This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Police Relations With Minority Ethnic Communities

3570 words - 14 pages

Police Relations with Minority Ethnic Communities

The Macpherson report was published in 1999 amidst problems of racial
inequality and a lack of faith in the police amongst minority ethnic
communities. There is an ongoing debate on whether Macpherson’s report
was a help or a hindrance with regards to minority ethnic relations
and the police; it is this dispute that the essay shall examine. To
begin with the paper will look at the problems, which existed prior to
Sir William Macpherson’s publication and which led to the publication
of his report. It will then proceed to examine the failures of the
Scarman report, in order to look at both the prior problems and
failures regarding the 1981 Scarman publication and see how these two
sets of factors affected the way in, which minority ethnic communities
responded to Macpherson’s report. The essay will then continue on to
highlight two main areas of recommendation made by Sir William
Macpherson and judge whether or not these were successfully carried
out and what effect, if any they had on the minority ethnic community
relations. Finishing with the introduction of the acts, which were
inspired by and followed the Macpherson report, and discuss the
results, which they had on police, minority ethnic relations.

The problems in Britain regarding racism prior to the Macpherson
report and the failure of the Scarman report to remedy these, could
have been said to have meant that police and minority ethnic
communities were instantly bettered just by the mere publication of
Macpherson’s article. Racism was not actually registered in the eyes
of the government and police as a crime until the early 1980’s. But as
a result of the rising public outcries and the increasing statistical
and research evidence suggesting unfair racist practices occurring
within the police, the government and policing bodies had to at least
acknowledge the existence of racism as a problem in society. The
Bradford riots in 1995, and other public outcries showed the growing
animosity that was being felt toward the police by minority ethnic
communities. Another factor, which led the opinions of minority ethnic
citizens of the police to become additionally hostile, is the ever
advancing statistical and research evidence of racism within the
police force. In 1978 Stuart Hall et al showed most clearly how,
largely on the basis of pre-existing stereotypes minority ethnic
people (in particular black people) were being criminalized and
subjected to extraordinary policing and punishment. Both these factors
increased the feelings of hatred for the police amongst minority
ethnic communities. This was then furthered by the subsequent failings
of the Scarman report. These included his failure to explain properly
in his report the main reason why black people were so angry with the

Find Another Essay On Police Relations with Minority Ethnic Communities

The Core Function of Police in Reference to Wilson and Keeling's Broken Windows Thesis

2848 words - 11 pages functions were carried out as noted by Lord Scarman in his inquiry into the cause of the riots. However it took the murder of Stephen Lawrence in 1993 and the following inquiry by Mc Phearson which found the police to be “institutionally racist” and legitimised the strong views from black and ethnic minority communities about the lack of trust and confidence in the police. Many of Mc Phearson’s recommendations were aimed

Kazakhstan: The Ethnic Controversy Essay

2136 words - 9 pages consequence of kazakhification policy and political uncertainty, many regions with large minority groups (such as Germans) have received support from their homelands in order to preserve their ethnic lineage. This has given rise to the concern that this external support will allow these minority groups “preferential economic positions in Kazakhstan’s open economy” (Danzer, 2009, p 1560). Titular elites with political power fear such an imbalances


1866 words - 8 pages neighbourhoods (James, 1998). Because of the imbalance of power leads unidirectional power relations which is to dichotomous division of power between the powerful and powerless groups (Coleman, 2000). In government institutions the ethnic minority groups also have restricted power in government institutions such as in courthouse because the police that assaulted Curtis may get away with the crime or not be punished as severe compared to if roles

Prestcom Analysis On Uk Police Force

2162 words - 9 pages effectively.Meanwhile the police are getting better training in race awareness and the recruitment of ethnic minority officers is slowly rising, however there is currently still only 2900 ethnic officers in a force of approximately 125 000. The full force of the Race Relations legislation should apply to all police officers, and that chief officers of police should be made liable for acts of discrimination carried out by officers under their direction and

Ethnic and Racial Inequalities in the Justice System

543 words - 2 pages Ethnic and Racial Inequalities in the Justice System There are many ethnic differences in each stage of the justice system. In order to be able to prove these it is important to break the system down, and evaluate it bit by bit, showing the possible signs of ethnic differences. Firstly Policing, Philips and Bowling (2007) have noted that in the 1970’s there have been many accusations of oppressive policing if minority ethnic communities

