This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Phil 201 Essay On Utilitarianism

1967 words - 8 pages

Mill's Utilitarianism held that things and actions were good in proportion to the amount of happiness they engendered and the amount of people they engendered happiness in - in other words, the aim was for the greatest happiness for the greatest number. Utilitarianism further holds that actions are right insofar as they promote happiness and wrong insofar as they promote unhappiness. Mill explains that some kinds of happiness are innately greater than others, as was shown by people favoring one over the other. Ignorance may be bliss, but Mill held that no learned person would choose to be ignorant even if the ignorant were, in a way, happier than him or her. "It is better to be a human being dissatisfied than a pig satisfied; better to be a Socrates dissatisfied than a fool satisfied." He claimed.But what is happiness? According to Mill, Happiness is pleasure or the absence of pain; unhappiness is pain or the absence of pleasure. Holding pleasure and happiness as the ultimate good is a principle Utilitarianism shares with Hedonism. This leads immediately to a criticism that Mill clearly wants to block: if pleasure is all that matters, then why isn't utilitarianism a swine's philosophy? Why doesn't it imply that a life of crude sensual pleasure is as good as any other life?Mill's first point is that if humans were only capable of the sorts of pleasures that swine are capable of, then a "piggish" life would be the highest good. But in fact, humans are capable of many pleasures that aren't available to swine at all. Still, the raw pleasure involved in, say, drowning a pint of ice cream is usually a lot more intense than the pleasures of listening to Beethoven. So even on Mill's criterion, it might seem that the swinish life still comes out on top. Mill would argue that this is wrong, he would point us to an obvious fact: There are people who like good ice cream but who, if given the choice, would frequently choose painting, Beethoven, chess, good conversation or playing tennis over eating ice cream. There are two points here. One is that, for reasons not having to do with the pleasure as such, some pleasures are preferable. They are more lasting, safer, less expensive, and so on, and what Mill takes to be the "higher" pleasures often fit into that category. So in Mill's view, on external grounds alone, a wise person would not choose a life of alcohol, drugs, or ice cream. Mill's second point is that, leaving external considerations such as permanence aside, pleasures are not ranked just by sheer quantity or intensity, they are also ranked by quality. Playing tennis well is hard work; it is often frustrating and even painful. It leads to plenty of dissatisfaction as one realizes their limitations or remembers missed opportunities for better play. People who work hard at tennis, however, find it enormously rewarding. Similarly, someone with little musical skill would find listening to recorded music much easier and more enjoyable than the first sounds...

Find Another Essay On PHIL 201 Essay on Utilitarianism

John Stuart Mill's Selections From Utilitarianism

577 words - 2 pages happiness” (77 Mill). Utilitarianism focuses on the general good of the world over individual pleasure. Although the theory sounds nice, for we all would love world peace, there are a few issues that I have with Mill’s responses that has me questioning the legitimacy of the theory. Mill explained in his essay that according to Utilitarianism, the moral value of an action relies solely on the outcome of the event, making the theory

Rules in Utilitarianism Reconsidered Essay

1670 words - 7 pages this essay is to evaluate how well both kinds of utilitarianism defend their positions on the importance of justice and honesty. (Words count: 1476) Works Cited 1. Audi, Robert. The Cambridge Dictionary of Philosophy. New York: Cambridge University Press, 1999. Print. 2. Chen, Te. "Rule Utilitarianism and Act Utilitarianism." The Ethics Interpretation Theory. 2 ed. Taipei: Dong da, 200901. 92 - 112. Print. 3. Deigh, John. "Utilitarianism." An

'Classical objection to utilitarianism is that it makes insufficient provision for considerations of rights and justice'. Discuss this quotation i

725 words - 3 pages are the main concern for utilitarian’s, yet if one individual suffers from an act but five do not, then is that act deemed morally acceptable since the maxim of people are happy? In this essay I will be answering this question by giving a detailed discussion including a summary on the ideas behind utilitarianism and how the theory makes insufficient provision for the consideration of rights and justice. In my argument against utilitarianism I


1465 words - 6 pages This essay will present the key features of Utilitarianism and identify the problems of Utilitarianism to the extent to which they make Utilitarianism unacceptable. Jeremy Bentham founded Utilitarianism. He lived at a time of great change. With revolutions in France and America, demands were being made for human rights and greater democracy. Bentham worked on legal reform. Utilitarianism is associated with the principle of

Liberals at odds

903 words - 4 pages This essay will analyze utilitarianism. James Mill and John Stuart Mill argue for utilitarianism as the correct means for liberalism to prosper. Though other philosophers, such as T.H. Green, disagree with utilitarianism as the correct means to allow liberalism to prosper. First one must have a definition of utilitarianism in order to argue for or against it. Andrew Heywood defines utilitarianism as a moral philosophy that assumes individuals

