Plato's Republic Justified Essay

1423 words - 6 pages

Plato's Republic Justified

In Plato's Republic, Socrates leads a discussion with his fellow philosophers attempting to isolate the concept of justice in the soul. In order to accomplish this task,
they hypothesize that justice can occur both in the city as well as and the soul. Because the philosophers are more familiar with the workings of a city than the soul,
they try to find justice by creating the ideal city, or Kallipolis. When they find justice in the ideal city, they are able to apply as well as justify the use of that same
concept in the soul. From their discussion, they conclude that the components of the soul and the components of the city are related, and that the concept of justice
occurs in both.

Empirical observation shows that a city is created because no single person is self-sufficient. All the needs of the citizens determine the components of their city, from
the basic needs such as food, clothing, and shelter, to the more elaborate needs such as swords, plumbing, and books. In an ideal city, the philosophers believe each
citizen will do the task that is best suited to him or her. Such a division of labor makes the city the most efficient, or ideal.

Socrates then examines these various tasks and is able to separate them into three distinct groups: those which produce something for the city, those which protect
the city from both internal and external subversion, and those which provide control and direct the other two groups. The people who carry out these tasks are called
producers, guardians, and rulers, respectively.

Socrates then deals heavily with education. He decrees that the citizens, specifically the guardians, are to have both physical and mental training, for "those who
devote themselves exclusively to physical training turn out to be more savage than they should, while those who devote themselves to music and poetry turn out
softer than is good for them" (410c). Here, starting to lay the groundwork for relating the city to the soul, Socrates likens the savageness to a person's spirited
characteristics and the softness to his or her philosophic characteristics. The two are in harmony to make the guardian both moderate and courageous.

Turning to the rulers, Socrates hypothesizes that they "must be the best of the guardians" (412c) and hence "the ones who are best at guarding the city" (412c). The
rulers need to be knowledgeable, not easily deceived, care for the city greatly, and pursue what is most advantageous to the city.

The producers of the city are not discussed as in depth as the other two classes. Socrates wants to wait until justice has been isolated before delving into the topic of
the producers' manner of education.

With their Kallipolis formed, they are now able to make certain assumptions that are needed in order to support the concept of justice in the soul. Foremost, they
can assume that the city is completely good, solely from the fact that it is an ideal city....

Find Another Essay On Plato's Republic Justified

The Noble Lie: Plato's Republic Essay

1718 words - 7 pages more stable and socially just society. In Plato's time each member of the ideal city would be inculcated even indoctrinated with this story from birth. So that the citizens of the republic learn to internalize its message, and thus are less likely to question their duty to the city. Henceforth I plan to show how Plato unwittingly created a separate class for himself, and how overly optimistic his benignant intentions where, they have since grown

Sport, Education, and the Meaning of Victory

3385 words - 14 pages setback; athlete pledges his allegiance to the goal of victory nonetheless, athlete trains tirelessly in pursuit of that goal; athlete achieves victory. The athlete's victory is a reward for and a sign of not simply toughness and endurance but the intelligent pursuit of excellence Plato described as courage. Plato's most famous work, the Republic explores the virtue of dikaiosune, often translated justice. Sports in general and victory in

about ethics

8550 words - 34 pages Plato's Republic who concluded that while justice is for the simpleton, injustice is for the wise: [Socrates:] Well, then, Thrasymachus... suppose you begin at the beginning and answer me. You say that being perfectly unjust is more profitable than being perfectly just? [Thrasymachus:]Yes, that is what I say, and I have given you my reasons... I affirm injustice to be profitable and justice not... [Socrates:] And would you call justice a vice

Oedipus rex by Sophocles.

3002 words - 12 pages Lombardo and Karen Bell. Indianapolis: Hackett Publishing Company, 1992. 194-223.Plato. "Protagoras". Plato's Famous Works. Trans. Stanley Lombardo and Karen Bell. Indianapolis: Hackett Publishing Company, 1992. 121-183.Plato. "Republic". Plato's Famous Works. Trans. Stanley Lombardo and Karen Bell. Indianapolis: Hackett Publishing Company, 1992. 30-110.

