Philosophy Before Socrates Early Ionian Achievement

2085 words - 8 pages

Is the early Ionian approach to accounting for the events in the world an improvement over that of the Old Testament? That depends on the parameters and definitions of the comparison. For simplicity's sake, we will let "account of the events in the world" include how the world came to be in the first place and how it is now. An improvement is defined as an account based on stronger logical (or scientific) foundation, since logic is the pervading method of accounting for things in present day Western civilization. Logic is the study of necessary truths and of systematic methods for clearly expressing and rigorously demonstrating such truths. Given these assumptions, it is indeed true that the early Ionians had a better account of the world than the author(s) of the Old Testament.The Old Testament is the first recorded history of a people and the first developed systematic view of the universe. Given the predisposition to polytheism by other contemporary cultures, the Judaic belief in monotheism was also a step forward, logically speaking. As the Ionian Xenophanes later stated, "it is unholy for any of the gods to have a master" (McKirahan, 62). Therein lies the most basic foundation of monotheism - one god exists and can do what he wills unrestrained by others. In the Old Testament, this one God created the entire world and all living beings in seven days, including making man out of the earth (Gen 1.1). This spontaneous creation process is clearly not based on sequential logic, but on miraculous powers of the God that go unexplained in the text, although it does follow that as the only god his powers are certainly capable of creating the entire world through his will. There is no attempt of an explanation as to how things came to be - just that God willed them and they were.Given that there is little to no logic used to arrive from step one, which is God being, to step two, which is God making the world, it is naturally useful to study this GodCicvara 2to get a better glimpse of the Judaic account of the world. At first glance, the Judaic God is very different than the Olympian Gods - he is not part of a hierarchy of Gods and he does not live in a specified physical place. Yet just as the Olympians had the characteristics of humans, so does this God. He is certainly not infallible or emotionally perfect - God makes mistakes and learns from them.A very interesting trait of the Judaic God is that he is not omniscient and cannot fully see the future. God creates men, but after a few generations realizes that he has put too much evil onto the earth, and acknowledging his mistake practically rebuilds all of society and animal life from Noah and his arc. Furthermore, many of the descendents of Noah turn into evil and sinful men who do not even believe in God. That a creation of God could become sinful is certainly a strange concept and further proves the fallibility of this divinity.Also like the Olympian gods, this god plays favorites with certain...

Find Another Essay On Philosophy Before Socrates - Early Ionian Achievement

Erroneus Assumptions in The Trial and Death of Socrates

2336 words - 9 pages to keep the impious agreement, while the opinion of the majority, represented by the laws of Athens, is that the agreement is right. But early in his conversation with Crito, Socrates insisted that the opinion of the gods be consulted on matters of right or wrong, and not the opinion of the majority of men. Socrates argued that the opinion of the majority cannot be used to determine if an action is right or wrong, just as it cannot be used

Do philosophers or theorists have anything of value to offer in the conduct of politics?

2438 words - 10 pages and in tending to their souls. Our best sources of information about Socrates' philosophical views are the early dialogues of his student Plato, including some of Socrates' ideals in 'The Apology.' Founded on the basis of rational intellect, Socratic ideas depend on the idea that philosophy is universal; that logical people would arrive at his conclusions and present no objections. Socrates' ideal was a class-based society, with the ruling class

The History of the Greeks: Hellenic and Hellenistic

6277 words - 25 pages was. This period of early philosophy was also the beginning of scientific thought. Thales of Miletus (c. 624-548 B.C.) began the early philosophical, scientific and mathematical thinking of the Greeks.Thales was the first Greek philosopher, scientist and mathematician. He was also the founder of the first Ionian school of philosophy. He wanted to understand the order of nature and believed that water was the basic element from which everything

Aristophanes’ Clouds a Satyr Play Written in 419 BCE

1337 words - 5 pages be read as a warning to Socrates. Aristophanes is a “friendly critic” of Socrates and warns Socrates to change his ways for Athens and for the good of himself (Whidden). Plato’s Symposium and especially his Apology of Socrates does not discount the claims made in Clouds about the dangers of philosophy and Socrates to the public, even if Plato’s Socrates is less exaggeratedly flawed than the Socrates in Clouds. In Apology, Socrates takes

The Overlooked Gift of Knowledge

1019 words - 5 pages , and other strategic ways to win difficult arguments. This also included coming up with facts, rather than relying on opinions to win arguments. Socrates also encouraged his students to think independently and for themselves. This is something that was lacking in Athenian youth before Socrates. Socrates felt that you can spark a change in people if you think about ethics, justice, politics, morals, and how to better the world around you. These


