Philosophy Of Milton In When I Consider How My Light Is Spent And Borges In Poema De Los Dones

3178 words - 13 pages

The Philosophy of Milton in When I Consider how my Light is Spent and Borges in Poema de los dones   

    Jorge Luis Borges espoused a philosophy that "all men are each other" (Stabb 52). His literature frequents the theme by finding the repetition of events that transpire regardless of the person involved. His becoming blind coincided with his appointment as Director of the National Library of Argentina, and he understood this "splendid irony of God" as another wrinkle in the circular repetition of existence. John Milton's formal use of the Petrarchan sonnet provides a balanced structure for him to blend his experience with the general human experience, but his effort promotes an inward, self-reflective goal of trying to find God's mandate when he becomes blind. While Borges universalizes his blindness in order to convey his idea of transindividuality in "Poema de los dones" ("Poem of the Gifts"), Milton responds to the permanence of his night by ultimately resigning to a justified ascetism, patience, and contemplation as he awaits God's command in "When I Consider how my Light is Spent."


A graceful tug of war between continuity and schism, a changing fusion of the personal and the universal, and a tone of resignation direct Milton to the difficult acceptance of serving God by standing and waiting. Continuity within a set of lines shapes the theme by urging the poet to continue his faith in God. Contrasts in images and audiences define the differences between the soul-seeking author and the well-meaning orator.


Petrarchan sonnets usually invite the poet to propose a series of distinct statements from line to line. Milton deviates from the anticipated sentence divisions by merging one idea within more than one line ("To serve therewith my Maker, and present/ My true account...") (Miller 22). By employing the poise of prose within the suaveness of poetry, Milton engages the continuity of style but the flow of poetic form, and therefore, poetic rhyme. Further example of continuity appears in the rhyme characteristic of a Petrarchan sonnet ("My true account, lest he returning chide;/ 'Doth God exact day-labor, light denied?'"). Finally, the poem consists of one sentence; therefore, the end thought unifies itself with its preceding comments, creating a smooth reading of one expression. Continuity, inherent in the rhyme and in the syntax of the poetry (22), represents the exigency of Milton's personal continuity, which entails his continued devotion to God but also demands a persistency of survival within that defeated environment of blindness. Division of the two parts of a Petrarchan sonnet and of the two audiences challenge the element of continuity. Milton engenders the most specific contrast; that of the poet attempting to understand his blindness, and then the poet attempting to understand his obligations before God; by referring to the popular application of Petrarchan form, which provides a forum for the poet...

Find Another Essay On Philosophy of Milton in When I Consider how my Light is Spent and Borges in Poema de los dones

How I Spent My Summer Vacation

702 words - 3 pages full of festivities we decided to venture out to the City of Chihuahua to site see. I must say it is a beautiful city. Most of the roads are lined with little shops full of handmade merchandise, lots and lots of ice cream shops and fruit stands. My children were amazed by all the ice cream. Many large historical buildings and statues to tour if you are into getting to know the culture more in depth. However, after several hours of walking in the

How I Wish I Spent My Summer Vacation

1465 words - 6 pages the morning, it does 50 laps around the track at an average speed of 200 mph. Needless to say, afterwords I am fully awake and not tired in the least bit!Next up is the game room. The only object in this room is a strange-lookinggold-plated pod sitting in the center of my room. My house is very roomy but sparsely furnished, don't you think? Well, as I was saying, there's this pod, and when you enter it, you will notice buttons, joysticks, a

George Milton in Of Mice and Men

1021 words - 4 pages George Milton in Of Mice and Men by John Steinbeck is crude, snarky, and downright normal. He’s a character that, while some of his decisions are questionable, is easy to relate to from his actions, thoughts, and personality. The idea of such a character being remindful of the reader by spirit or another is emphasized by Alan Moore’s quote, “I suppose all fictional characters, especially in adventure or heroic fiction, at the end of the day are

Consider how the monster is portrayed In Mary Shelley's Frankenstein and the Two film versions of Frankenstein

4474 words - 18 pages black and white, was produced in 1931 and directed by James Whale. He chose Boris Carlov to be his monster, and Colin Clive played Doctor Frankenstein. Kenneth Branagh directed the second film in 1995 and he also played Doctor Frankenstein. Robert DeNiro was the actor that was chosen to play the monster.From each film I have studied four clips which I have compared with the novel. They consider how the birth of the monster is portrayed, how the

House Of Doom. This essay is about an experience i had at my cottage when i was stranded in the middle of a lake with one of my friends.

813 words - 3 pages back.Finally my dad came out in the pontoon boat and we pulled the paddleboat in by tying the rope to the pontoon and slowing driving home.Now, you would think this is where the story ends. But no! Next, as we're about a half of a mile away, the rope breaks from the paddleboat and now we have no way of getting it home. We consider just leaving it there and letting it sink, but then...another miracle...and I do mean miracle. All the sudden a boat of really

This is my philosophy of life paper, required in eleventh grade health in my school. it describes my goals, accomplishments, and attitude toward life.

