This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Portfolio Of Five Studies That Changed Psychology

3159 words - 13 pages

Who’s Crazy Here, Anyway?
In this study conducted by D.L. Rosenhan, the following question is raised: are mental health professionals really able to tell who is mentally healthy and who is mentally ill? And what are the consequences of mistakes? To answer these questions, Rosenhan himself and eight other “pseudopatients” presented themselves at different psychological hospitals acting normally other than pretending to be hearing voices saying the same three words; all were admitted. The pseudopatients’ goal once they were admitted was to convince the staff that they were mentally healthy. The hospital staffs failed to detect the patients but interestingly enough, other patients knew pretty easily. While there was a severe lack of personal contact between staff and patients, there was no such lack of medications (the pseudopatients and many of the real patients flushed their pills down the toilet). One of the pseudopatients even noted that a nurse unbuttoned her uniform to adjust her bra in front of a dayroom of male patients; she wasn’t intending to be provocative, but simply did not view the patients as “real people”(Hock 2009).
Rosenhan’s study is critical to the world of psychology because it yielded two major results: 1) it appeared that the sane could not be distinguished from the “insane” and 2) it demonstrated the danger and damage diagnostic labels can cause. Rosenhan’s work caused extra care in diagnostic procedures to be taken and increased awareness of the harmful effects of labeling patients as well as a decrease in hospital populations, an increase in antipsychotic medications, and an increase in mental health facilities that focus on specific problems and tend to avoid labels(Hock 2009). In the study “Listen to My Madness,” Helen Lester and Jonathan Q. Tritter suggested that “mental health users become empowered to act as citizens rather than patients” and that “the social model of disability may offer an increasingly useful framework for understanding and making sense of their experiences” (2005). Studies building off of Rosenhan’s article pointed out that traditionally mental health professionals have assumed that patients were telling the truth about their symptoms but modern professionals are more likely to double check that patients aren’t faking their symptoms; so that criminals, for example, wouldn’t use psychological symptoms as a “get-out-of-jail-free card.” From an ethical standpoint, it made it apparent that, even to the medical professionals taking care of them, people with a “mentally ill” label attached to their name can be viewed as less than human (Hock 2009).
I found it very interesting that the real patients in Rosenhan’s study quickly perceived that the pseudopatients were faking their symptoms when the doctors didn’t. At first when I read how the patients were treated, I was disgusted but then I realized that it has become a common way to react to someone who is different than you are. That being said, it...

Find Another Essay On Portfolio of Five Studies that Changed Psychology

20th Century Philosophy: Ideas of Men that Forever Changed the World

970 words - 4 pages exceeding concepts is Ludwig Wittgenstein who has been considered the most influential philosopher of the 20th century. As described by Bertrand Russell, it was stated that Wittgenstein was merely a genius of ideas customarily conceived, passionate, profound, intense, and dominating in philosophical movements of the 20th century. Wittgenstein’s studies and theories of concluding controversial logical situations range in logic and language, perception

Parallels: The Influence of Lady Macbeth and the Three Witches that Changed Macbeth

1250 words - 5 pages Parallels: the Influence of Lady Macbeth and the Three Witches that Changed MacbethThroughout a person's life, there are many things, like strangers or the media, that influence how a person will behave. The main factor in this influence tends to be the people in their lives that they are closest too. Sometimes the influence of people can significantly change a person - whether in a good way, or a bad way. In the play Macbeth, written by William

The Document that Changed the Course of History: Victory or Death Letter

1580 words - 6 pages We may forget a lot of the important historical events that have occurred in the past, but there are some things that are well remembered by people everywhere. The impact of William Barret Travis and his famous “Victory or Death” letter is one of those things and will never be forgotten. The original letter is one of the few historical documents that has survived the test of time. Travis, one of the heros of the Alamo, with his call to all

Write about Three texts that have changed our concept of war

1947 words - 8 pages instead of embracing what was there and sticking with it. Although he was influenced by the media, bombarded with propaganda, told by his father that the smallest of actions could trigger the war, Jamie firmly believed he was just another victim of war. However, Jamie's ideals and thoughts of war changed towards the end of the novel, a dissimilitude of his original ideals and thoughts."These strange locations appealed to him, for the first time he

The Impact of Wilfred Laurier and a Policy that Changed the Nation: Naval Services Bill

1475 words - 6 pages , they began an arms race to show their military power. In 1906, Britain launched a new super battleship, the H.M.S. Dreadnought. In 1909, Britain discovered that Germany was secretly constructing four dreadnought-class battleships. The cry for more battleships was heard across the British Empire by the alliances. Canada, a part of the alliance, replied by refusal to add to Britain's navy. Canada, however, would construct a small navy of its own

