This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Piracy Is A Problem, But The Stop Online Piracy Act Is Not An Answer

1411 words - 6 pages

The internet is one of the few things in the world that is truly all over the world. Millions use the internet every day for more reasons than one person can think of; to connect with family and friends, find information for a research paper, or to achieve the perfect chicken marsala recipe. The internet is made up of a mass expanse of web content and copyright, which is where online piracy comes in. Online piracy is the illegal use or distribution of copyrighted content, such as music, films, and can even include pharmaceuticals. Millions of dollars are ripped off every year from the illegal downloading of just music. Millions of dollars that are stolen from the industries that make most of their money from copyright. There are already laws in place to fight piracy, including the Digital Millenium Copyright Act (DMCA) that was enacted in 1998. Though it has made an impression on stopping online piracy there are a couple things that restrict the act; it only has jurisdiction on American websites and is outdated compared to our fast paced society.That is why in late 2011 the House of Representatives introduced the bill H.R.3261: Stop Online Piracy Act (SOPA).
The goal of this bill is innocent: to stop online piracy and protect property on the internet. SOPA was designed to give the Department of Justice “the ability to require US-based internet service providers (ISPs) to prevent users from accessing foreign piracy websites and force payment companies or advertising companies to stop providing their services to piracy websites” (“Stop Online Piracy Act (SOPA)” 2). Those websites that do infringe copyright illegally would find themselves in court with fines from $200 to $150,000 per infringement. What makes the bill controversial is that it has a clause that can makes third party websites accountable for copyright infringement themselves, regardless of who posted it. SOPA was created in mind of the copyright holders and the governance of the internet, but not of those who have to correspond to the bill if it is enacted. The terminology of the act is also too broad and general; it would give the government an unreasonable amount of power over the internet. The law could potentially be manipulated to censor the internet. Those prosecuted for copyright infringement would be given the bare minimum of their due process rights. Websites could potentially be shut down for just mentioning something copyrighted or having a link to the copyrighted content.
SOPA will put enormous pressure on third party websites to police their forums with an intensity that would eventually cause pandemonium. Sophie Stalla-Bourdillon, a lecturer at at the University of Southampton Law School stated in her article about internet intermediaries that “how can one promote freedom of expression while expecting Internet intermediaries to take the initiative to police their systems or networks and in particular to react upon infringements of Intellectual Property (IP) rights.”...

Find Another Essay On Piracy is A Problem, But the Stop Online Piracy Act is Not An Answer

Online Piracy Essay

926 words - 4 pages likelihood of individuals to purchase music instead of pirating. While there is no clear solution to the general music piracy problem, changing social acceptance of music piracy or ethical feelings are often mentioned to be the most useful ways to get consumers to not pirate. It would be best to fight piracy by offering a value-added content when music is being purchased and as well by creating online shopping for music to be at least easily

'The Physics of Stopping,' is an answer to whether or not the statement "safety is not related to how fast you travel, but how quickly you stop," is true

801 words - 3 pages example so to will the momentum and thus the change in momentum, P = m x v, and therefore the same rule still applies. However, with distance quadrupling and time to stop doubling in an increase of double your velocity, you can see that safety is related to how fast you travel and how quickly you stop, because, what if the safety was related to stopping in a certain distance, not related to the force that will act, imagine driving towards the edge of

Digital Piracy: A Problem Without an Effective Solution

1597 words - 6 pages legislation (ibid). To conclude, the piracy is a considerable problem and the society should deal with this problem, because piracy is not just copying, it is stealing. Causes: In every region of world, there are different causes of piracy. Nevertheless the most of them are common. Firstly, the main cause of piracy is human agency. In terms of one person, one pirated music file or one video game is not significant. However, in terms of whole

Online Music Piracy

948 words - 4 pages costs, in most part because they don’t receive much of the profit from album sales, but guess who does, the record label. This is a game of money and how much can be made. Now that online piracy threatens sales you find the record labels complaining because their system is being challenged. They can come to realize that a change is needed, or they can continue to dump millions into trying to stop individual by individual. Piracy is illegal, but so

Online Piracy: Blacklist Folly

1070 words - 5 pages Property Counsel for the U.S. Chamber of Commerce. The U.S. CoC was integral in pushing the now failed legislative actions known as the Stop Online Piracy Act (SOPA) and the PROTECT IP Act (PIPA). These bills would have enabled the government to block access to websites identified by businesses as illegally distributing their intellectual property. The tools needed to combat these issues are lacking, but Tepp’s proposed website blacklisting is not one

International Copyright vs. Online Piracy

2103 words - 9 pages multimedia that corporations have to offer. Online piracy is the largest form of copyright theft. In order to find a solution to modern piracy, all countries involved have to reach a solution where their corresponding companies as well as their citizens are content. It’s an issue that involves anyone with internet access. Illegal file sharing has been a major global issue for over a decade, and despite all attempts to stop it; it has only grown

File Sharing and Online Piracy: How Does it Effect Copyrights? Is it Ethical?

