This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Physical Castration Is The Most Effective Punishment For Sex Offenders

2380 words - 10 pages

In Texas, May 2012 a repeat child sex offender Craig Stephen Hoard was handed seven life sentences. Hoard was convicted of indecency in 1977 and was released for parole from prison in February 2001. Seven days later he was convicted for sex with a child. He served nine years in state prison. Three months after his release from his nine year sentence in 2010 he was arrested again. In June 2010, Police arrested Hoard, finding child porn on his computer and iPod. A video of Hoard was found of him in a restroom stall at a pizza place in Conroe instructing a five year old to expose his genitals. Judge Hamilton could not change what Hoard has done to many children in the past but she can stop ...view middle of the document...

The offender’s mentality changes to the point where they have zero urges of any kind. James Jenkins, a convicted repeat sex offender, who castrated himself while in prison has said, "Castration has done precisely what I wanted it to do." James continues to say, "I have not had any sexual urges or desires in over two years. My mind is finally free of the deviant sexual fantasies I used to have about young girls." James believes that doing so will help him from reoffending. Little annoyances such as a busy work day or sitting in traffic wont set the offender off into an angry rage of emotion. Removing the testes help them to control their emotions. Elizabeth M. Tullio graduated Cum Laude from University of California Irvine with a double major in Criminology and Behavioral Psychology. Tullio attended Chapman university school of Law obtaining her jurist doctorate degree. In a article on Chapman Law Review, Tullio wrote, “Physical castration, or orchiectomy, is a surgical procedure in which a man’s testes are removed. This causes a dramatic drop in the levels of testosterone in the body which severely decreases a man’s sex drive.” The dropping of testosterone levels will change how the offender acts. Their sex drive is dropped greatly, leaving the offender with little to no sexual urges. The surgery leaves the offender feeling calm and not wanting sex. The offender is left feeling comfortable around other people, especially children because the offender has peace of mind. They are able to do everyday things and live a normal life without worrying that something may happen with someone around them. The offender as a human has the right to live a normal life of: shopping, going to the park, and going to see a movie. The surgery leaves the offender and other people around them able to live in peace.
Out of all known punishments for repeat sex offenders, physical castration has the lowest of all recidivism rates. John McMillan, Professor of Bioethics Centre from University of Otago stated in his article The Kindest Cut, A study done in Germany in 1989 by Wille and Beier showed the reoffending rate was way lower with having the surgery and not having the surgery at all. Wille and Beier’s studies showed “ We compared 99 surgically castrated sex offenders and 35 non-castrated sex offenders about a decade after their release from prison, and found that the recidivism rate of castrated offenders was 3%, while the rate for non-castrated offenders was 46%.” Wille and Beiers studies show such a small recidivism rate compared to other studies done. The surgery changes the mentality of the offender so they have not drive fore sex due to the much lower testosterone levels. On average a child sexual offender will stay in jail for at least ten years. Jail becomes a feeding ground for sex offenders because there are no other treatments happening in the prison. So when the offender is released the recidivism rate is very high for that sex offender. According to...

Find Another Essay On Physical Castration is The Most Effective Punishment for Sex Offenders

Penalties for Sex offenders Essay

1664 words - 7 pages depending on which state you are in. Sexual abuse is another crime punishable by law. Some of the penalties for sexual abuse are from one year to thirty years in prison; this is according to OLR Research report. Most of the treatment programs I mentioned previously are offered in prison. There are also a couple methods of punishment that are not implemented in today’s court system but are being considered for punishment of sex offenders, one of

Is castration cruel and unusual punishment?

295 words - 2 pages . Castration to me is only an option in certain circumstances. If someone is a first time offender I believe that they should be given jail time along with rehabilitation. Castration should be mandatory for repeat offenders and they should be given adequate jail time. Even though castration is not a guarantee that men will be repeat offenders, it should encompass both surgical and chemical methods. When the judge determines sentencing, depending on

the Effects of Chemical Castration and Physical Castration

1841 words - 7 pages Lata Mangeshkar- The Pride of India India, one of the highest movie producing countries, has many great singers. One such singer, who has been singing for the past 60 years is non other then my favourite singer Lata Mangeshkar. Lata Mangeshkar is and has been the most heard voice in all of India for some time now. Lata has been active in all Indian popular and classical music, sung film songs, ghazals , bhajans and pop (Nagma, 2004). Lata's

Treatment is More Effective Than Jail for Drug Offenders

2418 words - 10 pages One of the most profound problems that plagues our society is drug addiction. With drug addiction comes those who offend and have run-ins with the law. Our country deals with these drug-addicted offenders by placing them in jails for a year or longer, only to have them come back out to society when their sentence is over. They are still drug-addicts and so they return to the street only to commit yet another crime. From here the cycle of crime

