This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Playing God Essay

886 words - 4 pages

In The Case Against Perfection, Sandel warns us of the dangers that genetic engineering, steroids, and hormones poses to society and the natural order. According to Sandel, this type of control, especially in non-medical settings, violates a respect for life that should be ingrained in all of us. Life is something difficult to predict, something that shouldn’t bend to our every single will and desire. Genetic engineering, and the like, presents an egregious violation of this respect. According to Sandel, this violation serves only to reverse the human march of progress. Sandel weaves a well-balanced argument in his book. The issue of eugenic technology is most definitely not black or white. According to him, the aspects of modification can be applied selectively, so long as it doesn’t violate the respect for life society should hold closely.
Is it wrong to make a child deaf by design? How much leeway should parents have in selecting the characteristics of their child (when it comes to aspects of identity)? Should they have any? These are just a couple of difficult questions posed by Sandel. Presenting a similar case, Sandel discusses the case of an infertile couple seeking an egg donor. They sought a very specific type of donor, going as far as requesting an achieved SAT score. In both of these cases, the outcomes are still susceptible to a certain degree natural variation and uncertainty. Does this element of unpredictability add to the moral correctness of these cases?
When it comes to athletes and their sport, drugs and genetic fixes diminish achievement. The more an athlete relies on drugs and genetic engineering, the more difficult it is to respect his/her achievements. Sandel presents a scenario. Imagine a robotic baseball batter, whose every sing, controlled by a computer chip, generated the perfect amount of angle. Does this present a problem to human responsibility? Sandel, quite convincingly, argues that this is less achievement on the part of the athlete, and more of the inventor’s. Ultimately, there is a fundamental danger in mankind’s pursuit to coerce nature to serve our purposes. What this does is destroy the deep appreciation we should have for the gifted nature of every human life.
This appreciation for the giftedness of life provides us with a powerful thought. Perhaps our talents and abilities are not totally “ours” despite our effort to cultivate and perfect them. Our gifts are very much a result of the genetic lottery we all have no say in participating in. Recognizing and accepting this fact might be called a “religious sensibility.” But the ramifications of such thought extend far beyond the...

Find Another Essay On Playing God

Dangers of Playing God: Judging Others

1341 words - 5 pages messy. The opportunity to write this research paper on whatever went well. This topic really helped me open up to different types of writing, and it helped me express myself. Works Cited "Judging Others." CINERGY Coaching. N.p., n.d. Web. 22 May 2014. . "Judging Others: The Danger of Playing God (Part 1) | CCEF." Judging Others: The Danger of Playing God (Part 1) | CCEF. N.p., n.d. Web

Playing God in Mary Shelley's Frankenstein

1257 words - 5 pages Over two centuries ago, Mary Shelley created a gruesome tale of the horrific ramifications that result when man over steps his bounds and manipulates nature. In her classic tale, Frankenstein, Shelley weaves together the terrifying implications of a young scientist playing God and creating life, only to be haunted for the duration of his life by the monster of his own sordid creation. Reading Shelley in the context of present technologically

Playing God

1611 words - 7 pages As a species we’ve always looked for ways to be faster, stronger, smarter, and live longer. Many enhancements we take for granted today; blood transfusions, vaccinations, and birth control, seemed unnatural or immoral when first introduced. Yet over time we’ve become accustomed to these controls over our minds and bodies, and have used them to better ourselves and our world. Imagine a society without disease, cancers, or heredity disorders. Life

Playing God

1034 words - 5 pages Ships at a distance have every man’s wish on board. For some they come in with the tide. For others they sail forever on the horizon, never out of sight, never landing until the Watcher turns his eyes away in resignation, his dreams mocked to death by Time. That is the life of men.” Some men never find their ships. The works Their Eyes Were Watching God and Les Miserables can be compared due to the many similarities they share. It can be

Playing God?

948 words - 4 pages . God made them that way for a reason. Secondly we shouldn’t even try to play god and change how our future generation is like. Maybe they didn’t even want to be like that but because you changed them as a baby they are like that for the rest of their lives. It is morally wrong and just because the person wanted a specific baby doesn’t meant they should go to extreme measures and change the baby’s genes to get what YOU want. The babies that you are

Is Victor Frankenstein Possibly Playing the Role of God?

