Plagiarism: Adjusting The Consequence Essay

1077 words - 4 pages

1 Most universities believe students should be expelled immediately due to the acts of plagiarism. But is it really safe to jump to such an extreme conclusion for an action that in most cases, require some sort of investigation or trial? For many years, universities have battled students on this particular subject. Plagiarism has levels that should be dealt with by first locating the cause, examining the evidence, and determining whether it was purposely planned or not. Students, just like their professors, sometimes make simple mistakes and no student should be immediately expelled for unobvious plagiarism. Immediate expulsion is unruly and unfair to students who actually work hard, but may lack the necessary knowledge to detect plagiarism.

2 The problem with an immediate expulsion and why it is unfair to students is because it can overlook the truth too soon and cause permanent damage to one’s future without an explanation. It would be unfair to penalize students in such a way who have no history in plagiarizing and may even have straight A’s in their current classes. Some universities do not focus on bringing awareness to students on preventing plagiarism, so why should innocent students be forced to fail the entire class? According to writer Zinie Chen Sampson at Pilot Online News, Allison Routman, an Ohio University senior who attended an off-grounds program for the University of Virginia said she was shocked when a professor accused her of plagiarizing from an online synopsis of a movie. The University of Virginia has a single-sanction honor code, meaning students face expulsion after one violation. The professor had suspected plagiarism in a number of students for the assignment given and allowed them to come forth with the truth so that they would not receive expulsion as a punishment. Allison never came forth; because she did not think she had done anything wrong (Sampson). She said "No one had ever defined paraphrasing for me," Because of an immediate expulsion a student who probably had no record of plagiarism now has a tainted permanent record. Routman clearly states “Had I thought I had done anything wrong, I, of course, would come forward.” Failing the assignment or points off would have been a much more acceptable punishment for her if she knew she was going to be expelled immediately. Her father, Brent Routman says, “If you're going to have a death-penalty sanction, then you've got to build in safeguards for kids that are lost in the shuffle.” Creating “safeguards” for students will probably build confidence in students to ask the necessary questions to prevent future plagiarism cases.

3 The immediate expulsion of an innocent student unknowledgeable about his or her actions may even cause emotional hardships which may lead to an unexpected case of violence among peers. In The Hartford Courant, Loretta Waldman shares reports on a case that could have caused unnecessary violence because of an immediate expulsion...

Find Another Essay On Plagiarism: Adjusting the Consequence

The Policy for Academic Integrity: Plagiarism

960 words - 4 pages The awareness in regards to academic integrity is growing across campuses worldwide. This is a very serious subject in which students and faculty should take additional steps to educate themselves. A great example of this exposure includes Mississippi State University hosts an annual Academic Integrity week during the last week of October. “This program has been put in place to educate students on plagiarism and academic honesty and prevent

Plagiarism: A Pestilence in Education Essay

1830 words - 7 pages view plagiarism in this manner. Within education I conceive that there are two kinds of plagiarism: copying a paper word-for-word and not providing the correct recognition to the original author when utilizing their composition. I believe that each situation of plagiarism should be considered serious enough to investigate in order to determine an appropriate consequence. If an individual is not clear on how to cite works properly within the context

Student and Teacher Plagiarism

676 words - 3 pages believe that the simple consequence of cheating and plagiarism should be redoing the paper until it is right. This not only takes valuable time away from the student, but it also teaches the student through repetition. Personally, I believe that the amount of plagiarism and at what level should dictate punishment. A simple administrative error while citing should only equate to points taken off, as long as the error was minor and not seemingly

Ethics at School

1652 words - 7 pages Does Distance Education Promote Plagiarism?As the demand for distance education becomes increasingly popular many students, teachers and institutions are concerned that academic dishonesty continues to rise. Students are expected to adhere to the code of conduct set forth by the university in which they are attending regardless if they are in a traditional classroom environment or an online forum. However, does the online forum make it easier

Plagiarism

2832 words - 11 pages PlagiarismThe consequence of plagiarizing material carries with it shame, exposes academic lethargy and may become costly. Most students take away with them the importance of academic integrity from professors, counselors, peers and even the media. With so much emphasis put on the subject one would think plagiarism would be unheard of amongst writers. However, data presented by Associate Dean of Student Discipline Steven J Tyrell (2004) studies

