This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Physician Assisted Suicide: A Case Study Analysis

2139 words - 9 pages

Physician-Assisted Suicide: A Case Study Analysis
There are many legal and ethical issues when discussing the topic of physician-assisted suicide (PAS). The legal issues are those regarding numerous court cases over the past few decades, the debate over how the 14th Amendment of the United States Constitution comes into play, and the legalization vs. illegalization of this practice. The 14th Amendment states, “nor shall any State deprive any person of life, liberty, or property, without due process of law; nor deny to any person within its jurisdiction the equal protection of the laws” (U.S. Const. amend. XIV, §1). PAS in the past has been upheld as illegal due to the Equal Protection ...view middle of the document...

Washington State had previously passed a law titled Natural Death Act. This states that, “withholding or withdrawal of life-sustaining treatment…shall not, for any purpose, constitute a suicide or a homicide” (Natural Death Act, 1979). This law gave people the right to refuse life-saving treatment and the respondents of the Washington et al. v. Glucksberg et al. case argued that PAS was along the same liberties. They argued that every person should have the right to die a dignified death and the liberty to make these choices (Illingworth & Parmet, 2006). Despite their argument, the case was ruled in favor of the defendants for the following reasons; the state has the commitment to preserve life, prevent suicide, protect the integrity of the medical profession, and protect vulnerable groups (Illingworth & Parmet, 2006).
However, in November of 2008 the Death with Dignity Act passed, in the state of Washington, legalizing PAS. This shows how often this debate is brought to the courts and how important it is to health care providers and those at the end-of-life. Washington’s Death with Dignity Act, which was based off of Oregon’s Death with Dignity Act of 1997, states that if you are diagnosed with a terminal illness, given less then six months to live, and are mentally competent to make decisions, you can be prescribed a lethal dose (with two doctors consent) of medication that must be self-administered at home (Death with Dignity Act, 2008).
Moral Problems
There are many moral and ethical issues surrounding the topic of suicide and therefore PAS. The moral dilemmas surrounding why PAS is largely still illegal, is due to the commitment the State has to protecting life, the integrity of the medical profession, and vulnerable groups. There is also a fear of the slippery slope argument such as legalizing PAS could lead to involuntary acts of assisted suicide. The moral principles that are often used to legalize PAS include a person’s autonomy to decide the manner of one’s own death and the right to die with dignity.
Protecting Life
The government has the commitment to protect all human life, regardless of ones physical, emotional, or mental state. An argument used in the Washington et al. v. Glucksberg et al. (1997) case was that the State has an important role in preventing suicide and often time’s people who are suicidal are depressed or in physical pain. Once these two factors are removed, the suicidal tendencies drastically decrease (Washington et al. v. Glucksberg et al., 1997). As Frank and Anselmi (2011) stated, the court needs to help those who have a, “temporary imbalance with permanent consequences” (p. 12).
Protecting the Medical Profession
This is an important aspect to health care providers when discussing PAS, and includes doctors and nurses. The medical profession is based on integrity, honesty, and reliability. The Nursing Code of Ethics states that it is important to maintain the integrity of the profession and to continue to...

Find Another Essay On Physician-Assisted Suicide: A Case Study Analysis

Physician Assisted Suicide Essay

2568 words - 10 pages with some dignity. In this case study, “sixty percent [of physicians] agreed that physician assisted suicide should be legal for certain circumstances” (Gupta 4). People outside of the medical field propose that taking a life, even for valid reasons is still wrong. For most Americans, the argument against physician assisted suicide is not only based on the questions of the responsibilities and duties of the medical profession, but on more vague

Physician-Assisted Suicide Essay

2223 words - 9 pages Physician-Assisted Suicide In today's society, a very controversial issue is physician-assisted suicide for terminally ill patients. Many people feel that it is wrong for people, regardless of their health situation, to ask their doctor or attendant to end their life. Others feel it is their right to be able to choose how and when they die. When a doctor is asked to help a patient to their death, they have certain responsibilities

Physician Assisted Suicide

843 words - 4 pages alternative to continually living with the burden of a terminal illness. Allowing physician assisted suicide to be an option for terminally ill patients alleviates the suffering that they may have to endure. How can the government make a decision to keep aching patients from alleviating their pain? The incident of Matthew Donnelly illustrates the perfect case of a patient whose suffering had gone on too long: Matthew’s job of working with x-ray

Physician Assisted Suicide

641 words - 3 pages permitted in my point of view due to my beliefs. I believe that physician-assisted suicide is just another name for self-suicide that’s legal. However, I believe that since we are the property of God then we should wait until He is ready to receive us. Also, in my mind, the statement "Thou Shall Not Kill" also extends to euthanasia. Many medical doctors also oppose physician-assisted suicide for their beliefs. Who is a doctor to tell a patient how they

