This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Plato's Criticism Of Democracy Essay

1695 words - 7 pages

Plato's Criticism of Democracy

Do not be angry with me for speaking the truth; no man will survive who genuinely opposes you or any other crowd and prevents the occurrence of many unjust and illegal happenings in the city. A man who really fights for justice must lead a private, not a public, life if he is to survive for even a short time. (Apology 31e-32a)

These are the words of Socrates, who spoke before the Athenian jury in the trial that would, ultimately, condemn him to his death. Through works such as the Apology and The Republic, we can see Plato’s distaste of the concept of democracy. Why does he consider democracy to be so flawed? Let us look through his own eyes and see what his individual criticisms are, and determine if the very concept of democracy is as flawed as he believes it to be.

One of the contemporary definitions of democracy today is as follows: “Government by the people, exercised either directly or through elected representatives; Rule by the majority” (“Democracy” Def.1,4). Democracy, as a form of government, was a radical idea when it manifested; many governments in the early history of the world were totalitarian or tyrannical in nature, due to overarching beliefs that the strong ruled over the weak.

Although the Greeks coined the word “democracy” – the words demos “people” and kratos “rule” conjoined together to mean, literally, “rule by the people” – there is speculation about weather or not certain other peoples, such as the Sumerians and the Indians, managed to engage in democratic methods of governance first. However, the history of democracy is not what is being discussed here; we are focusing on Plato’s criticism of democracy, particularly with regards to the Athenian model and his writings in the Socratic dialogues. Let us continue on, before we veer off and lose sight of the argument.

So democracy is a system of government wherein the people elect their rulers; in the case of Athens, it was, more or less, a direct democracy, where all male citizens voted in an assembly and decided by majority rule (elected officials were chosen by allotment). Why would this be a bad thing? Is it not better than dictatorships or oligarchies, where anywhere from one man to a small group of elites have power over all? Why exactly would a government that has its decisions made by the very people it represents be considered something worthy of criticism?

This is where we get into the meat of the argument. Take note that there might be some consideration as to whether or not, particularly with regard to the Socratic dialogues, the criticism of democracy’s properties originated from Socrates or Plato. But with regards to this essay, such a consideration is irrelevant, as it is not incorrect to say that Plato did indeed have some problems with democracy, especially with regard to the Athenian model.

The crux of this argument will focus on three of Plato’s works: Gorgias, Apology, and The Republic.

In...

Find Another Essay On Plato's Criticism of Democracy

To what extent,how and why Plato's and Aristotle's democracy differ from the modern conception of the democracy

1703 words - 7 pages Reflection PaperManjieva EditaTo what extent, how and why, Plato and Aristotle's conception of democracy differ from the modern conception of democracy.Many of our ideas about democracy originated with the ancient Greeks. The Greeks roots of the world democracy are demos, meaning the "people" or, to put it in Aristotle's way, self-government by the many, as opposed to the few or the one. This is similar to Lincoln's definition: "government of

The Genius of Plato Essay

2131 words - 9 pages writings from him. (Internet) PLATO'S ACHIEVEMENTS Plato's actual achievements in his field was great. He had a greater claim than anyone else to be called the founder of philosophy. What is unique about Plato is the progress towards a much tougher, more precise logical and metaphysical theory, a moral philosophy and a philosophy of language. Through discussion and criticism, they shaped the entire future of philosophy

Plato Essay

649 words - 3 pages This essay attempts to disprove platos conclusion that democracy is a bad form of government. This is based on his premis that democracy is a form of government in which citizens make fundamental societal decisions.World renowned philosopher, Plato, concludes that Democracy is a bad form of government, however, I will attempt to disprove this based on the first premiss of his argument. Premiss 1 of Plato's argument, supporting his conclusion

PLATO: His Biography and Works

2417 words - 10 pages the universal form of a beautiful flower, meaning that it is very far away from the ideal Form. Plato's frequent criticism of the artists is that they lack genuine knowledge of what they are doing. Plato's opinion of artistic creation is that it is rooted from a kind of inspired madness. He feels this way because he believes that the artist who paints the picture is just as inaccurate as the picture itself.(HC)Plato is a vital piece to the

Plato and The Renaissance

1843 words - 7 pages , translators and commentators during Renaissance times often understood them in a very different way than intended. Plato's ideas were ahead of their time, but he was nevertheless clearly a product of Classical Greek culture. Many of his dialogues question beliefs of and praise the Greek gods. Political concerns revolved around political systems common in his day, and the distaste for democracy present in his Republic focuses specifically on

