Phantom Menace Vs Star Wars Essay

978 words - 4 pages

The Star Wars Saga In May of 1999, George Lucas released his highly anticipated Star Wars Episode I The Phantom Menace (TPM) to a bag of mixed reviews. Some were pleased that a new Star Wars had finally hit their local multiplex, while others where unhappy that after waiting 16 years the movie wasn't very good. George Lucas was in a very tough spot. He had to deliver the most hyped movie in history, while telling the back story for character so many are familiar with. The Phantom Menace does do some things well. The action, and battle scenes where well worth the wait. Also it featured some big time actors with Liam Nealson, Ewan McGregor, and Natalie Portman. But the story, drama, and the weak introduction of Anakin Skywalker, who later becomes Darth Vadar, left a lot to be desired. Also, TPM seemed to be made for a less intelligent audience than the original movies, and this too, turn a large percentage of fans off. The biggest downfall in TPM is the characters aren't as accessible as the first three Star Wars films, and Episode IV A New Hope (ANH), in particular.The first pair of characters to be examined is ANH's Han Solo and TPM's Obi Wan. Both characters are the most liked in both films respectfully. Harrison Ford's portrayal of a cool space drifter won the hearts of everyone to see ANH. Ewan McGregor had the same luck with his portrayal of a young Jedi apprentice, because he was portraying the younger version of a beloved figure from ANH. Both actor's received characters that where written very well rounded and realistic but Ford gets the nod here for the very funny dialogue written in the first movie. Also Solo's interaction with all the other characters makes his personality that more likeable. In TPM, Obi Wan's interactions don't display much of his personality, but the movie does show off his fighting skills. His fight between Darth Maul is one of the greatest swords fights recorded on film. Solo's fighting skills are somewhat limited to the use of a blaster, but he's quick with his tongue. He is a space pirate and never trained to use a light saber, where Obi Wan is well trained in the arts of fighting and therefore be able to fight more efficiently. Where Han lacks fighting skills he makes up for it with a very strong and likeable personality. Obi Wan can put on a great fight, but his less engaging personality makes him less likeable.Lucas has always included a strange character in all of the Star Wars movies. In ANH he introduced Chewbacca, and in TPM it was Jar Jar Binks. Chewy worked because he was paired with the highly likeable Han Solo, plus the viewer could never understand what Chewy was saying. He spoke in load grunts...

Find Another Essay On Phantom Menace Vs Star Wars

George Lucas Essay

2604 words - 10 pages opposition to this project. Some fans weren’t optimistic to see the story progress or change. Despite this, Lucas went on to release the highly anticipated “Star Wars Episode I - The Phantom Menace” in 1999 (Biography 1 of 2). He both wrote the script and directed the film. It was probably the most anticipated of the series. Fans lined up outside theaters weeks before the film was released. This “second coming” of George Lucas and his “Star Wars” empire

Attack of the Digital Cinema Essay

1327 words - 6 pages digital filmmaking achievable. During the making of his Star Wars prequel trilogy, George Lucas knew he had to take advantage of the up-and-coming digital technology. In 1999, Star Wars Episode I: The Phantom Menace became the first film to be projected digitally - albeit it was only in four theaters nationwide (two in Los Angeles and two in New York City). Digital projection was not enough for Lucas though, and the director headed to Sony. The

Beowulf Attacks Grendel's Mother

1343 words - 5 pages the movie. Click here to view the photo. -------------------------------------------------------------------------------- October 2, 1998: There is a great disturbance in the force. Director Steven Cameron finally set the opening date for the long-planned screen adaptation of the Old-English epic Beowulf. The movie will open next Memorial Day weekend. This forced George Lucas to move the opening of his new movie Star Wars - Episode I: The

Silver’s Remaking Eden and the Silver Screen

1114 words - 4 pages , including print fiction and especially film. Recent examples include 1997’s The Lost World: Jurassic Park, 1999’s Austin Powers II: The Spy Who Shagged Me, 2001’s Star Wars: The Phantom Menace, 2002’s Spider-Man, and, most recently, last summer’s The Island. These films—with their stories of dinosaurs gone wild, people as slaves, and clones for profit—have been box-office hits (Battaglia; Briggs and Kelber-Kaye; Lemonick; Vergano and

Mamoru Oshii's Ghost in The Shell

1909 words - 8 pages genetic level – effectively lending to an “atmosphere of scientific credibility.” Qui-Gon Gin explains to Anakin in the novel adaptation of George Lucas’s Phantom Menace: “Midi-Chlorians are microscopic lifeforms that reside within the cells of all living things and communicate with the Force.” (Brooks, 245). Just as Star Wars sets itself apart from standard fantasy by basing the seemingly supernatural on story elements more scientifically

