This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Peyton Manning Vs Tom Brady Essay

2432 words - 10 pages

“Peyton Manning and Tom Brady are the preeminent QBs of their generation (Battista and Breer).” Two quarterbacks, from two completely different backgrounds, are fighting for supremacy among all the men to quarterback in the National Football League (NFL). Football in the day and age today is a landscape unlike a few centuries ago. On paper just about any coach in the NFL would start Peyton Manning, former first pick in the 1998 draft, over Tom Brady, former one hundred and ninety ninth pick in the 2000 draft, just based on where each player was selected. Looks, although appealing, doesn’t reflect the careers of two of the greatest QBs in NFL history. Manning is a former number one selection, who has done nothing but live up to and exceed expectations. Brady was selected five rounds later at one hundred and ninety nine, and has done nothing but turned doubters into believers. In the midst of the madness, which player stands forsaken as the greatest quarterback of their generation?
An athlete’s college career is something seldom used when determining the best players at each position to play professional football. To seriously distinguish between whether Manning or Brady is the best quarterback of their generation their college careers must be carefully examined. Manning, a farm-boy, was born in New Orleans, Louisiana on March 24, 1976 ("Peyton Manning Career Biography and Statistics |"). His father attended Ole Miss, where he is very well known, but Peyton, when making his decision chose to attend the hated University of Tennessee. As a Tennessee Vol, Peyton Manning, not only set records, but also posted astronomical numbers. He won his first start as quarterback, 10-9 against Washington State, and lead the team to and 8-4 season as just a freshman, which included a 45-23 Virginia Tech win during the Gator Bowl ( As a sophomore, Manning, led his Vols to a 10-1 record, which not only included marquee wins over Alabama and a Citrus Bowl win over Ohio State, but also a sixth place finish in votes for the Heisman Trophy (Utsports.Com). Despite going 11-2 in his junior year, the team lost, for the second year in a row, to Florida and was surprisingly upset by an underdog, in the Memphis Tigers (Utsports.Com). Leading up to his senior year, Peyton had an opportunity to graduate early and be selected number one overall in the 1997 NFL Draft, but he choose to return to the University of Tennessee for his final year. That year he led them to a 12-1 record, while still coming up short to a seemingly unbeatable Florida team, for the third year in a row, 30-22 (Utsports.Com). After four seasons as a Tennessee Volunteer, Peyton Manning, complied 47 games played, 1,381 attempts, 836 completions, a completion percentage of 62.5%, 11,201 passing yards, 33 interceptions, and 89 passing touchdowns (Utsports.Com). Although Manning put up cosmic college football numbers, do they solidify him as the greatest quarterback of his...

Find Another Essay On Peyton Manning vs Tom Brady

Why America Needs Stricter Gun Control Laws

1299 words - 5 pages America). One innocent victim of a drive-by shooting was Peyton Benson, a five year old girl that was shot and killed eating breakfast in her home in Omaha, Nebraska on January 14, 2014 (Skelton). If there was stricter laws on who has access to guns, there would be a dramatic reduction in the number of drive by shootings, and innocent people such as Peyton would be saved. Another situation that could have been avoided if there was more gun control

Bryan Bartlett's Life and Accomplishments Essay

1401 words - 6 pages did Starr win an impressive 9 playoff games, “his teams won five NFL championships, which also include the first two Super Bowls” (Fox). Just winning the first two Super Bowls cemented Starr’s place in NFL history, yet he continued to add to his legend. Starr’s NFL career playoff passer rating is 104.8, the best postseason passer rating in the entire history of the NFL (“NFL”). Despite many incredible quarterbacks playing: Peyton Manning, Tom

Compare and Contrast: The BCS vs. A Playoff System

915 words - 4 pages a split or shared college football national champion. In 1997 The University of Nebraska battled The University of Michigan in the polls most of the season. Eventually, Nebraska entered the postseason ranked a close second to Michigan and accepted a bid to play in the Orange Bowl against the third ranked University of Tennessee Volunteers and Peyton Manning. Nebraska conquered Tennessee, easily defeating the Volunteers 42 - 17. In contrast

Watching the Story Unfold

2890 words - 12 pages Dreams, Philips moved on to create and work on such iconic shows as The Guiding Light, As the world Turns, Another World, Days of Our Lives and, most importantly for this essay, played a vital role in the early days of the first American primetime serialized series Peyton Place (IMDB). Before discussing Peyton Place however, one has to note its inspiration the British series Coronation Street. Having originally begun as a 13 episode whim of the

Worship of Sports Teams and Athletes

1506 words - 6 pages that many young kids have, they look up to stars like Peyton Manning, Russell Wilson, and other sports superstars. They bad thing about this worship of these athletes is that not many of these kids will have the chance to become a star. So if these kids grow up in life being told that they can do it, this can really affect those children’s goals in life. Instead of focusing on their school work they instead might just focus on trying to learn more

