Plato And Aristotle Essay

1272 words - 5 pages

Plato and Aristotle

Plato and Aristotle have two distinct views on wellness. However, each man’s opinion on wellness is directly tied in to his respective opinions on the idea of imitation as a form of knowledge. Their appreciation or lack thereof for tragedy is in fact directly correlated to their own perspective on wellness and emotion. Firstly, it is important to consider each man’s view of wellness—that is how does each man go about addressing emotional stability. One important consideration is the approach Plato takes in relation to Aristotle. It is this approach that we will see actually mirroring between how they treat emotional well-being and their tolerance for imitation.

In order to understand this hypothesis that each thinker’s handling of wellness is representative of how they handle imitation (and thus, representation), we need to step back and examine how in fact each gentleman approaches the question of emotional stability and happiness. For Plato, as defined in the “Republic”, emotion is to be suppressed. Speaking of poetry, he says: “We’d be right, then to delete the lamentations of famous men” (63). The idea of deletion is exactly what he is after. Taking something quite real, very much a part of the present moment, and with the swipe of an eraser, dimissing it as gone. In poetry, it is called deletion, and the words are no longer on the page. In psychology, it is called repression, and the concepts suggested for deletion are instead relegated to swell in the caverns of one’s mind. Plato speaks of emotion in poetry at other times as something we should “expunge” (61). Again, entrenched in his linguistics is a conscious hat tip to repression, to keeping emotion—be that joy, sadness, despair—out of higher thinking. But to suggest that emotion is editable, that it can be purged is to debase emotion entirely. What becomes clear is not only his opinion that emotion need be repressed in the mind and suppressed from the page, but that this is because emotion gets in the way of true understanding. After all, to ask someone to “expunge” their emotions is to desire a way of thought that is pretty callous, if not simply heartless. The choice of words by Plato is reflective of his view—only he contends that emotions may be expunged or deleted out of situations, like words erased off a page. To ask for a deletion or an expungement—these are not words we think of when someone asks us to discuss our emotional state. People do not often ‘delete’ characteristics of their personality, and when talk about them doing so, we see someone who believes strongly in the idea of repression. Plato’s handling of wellness isn’t very well at all, but it isolates any semblance of emotion and ensures it is not to be found within scholarly work.

Aristotle, on the other hand, believes in a bit more emotional truth—being honest about how one feels and not repressing it. For Aristotle, emotions were to color life, and so too forms of expression, but...

Find Another Essay On Plato and Aristotle

Political Justice: Plato and Aristotle Essay

2208 words - 9 pages Plato and Aristotle had different ideas of politics and political justice. In The Republic, Plato creates the ideal city, which is needed to guarantee justice. He aims to create a peaceful united city that will lead to the greater good of the community and individuals. Unlike Plato who imagines the ideal city, Aristotle looks at actual cities in The Politics. He doesn't want to create the ideal city; he aims to improve the existing city. While

Aristotle and Plato "Ideal Government" Essay

1618 words - 7 pages Aristotle and Plato had this idea in their minds that there was an Ideal Government. Meaning that there was a way for someone or a group of people to perfectly control a community where everybody would have equal rights, there would be no fights and everything was perfectly under control. As of right now we believe that there is no possible way for somebody to do that, but back then Aristotle and Plato believed that they were perfectly right

Classical Theories - Aristotle and Plato

1909 words - 8 pages Plato and Aristotle have both documented strong opinions about the influence and social purpose of poetry. Plato, in The Republic, outlines reasons for his `refusal to admit the imitative kind of poetry'(Plato cited in ed. Adams 1992, p. 31). Plato's reference to `poetry' does not apply to the poetry of contemporary society, as it was a performance art and not meant for silent reading and reflection. Julia Annas (1981, p. 94) believes that

Distinctions and Comparisons between Aristotle and Plato

1638 words - 7 pages The ideas introduced by Plato on the theory of forms, where deducted and critiqued by Aristotle. Both philosophers can be viewed as having opposing ideologies. Nonetheless, Plato and Aristotle are in agreement on certain factors of their philosophy. Many have scrutinized and compared the dissimilarities and similarities of Aristotle's doctrine of categories and Plato's theory of forms. The observations found are of an interesting nature

Historical Views of Leadership: Plato and Aristotle

1780 words - 7 pages through the eyes of two titans of Greek thought: Plato and Aristotle. Both men lived in 4th century BCE Athens, so much of their background and experience was shared. Aristotle was the younger of the two, and he was Plato’s student. Where leadership is concerned, both philosophers agreed that the “best men” should rule, and that the purpose of leadership was the betterment of the State. They also agreed that education was paramount to forming

