This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Anatomy Of A False Confession Essay

1613 words - 6 pages

Anatomy of a False Confession

     Depending on what study is read, the incidence of false confession is less than 35 per year, up to 600 per year. That is a significant variance in range, but no matter how it is evaluated or what numbers are calculated, the fact remains that false confessions are a reality. Why would an innocent person confess to a crime that she did not commit? Are personal factors, such as age, education, and mental state, the primary reason for a suspect to confess? Are law enforcement officers and their interrogation techniques to blame for eliciting false confessions? Regardless of the stimuli that lead to false confessions, society and the justice system need to find a solution to prevent the subsequent aftermath.
     In the adversarial justice system, when the offender admits to the criminal act, there is no further controversy and the case promptly proceeds to sentencing. Physical evidence and victim or witness statements may often be overlooked and not considered. The confession is considered unequivocal evidence of guilt and a conviction is ensured. Indeed, the interrogation process’ sole purpose is to obtain a confession. Zimbardo (1967) estimated that “of those criminal cases that are solved, more than 80% are solved by a confession.” (Conti, 1999) Without the confession, convictions may be reduced significantly. So why does a person falsely confess to a crime if the likelihood of a conviction is eminent? A false confession to any crime is self-destructive and counterintuitive.
     The mental state of the suspect can give explanation to a false confession. If a person is inebriated and is questioned before she is sober, that may lead to easier manipulation by the police. A suspect under the influence of alcohol or drugs may not remember all the events leading up to her arrest. This mental state allows police officers to give misleading information, which may imply that the suspect did commit the crime and does not remember the incident.
Mental retardation or suspects with low intelligence quotients (IQ) are easily manipulated by police comments and interrogation tactics. Those suspects usually do not understand the law or the consequences of a confession. They may want to please the police officer by being accommodating or agreeable. They may just want to go home to a familiar environment. Suspects with personality or anxiety disorders are more suggestible, as well, and are likely to provide self-incriminating statements.
     Age of the suspect is also a significant factor when discussing false confessions. Juveniles rarely understand the law or the justice system. Juveniles are unreliable, and often lie or tell exaggerated stories to fool or impress police officers. Children do not understand the implications of the confession. Sometimes children will confess because they falsely believe that they may be able...

Find Another Essay On Anatomy of a False Confession

Synopsis of Anatomy of a Murder

1685 words - 7 pages Anatomy of a Murder takes place in small-town in Michigan, in which a murder has taken place. Lieutenant Frederick Manion murdered Barney Quill a local bar and inn owner, after Mr. Quill raped his wife Laura Manion. Mrs. Manion contacts former state district attorney Paul Biegler to represent her husband, who is facing charges for first degree murder. Knowing nothing about the case, Mr. Beigler is pursued by his friend Parnell McCarthy to take

The Anatomy of a Roller Coaster

1764 words - 7 pages The Anatomy of a Roller Coaster To adequately understand the relationship between physics and roller coasters, it is essential to first describe and explain the basic structure of roller coasters. In simple terms, a roller coaster is much like that of a passenger train. To explain, a roller coaster consists of a series of connected cars that move on tracks. However, unlike a train, a roller coaster has no engine, or rather a power

The Automobile: A False Sense of Freedom

2503 words - 10 pages ”, (2006). This concept of freedom at a cost is present everywhere in our society; it can be seen as a false promise or a blatant denial of freedom. I will look at how both are constantly present and leave no one untouched. The best examples of both are present in the American Vacation. What was once a privilege for the wealthy; the American vacation became a staple in our culture. In Are we there yet?: the golden age of American family

America, A Land of False Hope

912 words - 4 pages people who attain 85% of the wealth (Domhoff). In American today, such a small amount of people own large proportion of the wealth, and suck a large amount of people own such a small portion of the wealth. The wealth distribution in American is completely discombobulated, yet America is supposed to be all about democracy. However, with such a small amount of people owning and controlling everyone else, it makes the entire idea of democracy false

Analysis of The Hanged Man's Bride, The Trial for Murder and Confession Found in a Prison

3638 words - 15 pages Analysis of The Hanged Man's Bride, The Trial for Murder and Confession Found in a Prison Introduction Based on my study of Charles Dickens, I have decided to focus upon three short stories to write about in detail. These are: The Hanged Man's Bride, written in 1860, The Trial For Murder, written in 1865 and Confession Found in a Prison, written in 1842. To enable me to understand the stories better and also Dicken's

