Pick A Historical Related Film And Analyse Its Historical Accuracy.

773 words - 3 pages

The historical accuracy of gladiator in some aspects was quite good but in others, quite bad. Even right from the opening scene, the inaccuracies start. First, there was no last great battle with the Germanic tribes on the eve of Marcus Aurelius' death. There was a great daylong battle late in the campaigning season of A.D. 179, but Marcus died on March 17 of 180, just as he was about to launch another great military campaign. It is most probable that the scriptwriters needed to shorten the chronology here to save time in a long movie, but that wasn't their only mistake relating to battles. The use of fire-hurling catapults and mechanical dart launchers against the oncoming barbarians was certainly dramatic but probably unhistorical. Such weapons were too burdensome for use on the open battlefield, thus were confined to more static siege warfare.I have found no proof corresponding to the Roman commander Maximus, the movie's hero, and if there were one, it would not have been a German shepherd, a breed that did not exist in ancient times.Marcus Aurelius was not quite 59 when he died, perhaps of plague. "Gladiator" does capture his kindly and philosophical nature, but his decrepit frailty, thin beard, and wispy fly-away hair in the movie bear little resemblance to his statues and portraits on coins. They show him as a fairly vigorous man with a full beard and a thick head of curly hair.The whole movie in addition radically compresses the chronology of the Emperor Commodus' reign. He became sole emperor upon his father's death in March of 180AD and was assassinated almost thirteen years later on December 31, 192AD. Although the time covered by "Gladiator" is not precisely indicated, it would appear that no more than two years could have elapsed before Commodus was killed. Within that time-frame, however, the movie does utilize some historical facts relating to him: Commodus was fascinated with shows of beast hunting, chariot racing, and gladiatorial combat and he did train himself in those skills; and eventually he fought in the public arena as the kind of light-armed gladiator known as a secutor (pursuer).Commodus was in fact a joint ruler with his father from the beginning of 177AD, when Commodus became the youngest of Roman consuls up to that time....

Find Another Essay On Pick a historical related film and analyse its historical accuracy.

Evaluate the historical accuracy of the Samurai way of life represented in the film, 'The Last Samurai'

2419 words - 10 pages to end their days of glory and loyal service. Although 'The Last Samurai' is not a strong source of historical information, it accurately represents the main themes that are focused on. The Samurai's family and home life; Zen and Shinto beliefs and how they are performed; their utter devotion to Bushido; their utmost respect for the Katana; and finally their ultimate downfall brought upon by their own Emperor; all are powerfully and precisely portrayed and the end result a film epic doing justice for the forgotten warriors, the Samurai.

Analysis of disneys brother bear in relation to historical accuracy

836 words - 3 pages A historical perspective on Disney's latest film "brother bear"This past weekend I saw the movie Brother Bear, it's a new Disney movie and rated G. I have some trouble with the historical accuracy of the film and will be discussing that at great length. Sure it's a children's movie, but does that mean it's ok to disregard historical accuracy? Perhaps the fact that it's designed for children makes it even more important to keep it historically

Atheism as a historical philosophy and its relevance in contemporary America

4776 words - 19 pages a country designated as Christian” (Odell v. Koppee). Of course, this is not the case – even Plato recognized that fact. In his dialogue Euthypryo, Plato’s protagonist Socrates asks, do the gods choose what is good because it is good, or is the good good because the gods choose it? If the former is true, and the gods choose what is good because of its goodness, then goodness is separate from and independent of the gods. If the latter is true

A Historical Journey through the American Conscience: The Public and its Courts

1739 words - 7 pages America has long taken pride in being a nation of idealism and of freedom. Still, while these values have remained constant, other areas of the American mindset have evolved repeatedly over the brief course of America’s history. Nothing could illustrate this change more than the complex, developing, relationship between American citizens and their criminal justice system. Each era of American history shows the mindset of its time through the

Analyse the historical and contemporary conditions in Italy leading to a fascist government in 1922, and comment on the view that a seizure of power took place

2184 words - 9 pages In order to analyse the historical and contemporary conditions in Italy leading to a fascist government in 1922, I will consider and illustrate a number of relevant points. That is the historical aspects being industrial and democratic weaknesses. The contemporary factors being; the threat of communism, the growing anarchism in Italian urban areas and the feeling of antipathy over the Versailles Treaty, particularly the idea that Italians had

Hotel Rwanda and United 93 Analysis of Film Techniques - Historical Representation of Veracity

