Plato's Account Of Socrates Apology Essay

2091 words - 9 pages

Plato's account of Socrates' Apology

In Plato's account of Socrates' apology, Socrates is brought to trial on the charges that he corrupted the youth of Athens through his teachings, and that he did not believe in the gods that the state believed in. Throughout the account, the argument against him comes across as unreliable and biased. Therefore, Socrates is innocent of the charges laid against him by Meletus, Anytus, and Lycon due to the facts that the jury consisted of men that already held a biased opinion of him, he does not make a living by corrupting the youth, and the accusation that he created his own deities was never validated.
Socrates enters into his trial acknowledging the fact that he is going up against a jury of men, many of whom already have a biased, negative view towards him. He explains that many of them, though not knowing him personally, feel as though they do based solely on word of mouth, weakening the validity of the trial against him. As Socrates states in the account of his defence;
these accusers are numerous, and have been at it a long time, also
they spoke to you at an age when you would readily believe them,
some of you children and adolescents, and they won their
case by default, as there was no defence (Plato qtd. in Melchert 18c).

He accepts the fact that he must defend himself and as he states “attempt to uproot from your minds in so short a time the slander that has resided there so long” (Plato qtd. in Melchert 19a). These are not people who can actually act as witnesses to his wrongdoings, yet they (the audience) have born witness to him not committing the alleged crimes of “walking on air and talking a lot of other nonsense” (Plato
qtd. in Melchert 19c). He then addresses first the accusation that he studies the things that are
Smith 2
considered to be the workings of the gods that the state believes in. Socrates contemplates how the accusation would transpire if his prosecutors were before him:
What did they say when they slandard me? I must, as if they
were my actual prosecutors, read the affidavit they would have
sworn. It goes something like this: Socrates is guilty of wrongdoing
in that he busies himself studying things in the sky and below the
earth, he makes the worse into the stronger argument, and
he teaches these same things to others (Plato qtd. in Melchert 19b).

Socrates brings up these charges by saying that these are the types of accusations that are typically used against all philosophers, and were brought before him simply because those that spoke against him, when asked, were “silent, as they do not know, but so as not to appear at a loss, they mention those accusations that are available against all philosophers” (Plato qtd. in Melchert 23d). He then explains how these were older charges brought against him before, and that Meletus, Anytus, and Lycon have just restated these typical charges to strengthen their case against him, also that these...

Find Another Essay On Plato's account of Socrates Apology

The Readings of The Apology of Socrates and Crito

1527 words - 6 pages The Readings of The Apology of Socrates and Crito Throughout the readings of The Apology of Socrates and Crito I have found that Socrates was not a normal philosopher. It is the philosopher's intention to question everything, but Socrates' approach was different then most other philosophers. From one side of the road, Socrates can be seen as an insensitive, arrogant man. He did indeed undermine the laws so they fit his ideals, leave

A Critique of Socrates' Guilt in the Apology

1133 words - 5 pages that needed to be disposed of for the elites to remain the power-holders in society.List of Works CitedPlato. 'The Apology of Socrates.' West, Thomas G. and West, Grace Starry, eds. Plato and Aristophanes: Four Texts on Socrates. Itacha, NY: Cornell University Press, 1984.1Plato, 'The Apology of Socrates,' Thomas G. West and Grace Starry West, eds., Plato and Aristophanes: Four Texts on Socrates. (Ithaca, NY: Cornell University Press, 1984), s.19c, p.66.2Ibid, s.29a/32d, p.80/p.85.3Ibid, s.28b, p.79.4Ibid, s.25e, p.75.5Ibid, s.26a, p.75.

Plato's "trial and death of socrates", Explains socrates view of self-examination (meditation) as the path to knowledge

897 words - 4 pages Knowledge as Self-ExaminationSocrates had an important point to make when he said," I do not think I know what I do not know." This was the reason why Socrates believed himself wiser than the wise men of Athens. This was the only reason Socrates was wiser than the other men considered wise in Athens. Socrates knew he didn't know something if he had no knowledge of it; where as, the men considered wise thought that they knew something when in

Plato and Socrates

518 words - 2 pages ;s valuable. Socrates declаres thаt hе has led а good lіfe, а lіfe of moralіty аnd virtue. Thе contradictory views Socrates holds about humаn virtue аnd wіsdom makes Plato's dialogs, thе Apology less pеrsuasive. Thе largest contradiction іs thаt thе laws аre right аnd should be obeyed but thе people аre not

A brief overview of Greek Philosophy: Socrates

754 words - 3 pages of our knowledge of him comes from the works of Plato (427-347), and since Plato had other concerns in mind than simple historical accuracy it is usually impossible to determine how much of his thinking actually derives from Socrates.Ancient Greece Reader--------------------------------------------------------------------------------The Apology of SocratesThe most accurate of Plato's writings on Socrates is probably the The Apology. It is Plato's