Essay 2

1327 words - 6 pages acts as the redeemer and if that is translated it is Luke taking on Ben Kenobi’s guidance and finally taking down the death star and Empire. Themes: With Star wars episode 4 one of the Key features that drive the story forward is the standard binary opposites, the main one being “good vs. evil, Luke vs. Vader “. One of the binary’s that are typical in a fantasy are “Aliens vs. Humans” but in this film that is not the case as the Humans and other

Star Wars and Religion

1442 words - 6 pages level. It's the age-old theme, good vs. evil, romance, sci-fi, "religion" if you will, everything all rolled into one. Whatever the meaning, whoever the audience, Star Wars has the power to touch people on a personal level. Maybe the words that say it all are those of a true Star Wars fan when she said, "it doesn't have to make some big point& even though I think it does" (Lloyd,110). Reflection I think that this field report went well in

The American Film Industry

3489 words - 14 pages or asteroids hurtling toward Earth: Mimi Leder's Deep Impact, and Michael Bay's Armageddon, both in 1998. At the close of the decade, three other major films appeared: George Lucas' computer-generated return to his epic saga with the first sci-fi space episode titled Star Wars Episode I: The Phantom Menace, in 1999; and writer-directors Andy and Larry Wachowski's ambitious virtual-reality flick The Matrix, also in 1999 - with computer

The Man I Killed, by Tim O'Brien

1677 words - 7 pages place. Were bound together by some painful history, but it’s not our liver or our appendix- it's a country (Alvarez, 2013)." The Vietnam War was one of the longest and most expensive wars in American history. It started from 1955 till April 30, 1975. This war lasted for almost 20 years. According to the article "How the U.S Got Involved In Vietnam" by Jeff Drake the U.S attacked Vietman and this wasn't supposed to happen. This war could have


1685 words - 7 pages statistics for more than 6,000 colleges on its Web site.VERBATIM: A co-author of The Phantom Defense: America's Pursuit of the Star Wars Illusion explains why a national missile-defense system still makes no sense, even after September 11.-------------------------------------------------------------------------------- MONEY & MANAGEMENT A FIGHT FOR VISIBILITY The Thurgood Marshall Scholarship Fund wants to attract more support for students

American Ideals: American Cinema. This essay is about how the ideal american is depicted in the cinema.

619 words - 2 pages newest and most innovative technology. The US is "user friendly." As an American I can relate to need for technology. Most Americans crave to "hip" or to have most up-to-date cell phone. You can see how technology has changed over the years in films such as Star Wars. In the first three you can see the lack of technology, in the special effects. Now, you look at Star Wars: Episode I and you see how George Lucas has used new technology and special

Similar Essays

Star Trek Vs. Star Wars Essay

1131 words - 5 pages Rodenberry, and the other from the mind of George Lucas. While both have many interesting facets, they are unique and similar at the same time.The first area that differs is where the stories take place. Star Wars takes place in a Galaxy far, far away, with Corosant being the primary capitol of the Galactic Republic. While Star Trek takes place in the future of our own galaxy with Earth being the base of operations for the United Federation of

This Is A Editorial Review On The Singer Wierd Al Yankovic.

654 words - 3 pages collections. As usual, the highlights tend to be song parodies; "The Saga Begins" is a retelling of Star Wars Episode I: The Phantom Menace from Obi-Wan Kenobi's point of view set to the tune of "American Pie", while "Jerry Springer" is a clever rewrite of the Barenaked Ladies' "One Week". Not all of them quite hit the mark, though: "Pretty Fly for a Rabbi" has the same borderline ethnic condescension of the Offspring's original, and Yankovic's

The Sixth Sense Essay

960 words - 4 pages The Sixth Sense Many movies today do not have plots. They consist of computer-generated images, poor acting due to the non-realistic aspects of the movies, and relatively bad overall story lines. This is mostly due to the fact that the director is more concerned with the special effects. This can be seen in the movie Star Wars: Episode One: The Phantom Menace. Its story line was weak, and the acting was poor due to the fact that most of

Whose Future? Essay

1909 words - 8 pages ." Subtly Star Wars tries to renew interest in religion or at least spirituality. Star Wars tackles the idea of God through "the force" and in the newest installment, The Phantom Menace, even tackles the idea of the virgin birth. However, in retrospect Star Wars isn't reviving older values, but catering to popular culture or the "new religion." What this means is that movies, television, video games and the Internet have become a moral authority