Five layers of Deception that Marked the Beginning of an End

1725 words - 7 pages deception plan known as “Bodyguard1.” Franklin Roosevelt, Winston Churchill, and Joseph Stalin first approved the outline for this plan at the Tehran conference in November 1943. Being one of the most complex schemes ever attempted, the plan was layered in five-folds of deception: Ferdinand, Vendetta, Ironside, Zeppelin, and Fortitude. The first component Ferdinand was a false invasion into the Mediterranean near Italy to convince the Germans that

Five Different Types of Knowledge That I Nurse Can Use to Care for Patients

2199 words - 9 pages knowledge in her care was when she made the ethical decision on which patient she should visit first, that being Mrs. Johnson. This is an example of ethical knowledge because since Mrs. Johnson was the newest admit, and had had a cardioversion forty-five minutes prior, she was the most unstable patient of Allison’s. Had Allison made the choice to assess her other patient’s first it would have not been the responsible choice in the situation. The

The evolution of negotiation. In essence this paper argues that the definition of negotiator success has changed

7640 words - 31 pages find ourselves on the dance floor" (Thompson, 2001, p34). As a result, scholars from an array of disciplines (e.g., psychology, economics, industrial and organizational behavior, sociology, communications, and law) continue to investigate the variables that account for negotiator success.Before scholars can generate a useful theory regarding negotiator success, and provide prescriptive advice for obtaining it, they must be clear about what

This paper is a literature review of studies that were based on the impacts of mega events and world fairs

1294 words - 5 pages AbstractThis paper is a literature review of studies that were based on the impacts of mega events and world fairs. The major focus was placed on sporting events such as the Olympics. Several of the significant impacts that were analyzed in this report included social impact, legacies, urban regeneration, tourism, and socio-economic factors. The current paper will attempt to explain the guidelines and procedural process that a city that is in

How have computers changed our lives? describes some of the things that computers can now help us to do

513 words - 2 pages How Computers changed our way of life? What could happen in the future?Computers have changed our ways in many different ways and aspects. Almost everyone depends on a computer to run effectively for one reason or another even if they themselves do not own one.People who own a bank account often have a bankcard, which is used in cash point machines. All of their bank details are kept on a computer system if this computer was to fail the bank

Review of Kotz's Book, Judgment Days: Lyndon Baines Johnson, Martin Luther King Jr., and the Laws That Changed America.

1214 words - 5 pages Judgment Days: Lyndon Baines Johnson, Martin Luther King Jr., and the Laws That Changed America. Judgment Days chronicles how Johnson and King seemed fated to lead the collapse of America's segregation views. The reader is first introduced to Johnson, the master politician soon after President Kennedy’s catastrophic assassination. Kotz shows how LBJ makes his way through this crisis to seize the moment and take the reins of the nation

Similar Essays

Fourty Famous Studies That Influeneced Psychology

3901 words - 16 pages confidently state that "there is no doubt that many aspects of brain anatomy and brain chemistry are changed by experience." However, many scientists were skeptical of there findings because there were factors that Rosenzweig and Bennett didn't take into consideration. The enriched rats were handled more which could have been a brain stimulus and the impoverished rats could have been stressed from having no contact with anyone or anything at

Five Themes For Psychology Of Personal Adjustment

1676 words - 7 pages few years ago. Going through that experience really changed the way I feel at night when I am alone. According to the Walker, “We all experience the emotion of fear. It is important to distinguish fear from anxiety. A specific situation or object elicits fear, whereas anxiety is objectless. Therefore we speak of fear when we think we know what we’re afraid of and anxiety when we’re unsure” (2013, p.157). The textbook offers a list of steps you

Battles That Changed The Outcome Of The American Revolution

1777 words - 8 pages Jack Johnston Mr. George-Reichely Social Studies 8 16 December 2013 Battles that Changed the Outcome The Americans started out as a bunch of uncivilized colonies, but after the revolutionary war, they become a strong country that beat Britain for freedom. On Christmas night General George Washington makes a bold decision to cross the Delaware and ambushed the Hessians. Although risky, Washington brought new life to his rag tag army. General

The Accident That Changed My Way Of Thinking

679 words - 3 pages . The accident changed my way of thinking about the law and the rules that are enforced. Everytime I get into a car, I am the first person to tell passengers to put their seat belts on. Things that I might think are insignificant, may be the very things that save my lif. I have only one life and I should take all neccessary precautions. A car will never start unless everyone is safely secured.