Plato

1284 words - 5 pages ] connection ... Plato's dialogues are not only a memorial to Socrates, but also the happier days of his own family".[17] Name According to Diogenes Laertius, the philosopher was named Aristocles after his grandfather, but his wrestling coach, Ariston of Argos, dubbed him "Platon", meaning "broad" on account of his robust figure.[18] According to the sources mentioned by Diogenes (all dating from the Alexandrian period), Plato derived his name

Socrates as Philosopher King

1720 words - 7 pages substance.  It was something that a person could possess.  But Socrates, in the Apology (and all of Plato's other works, especially Philo and Meno) shows that virtue is fluid, not rigid.  His famous belief is that "virtue is knowledge"7 and that knowledge is a kind of art.  Rather than focusing on particular virtues (justice, honesty, obedience, etc.), Socrates approaches virtue as a normative value.  He argues that specific virtues (justice, honesty

The Trial Of Socrates

1918 words - 8 pages revealed to many of my friends the counsels which the god has given me, and in no instance has the event shown that I was mistaken." The indictment charged that Socrates did not conform to the nomos of his city by "disbelief in the gods of the city." In essence this was another political charge, in the Greek city- states, not to recognize the city's gods was to be disloyal to the city.The indictment as stated in Plato's Apology says, " It is about as

No Harm Can Come to a Good Man

1184 words - 5 pages is expected to arise at the death of Socrates, the panache with which he departs is captured excellently in Plato's “Apology.” Specifically, at the end of the "Apology," Socrates makes a very important statement that has had great impact on philosophy ever since its original proclamation. The Stoics in particular have taken this to be the cornerstone of their ideology. The statement made is that "you must regard one thing at least as certain

Socrates' Fight for Justice

1233 words - 5 pages . Goldman, Harvey S. "Reexamining the “Examined Life” in Plato’s Apology of Socrates." EBSCO Publishing Service Selection Page. 2004. Web. 11 Feb. 2011. Blyth, Dougal. "Socrates' Trial and Conviction of the Jurors in Plato's Apology." Project Muse. Penn State University Press, 1 Nov. 2000. Web. 11 Feb. 2011.

Is Socrates Innocent or Guilty?

1942 words - 8 pages and knowledgeable people for sport. Perhaps this overshadowed aspect of the charges is true after all. Bibliography: Works Cited Brickhouse, Thomas C. Socrates On Trial. Princeton University Press, Princeton: 1989. Plato. Five Dialogues. Hackett, Indianapolis: 1981. Reeve, C. D. C. Socrates in the Apology: An Essay on Plato's Apology of Socrates. Hackett, Indianapolis: 1989. Stone, Isidor. F. The Trial of Socrates. Little Brown, Boston: 1988. Xenophon. Recollections of Socrates, and: Socrates' Defense Before the Jury. Collier Macmillan, New York: 1965.

Similar Essays

The Apology Of Socrates Essay

1093 words - 5 pages my account they try to imitate what I say, which causes their fathers to be angry with me. Socrates says I have been accused of corrupting the youth, but I say Meletus is guilty of such things. For it is Meletus who does not believe in the gods of the city and corrupting the youth, Socrates and Meletus start to argue about the rights and wrongs of the law. Socrates proves his point by saying that Meletus contradicts himself, for he say that

The Apology Of Socrates: Guilty Or Innocent?

954 words - 4 pages The Apology of Socrates: Guilty or Innocent?    In any case of law, when considering truth and justice, one must first look at the validity of the court and the system itself.  In Socrates' case, the situation is no different.  One may be said to be guilty or innocent of any crime, but guilt or innocence is only as valid as the court it is subjected to.  Therefore, in considering whether Socrates is guilty or not, it must be kept in mind

Women In The Apology Of Socrates

1404 words - 6 pages Women in the Apology of Socrates The most striking thing about women in the Apology of Socrates is their absence from where we might expect them. Only two specific women are mentioned: 1) the Pythia, the priestess of Apollo, who answers Chaerephon's question that no one is wiser than Socrates (21a); and 2) Thetis, the mother of Achilles (who himself is not mentioned by name but only referred to as the "son of Thetis"), who warns him

The Presentation Of Socrates' Arguements In Plato’s Apology And Crito

967 words - 4 pages philosophers, who is dedicated to his state. Exploring this contradiction between Socrates the loyal citizen and Socrates the philosophical man will help position Plato's arguments. Although, Socrates approach to his defense in my opinion is not the best, and is certainly not an apology. The argument in Plato’s Apology is that one should never betray one’s values for any reason, even if the reason is death. This statement is the basis of everything