2292 words - 9 pages vehemently, is what Socrates flat out told Phaedrus, is nothing short of god-like. Socrates said this after his first speech when I believe Phaedrus is just starting to “fall under the spell” that Socrates is attempting to blind him with. Speak without fear (465) Phaedrus says to Socrates just a moment before Socrates, I my opinion gives a little more information than he wants to, so early in the text. The quote on page 465 was also very strong

Socrates: One of the Most Important Figures in Western Philosophy

1581 words - 6 pages pursuing wisdom. Plato was Socrates’ most famous student because of his devotion that he had with philosophy. “Philosophy, the love of wisdom, was for Socrates itself a sacred path, a holy quest -- not a game to be taken lightly. He believed -- or at least said he did in the dialog Meno -- in the reincarnation of an eternal soul, which contained all knowledge. We unfortunately lose touch with that knowledge at every birth, and so we need to be

Socrates versus Nelson Mandela

1785 words - 7 pages like all men, contained very little or no wisdom at all. He was content with knowing this, and upon meeting others that lacked this philosophy, felt he was superior to them. He was unsure of the limitations the afterlife had on wisdom, but he was aware of it’s constraints on earth. This self awareness is what gifted him with the highest sense of enlightenment. With such a positive outlook on death, Socrates also developed a philosophy on

Plato's "trial and death of socrates", Explains socrates view of self-examination (meditation) as the path to knowledge.

897 words - 4 pages learning how to speak the philosophic language for Socrates. This is why he tried to get certain important people in Athens to know more of themselves. Socrates was speaking the philosophic language to Euthyphro, but he didn't understand the purpose behind it. Since Euthyphro didn't understand why Socrates kept asking philosophic questions, he is not considered a student of philosophy. Euthyphro has not self-examined himself or analyzed what he

Political Philosophy: Steering the Middle Course

1615 words - 6 pages another time, Xenophon says Socrates somewhere said that a president over a city who made its citizens fewer and worse was as bad as the herdsman over a herd of cattle who made the cattle fewer and worse. When this was reported to Critias, he brought Socrates before him and showed him the law. Leo Strauss, a political philosophy scholar, offers the most related parallel to this event in the prophet Nathan from the Bible. Nathan confronts and

Personal Socrates.

1474 words - 6 pages in Athens. I agree with Socrates because exiling is being away from the place you want to be most, your homeland. This shows that Socrates contemplated with both ideas before concluding that exile will be defying another principle of Athens. He believed that he would have defiant because he would have no respect for the law and other “professional” people before him. I disagree with Socrates when he explains that choosing to be exile is defying a

Similar Essays

Socrates: A Great Philosopher Essay

943 words - 4 pages was old enough his father taught him how to be sculptor but his creations always came out less than acceptable in the eyes of the clients. His mother was a mid wife. She helped deliver a lot of the children in Athens. In Athens it was common for young men like Socrates to have an elementary level education. After this education it has been shown that he was the pupil of the philosopher before him Archelaus. Before he became a philosopher he was a

Socrates Essay

2068 words - 8 pages mental strengths. Socrates then went on to learn from Archelaus the philosopher. Here he studied astronomy, mathematics, and was introduced to philosophy, which was a new concept at the time. Archelaus taught of explanations for the world with a scientific approach. Socrates, however, turned away from this idea and created his own. He decided that instead of trying to understand the universe, a person should try to understand himself. To express

Socrates And His Conception Of Philosophy. Done By A. Sogoyan.

1213 words - 5 pages ICEF, 2005An essay on Socrates and his conception of philosophyDone by Arsen Sogoyan , year 1, group 1Teacher: Krister SairsinghIt is no wonder when we are asked about philosophy, Socrates is the name that comes to mind first. He was one of the greatest thinkers of the ancient times whose style of questioning and reasoning even nowadays amazes people (me, for instance).When Socrates was young he attended lessons of Archelaus and got interested

Plato’s Crito: The Last Days Of Socrates

1480 words - 6 pages As Socrates awaits his upcoming execution; he is visited before dawn by a close old friend Crito. Crito has made arrangements to help Socrates escape from prison. Socrates is grateful to his old friend for his willing to help aide him in the escape. However, Socrates is quite willing to await his execution. Crito tries to change Socrates mind about escaping by presenting him with several arguments. The first is that if Socrates choices to stay