This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Plato's Philosophy Of Democracy Essay

2066 words - 8 pages

Democracy is a topic extensively studied by political philosophers all around the world. Plato was one of these philosophers. Plato believed that “democracy […] is a charming form of government, full of verity and disorder; and dispensing a sort of equality to equals and unequals alike”. An analysis of ancient Athenian democracy and the Republic provides great understanding of the statement within its context. The statement itself is valid, but Plato does not appear to mean what he said.
The statement itself has two main parts that one must understand in order to fully understand the statement. Plato wrote the Republic in 380 BCE, in Athens (Spark Notes Editors). The first part of the statement discusses the variety and disorder found in the Athenian democracy. This section is discussing the issue of the use of the ‘lot’ system, and the freedom of opinion and speech. The ‘lot’ system, and the freedom of opinion and speech causes a lot of variety in the polis (Breaugh, Lecture 3). When Plato is referring to disorder, he is referring to the civil unrest involved in the transition to democracy (Breaugh, Lecture 3). Plato might also be referring to the lack of harmony due to the level of freedom that is offered in Athenian democracy (Saxonhouse, 279). The freedom can cause civil unrest due to the differences of opinion presented by a variety of people. The second part of the statement discusses equality within democratic Athens. This section basically discusses the principle of isonomy, which was the core principle of Athenian democracy (Breaugh, Lecture 3). Democracy provides a sort of equality because, in Plato’s view, the different classes of citizens are equal, but only politically, not socially. This also did not apply to non-citizens, including metics and women (Breaugh, Lecture 4). The only form of equality that non-citizens got was equality before the law, which is really good for the time. However, non-citizens had no say in the laws that were being created, and could have no impact on political life in the polis.
In further analysis of Plato’s beliefs and the Republic, one will realize that Plato did not really mean what he said. It is evident from reading analyses of the Republic that Plato advocated an aristocratic form of government. In the Republic, Plato defines justice as having a structure, where each citizen does the job that they are specialized in (Spark Notes Editors). Plato implies that philosophers are the most suitable people for ruling (Spark Notes Editors). Plato believes that philosophers are the most ‘just’ and rational men, and are therefore the best people to rule (Santas, 73; Spark Notes Editors). This is implying that these rulers must be aristocrats (rule of the best).
Plato believed that Athenian democracy was unjust, since citizens could run for ruler, without being specialized; and citizens in other professions could get involved with the business of ruling, which Plato also considers unjust. Plato...

Find Another Essay On Plato's Philosophy of Democracy

PLATO: Greatest Contributor to Philosophy A report about Plato's contributions to the development of philosophy. It covers his Academy, Dialogues, and his student Aristotle

740 words - 3 pages , student of Socrates, was one of the greatest contributors of philosophy. Proof of Plato's prominence in the world of philosophy can be clearly seen with his Academy, his renowned scholar Aristotle, and his Dialogues.Plato made a huge contribution to philosophy when he founded the Academy. The philosopher loved science although he was never especially accurate. Given that many of his theories about science have been proven extraordinarily wrong

Plato and The Renaissance Essay

1843 words - 7 pages , translators and commentators during Renaissance times often understood them in a very different way than intended. Plato's ideas were ahead of their time, but he was nevertheless clearly a product of Classical Greek culture. Many of his dialogues question beliefs of and praise the Greek gods. Political concerns revolved around political systems common in his day, and the distaste for democracy present in his Republic focuses specifically on

Plato's Rule by Philosopher Kings

1519 words - 6 pages democracy is key in understanding Plato's argument for rule by philosophers. Nowadays, most modern states are democratic, in the sense that people have a say in the running of the state. Since Plato's time there has been a debate regarding what democracy is: whether it is the idea of majority rule, or what has come to be known as the 'Madisonian view' that democracy involves the protection of minorities. To Plato, it all boils down to what democracy

Democracy

1559 words - 6 pages . One day his pleasure may be flute playing; the next, studying philosophy. Unlike the other constitutions, the democratic state and man are not hostile to philosophy, they are simply indifferent. Plato's democracy is a "do your own thing" society. If your thing is to read philosophy, fine; if not, that's okay, too. Is Plato suggesting that philosophy is among the

The Most Influential Philosopher in History, Plato

1003 words - 4 pages Philosopher Aristotles. Plato primarily stayed at the Academy until his death at about 347 B.C.Plato is considered the best known Greek Philosopher. Plato's areas of concentration in philosophy are the metaphysics, epistemology. You could also add ethics to one of his areas of concentration but since ethics concerns how one ought to live and focuses on pleasure, virtue, and happiness. So according to Plato, virtue and happiness require knowledge

