The Ashley Treatment: Practical, But Ethical?

788 words - 4 pages

The Ashley Treatment: Practical, But Ethical? Allison Veeder, RN
- Hitler times – medical experiments
- Kennedy sister – lobotomy
- Potential grave consequences that can result from irresponsible, or criminal, medical experiments. While we must be vigilant to protect innocent victims from such experimentation we cannot let that stifle our duty to continue making advances in healthcare and improving the lives of patients.
- Moral obligations should typically not be so demanding that enormous sacrificies must be made in order to fulfill them (Liao, Savulescu, & Sheehan, 2007).
- Beauchamp and Childress – ethical principles of autonomy
- One must ask if a treatment is practical does that make it ethical?

‘Hopes of keeping her as comfortable as possible’
‘”The Ashley Treatment” included high dose estrogen therapy, a hysterectomy, and breast bud removal.
Ashley had a normal birth, but her mental and motor faculties did not develop (“The Ashley Treatment,” 2007).
Ashley was diagnosed with encephalopathy of unknown etiology. This meant that she would forever have the mental capacity of an infant, though she had no physical deformities.
Although being awake and alert, Ashley cannot walk, talk, sit up, or even support her own head.
Ashley is cared for primarily by her parents and grandparents in their home.
Ashley’s parents state they became concerned when she developed precocious puberty at the age of six.
They spoke with their physician’s at Seattle Children’s Hospital about attenuating her growth process to minimize her adult height and weight. They also discussed two other treatments that they felt would enhance Ashley’s adult quality of life. One was a hysterectomy, which would prevent Ashley from feeling menstrual cramps and prevent the
heavy bleeding that would result from the estrogen therapy. The second was the removal of her breast buds. Ashley’s parents wanted to avoid the discomfort that large breasts would bring (her maternal and paternal lineage included large breast)
Ashley’s parents believed that by keeping her in a body that appears child like would be less likely to suffer sexual abuse from future caregivers.
Research has shown that females with disabilities are twice likely to suffer sexual abuse as females without disabilities (Clark & Vasta, 2007)
Reasoning
(1) Less likely to develop skin breakdown, infections...

Find Another Essay On The Ashley Treatment: Practical, but Ethical?

Animal Testing and People for the Ethical Treatment of Animals

1307 words - 5 pages animal. For example, penicillin kills guinea pigs but it is totally inactive in rabbits. When tested on animals the results are not always the same. Alternative methods would be beneficial to companies so that they don’t loose money when people start to not by their product. Researching on the PETA (People for the Ethical Treatment of Animals) website a Journal of the American Medical Association and British Medical Journal stated that “Animal

P.E.T.A -The Protection of the Ethical Treatment of Animals (Special Interest Groups)

540 words - 2 pages PETA (People of the Ethical Treatment of Animals), which operates under the simple principle that animals are not ours to eat, wear, experiment on, or use for entertainment.Testing at the University of Oregon, Barbara Gorden-Lickey, Ph.D, sewed kittens' eyes shut and forced them to jump from various heights onto a platform surrounded by water so she could study the effects of sight deprivation on the brain. Cruel and inhumane experiments like this

This case study is based upon the case article by Peter A. Stanwick and Sarah D. Stanwick titled; ‘Wal-Mart: But We Do Give Them a 10 Percent Employee Discount’, in which addresses the ethical issues...

1472 words - 6 pages Case Study: Wal-MartJune 12, 2012This case study is based upon the case article by Peter A. Stanwick and Sarah D. Stanwick titled; 'Wal-Mart: But We Do Give Them a 10 Percent Employee Discount', in which addresses the ethical issues facing Wal-Mart. According to Stanwick and Stanwick (2009, p. 409), the culture "has created a number of twenty-first-century problems for Wal-Mart."SummaryThe authors' viewpoint is that of the Wal-Mart employees are

Conservation in the Art Market

1630 words - 7 pages material (Ashley-Smith 2009:20). In the last twenty years, conservators have become more sensitive to the value of the sacred. Nowadays, the code of practice considers the spiritual and non-scientific aspects of the objects in terms of care and conservation treatment. The tendency of defining the profession in terms of ethical behavior has led to the belief that there is one set of ethics for all occasions (Ashley-Smith 2009: 21). When

Pragmatism Versus Idealism Book Review on Gone with the Wind

786 words - 3 pages till her death in 1949 in a car accident.2,Main PlotThe story begins in Georgia, just prior to the American Civil War. Spoiled southern belle Scarlett O'Hara concerns herself only with balls and flirtation and schemes to win the love of the refined Ashley Wilkes despite his engagement to his saintly cousin, Melanie.She confesses her love to Ashley in a barbecue and is rejected, but Ashley tells her he does love her, which leads to nearly all of