Democracy Outlined by Plato and Aristotle

1114 words - 4 pages for the basis of modern political thinking, although many in modern society UK would be sceptical to call it a democracy. Plato and Aristotle in The Republic and The Politics respectively were critical of the Athenian democracy, by examining the culture and ideology present the limitations and possible downfalls of a democratic way of life. Within this essay I will outline these limitations and evaluate their validity. Plato defines Athens as a

Examining the Ethics of Plato and Aristotle

1051 words - 4 pages This essay will be examining the ethics of Plato (428-347 BCE) and Aristotle (384-322 B.C). I will firstly attempt to summarise the five fundamental concepts of Plato and Aristotle before providing my own opinion and view on their ethics. I will concentrate on their theories on the good life as a life of justice, censorship, knowledge and the good life. I will first examine Plato’s ethics. Plato was a philosopher who was both a rationalist

A Comparison of Plato and Aristotle

1892 words - 8 pages Plato and Aristotle, two philosophers in the 4th century, hold polar views on politics and philosophy in general. This fact is very cleverly illustrated by Raphael's 'School of Athens' (1510-11; Stanza della Segnatura, Vatican), where Plato is portrayed looking up to the higher forms; and Aristotle is pointing down because he supports the natural sciences. In a discussion of politics, the stand point of each philosopher becomes an essential

Arroyo Administration: The Plato and Aristotle Views

2842 words - 11 pages enough to support their basic needs and some minute luxuries. At the bottom are the poor. These are those that could not even support their necessities. And this class actually constitutes a large proportion of our population. That is why Philippines can still be considered a poor country, belonging to the third world. The classification of the people today is somewhat the same with what Plato and Aristotle had described. However, there are

Normality and Coercion: Plato, Aristotle, Locke, Rousseau, Kant, and Rawls

2603 words - 11 pages the political writings of Plato, Aristotle, Locke, Rousseau, Kant, and Rawls. Hobbes is famous for his early and elaborate development of what has come to be known as “social contract theory”, the method of justifying political principles or arrangements by appeal to the agreement that would be made among suitably situated rational, free, and equal persons. He is infamous for having used the social contract method to arrive at the astonishing

A COMPARATIVE STUDY ON THE PHILOSOPHIES OF PLATO AND ARISTOTLE

1803 words - 7 pages Plato and Aristotle are undoubtedly the greatest of philosophers that the world has seen. Both Plato and Aristotle formed unique and distinct theories about the Greek city states. While most people believe that Plato and Aristotle are complete opposites of one another, it is not completely true. For those who have studied the works of both the philosophers, the theory proposed by Aristotle is just a development of the Platonic system because

Similar Essays

Socrates, Plato, And Aristotle Essay

856 words - 3 pages Socrates, Plato, and Aristotle, three men considered to be the quintessential basis of ancient Greek philosophy. Not only were they responsible for Greek enlightenment, but also foreshadowed the coming of Christ in there speculations. Plato, the protégé of Socrates, became the first to document the philosophy of his teacher, which in turn is passed down to Aristotle. This process of mentoring aided ancient man in the intellectual evolution

Comparing Plato And Aristotle Essay

2127 words - 9 pages sophrosyne, virtue of spirit is Courage, and the virtue of Reason is wisdom. Plato has now defined the just city and the just person. Aristotle was born in 384 BC, in ancient Stagira in Greek Macedonian. Macedonian is located in northern part of Greece and was not considered to be a true part of Greece by the southern Greeks of Athens, Sparta, and Thebes. Aristotle's father was a physician to the royal court, which allowed him to go up in the upper

Comparison Between Aristotle And Plato Essay

1380 words - 6 pages ). Aristotle believes that Plato is underestimating the qualitative change in human character and personality that would have to take place in order to achieve hisutopia (Hacker 81). Plato chose to tell the reader of his Republic how men would act and what their attitudes would be in a perfect society (Hacker 81). Aristotle tries to use real men in the real world in an experimental fashion to foresee how and in which ways they can beimproved

Conversation Between Plato And Aristotle Essay

969 words - 4 pages Dialogue Between Plato and Aristotle 2 As students file into the auditorium of the Academy the first thing that we all notice is the two professors that were standing at the front of the room. After all the students were seated that is when the first professor stepped forward to address the class. Plato: Good Morning Students! Students: Good Morning Professor! Plato: Many of you may know who I am and then there are those of you that do not