Plato's Republic

1289 words - 5 pages the downfall of Democracy; the unending thirst for more liberty. The people demand more and more freedom, eventually spiraling down into anarchy; which is the extreme form of liberty. Out of this anarchy arises a tyrant, and Plato's cycle continues on. In conclusion, Plato, a political philosopher, was in the pursuit of philosophical truth and improving existing society. Plato sees the justice and law as what sets the guidelines for societal

answers

1867 words - 7 pages Platonic thought. Rebuttals follow these critical sections in order to uphold Plato's ideas. The impracticability of Plato's ideals is one such objection which receives a refutation. One quote in reference to Plato highlights the argument particularly well: "He is knowingly sketching the ideal, because only when the ideal has been comprehended can any approximation to it ever be achieved."Bluck's refutation of the impracticability criticism proves

Are you convinced by Plato's claim that philosophers should rule

1626 words - 7 pages interest of the State and confuses them with transient political pressures is understandable and certainly favours the State that is developed along Plato's model. It is true that making accommodations with political opponents can dilute the effectiveness of previously well conceived policies and that electorates may unwisely vote for people who both lack the necessary tenche to rule and are dishonest. Democracy, Plato seems to argue is a luxury

Plato's Involvment and Legacies within the Western World. This is a 6-7 page double spaced paper with a biography which recieved an A+ in my Western Civ Honors class

1940 words - 8 pages in the opinion of Socrates. Plato's friend and mentor Socrates was sentenced to death by a general prejudice and was charged for corrupting youth, introducing new gods into the city, atheism and engaging in unusual religious practices. Strongly affected by the decision of the Athenian democracy, in 399 B.C.E. Plato fled to other countries and areas. Probably in fear for his own safety, he left Athens and traveled to Italy, Sicily, and Egypt

Platos Forms

1975 words - 8 pages I. Introduction Purpose      I intend to show the validity of Plato's arguments about his theory of Forms. Aristotle, along with others, cross-examines Plato's proposals. Yet, I happen to see the potential of his point of view and would like to take a deeper look into his theory. The purpose of this paper is to critically analyze the theory of Plato's Forms from his perspective and that of several others, including

Explain the Criticisms of Plato's Theory of the Forms

1605 words - 6 pages doesn't mean that it exists separate from our bodies. Plato does not prove, or even try and prove that these perfect forms are self-evident. It is Plato's disability to prove this that causes people to criticise his theory. As Aristotle was one of his pupils, he does not totally reject Plato's theory but argues that it may not be the only logical reason towards how something is classified.Another criticism made by Aristotle. Linked to the previous

Similar Essays

Plato's Criticism Of Democracy Essay

1159 words - 5 pages Plato's Criticism of Democracy Plato, having defined his perfect society, now seeks to compare contemporary 'imperfect' societies with his ideal standard. He initially criticises the imperfect society as a whole, before leading onto a criticism of any given individual within that society; the imperfect character. He has already dealt with the Oligarchic society and character and now moves onto Democracy and the democratic character

Plato's Philosophy Of Democracy Essay

2066 words - 8 pages . “The Modern Democratic Revolution.” York University, Toronto. 31 October 2011. Lecture 6. Doody, Rodney. "Democracy Ancient and Modern: The Polis as a Way of Life." York University, Toronto. 26 September 2011. Lecture 2. Manin, Bernard. The Principles of Representative Government. Cambridge, Cambridge University Press, 1997. Print. Saxonhouse, Arlene W. “Democracy, Equality, and Eidê: A Radical View from Book 8 of Plato's Republic

Plato's Concept Of Democracy And Justice

835 words - 3 pages Book one of Plato's Republic examines the concept of democracy and justice. Thrasymachus, the Sophist declares that justice is the advantage of the stronger, whereas Socrates argues that justice is wisdom, something good and desirable. According to this in Athenian times, a democracy could not survive with out a system of justice in place. This still holds true in the contemporary Western world. Throughout the dialogue of book one, Socrates

Criticism Of Democracy As A Criticism On How To Live One’s Life

1090 words - 4 pages The majority of Socrates’ criticism of democracy in the Republic deals with how he ideally thinks a society should be structured. However, if individuals witnessing this dialogue in fifth century Athens were considering this argument simply in terms of how a government should run, they would be missing Socrates’ main point. For Socrates is actually discussing something much more personal to his audience through means of the republic, their