Philosophy In Religion Essay

1831 words - 8 pages

David Hume in his famous work called Dialogues concerning natural religion he questions himself about the god: can we prove his existence and know what he looks like. He says about the first question as pretty obvious and tries to give a rational description of him by using three characters: Demea, Cleanthes and Philo. Hume’s conclusion on behalf of his character – Philo, seems to be very interesting regarding about the nature of God, in particular his moral attributes. I will argue that the Hume’s point that we can conclude the god’s neutrality in terms of goodness by leaning on the evidence or experience we may notice on the Earth is not accurate, because here he does not take into account ...view middle of the document...

As behind machines we see intelligence, and the universe is like a machine, there should be something similar to human intelligence in God.
Demea objects his logic, as he used design to prove God’s nature already implying nature. Philo supports Demea’s objection, but provide different approach. First, it’s questionable to compare universe and a machine as a part of it. It’s wrong because we’re aware of a little part of the universe and no idea of the rest of it, so it’s possible that the rest isn’t like a machine. Another point’s that things are known because they are repeating, over and over again, but the universe is created once, no experience of its cause, we know about things by knowing that causes are repeating.
Next, Philo turns the attention on moral attributes of God, he asks Cleanthes why there’s suffering in the world, if universe is the perfect machine created by infinite God. Then he tries to examine the goodness of God, and asks: if he willing to prevent evil, but not able – then he’s incompetent; if he able, but not willing – then he’s evil; if both able and willing – why there’s suffering? So there’s a conflict between two God’s moral attributes, either he’s infinitely good or all-powerful or none of it.
Demea’s conclusion’s simply to believe in God’s goodness, as we cannot know the whole picture of universe; it may be perfectly balanced. Cleanthes understands the conflict and he immolates God’s infinity of power. So he’s finite powerful and created the world at his best. However Philo says it won’t help, we haven’t evidence to say that it’s the best world he could create with his abilities; he provides the analogy of rudimentary palace: even the architect’s talented; we cannot confirm it only by looking at his work done using limited resources.
Furthermore, he explains the reason of suffering. First, pain’s used to make people act, while pleasure can be used. Second, laws are universal, bad things happen to whoever you’re good or bad, as well as good things, while good/bad things could happen to good/bad people respectively. Third, all we have is the abilities to survive not to live, while life could be created to make us happy. Finally, there’s meticulous precision of activities in nature, while it could be without such fragility.
In the end, he concludes: it isn’t sufficient to say about God’s goodness, using only part of universe, as it’s possible that everything in the world leads to something in unknown way. Nonetheless, it’s wrong to say he’s good or evil, because there’s evil and good in the world as well as he’s some good and evil, because there should be the struggle between these counter powers, so there’re moments when someone dominates, but we have situations only caused by the 2nd explanation of suffering. So God is neither good nor evil, therefore morally he is neutral.
The Hume’s argument about neutrality of god gradually follows from 4 unnecessary evils that I am going to argue. First, he resents about the way...

Find Another Essay On Philosophy in religion

Religion vs philosophy Essay

890 words - 4 pages dynamics. It is sometimes an institution that sets itself apart from a culture, and it is sometimes the central part of a culture. Philosophy has also taken an important place in society, without people with "the faculty of wonder" we wouldn't have any scientists, doctors and a lot of important people who had asked themselves, "how could I make this world a better place". Like in religion, scientists have let science take a part of their interest

Philosophy and Religion - Are they Compatible?

3648 words - 15 pages would disagree with Weber that the way of life has come about because of religious philosophy. In his opinion, religion is not a base but rather a way to deal with the way the means of labor has caused people to live. In other words, man's thoughts stem from his own actions, rather than from words that are spoken to attempt to change his way of thinking. What is so horrible about the fact of labor that man must turn to religion? Marx said, "So much

Confucianism: Reluctant Religion or Flawless Philosophy?

1241 words - 5 pages Sage should be cherished for its message of attaining self-fulfillment through positive attitude and treating others with respect, deference and honor. There is no culture or country on Earth that would not benefit from this philosophy. The underlying message in Confucianism, which seems to have finally come into its own in China, is that religion, faith, creed or philosophy by any name, is beneficial, even crucial, to establishing and maintaining

Hinduism; a basic overview of this eastern religion and philosophy

2125 words - 9 pages life. This ideal had dominated the Indian religious landscape for over forty centuries. Hinduism, known as Sanatana Dharma, or everlasting religion, to its followers, differs from Christianity and other Western religions in that it does not have a single founder, a specific theological system, a single system of morality, or a central religious organization. It consists of "thousands of different religious groups that have evolved in India since