Plato's life and contributions to society.. What is known about his past, and how he enhanced the world around him

1629 words - 7 pages Plato's specific surroundings and environment. However, most of the specific biographical information about Plato is based upon assumptions and educated guesses, none of which can be proven. Third, one should examine one of the most significant people in Plato's life, his teacher Socrates. There is much information to begotten from Socrates, though most of it is found indirectly in Plato's writings, being that Socrates never wrote anything. Fourth

The Genius of Plato

2131 words - 9 pages , answers, and additional questions. After witnessing the death of Socrates at the hands of the Athenian democracy in 399 B.C., Plato left Athens and continued to travel to Italy, Sicily, and Egypt. (Internet) In 387 B.C. Plato founded the Academy in Athens otherwise known as the first European university. The Academy provided a wide range of curriculum including subjects such as astronomy, biology, philosophy, political theory, and

PLATO: His Biography and Works

2417 words - 10 pages Ages and the Renaissance, and continues to be crucial to an understanding of philosophical issues. Although the correctness of his doctrines has always been the subject of vigorous debate, no one can deny the pervasive influence of Plato's thought on the history of Western philosophy. Plato's thrilling life-story and his multiple theories will influence mankind for all eternity.(Kenny 22)From Plato's birth to his death, he experienced the life

The Philosophy of the Matrix

1125 words - 5 pages duty is to share one's education with the general man because "[philosophers] have [been] educated far better and more perfectly than [the general man]" and thus, know more. However, in Plato's time of democracy, philosophers were required to return into the cave in order to "bind up the State". Ergo, the enlightened prisoner can attempt to share his acquired knowledge with his fellow-prisoner but has to return to the cave regardless. Neo though

Traditional versus Modern Ethics

552 words - 2 pages , 2005, p. 274-275). Kant followed both Plato and Aristotle that reason played an integral role in philosophy (Moore & Bruder, 2005, p. 278). Nietzsche, and the other existentialist philosophers, rejected the previous metrics for moral philosophy and redefined things on an individualistic level (Moore & Bruder, 2005, p. 285-286).Much like moral philosophy, political philosophy has at its root Plato and Aristotle. Plato's contribution was of

Plato Essay

649 words - 3 pages This essay attempts to disprove platos conclusion that democracy is a bad form of government. This is based on his premis that democracy is a form of government in which citizens make fundamental societal decisions.World renowned philosopher, Plato, concludes that Democracy is a bad form of government, however, I will attempt to disprove this based on the first premiss of his argument. Premiss 1 of Plato's argument, supporting his conclusion

Similar Essays

Plato's Criticism Of Democracy Essay

1159 words - 5 pages Plato's Criticism of Democracy Plato, having defined his perfect society, now seeks to compare contemporary 'imperfect' societies with his ideal standard. He initially criticises the imperfect society as a whole, before leading onto a criticism of any given individual within that society; the imperfect character. He has already dealt with the Oligarchic society and character and now moves onto Democracy and the democratic character

Plato's Criticism Of Democracy Essay

1695 words - 7 pages Plato's Criticism of Democracy Do not be angry with me for speaking the truth; no man will survive who genuinely opposes you or any other crowd and prevents the occurrence of many unjust and illegal happenings in the city. A man who really fights for justice must lead a private, not a public, life if he is to survive for even a short time. (Apology 31e-32a) These are the words of Socrates, who spoke before the Athenian jury in the trial

Plato's Concept Of Democracy And Justice

835 words - 3 pages Book one of Plato's Republic examines the concept of democracy and justice. Thrasymachus, the Sophist declares that justice is the advantage of the stronger, whereas Socrates argues that justice is wisdom, something good and desirable. According to this in Athenian times, a democracy could not survive with out a system of justice in place. This still holds true in the contemporary Western world. Throughout the dialogue of book one, Socrates

To What Extent,How And Why Plato's And Aristotle's Democracy Differ From The Modern Conception Of The Democracy

1703 words - 7 pages Reflection PaperManjieva EditaTo what extent, how and why, Plato and Aristotle's conception of democracy differ from the modern conception of democracy.Many of our ideas about democracy originated with the ancient Greeks. The Greeks roots of the world democracy are demos, meaning the "people" or, to put it in Aristotle's way, self-government by the many, as opposed to the few or the one. This is similar to Lincoln's definition: "government of