Pornography Should Be Regulated Essay

2343 words - 9 pages

When deliberating over whether access to pornography should be prohibited, four areas of contention must be elaborated upon and evaluated critically to provide a sensible basis on which a judgement can be made. Firstly, it must be concluded whether pornography can be classed as a form of speech, and whether it enjoys the same protections as art and literature under the principle. Secondly, works such as those of Catherine MacKinnon can be drawn upon to offer a feminist perspective of the effects of pornography on the treatment of women within modern democratic society. Moreover, the principles of Devlin and Feinberg offer relevant acumen regarding the criminalisation of pornographic media. Overall, this essay will argue that whilst access to pornography should not be entirely prohibited; publications that depict ‘extreme’ situations should be subject to regulation and restriction.

Freedom of speech is archetypally recognised as a basic human right in free and democratic societies. When contending whether speech that may be deemed offensive should be safeguarded one may refer to the judgement of Redmond-Bate v. DPP:

"Free speech includes not only the inoffensive but the irritating, the contentious, the eccentric, the heretical, the unwelcome and the provocative provided it does not tend to provoke violence..."

Any speech therefore, however disagreeable it may be; that does not incite violence must be allowed in our society. One must then consider whether pornography may be classed as speech. Nadine Gourgey argues that speech is not solely defined as the communication of information, but rather encompasses any act made by a party that which can be viewed and comprehended by another. Gourgey states that if pornography may be classed as speech then society would need compelling evidence for its regulation than it might require for regulating public conduct. As a free and democratic society, Gourgey asserts that we are committed to upholding a 'Free Speech Principle.'
However, it might appear that pornography cannot be protected as free speech through the traditional justifications that the public must have access truth and democracy. In fact, Gourgey hints that pornography does the opposite, as many feminists argue, it 'hides and distorts the truth' regarding what is 'normal' sexual conduct. It goes without saying that pornography cannot be said to provide any insight into democratic process.
On the other hand, these justifications are based solely on the requirements of society rather than the individual. Gourgey 's article offers support for the claim that from an individual stance, pornography offers a means by which the rights ' self-development and self-fulfilment' may be realised. If this is to be believed, then pornography is justifiably unregulated.
In contrast, Frederick Schauer wrote that:

“...a refusal to treat hard-core pornography as speech in the technical sense at issue is grounded in the belief...

Find Another Essay On Pornography Should be Regulated

Should Virtual Child Pornography Be Banned?

1024 words - 4 pages In today’s society, people are debating if “virtual” child pornography should be banned. Most people believe that it should, while others believe that it should not be banned at all. Since the Supreme Court decided that “virtual” child pornography is legal, most people have felt that they have made a horrible mistake. By check many articles on this topic, I have decided to use two fairly good articles, written by two well-known editors, Wendy

Violent Video Games Cause Aggression in Violent Video Games Cause Aggression in Children and Should Be Regulated

1344 words - 5 pages long time of studying overall the controversy, many scholars say that violent video games indeed can make players have violent thinking and aggressive behavior. Therefore, the violent video games should be regulated in producing and purchasing for kids and adolescents. Of course, have fun with healthy entertainment after the hard working time is such a normative thing for anyone to do. When people get bored with funny, simple and cute game, they

Youth access to Internet Pornography; should it be banned? Title: Trash Folder is full.

1450 words - 6 pages information sites and blocked 5 percent of the sites at the intermediate level. However, at the most restrictive level filters blocked 24 percent of these 'good' in ten sites containing pornography were still accessible" (Filters Bring Problems, 12). This study proves that no matter what settings filters are set at they are ineffective--either the child can't reach information that they should be able to or they view information they

Human Cloning Should Not Be Regulated

1084 words - 4 pages these breakthroughs in their sights, would be forced to take their experiments underground to avoid political repercussions.           The opposition insists on the regulation of cloning and is suggesting a permanent ban, arguing that cloning in any way is unethical.  Some take the position that scientists can not be trusted, ethically, to know when the experiments should stop, therefore, the scientific community would be unable to effectively

Should We Support Virtual Pornography?