Physician Assisted Suicide

1108 words - 4 pages The practice of assisted suicide is not a modern phenomenon. In ancient Greece, the government gave hemlock to those who wanted it. William Shakespeare memorialized the Roman practice in Julius Caesar by depicting Brutus running into the sword held by Strato (Egendorf). While physician assisted suicide is not a new concept the moral debate surrounding euthanasia in America has certainly been brought to the forefront in the last thirty years with

Physician Assisted Suicide - 1798 words

1798 words - 8 pages . Physician assisted suicide PAS or physician assisted death PAD is the voluntary ending of one’s life primarily by taking a lethal substance (usually a barbiturate) prescribed by a physician (Friend, Mary, & Louanne, 2011, p. 110). In each case, the patient has explicitly come to the conclusion to expedite his or her own death owed to a terminal illness.
 Four of fifty states in the United States have legalized physician assisted suicide

Physician Assisted Suicide

2322 words - 10 pages Canada as well for many reasons. People that are under constant suffering whether it is at the hospital or at home can die with dignity. One of the most important reasons physician assisted suicide should be legal in Canada is that it is a humane way for terminally ill patients to end their lives without suffering any longer. Patients that cannot enjoy their last days on earth due to suffering should have a choice, if they know that there illness

Physician Assisted Suicide

814 words - 3 pages Csorny PAGE 4Danielle CsornyPaper #3FYS Word Count: 71423 October 2014Legalizing Physician-Assisted SuicideBrittany Maynard, a very active young wife, chose to take advantage of her right to "die with dignity". She was diagnosed with terminal stage 4 cancer of the brain, formally known as Glioblastoma multiform. Only having a few months to live, Brittany requested a life-ending medication to avoid the pain and suffering. This is a case of

Physician Assisted Suicide - 624 words

624 words - 2 pages Advances in medical technology have produced ethical dilemmas that people at any other time have confronted. The most imperative is, "how far do we go to save lives?" Today, compassion and common sense have been taken over by machines and technology. More than ever, there is an urge to change the rules.Legalizing physician-assisted suicide would create a "slippery-slope" to euthanasia. Euthanasia is defined as the practice of terminating the

Physician Assisted Suicide - 1559 words

1559 words - 6 pages definition. The definition of physician-assisted suicide is “when a person - typically someone suffering from an incurable illness or chronic intense pain - intentionally kills him/herself with the help of a doctor. A doctor may prescribe drugs on the understanding that the patient intends to use them to take a fatal overdose; or a doctor may insert an intravenous needle into the arm of a patient, who then pushes a switch to trigger a fatal injection

Physician Assisted Suicide - 2539 words

2539 words - 11 pages classical Greece, which should bare no relevance today in modern times but just a conventionality. One may deduce that since doctors should not aid in people's will to die and leave them in the pain and suffering that is their lives, and that no prescription should cure, is the direct opposite of the Hippocratic oath, so why have the oath in the first place, in that case it should be called the hypocrit-ic oath. ​Physician assisted suicide

Similar Essays

A Case For The Legalization Of Physician Assisted Suicide

1379 words - 6 pages A Case for the Legalization of Physician-Assisted Suicide On February 20, 2009, my grandfather was diagnosed with stage 3 pancreatic cancer. When initially diagnosed, his oncologist told him that he had less than one year to live. During the last year of his life, my grandfather received palliative care that was meant to ease the pain caused by the progression of his disease. However, as the weeks progressed, my grandfather's cancer ravaged his

Physician Assisted Suicide: A Crime Or Not

864 words - 3 pages suicide was legalized the doctor could bring the papers and tape to court if he/she was accused of murder. Scott M. Peck MD also said, "Thousands of people a year participate in assisted suicide" (101). If this many people are doing it and getting away with it assisted suicide must be helping people. So it should be legalized so it doesn't have to be such a secret when it happens. On Oct. 27, 1997 the state of Oregon legalized physician-assisted

Legalizing Physician Assisted Suicide Essay

1424 words - 6 pages promise and convictions they have built their career on. Legalizing physician assisted suicide would also directly violate many physician’s moral and religious notions. A study conducted by The University of Chicago Chronicle revealed that the majority of physicians are religious. “The first study of physician religious beliefs has found that 76 percent of doctors believe in God and 59 percent believe in some sort of afterlife” (Easton 1). A primary

Physician Assisted Suicide Essay 1295 Words

1295 words - 5 pages it comes to personal body decisions and California should look at physician assisted suicide in that same context. Physician assisted suicide may seem irrational and selfish to some but in reality an individual who takes advantage of this is not doing so strictly for selfish reasons, benefits to the grim situation include preventing family from accruing future debt. In a study conducted on two hundred patients receiving physician assisted