UK Institutions Promoting Health of Ethnic Minority Women

2539 words - 10 pages This essay intends to give a critical analysis of interagency working to promote the health of ethnic minority women suffering from domestic violence. The essay starts with a definition of health and then briefly looks at varying definitions of public health and how these definitions lend credence to need for interagency working in public health. The essay then looks at the social construct of community and minority communities (BME) in England

Economic Inequality Causes Police Brutality

731 words - 3 pages 1998). These urban conditions include poor living lifestyle, low income, low employment, unsanitary environment, and dangerous crime related habits. Therefore, underprivileged minority communities are perceived as extremely unsafe and dangerous because people who live in these communities often associate with gangs (Jacob and O’Brien 1998). These gangs and juvenile delinquents commit illegal activities based on a variety of different

Discrimination in the British Police

2336 words - 9 pages be drawn is that the working culture of the police remains hostile towards women and that women continue to find themselves underrepresented at higher ranks and within the whole range of police duties.The lack of harmony between ethnic minority communities and the police and problems faced by black and Asian police officers is mirrored in the gay and lesbian community (Burke). Despite police equal opportunities policies including sexual

Educational Requiremenmts for Police Officers

1962 words - 8 pages it can be done by those unencumbered by the study of liberal arts. Officers of any department should certainly be conversant with the structure of government and its philosophies. They must be well-grounded in sociology, criminology, and human relations in order to understand the ramifications of the problems which confront them daily. (Standards for the Urban Police Function, 1972) The need for postsecondary criminal justice education

Hate Crimes Essay

1589 words - 6 pages ethnic officers with a goal of having them serve and protect ethnic and minority communities is a major item of culturally sensitive policing. However, 'same background' does not necessarily mean that officers would always show greater sensitivity. In cases like these, I feel it would be important for agencies to make sure these officers do not adopt a "heavy-handed" approach to people they consider to be bringing a negative view upon their

Greater Manchester Police (GMP) as More User Friendly

1150 words - 5 pages their career progression. Although the survey did show that a small minority of ethnic officers found that they have felt racism hit them at one point, but the majority of ethnic officers found that they have comparable experiences to their white counterparts. There was also a similar sort of survey taken out with the ethnic support staff. This shown that 72% of the support staff were satisfied with the career opportunities that are available for them at Greater Manchester Police.

Similar Essays

Police Brutality: A Minority Group Concern

1926 words - 8 pages caused by them identifying themselves as targets of discrimination and police brutality. As stated by Tyler (2005), “issues of public confidence and trust are intertwined with questions about the relationship between ethnic and social groups, including concerns about racial profiling, the excessive use of force, and the disproportionate impact of drug laws on the minority communities” (p. 324). Likewise, minority groups are the ones who also state

How Far Have The Police Embraced The Notion Of 'diversity' As A Response To Recent Legislation And Governmental Policy Initiatives?

2154 words - 9 pages which disadvantage Minority Ethnic groups". (McPherson 1999) There was an immediate onus placed at the door of government to help the restoration of confidence within the police by helping to ensure its openness and accountability. Also it was realized that a strategy was needed to develop an appropriate level of awareness, knowledge and skills to enable staff to deal with and manage diversity at work and a look at recruitment campaigns. "I

Macpherson Report (1999)

2264 words - 9 pages and retention strategies."A Guardian survey one-year on from Macpherson indicated that with the exception of the Metropolitan Police force, there had been little or no progress in the recruitment of ethnic communities into the police. In fact more than a third of forces failed to hire even one extra black or Asian officer during this period, and for nine forces their number of ethnic minority officers actually decreased. These facts are in spite

The Public's Confidence In The Police And Their Pledges

2566 words - 10 pages succeeded in doing so. Once the ‘New Labour’ were in charge Tony Blair approached this problem and implemented new aims such as police were to reduce crime, set and monitor performance targets and work with the community (Newburn and Reiner 2007). As these new aims and objectives were put in to place the public began to have more confidence with the way the police were working to help reduce crime and keep communities safer. Unfortunately