Plagiarism - A Severe Threat to the Society

1161 words - 5 pages Plagiarism - A Severe Threat to the Society Every day throughout the world, teachers strive to attain the most from their students in every aspect of life, from effective communication and language skills, to the development of individualism and the concept of being the best that you could be. With the use of exams, class discussions, and written assignments, educators subconsciously reinforce the idea that success can only be

Acts of Dishonesty

1166 words - 5 pages a lie from another. If every thought man could have has already been thought it seems as if plagiarism is inevitable. Through the quest of honor one is often subject to dishonesty. We are left with a motto veritas est prevalate, the truth will prevail. Whether he intended to or not the narrator was dishonest in his plagiarism of his story. Though there was a truth in the story, an honest portrayl of himself it was stolen. Through the act of his dishonesty he discovered himself, a prize worth more than a meeting with Hemmingway. “I didn’t have a lot of adjusting to do. These thoughts were my thoughts, this life my own.”

Using Technology to Cheat

1826 words - 7 pages Jefferson never wanted his "Declaration of Independence" to be on the side of women's rights. But this form of cheating is acceptable because it enhances the common good, rather than detract.Here's a quote from the writer Wilson Mizner. "When you steal from one author, it's plagiarism; if you steal from many, it's research." It's considered cheating when we use someone's quotes and don't credit them. Isn't it also cheating if we do credit them? The

Reflective Essay

788 words - 4 pages adjusting into the system, was very different for me, and a task on its own. Being an international student, there are pre-determined differences that are instilled into society. Most people from local areas assume that you speak ‘Indian’ because I’m from India, or use Fahrenheit to describe the temperature outside, instead of Celsius. Adjusting to the culture of the United States is a big adjustment, but as I saw this semester blow by, I

The Barriers Students Face in Adjusting From Normal Life to University Culture

1606 words - 6 pages This essay investigates the barriers that students may face in adjusting from normal life to university culture. The barriers are changing in attitudes and experiences of students, developing metacognitive skills, culture shocks and the university requirements such as IELTS exam and learning. The changing in attitudes and experiences of students can be A survey was made for the first year students and was conducted at five year intervals for

Collusion

751 words - 3 pages CONSEQUENCES OF CHEATINGAcademic Misconduct: Collusion, Plagiarism and Misrepresentation of FactsThe definition of collusion is: 1. a secret agreement, esp. for fraudulent or treacherous purposes; conspiracy; 2. a secret understanding between two or more persons to gain something illegally (Dictionary.com, Unabridged (V 1.1). On the website for Boston College (www.bc.edu/schools/cas/polisci/integrity/), collusion is defined “as assistance

Similar Essays

Obstacles In Higher Educational Institutions: Plagiarism

1190 words - 5 pages face is the need of obtaining high grades. As a consequence, grades became the main reason of plagiarism and it is the reason of 59% of plagiarism acts among students (Neville, 2010). During this present time higher grades are not just needed to pass a course or a subject, high grades are also necessary to acquire internships and job interviews in firms and business, due to this education is now viewed as a “commodity” by students and the

The Silent Harm Of Plagiarism Essay

1107 words - 4 pages academic integrity. In the discussion of plagiarism, a controversial issue is whether plagiarism is taken seriously enough and whether the consequences are severe enough. Many people assume the obvious — that the consequences of plagiarism result in a letter grade deduction on a paper or a complete zero on the assignment. The real consequence of plagiarism is the deterioration of academic integrity and degeneration of ethics. Unfortunately, students

What Is Plagiarism And Its Consequences

773 words - 4 pages source. Sometimes a writer will use his own words to acknowledge a concept or information that is not considered general or common knowledge. In this case the writer must acknowledge the original source of the idea. There are more stern ways of dealing with plagiarism. A tutor might invoke fear of consequence into his students by imposing punishments that come with plagiarism. This tactic has been found to work well with students. A more productive approach is rethinking the course assignments and giving assignments that bring out the creative rather than the generic side of tutors.

The Contextual Factors Behind Academic Dishonest Behavior Among Undergraduate Students Of The University Of Prishtina

629 words - 3 pages common. Students today are used to have the ability to search instead of researching and having their own thinking, they do the assignment by copying and pasting different words and ideas. Students should be good informed about what plagiarism is and its consequence in order to make it lower. Teachers should cooperate with students, for instance, students can chose what they want to write about, for assignment or any projects. If a teacher is concerned about students involved in learning process, students are less likely to plagiarize or do any dishonest behavior.