Plato Shows That Belief In The Soul Can Be Justified.’ Discuss

1586 words - 6 pages

Charlie Gilhooley'Plato shows that belief in the soul can be justified.' Discuss.During this essay I am going to outline Plato's arguments for his belief in the soul, then put forward a number of criticisms against these arguments. Finally, I will conclude with why I believe Plato doesn't provide sufficient evidence for belief in the soul and how the materialistic view, as held by Richard Dawkins, and supported by the development of neuroscience (the study of the nervous system) provides evidence as to why Plato fails to justify belief in the soul.The 'spiritual or immaterial part of a man, held to survive death' is the official definition of 'soul,' as found in the dictionary.Plato believed that each person has a soul, which lives on after the body dies and wanted to demonstrate that this belief is reasonable and can be justified through logical argument. His dialogue Phaedo is mainly concerned with these arguments; Cebes, the person who is in dialogue with Socrates, suggests that perhaps the soul just disappears, like smoke, into nothingness when the body dies, and he asks for some kind of persuasive argument to justify Socrates' belief in the immortality of the soul: 'The soul of man is immortal and imperishable.'Plato's first argument depends on the idea that every quality comes into existence from its own opposite. It relies on the existence of its opposite, or it would not exist at all. Plato argued that it followed that death must come from life, and life from death: people who are dead are just people who were in the past alive but then experience the change we call dying, and people who are alive are just people who were among the dead but then experienced the change we call being born. Plato's argument supports the idea of reincarnation, since if something is dead its opposite is being alive and vice versa. Plato strongly believed that there were two separate realms that we have access to, the physical world and the world of Forms. He came to the same conclusion when debating the topic of the soul, taking the view that the soul is distinct form the body. Here Plato takes the dualist approach, the view that human person consists of two distinct elements: the mind/soul and the body. The mind/soul is immaterial whereas the body is physical. Thus the soul has the ability to know the truth and understand Forms, through reason. On the other hand, the body is physical and can only obtain knowledge through the physical experience. Plato stated that 'knowledge is the food of the soul' and believed that knowledge was gained through sense experience is inferior to the knowledge that can be gained through reason, due to the fact that our senses can be mistaken. As the body is clearer a physical matter, it is in constant change and thus cannot truly be the object of true knowledge and cannot be the source of such knowledge.However, for Plato, the soul is capable of certain knowledge. Therefore Plato concluded that this must mean that the soul is...

Find Another Essay On Plato shows that belief in the soul can be justified.’ Discuss

Discuss some of the differences and inequalities that can be seen on the street in the UK

800 words - 3 pages Social Science looks at the world by asking questions such as why are things the way they are and how did they come to be as they are? By looking at the patterns as well as the meaning and connections in our lives we can answer those questions. The DVD Making Social Lives shows a street, City Road in Cardiff as a way of introducing the social sciences. The street is a place in which people, objects and ways of living interact and make up

Discuss some of the differences and inequalities that can be seen on the street in the UK.

820 words - 3 pages Untitled Social Science looks at the world by asking questions such as why are things the way they are and how did they come to be as they are? By looking at the patterns as well as the meaning and connections in our lives we can answer those questions. The DVD Making Social Lives shows a street, City Road in Cardiff as a way of introducing the social sciences. The street is a place in which people, objects and ways of living

Can the notion of Human Rights be justified and in what are such rights grounded?

2709 words - 11 pages Can the notion of Human Rights be justified and in what are such rights grounded?"Human rights are a set of universal claims to safeguard human dignity from illegitimate coercion, typically enacted by state agents" (Brysk, 2002 p. 3). The notion of human rights is an important ideal in society and a cause of great debate these days. Rights limit the extent to which other humans can intrude on other individuals and groups and are a necessary

Can Crime Control be Justified?

1341 words - 5 pages out of every eight people are minorities.Overall, in my opinion, the emphasis on street level crime can be justified. Everything relates to something else. This world goes in giant cycles. Overtime, we have seen that minorities, the poor, and those with a lower socioeconomic status commit more crime. They have a need to succeed. There is also a problem with police presence proportionality. Police patrol poorer areas, because it is said that poorer

Can capital punishment be justified?

773 words - 3 pages Can Capital Punishment be justified?In this day and age it is quite common for young men to carry knives and other weapons. In spite of police campaigns to educate people against carrying weapons there has been a significant increase in the deaths of young British males. Often an argument may become heated, weapons are pulled put with tragic consequences.As well as carrying knives it has become increasingly common, particularly in the English

Can Euthanasia Be Justified Morally?