1914 words - 8 pages are doing, the lack of moral behind it, and the legal dangers behind but continue to do it anyway (File Sharing/ Torrenting). Theft is defined as the taking of someone else’s property without permission (Theft Overview). By not purchasing certain files or streaming them online through a legitimate means, a court could easily condemn a downloader for copyright infringement. However, there is one legitimate argument that defendants in copyright

Online Piracy: Threat to the Entertainment and Software Business

1597 words - 7 pages patented file format. Zimerman (2011). Challenges and Concerns Industries making digital products can that be pirated have attempted to fight piracy. The threat of lawsuits appeared to have a small effect on the amount of music piracy, but lawsuits are divestments that do not benefit the music industry. File-sharing has become part of the culture and is difficult to stop it. Some factors that cannot be controlled to avoid purchasing music online are

Violence Might Not Be the Answer, but It Is the Solution

2073 words - 9 pages killed by an oppressor then the individuals in slavery will be terrified of other violent acts the king might commit. Second, this proclamation also works as an illustration for how remarkable Moses’ survival was. Unlike the other newborn Israelite men, Moses is spared not only through the protection of his mother and sister (Exodus 2:1-4), but also by the benevolence of Pharaoh’s daughter. The bible states that: “The daughter of Pharaoh came

Online Piracy; the Economic Effects of the Music Industry

3423 words - 14 pages earned music. When sharing and downloading these files you might not care, but the recording industry does care because of the fact that they are losing thousands on each individual album because of piracy. The 24 and under crowd has been buying albums just not at a rate which they once were. This problem is due to online piracy and music files becoming more easily accessible.Even though all of the effort by the RIAA of trying to prosecute

Software licenseing and piracy act for a business lay class

3694 words - 15 pages be deposited with the Copyright Office in Washington, D.C. for the program to be protected as copyrighted. With that in mind then a copyright is a property right only. In order to prevent anyone from selling your software programs, you must ask a court (federal) to stop that person by an injunction and to give youdamages for the injury they have done to you by selling the program.The Software Rental Amendments Act Public Law 101-650) was

Similar Essays

Piracy Is A Problem, But The Stop Online Piracy Act Is Not An Answer

1862 words - 8 pages capitalists would find their business elsewhere while the government could potentially start censoring the internet through SOPA. Online piracy is a problem, but SOPA is not an answer. Before the government tries to pass a law that governs the internet, they need to find something that keeps in mind not just the copyright holder, but also the copyright user. Works Cited Bayrasli, Elmira. “SOPA Threatens American Innovation”. 2/13/2014.

The Stop Online Piracy Act Essay

2024 words - 9 pages back to square one. “Both sides agree that protecting content is a worthy goal. But opponents say that the way SOPA is written effectively promotes censorship and is rife with the potential for unintended consequences” (SOPA Explained: What it is and why it matters). Another method to stop online piracy that was brought up was to block the sites that host the online pirated files. The only problem with that method is the fact that anyone can make

Archival Is Not Piracy Essay

2456 words - 10 pages Archival Is Not PiracyToday, access to piracy is everywhere in computers. We can decrypta DVD to allow others to watch copies. We can rip music off a Music CD and sellcopies worth less than a penny each. We can let others intall our purchasedprograms on multiple computers. Piracy can happen as easy as Copy and Paste.Are these acts legal? No, but "fair use" laws say that as long as the copies arefor archival purposes only, it's legal. Now, if

Behind The Stop Online Piracy Act Bill (Sopa): Copyright, Censorhip, And Free Speech

1700 words - 7 pages Stop Online Piracy Act (SOPA) which “has the potential to significantly change the way that information can be shared through the Internet.”(Wikipedia, 1) SOPA is designed to tackle the problem of websites that provide illegal download of pirated movies, music and other products. For websites consist of user upload materials like Youtube and Facebook, they are responsible for all the materials on their websites in SOPA. SOPA requires them to