829 words - 4 pages Victor Frankenstein: Possibly playing the role of God? In the book of Frankenstein, Victor is known for playing the role of God. Some people strongly disagree with the position of anyone playing God. I strongly agree with the idea that Victor is playing God because he creates life, he isn’t religious, and he serves the purpose he was given. It is believed that human life is impossible to create unless you are God. Does Victor take life into one

Frankenstein: The Danger in Knowledge, Science and Playing God

2160 words - 9 pages What is Frankenstein’s monster? Is the Monster a man? Is he a living, breathing demon? What does he represent? Is the Monster a representation of the dangers of playing with science? Is he representative of the dangers of pursuing knowledge? Alternatively, does he reveal to us the dangers of playing God? Mary Shelley’s Frankenstein uses Victor Frankenstein’s creation to expose the dangers of knowledge and playing God. Shelley exposes the

Prenatal Screening and Genetic Manipulation: Are We "Playing God"?

1655 words - 7 pages that we are "playing God" (Hinman). Is a strong and healthy person necessarily better than a small and weak one? Does not everyone have their strengths and weaknesses? (Weiss) Consider President Roosevelt, who had polio, or Beethoven, who was deaf. These procedures could very easily be abused if technologies were advanced enough to offer possibilities never before thought of.Questions of what "should" and "should not" be done are yet to be

Dangers Of Playing God

1071 words - 5 pages up. People will talk, people will whisper, but in reality, most of it is probably in your head. When you start to care less, the happier you will be. In all honesty, we were not put on this earth to determine what people are, and how they should live. Consequences are a key factor in the way you portray yourself though, think wisely before you act on something. There isn't a law that says you may not judge, but it will not even matter if you do judge people, cause the only person who counts is God. So as I found out, there is a difference between making good judgment calls, and just judging someone out of spike.

Playing God in Shelley's Frankenstein

1644 words - 7 pages For as long as science has existed to satisfy man's appetite for knowledge and exploration, there have been people with the belief that science is none other than man's attempt to play God. The 19th century was a time of enlightenment where philosophical thought began and man's concern to better himself in a psychological form developed. During this time of enlightenment and exploration however, the standards of Christianity and ethical

Genetic Engineering: Consequences of Playing God

730 words - 3 pages ). "The bark of a tree may take the bite out of cancer".Heaf, David. (2001, April). List of pros and cons of genetic engineering. Retrieved May 6th, 2007, from Russo, Michael T; Sunal, Cynthia Szymanski; Sunal, Dennis W. (2004). "Teaching Bioethics".Lisa Turner. (2007, April). "Playing with our food: get the latest on genetically modified organisms and learn how they may harm the body, not to mention the eart

Similar Essays

The Golem: Playing God Essay

2124 words - 8 pages “Every act of creation is first of all an act of destruction.” These famous words by the painter Pablo Picasso prove true in the infamous Jewish myth, The Golem: How He Came into the World (The Golem), and Karl Capek’s play, Rossum’s Universal Robots (R.U.R.). Throughout history, many persons have tried to play God, through acts like cloning in the 1990’s or simply calling themselves God, as was practice in ancient Egyptian societies. Rarely in

Egg Donation Playing With God Essay

820 words - 3 pages need of money and couples that have been trying to start a family for years. I figured that eggs were donated by an anonymous woman and then stored in a freezer or tank until used by a woman in need. I assumed name, address, and personal traits were keep concealed from the woman receiving the eggs, but as I began to research my thoughts began to change. I wondered if egg donation was playing with God and if the processes used are effective.There are

Euthanasia Are We Playing God?

1960 words - 8 pages EUTHANASIA - Are We Playing God? Dr. Kevorkian a doctor whom most of us know, has performed hundred's of assisted suicides. He has been convicted of murdering human beings, and yet he still continues to do it.Euthanasia, is a process of helping a person to die through a direct action. It is assisting a person in suicide by means of injecting a lethal overdose of medication.David Cundiff the author of a book called EUTHANASIA IS NOT THE ANSWER

Frankenstein: "Playing God" Advancements In Biomedical Techology

1005 words - 4 pages The fact that there have been many advancements in biomedical technology over the years have given us the ability to cure and prevent diseases that have once devastated the human population. These breakthroughs have allowed people to live longer and healthier lives, yet others believe that it runs the risk of “playing God” and that such matters should be left into the hands of a higher power. Today, this ethical debate still continues to raise