Harsher Laws for Sex Offenders

1627 words - 7 pages   Introduction When a dog viciously attacks a small child and scars the child for life, dog is euthanized because of the trauma it causes. If we are putting down dogs for attacking children, why are we not doing the same thing for sex offenders? Child sexual abuse is defined as “the activity between adults and minors or between two minors when one forces the act on the other. This includes sexual touching, exposure to pornography, photography of

Civil Commitment For Sex Offenders

1948 words - 8 pages is still the question, what drives a sex offender? People have wondered for decades, why do sex offenders do what they do? What causes them to want to pursue inappropriate relationships with children or forces themselves upon another? The answers to these questions are simple: it varies. Each person is different from the next, meaning whatever led them to committing whatever sexual crime they committed could differ greatly. One this to note

The Reasons Sex Offenders Offend

787 words - 3 pages wants lived out. The third is tied in with the second which is the aggressor has a sadistic aim where he feels that some violence must occur for there to be sexual pleasure. (Hollin, p. 41) The second theory is the behavioral theory, which states that "rapists in general are less aroused by stimuli depicting forceful sex that by stimuli depicting mutually enjoyable sex."(Hollin, p. 42) There is an exception to this with extremely violent

Corporal Punishment is physical abuse

824 words - 3 pages Corporal Punishment is physical abuseCorporal punishment is the execution of a judicially imposed sentence that inflicts a manner of physical pain upon the offenders body without killing him. In the past corporal punishment included flogging, whipping, branding and facial or bodily mutilation of all types. Corporal punishment also refers to the discipline of children at home and in schools but it was made illegal for punishing schoolchildren in

Supervising Sex Offenders in the Community

1142 words - 5 pages a sex offender is living in their neighborhood then most people tend to keep an eye out. With the help of more advanced monitoring tools, individual treatment programs, and statutory mandates community corrections officials have many different strategies for monitoring sex offenders in the community Effective supervision of sex offenders released back into the general public is a priority for community corrections. With advancements in

Stop the Harassment of Sex Offenders

1216 words - 5 pages convicted sex offender who lived in her neighborhood. People in her neighborhood did not know of his past (Internet: Don't...). This brought about the spread of the so-called 'Megan's laws', states must now keep registers of sex offenders. Some states go a step further with these laws. Janet Reynolds of the Hartford Advocate reports that, in addition to the registry, California legislature voted to make chemical castration mandatory for sex

who is the most effective leader ralph or jack

943 words - 4 pages and control a group. As the novel goes on one of the boys is more effective than the other.One way in which Golding portrays Ralph and Jack as leader is the way the boys handle situations. Ralph is seen as a good leader with his response to the beastie that the littluns have reported seeing. Unlike Jack who completely dismisses the topic, Ralph listens to what they have to say. This shows he cares for the littluns, by trying to comfort them in

Similar Essays

Castration: An Option For Sex Offenders

2465 words - 10 pages violate one of society's most despised taboos. Perhaps the most apropos revenge against the child molester...the sex offender!Or is it?Castration as a punishment is clearly a violation of the U.S. Constitution that prohibits cruel and unusual punishment. This has already been upheld in several U.S. courts. Castration as a treatment of sex offenders may also be a constitutional violation if it is done as a condition for release or parole or as a

Chemical Castration For Repeat Sex Offenders

2375 words - 10 pages and continual use it can be the most effective course of action for sexual offenders today. Monitored chemical castration should be the only alternative to full sentence prison time for repeat sex offenders, and child molesters, unless he voluntarily requests surgical castration. “Sometimes the gangrenous toe has to be sacrificed for the well being of the rest of the body” UNKOWN. Chemical castration in short, is the suppression of sex

Punishment For Sex Offenders Essay

949 words - 4 pages offenders; it would also allow the victims peace of mind knowing they will not harmed.and would be the most suitable punishment for such a crime. Castration is the most logical solution for rehabilitating sex offenders. Castration is the surgical or chemical way of reducing the amount of hormones that produce in the body to lower sex drive. There are two different forms of castration chemical and surgical. Chemical castration is the process of

Is There Help For Sex Offenders?

978 words - 4 pages the hands of “good behavior?” More important than the added anger of sex offenders at the extension of their captivity, the program would require a considerable amount of money to run. Is the money worth investing in for what seems like the good of those who are at fault? It seems easier to just allow offenders to do their time and get release if they are not a disturbance in the prison. Many may see the program as an absurdity bent on robbing