1198 words - 5 pages 12/17/03 Philosophy of Life Paper My philosophy of life is probably quite different than most people. I have been through several traumatic events, as well as maintained high grades in rather high-level courses. Most people fail to understand how I manage to keep up my grades. However, perfectionism is one of my many flaws, and one that I struggle with each and every day. Perhaps this paper will help you understand me better. In my life

Death in Emily Dickinson's Because I Could Not Stop for Death, I Heard A Fly Buzz-When I Died, and I Felt A Funeral In My Brain

1330 words - 5 pages Death in Emily Dickinson's "Because I Could Not Stop for Death," "I Heard A Fly Buzz-When I Died," and "I Felt A Funeral In My Brain" Emily Dickinson's poems "Because I Could Not Stop for Death", "I Heard A Fly Buzz-When I Died", and "I Felt A Funeral In My Brain" all deal with one of life's few certainties, death. Dickinson's intense curiosity towards mortality was present in much of her work, and is her legacy as a poet. "Because I

Reflections of Milton in Paradise Lost and On Having Arrived.

958 words - 4 pages a major weakness. Later in the text, he describes Hell ashaving "no light, but rather darkness visible"(Hndout 270). It is Milton'sway of almost subliminally implying that his condition is comparable tobeing damned to the underworld. His blindness was something that heconstantly had to deal with and he managed to include it in most of hisworks.At the prime of Milton's life, the political situation in England wasvery unsteady. Charles I was

Elevator Ethnography: My 2 hours spent in an Elevator.

967 words - 4 pages and glance. Oh my, how they all gaze and glance. And the beep, ah yes, one cannot forget the beep. Every floor that is passed there is a beep; and that beep comes from the small light display in the upper left hand corner of the elevator. For every floor that goes by, that small light changes to a different number and it beeps. Elevator riders don't know it, but they love that beep. It is that very beep that saves them in their absolute moment of

The Concept of Infinity and Immeasurability in Jorge Borges' The Library of Babel

618 words - 2 pages to his birth place and his insinuated futile effort in the book search conveys a sense of a underachievement that the writer seems to view of his life. The theme of infinity creeps in again when the author says his body will be thrown into the bottomless air and will be allowed to ‘sink endlessly’, dissolving in the infinite wind. Once again, there’s a repetition: ‘I say that the Library is infinite’. Now, the author informs the reader about

Consider the theme of loneliness in 'Of Mice and Men'. How does it

1398 words - 6 pages Consider the theme of loneliness in 'Of Mice and Men'. How does it affect the friendships and relationships in the novel? This novel that was written by John Steinbeck which was set in the 1930s in Salinas Soledad which is in California. The novel consists of many historical factors which have affected the characters in this novel and one of them includes "the great depression" Which leads the novels inspiration for the famous writer

Similar Essays

Legacies In Ozymandias And When I Consider How My Light Is Spent

1687 words - 7 pages The Petrarchan sonnets “Ozymandias” by Percy Bysshe Shelley and “When I Consider How My Light Is Spent” by John Milton both consider a man’s legacy after death. However, both poems talk about a man’s legacy from very different perspective and come to their own conclusions. In “Ozymandias”, a traveler describes a broken statue of King Ozymandias (the Greek name for the Egyptian Pharaoh Ramses II) and the barren ruins surrounding the statue

Discontinuity In Self Reliance And When I Consider How My Light Is Spent

1862 words - 7 pages his use of a Petrarchan sonnet in the poem "When I Consider How My Light Is Spent." Nonconformity and discontinuity in a man’s approach to life are the doctrines espoused by Emerson in his work "Self-Reliance," and Milton embodies an Emersonian outlook while inwardly searching for personal truth in his sonnet. The lack of formal structure in the works of the two authors enhances rather than inhibits the reader’s grasp of the literature. Although

When I Consider How My Light Is Spent

2356 words - 9 pages John Milton’s Sonnet XIX, known as “When I Consider How My Light Is Spent” is a poem considering one’s disabling affliction in light of a time-less truth that the Apostle Paul wrote of: all things work to the good who love God and one thereby learns to be content in all things. Milton’s disabling affliction was blindness and by most interpretative accounts he was blind when he wrote Sonnet XIX. Under God’s providence Milton “considers” his dark

Comparing Do Not Go Gentle Into That Good Night And When I Consider How My Light Is Spent

1188 words - 5 pages Comparing Dylan Thomas's poem Do Not Go Gentle Into That Good Night and John Milton's poem When I consider How My Light Is Spent Dylan Thomas's poem "Do not go gentle into that good night" and John Milton's poem "When I consider how my light is spent" were written during times of trouble in their respective poet's life. Thomas was faced with losing his father to death; Milton was dealing with becoming completely blind at the age of forty