Justice vs Revenge

1444 words - 6 pages closure, while as revenge focuses more on a personal vendetta, enforced’ by an individual seeking retribution for a wrongdoing. Works Cited 12 Angry Men. Director, Sidney Lumet. 1957. DVD. To Kill a Mockingbird. Director, Robert Mulligan.1962. DVD. Hourani, George. Thrasymachus' Definition of Justice in Plato's Republic. 2. 7. Focus Publishing, 1962. eBook. . Rosenbaum, Thane. "Justice? Vengeance? You Need

Plato’s Republic: Justice and Injustice in Thrasymachus' Account

6506 words - 26 pages Justice: A Reply," p. 14; An Introduction to Plato's Republic, p. 42. In their commentary Cross and Woozley maintain that Thrasymachus’ position would have remained consistent had he accepted Cleitophon’s suggestion. As they see it, there would then be "no conflict between its being just to serve what the stronger (ruler) believes to be his interest and its being just to obey the ruler, for while a ruler may make a mistake as to what actually is his

Can Skepticism Be Defended, Perhaps In A Limited Form?

1983 words - 8 pages may see a perfect rectangle the other a perfect square. (Cornman, Lehrer, Pappas, 1992, pp. 46-47) The point I am making here is that sensual perceptions are all relevant to the position of the observer. This is not a good situation for something that we contrive to get justification for our knowledge from. 5. The Brain in the Vat Argument This argument is similar to the one in Plato's republic in that it involves an imaginary situation where

The Sceptical Argument. Can it be defended, perhaps in a limited form?

2114 words - 8 pages , pp. 46-47)The point I am making here is that sensual perceptions are all relevant to the position of the observer. This is not a good situation for something that we contrive to get justification for our knowledge from.5. The Brain in the Vat ArgumentThis argument is similar to the one in Plato's republic in that it involves an imaginary situation where the people or person involved believes that they have knowledge (Plato, Cave Analogy, Book VII

It is 300BC, you are a Platonist. Your friend, also a student, has been condemned to death by the Athenian court. Write him a letter preparing him for his last hours.

2890 words - 12 pages orator; Demosthenes, and to both Socrates' and Plato's own opinions on the nature of the soul.Do you remember that I recounted the story passed down to me by Cebes and Simmias about Socrates' last dialogue before his death? Do you remember I said that the same reasons could be used to show that Demosthenes' death should not be mourned? For he too spent his life in pursuit of truth and wisdom, from whence true happiness is derived.No matter whether

Virtue Theory

2522 words - 10 pages good for two reasons1.It would get you whatever you want more effectively than a soul dominated by animal desires.2.It is harmonious and beautiful and can be called 'right'.In Plato's view therefore, goodness has both prudential and intrinsic value because it is useful as well as beautiful.In his Republic, Plato emphasized four virtues which were later called Cardinal Virtues. These are wisdom, courage, temperance and justice. The other virtues

Philosophy Overview

10212 words - 41 pages t/2 to traverse the distance 1.4.Knowledge as a justified true belief vs. opinion (epistēmē and doxa): Parmenides (aletheia (truth) and doxa), Plato (the Allegory (or Metaphor) of the Cave, and of the Line: eikasia, pistis, dianoia, noesis).Knowledge (Episteme)-a justified true belief, Plato stated it 's a true belief with a logos (reason)'.Knowledge vs. opinion in ancient Greek philosophy epistēmē vs. doxa (belief), the

Similar Essays

The Ethical Egoist In Plato's Republic

1140 words - 5 pages The ethical egoist is one who believes that it is morally right to act strictly in one's own self-interest. Understandably, this belief poses a threat to social cooperation and, therefore, clearly introduces a significant political problem. I believe that the best example of ethical egoism is displayed in Book I of Plato's The Republic. In this Book, Plato introduces the idea of ethical egoism, explains the political problem posed by it, and

Platonic Communism In The Republic Essay

2866 words - 11 pages settled. Each of the proposals can be supported independently, and their dovetailing effects can be claimed as a happy convergence.But the grounds for these proposals will matter significantly to a further question. Many readers have seen in Plato's Republic a rare exception in western philosophy's long history of sexist denigration of women, and some have even decided that Plato's willingness to open up the best education and the highest jobs

Well Governed Societies Of Plato And St. Thomas Aquinas

1563 words - 6 pages right way to govern a society."Injustice causes civil war, hatred, and fighting, while justice brings friendship and a sense of common purpose." (Plato, 351d) Evident by Plato's "Republic," justice plays a significant role in his well-governed society. Throughout this work, an ideal state ruled by philosophers is presented and described, however it is obvious that this society is not necessarily made to be put into practice, but rather to show

Knowledge Of Good In Plato's The Republic

970 words - 4 pages knowledge of goodness is a sufficient condition for being good. A person who has seen what goodness is will henceforth act in a way that is good. Is this belief justified? For instance, we sometimes do things that we know are not good but we do them nonetheless and feel guilty after that. If, as such cases imply, knowledge of goodness is not a sufficient condition for being good, then Plato's dream of a utopia ruled by philosopher-kings could well be a