This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Pluto´S Ideals From The Republic Essay

1635 words - 7 pages

Plato’s ideals
Arguably, in the history of ideas, Plato has planted the strongest and deepest seeds to the mind of humans and we have been pondering and trying to exercise them ever since. His “theory of forms” will be discussed, and somewhat hesitantly dismissed, in the context as he writes in the works of “The Republic”, because his theory is sound the same way math equations are sound and lead to undisputable answers, but problematic in how it can be proved and to whom it actually benefits will always vary. The definition of knowledge is too undetermined for Plato’s ideas to be necessary. Lastly his notion that philosopher kings must rule the ideal city will be decisively dismissed because the word “ideal” leaves room for creation and I argue that permanent procedures can be placed in the “ideal” society, which leaves open the position or positions of power for anyone to operate and the philosopher king no longer is needed for the “ideal” city to it run.
The “Theory of forms” is taught in Plato’s “allegory of the cave”, a thought experiment which makes his point from a real world scenario. He wants us to imagine humans in the conditions of enslavement to the extent that we cannot move and what we can only see are images of everyday objects: pencils, books, tables, letters, etc. What the people, in this condition, are actually seeing are shadows, because behind them there are imperfect representations of the actual objects made out of wood which are moving across their vision as shadows because behind the objects there is a fire which is the only light in this dark cave. Once we at least have semi-clear vision of what this thought experiment entail then we can see what Plato is trying to say in his theory of forms. The shadows, which the slaves see and perceive as reality, are actually illusions just as human perceptions are illusions. The objects we see every day are shadows of the perfect objects, their forms. What is real is not what the slaves see in the cave rather what is outside which the world of forms, just as for humans what is true is not perceptions but what is behind them; the world of forms.
Forms, which can be thought of as ideas or concepts, are perfect everlasting and are the only things to which everything human beings have ever created are inspired or drawn from. For example someone’s table is only a thing which is close to being the form of a table which is the perfect table. The problem arises when Plato argues that the forms are perfect while everything in our world is only representations or copies of the forms. His assertion raises many questions. Where are these forms located? I could claim as Bertrand Russell, did that there is a tea cup on the moon. I could neither disprove nor prove that a tea cup is there but I believe there is an everlasting tea cup on the moon. It’s this lack of certainty which makes it hard for Plato’s theory of forms to be accepted; there are too many problems with his theory even if...

Find Another Essay On Pluto´s Ideals from the Republic

Ayn Rand´s Anthem: Failure in the Implementation of Marxist Ideals

787 words - 3 pages structures. Socialism’s attempt to remove class structure fails miserably. The most prominent demonstration of rebellion rises from Equality 7-2521 and his emotions and desire for knowledge. After being denied by the Council of Scholars, Equality 7-2521 rashly breaks a window and flees “in a ringing rain of glass” (Rand 75). Equality 7-2521’s actions illustrate the ‘working class’ rebelling against the ‘elitists’ though this society attempted to

Beowulf's Display of the Anglo-Saxon Ideals from the Era He Represents

1448 words - 6 pages submerges him underwater, he does not panic and after drawing his blade, with a steady hand "Fate let[s] [him] / Find its heart" and permanently eliminate that threat from others (289-290). After King Hrothgar approves of Beowulf engaging Grendel, without hesitation he quickly detains the beast and imprisons "Hell's captive ... in [his] arms" (470). A final example of this bravery idealized by the Anglo-Saxons remains in the fact that Beowulf

What were the problems in Weimar Republic from 1919-1923?

1066 words - 4 pages -based republic like Russia was crushed mercilessly by the regular troops and Freikorps. A suppression over the Bavarian Soviet Republic was carried out and it held a bitter grudge against the new SPD government. On the other hand, the Right also started a coupdetat, best shown in 1920's Dr. Wolfgang's Putsch. The attempts to overthrow the government from both sides undoubtedly weakened the government. In addition, the Treaty of Versailles also

The Czech Republic. Transitional Success: from USSR to EU

6740 words - 27 pages IntroductionIn 1989, after nearly 40 years of Soviet control, Czechoslovakia once again became an independent nation, the Czech and Slovak Federalist Republic. This transition from Soviet socialism to democracy culminated throughout Central and Eastern Europe with the literal collapse of the Berlin Wall in East Germany, the heroic Gdansk Shipyard Strikes in Poland. The student and worker protests in Prague and Budapest were no less important.The

Book Review of Edmund S. Morgan's The Birth of the Republic, 1763-89

736 words - 3 pages father was a revolutionary soldier and an author, which may have made his work biased toward the Patriots rather than the loyalists. Works Cited 1.Yale University. "Department of History." Accessed January 28, 2014. 2.Morgan, Edmund S. The Birth of the Republic, 1763-89. Chicago: University of Chicago Press, 1992.