Effect of False Suggestions on Memory in a Traumatic Event

2549 words - 10 pages 1Running head: EFFECT OF FALSE SUGGESTIONS ON MEMORY IN A TRAUMATIC EVENT2EFFECT OF FALSE SUGGESTIONS ON MEMORY IN A TRAUMATIC EVENTEffect of False Suggestions on Memory in a Traumatic EventClinton Dsouza (998609796)University of TorontoLoftus & Palmer (1974) set the ground running with a classical study that looked into the interaction between language and memory in their 'Reconstruction of Automobile Destruction' study. They discovered

Effect of False Suggestions on Memory in a Traumatic Event

2549 words - 10 pages 1Running head: EFFECT OF FALSE SUGGESTIONS ON MEMORY IN A TRAUMATIC EVENT2EFFECT OF FALSE SUGGESTIONS ON MEMORY IN A TRAUMATIC EVENTEffect of False Suggestions on Memory in a Traumatic EventClinton Dsouza (998609796)University of TorontoLoftus & Palmer (1974) set the ground running with a classical study that looked into the interaction between language and memory in their 'Reconstruction of Automobile Destruction' study. They discovered

The American Dream: A False Sense of Hope

3553 words - 14 pages can be who you have always wanted to be. However, the sad reality is that these people are lucky. It rarely happens that someone makes it in the music industry in a matter of months, looses two-hundred pounds in less than a year, or wins millions of dollars within days of buying a piece of paper. Because few exploit the American Dream by promising wealth or fame to many others, a false sense of hope has been created for those who are

Ecstasy: The True Side Of A False Drug

1328 words - 5 pages Ecstasy: The True Side of a False Drug. "A survey of 16-29 year olds in the United Kingdom showed that 9% of surveyors had used ecstasy. After surveying members of the rave scene, the numbers rose to 91%" (Weir 5). A statistic like that gives plenty of reason for the need of both awareness and a form of enforcement against the use of the drug ecstasy. Although this drug is relatively new, the use of ecstasy is rising. Unfortunately, the

Nature vs. Nurture: Parental Promotion of A False Dichotomy

1784 words - 7 pages development of gender is the concern of this paper. As parents, we want our children to succeed and have opportunities that we may not have been privy to. In order to do so, we often want our children to live normal and fulfilling lives that conform to society. This leads us to the question: as a heterosexual parent, how (1) 2 am I imparting the false dichotomy of gender, a stereotype of personality traits being either masculine or feminine, to my

Comparing the Anatomy and Physiology of a Domestic House Cat, to that of a Human

3948 words - 16 pages Introduction For the cat lab, there is no hypothesis as this is a observational activity. The purpose of this lab is to compare the anatomy and physiology of a Domestic House Cat, to that of a human. The references are “New” Lab manual, and Disecction of the Cat. The scale of refrence is one bar = 3mm. Anatomy, Observations and Comparisons: External Anatomy. Firstly, when we got to our table, we removed our cat, which was a black and white

Similar Essays

Anatomy Of A Hurricane Essay

1787 words - 8 pages Anatomy of a Hurricane Many of American citizens along the southern boarder states such as Florida , Louisiana , Mississippi, Alabama, and the Carolina’s that have water on one or both sides of it, and knowing the dangers and flash back pictures associate with the word hurricane begin their preparation would be considered a tropical storm. It can put even those who lived through tropical storms and Hurricane s to become in either

Confession Of A Mask: A Perverse Text?

2970 words - 12 pages to be.In Yukio Mishima's Confessions of a Mask, the I-narrator describes his childhood and adolescent experiences in an attempt to isolate early signs of his homosexuality, seemingly to aid his rhetoric of confession. His account of sadomasochistic homosexual desires tangles between fact and fiction, without a clear distinction between notions of masking and unmasking. Is the narrator's sexuality a performance? How do ideas of abjection, fetishism

Anatomy Of A Muscle Cell Essay

1003 words - 4 pages Anatomy of Muscle Cells There are three types of muscle tissue in the human body. These muscle tissues are skeletal muscles, smooth muscles and cardiac muscles. Each of these muscle tissues has it very own anatomical makeup, which vary from muscle to muscle. The muscle cells in a muscle are referred to as muscle fibers, these fibers are skeletal muscle fibers, smooth muscle fibers and cardiac muscle fibers. The anatomy of a skeletal muscle

The Anatomy Of A Lie Essay

1066 words - 5 pages because we have all been lied to. Whether you were told white lies about the Easter bunny and Santa Claus or someone lied to you about their whereabouts any false statement is quite simply a lie. The effects of a lie are what I have the most experience in and it is those effects which caused me to be a liar in turn. Living a lie or maintaining lies an individual has told over time is a tiresome process and a difficult one to bear. My experience in