Gone With The Wind

1045 words - 4 pages Butler. Scarlett, Ashley, and Melanie were raised together, and Rhett Butler was an outsider who came from Charleston. Scarlett was the daughter of a wealthy Irish plantation owner. She was not beautiful but she was spoiled. She was selfish and scheming. She was also charming so men easily fell in love with her. Scarlett was obsessively in love with Ashley Wilkes and attempted several times to lure him away from his lovely wife Melanie. She was also

"Perfect" by Natasha Friend

538 words - 2 pages about her problems so they assumed. When Isabelle found out that Ashley not only made herself throw up, but also took ex-lax, she lost some respect for her and also gained some respect in an odd way because she thought it was a good thing that Ashley knew about that stuff.Isabelle had lost her father and that was why she was having emotional issues. Not only had she lost her Father but her mother didn't want to deal with the loss of her father so it

The Shadow

1916 words - 8 pages of the fall. Seconds later, she didn't feel the impact and took a little peek from the corner of her eye. She saw Vic trying not to laugh at her awkward position. They had stared at each other for the longest of times, both of them trying to contain their laughter- but failing. * * * * * * * * * * * * "Remind me to plant a soft bed of flowers under the tree," Ashley said with a hint of laughter in her voice

Child Psych Case Study

1234 words - 5 pages Verbal Score was in the Mild Disability Range raising possibility of global intellectual disability rather than language disorder (she was later diagnosed as autistic). However this score was inconsistent with previous Wechsler score. Expressive language has increased significantly since the beginning of the year but is observed to be non-reciprocal and incessant about her particular interests. Ashley was given a low priority for language Support

Shopping

1096 words - 5 pages wistfully, “ but they are almost eight hundred dollars! My parents would kill me if they knew I was in Barney right now looking at expensive shoes instead of meeting with my counselor!” “ Loosen up Kris! Who cares if you miss one meeting with your counselor, we are in New York right now!” Ashley said, continuing to look through the aisles. Two hours later, Ashley and Kristen walked out with many bags, Ashley strutting down the streets with her while

Report on "Gone With the Wind" by Margaret Mitchel

998 words - 4 pages with her. But the Tarleton twins, whom Scarlett enjoyed spending time with, were madly and deeply in love with her. The only problem though was that Scarlett didn't love them. Instead she was madly in love with Ashley Wilkes, her neighbor. She believed that Ashley Wilkes and her were meant to be together and neither the coming civil war nor the Tarleton twins were going to change that.But then, Scarlett learned from the twins that the love of her

Similar Essays

The Ashley Treatment Essay

1789 words - 7 pages individual is afforded? To take it to a more fundamental level, what ought we to do as humans to help people with disabilities, while at the same time making sure we are treating them as equal beings? Once questions like these can be addressed, the more pointed question can be reflected upon: is the Ashley Treatment ethical? When answering this, it is important to remember that all people deserve a voice in the goings on in the world

The Ethical Treatment Of Animals Essay

736 words - 3 pages , the same land would feed a family of four people every day for a year. My conclusion is that I do not see an obligation for killing animals but many consequences. The ideal in life is to treat others how we would like to be treated in return. Therefore, I support the ethical standards for animals and believe there should be laws protecting them and supporting there lives. References People for the Ethical Treatment of Animals (2003). . Retrieved 3/9/05, http://www.peta.org Trivedi, D. (2002, May 29). Ethics and Vegetarianism. Retrieved 3/9/05, http://www.vegdot.org/story/2002/5/29/75156/2496

The Ethical Treatment Of Prisoners Essay

2355 words - 9 pages crimes or they may have been convicted falsely, but if God has hope for humanity then the utilitarian relativism of treatment should conclude we treat fellow humans with the hope that they can change and not exploit their labor capabilities. Using their labor as means for profit is not ethically correct. I’m not saying there is an easy answer; it involves many facets of virtues well within the prison system and the individuals themselves. Yet the

People For The Ethical Treatment Of Animals

1043 words - 4 pages People for the Ethical Treatment of AnimalsBy: Jonas TrefzgerPeople for the Ethical Treatment of Animals (PETA), is an American organization focusing on animal rights. It is a non-profit corporation with 300 employees, and it claims to have three million members including supporters. It also claims to be the largest animal rights group in the world, with its slogan being "Animals are not ours to eat, wear, experiment on, use for entertainment or