Should Athletes Make More Money

1237 words - 5 pages football player makes? Payton Manning makes $42.4 million a year; Tom Brady makes $27.1 million a year, but why? Why have we as Americans made sports more important than our military fighting to keep our freedom, or our police and firemen saving our lives on a daily basis. This is a question people have been asking for what seems like forever. Did you know that there is more than a billion dollars brought in every year just by college sporting events

Put 'em Back in the Holster: Why We Need Gun Control

1132 words - 5 pages January 1, 2014. (New York Times) (2014). Do not allow these innocent individuals deaths go in vain stand up and let your voice be heard, talk to your congressmen about gun reform, stress the issues of stricter gun enforcement “Our voices can make a difference.” Works Cited NRA ‘plucks the bird’ to weaken gun proposals. Tom Cohen. (2013). Retrieved from Pros vs. Cons: The gun control debate. Brady. (2009). Retrieved from http

History of Football: Walter Camp

1247 words - 5 pages and early 2000’s, broke the all-time rushing record (Brooks and King). New England Patriots quarterback, Tom Brady, holds the most touchdowns in a season with 50 (Brooks and King). He broke the record in 2007. In 2008 The Pittsburgh Steelers win their sixth Super Bowl most by any NFL franchise history and it still holds today (Brooks and King). There are a bunch of strategies and formations in football today like Pro Set, Flexbone, Wing-T, I

History of Football

1184 words - 5 pages (Brooks and King). New England Patriots quarterback, Tom Brady, holds the most touchdowns in a season with 50 (Brooks and King). He broke the record in 2007. In 2008 The Pittsburg Steelers win their sixth Super Bowl most by any NFL franchise history and it still holds to today (Brooks and King). There are a bunch of strategies and formations in football today like Pro Set, Flexbone, Wing-T, I-Formation, Spread, and a lot more and that is just

Should Children Play Tackle Football?

1940 words - 8 pages Company, 2012. Print. Daniel, Ray W., Steven Rowson and Stefan M. Duma. “Head Impact Exposure In Youth Football.” Annals of Biomedical Engineering. 40.4 (2012) : 976-981. Web. 3 Apr. 2104. Fainaru, Steve and Mark Fainaru-Wada. “Questions about Heads Up Tackling.” ESPN Outside The Lines. ESPN Internet Ventures, 13 Jan. 2014. Web. 11 Apr. 2014. Jenkins, Sally. “Youth Football Concussions Can Be Prevented Ask Archie Manning and Tom Brady Sr. How

The Three Trials of Byron De La Beckwith

2234 words - 9 pages thereafter and by the end of the year, had chapters in seventeen counties. After hearing founding member, Circuit Court Judge Tom P. Brady, speak at a meeting of the Sons of the American Revolution, Beckwith zealously joined the group. One of Council’s first projects was to successfully pass an amendment to the Mississippi Constitution requiring that Blacks pass a competency test before voting. The Sovereignty Commission was created in 1956. The

Similar Essays

Fantasy Football Essay

720 words - 3 pages are so good is that they both have really good quarterbacks. Jimmy Graham has Drew Brees, and Rob Gronkowski has Tom Brady who are both top 5 fantasy quarterbacks. Tight ends can be important because it is hard to find a good one who is reliable to get a good amount of points for almost every game. Wide receivers are probably even more important even if they are easier to find. The best wide receivers in the NFL right now are probably Calvin

Searching For Knowledge And Expert Opinions

1381 words - 6 pages particular fields of interest. Both Payton Manning and Tom Brady are expert quarterbacks. Peyton Manning’s “anticipation and accuracy are virtually unmatched because he throws the ball before defenders are ready and puts it in a place where only his guy can catch it” (Tucker 3). Tom Brady was an incredible leader who put up astounding numbers at times while seemingly willing his team to multiple Super Bowl titles (Tucker 1). John Maynard Keynes was

Football Versus Soccer Essay

874 words - 4 pages and rise to super star fame nationally, like Peyton Manning or Tom Brady, and internationally, like Cristiano Ronaldo or Lionel Messi. Both games have a distinct way of capturing an audience’s excitement and can both be rather dull to the uneducated eye. Football breaks up the action into short, exhilarating periods of play followed by a rest. Soccer, though, never stops going, with 90 minutes of close to uninterrupted play. In conclusion, both sports have their own rules, athletes, and appeal even if they are drastically dissimilar. Both capture the dreams and inspiration of people all over the world.

Patton Vs Rommel Essay

2022 words - 8 pages While going through readings and researches about George Patton and Erwin Rommel, every time I thought about how to contrast the two greatest Field Marshals of World War II, all I could think about was the rivalry between Peyton Manning and Tom Brady. Of course, if they have never faced each other on the game field. Both were heroes to their nations, but also were feared and, most of all, respected by the opponent.Rommel was admired amongst the