Discuss the successes and failures of the Weimar republic from 1919 to 1929

2051 words - 8 pages The Weimar republic from 1919 to 1929 had many successes and failures, starting in chaos and ending in relative stability. However, due to individual perspective these successes and failures were often viewed as both successes and failures- not either. Class, political leanings and other moralistic beliefs, primarily influenced the individual's perspectives. Overall, due to the relative stability, (the aim of any government) primarily achieved

The Allegory of the Cave, from Book VII of Plato's Republic

958 words - 4 pages The cave, symbolic of the mother's womb, is the source of life and death. In “The Allegory of the Cave”, from Book VII of Plato’s Republic, the theme of the cycle of life and the transition from the unborn to the deceased is representative of the cycle of entry and exit from the cave. If based upon this idea, one can conclude that the chains are symbolic of the umbilical cord. This concept reflects the Greek values of reproduction, humanism

A concise analysis of 3 main problems facing the Weimar Republic from 1919-1923

547 words - 2 pages The Weimar Republic began in 1919 with Ebert as their first president. The republic faced many problems from the very beginning because of the stage Germany was in. Germany had lost a large proportion of their troops in World War I, some still believed that they had not lost, and the economy in Germany was in the most disastrous condition. Many problems cause the Weimar Republic to be unstable, such as their president and the constitution, the

"How far is it true to say that the Weimar Republic was doomed from it's foundation?"

2034 words - 8 pages responsible for the collapse of the Weimar Republic, but the combination of factors and circumstances that lead to it's downfall." .The ideas coming from Bolshevik Russia were quite influential within the KPD (Kommunistische Partei Deutchlands or German Communist Party) and this party continually opposed the new democracy, but never became a serious threat to her survival because of the general German attitude towards communism . "The extreme left

Output and Gender Discrimination in Pay: Evidence from Manufacturing Industry of the Kyrgyz Republic

4372 words - 17 pages statistical significance and anticipated outcome. As stated in economic theory and proved in the majority of the literature discussed, evidence from manufacturing industry of the Kyrgyz Republic (years 1999-2007) demonstrated a negative relationship between gender pay gap and output, when control for gender gap in employment. With existing data and econometric knowledge, results of the regression indicate that a 1% decrease in gender wage gap leads

How far is it true to say that the Weimar Republic was doomed from its foundation?

1361 words - 5 pages How far is it true to say that the Weimar Republic was doomed from its foundation ?In November 1918, the first republic is declared in Germany. It is however unable to survive, and only 25 years later replaced by the dictatorship of Hitler. Indeed, the democrats lacked legitimacy right from the start. Directly after the war, army generals blamed the SPD as "November Criminals", accusing them of having betrayed the German people by signing the

Similar Essays

The Demotion Of Pluto From Planetary Status

1607 words - 7 pages Elyse Aucoin Professor David Smillie HIST 1250 21 March 2014 The Demotion of Pluto from Planetary Status “Pluto has been voted off the island” (Inman). In August of 2006 the celestial body was officially retitled a dwarf planet. The media’s portrayal of the demotion of Pluto began in 2006 and covered a broad variety of topics including the official ruling in Prague, the public’s reception of the decision, a book written by a scientist

The Republic In Shakespeare´S Julius Caesar

1467 words - 6 pages the people. He has complete support from the Romans on account of his victories for their homeland and for having thrice refused the crown, showing the highest regards for civic equality, a concept central to the idea of classical republicanism. However, the play shows a conspiracy by a group of Senators, most notably Caius Cassius who suspect that Caesar intends to overthrow the republic and establish a monarchy. Clearly, their suspicions are a

Analysis Of Socrate´S The Republic

1073 words - 5 pages Mary Vient Professor Julius Jackson Philosophy 105 17 February 2014 The Republic Analysis In The Republic, Glaucon is very keen on finding the true importance of what justice truly is. To do this he chooses to commend inequality in the virtuous way so that Socrates will disprove it and give him the true meaning of justice in its most sheer form. Glaucon addresses the situation by talking about the following three points: what people consider

Plato's Thoughts On Poetry From The Republic

1580 words - 6 pages Sonia AlexanderTexts & Ideas: This World and the NextEssay Prompt #69/18/2014Plato's Condemnation of The Wolf of Wall StreetIn the Republic, Plato outlines and justifies his reasons for banishing poetry in his envisioned just city. Plato fears that the desires and hankerings of society are easily manipulated and influenced by poetry, and this fear is validated by the recent Hollywood blockbuster The Wolf of Wall Street. This film appeals to