where the greatest of sinners are damned, Dante no longer feels pity. As

Sympathy for the Devil

2310 words - 9 pages that drives him to murder despite his natural kindness and benevolence. Shelley reflects many layers in her own rendering with the temptation and power Frankenstein finds in knowledge, as well as the danger that surfaces once it becomes apparent that he has misused his knowledge and overstepped his bounds in acquiring it. The level of moral ambiguity in the novel makes it difficult to clarify who are the villain and hero. Victor suffers for his

The Effect of Gender and Criticism on a Viewer's Opinion

1532 words - 6 pages that test both the effect of gender and criticism. The purpose of this study is to determine whether the gender of the critic will influence a viewer's judgment about a film. It is expected that when subjects are exposed to both positive and negative reviews of the same film, the gender if the critic will manipulate their opinion.Materials*The DVD chosen is "the Red Violin" it has 4 unique scenes which all have one topic which is a violin, but

The Go-Between by L.P.Hartley - "It did not occur to me that they had treated me badly" - What Sympathy do you have for Leo?

2316 words - 9 pages 'The Go-Between' by L.P.Hartley"It did not occur to me that they had treated me badly"What Sympathy do you have for Leo in the Go-Between?This essay is to assess how much sympathy is deserving of the young and naïve Leo Colston after being permanently emotionally damaged from a visit to a school friend in the country in the summer of 1900.The prologue acts as the introduction to the elder character of Leo Colston, a man in his sixties, and

The Power of Sympathy

1021 words - 4 pages can help Harrington, asking him to “take the light of facts, and reason from them.” (96) For the third time in the novel, a character is contemplating suicide and it is recommended that reason be considered rather than one's own misery and situation. When people are enveloped in “anxious fears, the result of too much sensibility, human nature feels a degree of oppression” ( 96). Harrington becomes trapped by his situational prejudice and the

Close analysis of the film "Witness" by Peter Wier

1207 words - 5 pages many differences between both worlds. In Rachel's world the Amish have pacifist attitudes, work together for the common good and are innocent of the corruption of the modern world. In Book's world there is violence and corruption, but also the possibility to be an individual.It is through developing these ideas in the story and by the use of symbolism, lighting, music and camera angles, that Peter Weir successfully depicts the clash between two very different worlds.

Does Shylock win your sympathy after all that had happened to him? "The Merchant of Venice" by Williams Shakespeare

564 words - 2 pages Antonio's flesh. However, just as Shylock is to receive his amount of flesh agreed, then Portia disguised as a lawyer, twists the bond and so results in Antonio remaining alive and Shylock losing most if not all his money.Is then Shylock , a villain who just happens to be a Jew, is he deserving of being ill-treated and prosecuted? After all that has happened, he surely wins my sympathy and to make things worst for him his own daughter, Jessica, who he

Forgiveness allows us to let go of the pain in the memory and if we let go of the pain in the memory we can we can have the memory but it does not control us. When memory controls us we are then...

547 words - 2 pages , eye to eye with that person who emotionally scared you for years to come and say, "I forgive you" because you don't know how that person ask.Forgiveness allows us to let go of the pain in the memory and if we let go of the pain in the memory we can we can have the memory but it does not control us. When memory controls us we are then the puppets of the past.

Explore Kathy’s narration in Never Let Me Go and what it reveals regarding the importance of memory as a source for narrative

1865 words - 8 pages When memory is used as a source for narrative in literature many of the essential qualities of conventional narratives are lost. However, Kathy’s narrative voice in Never Let Me Go is by no means exclusive, it instead resonates on a universal level; each individual’s memories are fundamental in forming their identity. The supposed unreliable aspects of Kathy’s narration are only unreliable in so far as they present an intimate portrait of this

Sympathy for the Character in Charlotte Brontë’s Jane Eyre

2594 words - 10 pages appearance comes solely from the outside and who has a hollow inside, which we do see John to have later on in the book. Jane’s vulnerability is really shown when she says “I trembled at the idea of being dragged forth by the said Jack.” In this scene the use of both language and structure evoke not only sympathy, but also an empathising fear in the reader. The word ‘tremble’ is used brilliantly here as it really shows Jane’s innocence as a little

Similar Essays

The Audience's Response To 'let Him Have It!' And 'the Daily Mail' In Peter Medak's Film

2923 words - 12 pages The Audience's Response to 'Let him have it!' and 'The Daily Mail' in Peter Medak's Film How is the response of the audience manipulated in Peter Medak’s film ‘Let him have it!’ and ‘The Daily Mail’ article of November 1952? Do they both show bias? In November 1952 a policeman was shot dead and another left wounded in what the Daily Mail called a ‘gun battle’ when Christopher Craig and Derek Bentley broke into the

Let Him Have It Essay

974 words - 4 pages Let him have it The film ‘let him have it’ is based on a true story: however the director gives us facts from his own viewpoint. Focusing on the first three scenes, show how the director persuades us to feel sympathy for Derek Bentley, and how he attempts to influence opinions concerning capital punishment. ‘Let Him Have it’ is set in 1952 and based on the true story of the case against Derek Bentley, who was hanged for the murder of an

Methods Of Presentation Influence The Viewer's Response

842 words - 3 pages , yet the two main components in this report are the usage selection of detail and the usage of language.Current affairs and news reports all have ways of presenting a story whether it be on a critical topic such as whether the country should go to war or on a non critical one such as building a new roadway. Yet we as viewers will be drawn in to the report due to the methods that are used by presenters of the story. These stories are presented in

Sympathy For The Devil Essay

882 words - 4 pages depictions of Satan view him as the ruler of all suffering, Dante suggests that Satan himself also suffers in Hell, sobbing for all eternity at his harsh punishment. Peter Cook’s devil is much less sympathetic, as he roams the earth free to rein torment on all of humanity. However, George Spiggott’s resentment toward God inspires sympathy in viewers as Spiggott describes God’s omnipotence and unjust power. Spiggott explains to Stanley, “All God has