Confucius, Philosophy of Religion. About cinfusianism and christianity

1096 words - 4 pages , NewYork; 1994.Hughes, E. R. and K. Chinese Philosophy in Classical Times. J. M. Dent and Sons,London; 1942.Hughes, E. R. and K. Religion in China. Hutchinson's University Library, London;1950.Kelen, Betty. Confucius: In Life and Legend. Thomas Nelson INC., New York; 1971.Küng. Hans and ed. Christianity and the World Religions. Doubleday, New York; 1986McCuen., Gary E. The Religious Right. Hudson, Wisconsin; 1989.O'Brière, S. J. Fifty Years

The Importance of Religion for Two Paradigms: Science and Natural Philosophy

906 words - 4 pages the enlightenment and after the enlightenment. Namely the times of natural philosophy and times of science since the term produced after the mid eighteenths. Before the enlightenment religion was the core, center pillar of natural philosophy when the medieval Europe was thought. Nevertheless, after that era the religion was secluded from the “science” in a way that it may have affected the processes but it did not have such condition that could

Reflection Paper For Philosophy Of Religion: The Continous Conflict Between Religious Pluralism And Exclusivism

1707 words - 7 pages be said then that the matter of belief can be left to the personal opinions and values of the believer, or simply put, belief is completely subjective.Just like understanding any other major term in philosophy of religion, completely understanding the existence of variety of human beliefs in this case would be as hard as pinning gelatin to a wall. Just as one thinks one has held the whole thing in one point, the rest of it slips away and falls

Philosophy and Religion

776 words - 3 pages should dedicate their whole life into worshiping a higher being. I think that if you want true happiness, you will not depend on something else, but will go after it yourself. That is how I feel about gods.      In closing, I can find a few things that I agree with in religion. Though there are many philosophies and beliefs, there are three that I feel strongest about. Loving yourself is something that we can all learn

Philosophy of Religion

689 words - 3 pages In his work “A Critique of the Design Argument” Hume asks himself and his main characters whether we can logically discover the nature of God. The three main characters: Demea, Philo, and Cleanthes are representing different sides of the issue. Demea believes that we cannot understand the nature of God, because it is naturally beyond the perception of people. Philo looks on the God’s nature from the philosophically- skeptical point of view. He

Philosophy of Religion

300 words - 2 pages Philosophy Paper #8 Theists, atheists, and agnostics all come up with reasons why each of their views are the strongest of the three. To my mind, however, it is blatantly obvious that agnosticism is the strongest viewpoint. Agnosticism is the view that knowledge of whether or not God exists is inaccessible; we just simply cannot be justified in believing either that God does exist or that he does not. There are two approaches to arguing for this

Reflections on MSN - a rational thought excercise covering philosophical topics and concepts such as; aesthetics, globalisation and philosophy of religion

9421 words - 38 pages HIS LATER DEPARTURE. PERHAPS HE IS SEATED IN FRONT OF HIS COMPUTER, ABSORBED IN ANALYSING TWO MASTER CONVERSATIONALISTS WEAVE AN INTRICATE WEB OF PHILOSOPHY. PERHAPS HE IS WATCHING THE COVERAGE OF READING FESTIVAL ON MTV2. WE'LL NEVER KNOW...-Peresephalus the Enlightened says:Hmm, I think touch, yes: because, as Mike (or Diomi) said, beauty is appreciation of something harmonious. If you run your hand along the smooth edges of a piece of wood do

Similar Essays

Philosophy And Religion In Education Essay

4093 words - 16 pages Philosophy and Religion in Education The education mission of the philosophy and religion department serves the general studies core and the major. The department takes seriously its obligation to introduce general studies students to philosophy and religion as humanities disciplines. All courses at the 100 and 200 level

Ideas Of Philosophy, Religion And Psychology In Mary Shelley's Frankenstein

1860 words - 7 pages Ideas of Philosophy, Religion and Psychology in Mary Shelley's Frankenstein One of the most prominent themes of Frankenstein is that of philosophy and in as I will explain in particular the need for companionship. There are indeed many passages that describe "domestic affection"; for example, Victor's description of his childhood: No human being could have passed a happier childhood than myself. My parents were

The Problem Of Evil In The Judeo Christian Tradition Depicted In Hicks' Philosophy Of Religion

973 words - 4 pages flaws of its own. In the excerpt from Philosophy of Religion, John Hicks outlines the problem of evil as such: (a) If God were truly omnibenevolent, he would then wish to eliminate all evil; (b) If God is were truly omnipotent, he would then be capable of eliminating evil; (c) Evil exists in the world. Therefore: (d) God is not omnibenevolent or He is not omnipotent. Either element of the conclusion is damaging to the traditional

Discuss And Evaluate What Part Eastern Philosophy And Religion Play In George Lucas's Conception Of Star Wars?

669 words - 3 pages for the interpreter.Clearly the Force of the Star Wars films is not like the concepts typically found in Eastern or Western religion or philosophy. We then have the opportunity to learn about just what the Force is. We can also attempt to find if it is a more coherent description of ultimate reality than the concepts typically found in Eastern or Western religion or philosophy.Near the end of Star Wars: A New Hope, when Luke destroys the death star