1707 words - 7 pages the government had significant interest to make such works illegal. The Supreme Court reasons to why child pornography should be banned are as followed: 1) the government has a high interest in preventing the sexual exploitation of children 2) there is a casual relationship between the sexual abuse of children and the distribution of children pornography. As long as the images are in circulation and not regulated, the victims of child

The Government Should NOT Censor Internet Pornography

2374 words - 9 pages highest level of free speech protection, the same given to books, newspapers, magazines, etc (Miner). They continued by stating that the Internet is not the same as radio and television, and should not be regulated as if it was (Miner). Through this decision, it is clear that the use of Internet filters to block Internet pornography would be an unconstitutional act, just as the Communications Decency Act was


1413 words - 6 pages , but merely shows them in a pure and natural state, I do not see a problem with it. I think that in the debate over pornography, people are forgetting that the human body is a beautiful thing and is something that as long as it is not patronized there should not be a problem with displaying it. I also think that the Pornography industry should be enforced and regulated, and that the accessibility of it by nearly everyone, should be reduced to

"A First Amendment Junkie" by Susan Jacoby.

529 words - 2 pages , but she felt that its rights guaranteed under the First Amendment should not be excluded.There is no universal definition for the interpretation of the First Amendment in which every single American can agree upon. It was created with the basic understanding that everyone share the same rights. Trying to appeal to feminists that pornography is protected under the First Amendment is almost an impossibility. Susan Jacoby refers to the feminists as

The Wrongs Of Child Pornography From A Christian Perspective

3183 words - 13 pages that this is pornography. But there are circumstanced where I believe that it would not be considered pornography because there is no sexual use or intention involved. This piece of work was created for fully artistic purposes and not for sexual ones. I believe that it also depends on how you take something that helps determine whether it should be considered pornography or not. If you look at a nude statue or something and just using it for it's

Pornography and the Internet

2869 words - 11 pages are not likely to be charged with an offence providing the material is not category II or stronger, and you are not distributing or displaying it to others in any shape or form.How pornography should be regulated is one of the most controversial topics to arise about the Internet. As the Internet has become more mainstream its tail wind has stirred up a moral panic concerning the pornographic content available. There is a lot of controversy over

The Negative Impact of Pornography on Society

1168 words - 5 pages for or against pornography. The word pornography generally means sexually explicit words and images whose sole purpose is sexual arousal. Feminists are trying to ban pornography because they feel it will lead to discrimination and violence against women, while others believe that the censorship of this type of pornography is a direct violation on the first amendment. Though not all pornography should be censored, pornography that contains sexual

Similar Essays

Should Hate Speech Be Regulated?

1840 words - 8 pages regulated or if it should be regulated. It is hate speech. What exactly is hate speech? Hate speech is when a person uses words intentionally to hurt someone else; they can use hateful words based on race, religion, gender, or sexual orientation ( Yet the origin of hate-speech laws has been largely forgotten. The divergence between the United States and European countries is of comparatively recent origin. In fact, the United

Should Hate Speech Be Regulated On Campus?

1229 words - 5 pages Johnathan Rauch would not be in favor of the speech codes proposed at ISU because he argues that racist speech cannot be regulated without political and all other speech also falling victim to censorship. In Rauch's view the question is not which speech or expressive behavior is acceptable or is not acceptable because if any is restricted all speech is in jeopardy. Rauch would use two different schools of thought to explain his views on hate

Marijuana Should Be Legalized And Regulated

2068 words - 9 pages Should U.S Federal Government legalize marijuana and let the States choose their own path? A progressive thinker and realist would say yes. Cannabis possession and use, both recreational and medical, need to be legalized by Federal Government. It has to allow the States to decide whether they want it or not. Much of the modern marijuana problem happened after it was prohibited in 1937. Before that date, a few people used marijuana for recreation

Animal Testing Is Unethical And Should Be Regulated.

1255 words - 5 pages Animal testing is unethical and should be regulated.In the present era of science and technology, animals are used for experiments in various domains such as cosmetic testing, education, biomedical research and so on. Educational institutes from all over the world use animals in biomedical testing; cosmetic and genetic industries primarily use animals for different types of tests. Sarah Rose A. Miller, who wrote the prize-winning essay for the