1152 words - 5 pages – therefore one will follow the truth in one's mind (categorical imperative) (Macintyre 1996: 193). Is there such a universal order to justify the actions of both doctors? The doctors will argue that their actions were morally right insofar as a universal law can be applicable. Their rationale is to treat others just as others will treat them; hence their actions are justified because they will expect similar treatment if the roles of the patients and

The Death Penalty: Can It Ever Be Justified?

1500 words - 6 pages “The Death Penalty: Can It Ever Be Justified?” Edward I. Koch uses his essay “The Death Penalty: Can It Ever Be Justified?” to defend capital punishment. He believes that justice for murderous crimes is essential for the success of the nation. The possibility of error is of no concern to Koch and if would-be murderers can be deterred from committing these heinous crimes, he feels the value of human life will be boosted and murder rates

Hamlet's ability to sense the hidden corruption in Denmark shows that he is not mad but perceptive. Discuss.

1259 words - 5 pages of locating he epicentre of the corruption, although it is made fairly clear from the ghost. Many believe that because only Hamlet heard the ghost speak that it could be a fabrication of his imagination or self-invention, but as mentioned earlier it is an age-old belief that ghosts only appear to warn the living. Horatio is the first to mention this, so regardless of whether Hamlet heard the ghost or not, it still indicates corruption in Denmark

Why does Plato argue that divine commands can never be genuinely moral commands? Do you agree?

823 words - 3 pages . For example, God condemns murder because it is immoral which shows that murder as an immoral action already existed before God. This shows that God is placed under the restrictions of morality yet if there is a belief in God, a grand creator, is it not God who has created all things? So how can be subjected to something in which he has created? If holiness is an intrinsic part of God's nature, he is separated from all that is imperfect and he is

Research Essay: Can Terrorism Ever Be Justified?

1588 words - 6 pages Research Essay: Can Terrorism Ever Be Justified? “One man’s terrorist is another man’s freedom fighter.“ This is a popular quote regarding the state of terrorism, and how certain people may consider terrorism justifiable. Justifying terrorism is, however, not different from justifying innocent slaughter. Justifying innocent slaughter suggests that terrorists believe that political or religious conflicts are more prominent than a segment of

When can war be justified or wronged?

627 words - 3 pages War Can Be Justified“Life, Liberty, and the Pursuit of Happiness” are few of the rights the constitution guarantees everyone as an American citizen. How can that be obtained if America is being attacked by foreign countries that won’t stop? Our nation will not go to war, because we have decided that war is not worth the bloodshed. Until war is upon the attackers, what makes them afraid so that they will stop the attacks? Nothing

Similar Essays

‘Plato Shows That Belief In The Soul Can Be Justified.’ Discuss.

1586 words - 6 pages Charlie Gilhooley'Plato shows that belief in the soul can be justified.' Discuss.During this essay I am going to outline Plato's arguments for his belief in the soul, then put forward a number of criticisms against these arguments. Finally, I will conclude with why I believe Plato doesn't provide sufficient evidence for belief in the soul and how the materialistic view, as held by Richard Dawkins, and supported by the development of neuroscience

Can Terrorism Be Justified? Essay

685 words - 3 pages Lebanon.Terrorism cannot be justified; going back to the Beirut barracks bombings in 1983 clearly proves this. The killing of men, who were in Beirut for the reason of peace and stability, is tragic. The attack was unsupported, and the group have not announced or shown significant reasons to back up the bloodshed they have caused. The attack is not recognizably accounted for, and with the aforementioned points it shows that Terrorism cannot be justified.

Can Abortion Be Justified Essay

823 words - 3 pages this ground, would be like legalizing drugs trafficking, war or nuclear weapons throughout the world!Many sociologists claim that abortion can be justified to some extent in many under-developed countries such as Madagascar where poverty and overpopulation are perennial problems. Abortion helps prevent bringing children into a cruel world where they will suffer and face deprivation in all spheres of their life. However, it makes no more sense to

Miracles Identify A Philosopher And Examine Their Understanding Of The Term Miracle. Examine Arguments That Can Be Used To Discredit Belief In Miracles. How Is Belief In Miracles Still Strong?

2604 words - 10 pages MiraclesIdentify one philosopher and examine his/her understanding of the term miracle (6 marks)Examine the arguments, which can be used to discredit belief in miracles. In what respect do you consider belief in miracles to be strong in spite of these criticisms (14 marks)The topic of miracles and their existence is a controversial one due to the lack of proof of their existence and a recognised definition. Philosophers have long debated