752 words - 3 pages extra bits to add to its entertainment value, yet managed to capture the scope of the genocides very well, tell the story of Paul Rusesabagina in a credible manner, and maintain historical veracity."Hotel Rwanda" (2004) directed by Terry George"United 93" (2006) directed by Gary Ross

"The black robe": purpose of making of film, analyzis of characters and historical context

1058 words - 4 pages Film CritiqueThe Black RobeThe purpose for production behind The Film "The Black Robe" by Robert Lantor was to tell the story of a Jesuit missioner named Paul Lafarge and his quest to convert the indigenous population of Canada into Christianity in the 1600's. Although the main plot of the story is to tell Lafarge's story, it is also intended to portray trough the film the differences between the indigenous customs and traditions and the

The Historical Context of The Bhagavad Gita and Its Relation to Indian Religious Doctrines

2519 words - 10 pages The Historical Context of The Bhagavad Gita and Its Relation to Indian Religious Doctrines The Bhagavad Gita is perhaps the most famous, and definitely the most widely-read, ethical text of ancient India. As an episode in India's great epic, the Mahabharata, The Bhagavad Gita now ranks as one of the three principal texts that define and capture the essence of Hinduism; the other two being the Upanishads and the Brahma Sutras. Though this work

The Historical depictions in the film, the Mission

1963 words - 8 pages HST119"The Mission" directed by Roland Joffe- The Historical depictions in the film, the Mission -Has anyone ever invaded your house before? Or have you ever been enslaved by people you don't know before? You're home may be a very sacred and comforting place for you and your family, but during the 1750's in South America, home to many Indian tribes called the Guarani, were subtle to enslavement by powers that were nearly beyond their control. In

The Civil War in Sudan its Historical Background and its Effects on Comparative Politics and International Relations

1492 words - 6 pages On January 1st, 1959 Sudan finally became its own independent country, and it looked as if it’s history of conflict would soon come to an end. But this was not to be, throughout most of Sudan’s independent status as a country it has been in constant turmoil. For the first thirteen years, 1959-1969, an elected government ran Sudan, but in that year, 1969, the elected government would be toppled by a military coup. Ever since this incident

How does propaganda work? What are its historical origins? Was the war in Iraq initiated by a campaign of propaganda and disinformation?

2864 words - 11 pages , loathes, or finds undesirable. Its intention is that the audience will reject the person or the alluded notion with respect to the negative symbol, in place of examining the available evidence (Delwiche, 2002). 'Glittering generalities' is a short cut to form perceptions; they are intensely emotional words, closely associated with highly valued concepts and beliefs that they carry conviction without supporting information or reason. They appeal to

Similar Essays

Historical Accuracy Of The Film From Hell

1921 words - 8 pages historical merits of the film From Hell will be examined by looking at the general known facts about the case; the accuracy of the film, whether the film is fair, biased, one-sided, or propagandistic; and lastly, the social climate of the late 19th century in Victorian England.WHAT THE MOVIE STATES HAPPENEDThe movie chooses the popular Royal Conspiracy theory connecting the Ripper's victims to a royal scandal. The scandal centers on Prince "Eddy

Shakespeare's Historical Accuracy Essay

1194 words - 5 pages Shakespeare’s Historical Accuracy William Shakespeare is possibly the greatest English writer every to live. Many people all around the world enjoy reading his plays. Often in his plays, Shakespeare describes things like lifestyle and laws of his time period. However, some people claim that Shakespeare’s plays are not historically accurate and therefore, mislead the people who read his plays. So how can one determine if Shakespeare is accurate

Analyse The Historical And Cur Essay

2154 words - 9 pages leadership. Mitterrand's victories in the presidential elections of 1981 and 1988 had a big part to play in the rise of the PS, but he perhaps precipitated its fall as well.Even by the mid 1980's many voters disillusioned by the socialist performance in office, especially the recourse of austerity policies in 1983-84, had deserted the left, leading to defeat in the 1986 parliamentary elections. However this turned out to be a mere 'bump in the road

Historical Accuracy Of The Film Good Night Good Luck

817 words - 3 pages his political career. “Good Night and Good Luck” impeccable historical accuracy is demonstrated by showing McCarthy in actual film. The Film easily found actors to play McCarthy’s part however actual film gives a view that no actor could. Seeing McCarthy as an actual human being gives a face to the watchers that an actor would not have done. Using the news reels the movie does helps illustrate the Red scares tension and paranoia. George