Philiosophical Analysis Of Eternal Sunshine

1147 words - 5 pages

‘Eternal Sunshine of a Spotless Mind’ is a philosophically provocative film which tracks the relationship of two main characters, Joel and Clemantine, in their search for happiness. Saddened with the heartbreak from ending their relationship, they both undergo a memory removal proceedure to erase their memory of each other in order to eliminate their emotional suffering. As the film unfolds, it becomes clear that having a ‘spotless mind’ does not ensure ‘eternal sunshine’, contrary to what the title suggests. Instead, there is a sense of tragedy and loss which prevails as the unfortunate consequences of their decision transpires throughout the film. This essay attemps to analyse whether utilising such memery-removal technology can be justified as a good or bad thing; whether ignorance truly is bliss or if it is better know the truth and suffer. It will also explore the affects of erasing memories on ones personal identity by discussing the concepts of philosophers such as John Locke and Thomas Reid.
Questioning the use of memory removal technology as morally good or not may elicit a utilitarian response. Utilitarians would look to the consequences to decipher an answer. John Stuart Mill argues that for an action to be morally correct it must maximise overall happiness while avoiding suffering and pain. “If a memory-removal proceedure can function in such a way that it brings about more happiness than would otherwise be possible, the use of such a proceedure is not only justified, but in fact morally required on utilitarian grounds (Grau, ).” However, this may be disputed by the value placed on truth. Nozick refutes utilitarianism and other theories valuing happiness and pleasure in his thought experiment known as the Experience Machine. Nozick questions whether or not people would plug in to an experience machine to gain false but pleasurable experiences. He argues that many would refuse the opportunity since people place great value on being and becoming. Humans have a basic desire for truth and entering the machine would only allow for an illusory satisfaction. This illusion may seem more desireable during emotionally difficult periods however it will ultimately hinder ones self-identification. People are reluctant to accept deceipt as it is human nature to seek truth and knowledge; wanting to know that they living their own life and not a lie or illusion. Memories, even negative ones should never be deliberately removed as they are important to our being; they provide life lessons and experience to improve our decisions in the future. If knowledge and truth derives from experience, then removing events from ones memory creates a distorted view of the world and a detachment from reality. Memory removal is reagarded as morally problematic due to this conflict between fundamental values.
Furthermore, it may be argued that using memory removal technology may undermine a person’s dignity. Kant states that ‘persons are unique’ and so they should...

Find Another Essay On Philiosophical Analysis of Eternal Sunshine

This is a film review of the fantastic movie Eternal Sunshine of the Spotless Mind

868 words - 3 pages This fabulously imaginative and deliciously loopy romance is the sweetest movie yet from the magnificently twisty mind behind Adaptation, Human Nature, and Being John Malkovich.Once again Charlie Kaufman plays with the themes of identity, time, memory, and attraction in a slightly off-kilter world that seems oddly homelike and familiar. The movie is tougher, truer, more heart-breaking and then more heart-healing than a video store shelf of

Sunshine Apples Essay

3705 words - 15 pages regression analysis (McLeod, 1994), Sunshine Apples could forecast the demand for apple by establishing a correlation between independent and dependent variables such as consumer spending on apples, income level, the amount of imports of apple to Australia. Therefore, Sunshine Apples could monitor the changes in these independent variables to determine the potential for apple fruits. Statistical packages such as SAS or SPSS could be used. In

The Purpose of Feminist Legal Theory

1400 words - 6 pages . Professor Nicola Lacey talks about gendered assumptions present in the general principle, in other word saying that the laws are very extensive and results in undetailed analysis of the difference between men and women (Susan Brophy, 2014, Lecture 8A). This theory gives us to think if women and man has total equality in our society. APPLICATION OF THEORY B Now, I would like to apply feminist legal theory to the Bedford case, the case it self


3883 words - 16 pages practice approach to successfully launch marketing of the Exciting new products in Vietnam. Here are some of the issues will be discussed in the report on marketing new products in Vietnam:- Analysis of external and internal factor of Sunshine Vietnam.- Explain the various elements of the marketing concept.- Analysis the benefits and costs of a marketing orientation for Sunshine.- Identify and explain macro and micro environmental factors which

The Florida Comprehensive Assessment Test (FCAT)

1242 words - 5 pages Growing up in Florida, the sunshine state, all my years of schooling was practically determined in the months of February and March, by the Florida Comprehensive Assessment Test, most commonly known as the F.C.A.T. The Florida department of education (2005) presents (to parents and guardians of the students), the F.C.A.T. as a test given to Florida students to measure what they know and are able to accomplish in reading, writing, mathematics