History Taking Self-Assessment Project

905 words - 4 pages reflect and improve on interviewing skills from watching my own patient interview. My critiques and thoughts are delineated in this essay from which I hope to improve upon. The patient whom I encountered during the standardized patient interview was Phil. Despite my failure to inquire how to address the patient, my initial encounter with Phil started smoothly with proper introductions, negotiating priorities, and agenda setting. Within minutes of

Problems and prospects for Utilitarianism

1919 words - 8 pages single act are considered into a wider sphere; thereby producing rules that the utilitarian can adhere to. Rule utilitarianism is then in Austin's words "... [rules are] fashioned on utility; our conduct on rules."One major problem with rule utilitarianism is as Mackie states in his essay The Ethics of Fantasy;"that it is extensionally equivalent to act utilitarianism in that the outcome of its two-stage procedure, consistently carried out, will

0nline dating

895 words - 4 pages and family. For this essay as an example, Phil developed an addiction to work. He became a workaholic who got isolated from his family and his own self focusing on his job only; he ignores everything else including himself, his wife, and kids. Just like Phil, the father of Sanders was an addict too; he was an alcoholic, getting drunk all the time and causing a lot of suffering to his family and children. Sanders, in his “Under the Influence” essay

Title: two theories of right and wrong

1284 words - 5 pages Two Theories of Right and WrongJohn Stuart Mill, author of the essay entitled Utilitarianism, gave an in depth theory of right and wrong commonly referred to as utility or the utilitarian view of morality. Utility claims thatactions are right in proportion as they tend to promote happiness; wrong as they tend to produce the reverse of happiness. By happiness is intended pleasure and the absence of pain; by unhappiness pain and privation of

How successful was J.S. Mill in overcoming the problems associated with Bentham's Utilitarianism?

1120 words - 4 pages How successful was J.S. Mill in overcoming the problems associated with Bentham's Utilitarianism?"The greatest good for the greatest number" is a simple way to sum up a fairly simple idea. But despite its simplicity it still has lots of problems; in this essay I will be looking at how John Stuart Mill tries to overcome these problems.In 1789 utilitarianism was born, the brainchild of Jeremy Bentham. Bentham was a hedonist or someone who is

Qualitative Hedonism and Happiness

1367 words - 6 pages distinction of pleasures is inconsistent and problematic for hedonism, which brings about more problems than it solves for Utilitarianism. Mill begins his essay on Utilitarianism by explaining his Greatest Happiness Principle, stating actions are right in that they promote happiness and actions are wrong if they take happiness away (Mill, “What Utilitarianism Is,” para 2). Following from this idea, happiness is pleasure, and unhappiness is pain

Similar Essays

A Philosphical Essay On Utilitarianism

660 words - 3 pages Utilitarianism is a way of looking at ethics, it focuses on trying to ensure the maximum happiness in many different ways. There are many different forms of utilitarianism, the four I will discuss are act, rule, naive and preference utilitarianism.Rule utilitarianism tries to give the greatest overall benefit to society, the best rule/law of conduct is found and everyone is found an a rule utilitarian will follow it. However, this can cause

Phil Essay On "Why God Allows Evil Into The World" The Teacher Really Liked It!

781 words - 3 pages good and great things. To toss a dollar to the beggar on the street or to volunteer at a homeless shelter, contributing time and compassion helps spread good to one person, one minute at a time. Say, if your presence at the homeless shelter assists just one person to instigate a change in their life for the better, that is the good that created by free will. When a young boy is walking to church to participate in a service project and encounters

Healthcare Professional's Obligations On Informed Consent University Of Alberta, Phil 386 Essay

1371 words - 6 pages Is a physician or a nurse always morally required to ask a patient for her or his informed consent to the medical plan or biomedical intervention performed on that patient? Introduction The relationship between physicians and patients has changed drastically in the last twenty years. It has evolved from paternalism, where the doctors make decisions for the patients, to a shared decision making process and the patient is considered an equal

An Analysis Essay On The Philosophical Differences Of Descartes And Locke Santa Clara University Phil 17 Essay

1213 words - 5 pages Exam 1 – Early Modern Philosophy Bersabel Asres 10/23/17 1) What is the basic difference between Cartesian Rationalism and Lockean Empiricism? Give one example of how something can be known according to each view. Cartesian Rationalism is a belief based on innate ideas, reason and deduction. Rationalists believe that the ultimate starting point for all of our knowledge is not our senses (which can be deceptive and inaccurate at times), but it is