Religion and Separation of Family in Eliza Suggs’s Shadow and Sunshine

2081 words - 8 pages Eliza Suggs’s slave narrative titled Shadow and Sunshine tells the story of her parents’ experiences with slavery. It also details the life of Eliza Suggs living as child just one generation removed from slavery. Shadow and Sunshine was copyrighted in 1906. The narrative opens with an introduction written by Burton R. Jones that informs the reader of Suggs’s character. He emphasizes Eliza Suggs’s strong beliefs in Christian doctrine, resilient

This Just In: New Scientific Experiment Reveals the Key to Self-Fulfillment

570 words - 3 pages affirming the original results, the theory that these results might’ve been just coincidental was abandoned. After analysis, the experimenters concluded the question topics that caused the most frontal lobe activity were: hybrid cars, endangered species, and urban developments. As stated by the researching team, “the frontal lobe is associated with producing the feelings of disgust and self-satisfaction…our participants apparently perceived both of

French New Wave

1564 words - 6 pages called Cahiers di Cinéma decided to make films more about the techniques of film, rather than the content or story line. Directors still use this style a lot in modern films like Eternal Sunshine of the Spotless Mind, Pulp Fiction and more. But to understand how it is used you must firstly understand what this style is and what it consists of. The French New Wave (FNW) style allows you to make your film in a "natural" way, using hand held

The Historical and Romantic Aspects of Pope’s “Eloisa to Abelard”

1683 words - 7 pages blameless vessel’s lot! The world forgetting, by the world forgot. Eternal sunshine of the spotless mind!” (ln. 207-209) so does the modern Kaufman give his audiences his own take on Pope’s epic tale. Based in accurate historical context and toying with the romantic invention before his time, Pope gave the literary world a poem of full of raw, human, emotion and insight to how similar the return to nature really is compared to then and now

Implementing SMS into Part 139 Airports

2372 words - 10 pages SMS. ACI-NA saw this model as complex, lengthy and confusing. Rules also left operators wondering if implementation plans required inclusion of a safety gap analysis, organizational studies, or implementation schedules and delayed compliance dates (Oswald, 2011). Sunshine Laws Implementation of SMS by U.S. airport operators has the potential to increase safety at airports in the United States. However, implementation of SMS may also increase

Semiotic Analysis of a Advertising Image

1459 words - 6 pages For my semiotic analysis I chose to talk about a commercial for ‘Be delicious’ from Donna Karan New York to demonstrate how advertising generates its meanings, construct the image and behaviors ideology in order to attract customers. ‘Semiology provides the analyst with a conceptual toolkit for approaching sign systems systematically in order to discover how they produce meaning’ (Bawer et. all, 2000: 227). Advertising is one of the

Similar Essays

Movie: Eternal Sunshine Of The Spotless Mind

1532 words - 7 pages In the film Eternal Sunshine of the Spotless Mind stresses the importance of memory and how memories shape a person’s identity. Stories such as “In Search of Lost Time” by Proust and a report by the President’s Council on Bioethics called “Beyond Therapy” support the claims made in Eternal Sunshine of the Spotless Mind. In Eternal Sunshine of the Spotless Mind, Joel Barish (Jim Carrey) and Clementine Kruczynski (Kate Winslet) meet on a train

Empathizing With Joel Barish In Eternal Sunshine Of The Spotless Mind

1942 words - 8 pages Hollywood film producers have always taken interest in depicturing the alternative worlds of particular kinds and types. We might consider as a good example the techniques in which the contrast worlds are being embodied in Michel Gondry’s Eternal Sunshine of Spotless Mind, and how, in that film, main character Joel Barish attempts to regulate his memories and not let them be vanished. While watching this film we unwittingly get involved into the

Character Exposition Through Mise En Scène In Eternal Sunshine Of The Spotless Mind

1606 words - 6 pages upon the filmmaker’s interpretive point of view. In the film, The Eternal Sunshine of the Spotless Mind, Director Michael Gondry utilizes mise-en-scène to denote the complex temporal relationships between his characters, their circumstances, and a fragmented plot structure which progresses through elliptical patterns between memory and reality. In fact, the use of mise-en-scène in Spotless Mind is central to understanding the inner construct of

Internal Analysis Of Sunshine Generations Nursing Home

608 words - 3 pages This internal analysis of Sunshine Generations Nursing Home will depict Nursing Home’s uniqueness in the market and its ability to remain competitive while still providing exceptional care to its residents. First and foremost, Sunshine Generations has consistently met and exceeded both State and Federal Nursing Home regulations and standards. We have Nursing Home inspections conducted annually which includes the residents’ rooms and appearance